Hmmm I don't remember people thinking it was Buggy on PH …. I missed that one.
His name was mentioned all over the Chapter 656 thread.
Hmmm I don't remember people thinking it was Buggy on PH …. I missed that one.
His name was mentioned all over the Chapter 656 thread.
Also for the "___ for namaka!" bandwagon, is this=
IF a guy spends any time fighting beside the SHs, then there will be calls for him to join.
Paulie, Wiper, Hatchi, and even Duval have had the rallying cry for them.
(Some I didn't mention because this is for 'old wrong theories' and they are still current(Law, Kyros, ect))
(nor Jinbe because there's a chance he may still join)
@Galaxy:
Any "random female who appeared, and therefore must be a Straw Hat" theory fits this bill.
Buggy being the Warlord on Punk Hazard is another good one I remember people saying because of the splitting.
Ah yes, I remember the "Buggy can split other people too now" theory.
Oh that reminds me, before it was revealed that its from Blackbeard, this was a common theory=
Buggy was the one to give Shanks the 3 scars.
It started shortly after Buggy first encountered Luffy in East Blue. Buggy was shown wielding multiple knives in his fist at once. He had attacked and hit Luffy in the face (seriously, there were people posting that for 'support', and causing rips in the strawhat at another.
Oh that reminds me, before it was revealed that its from Blackbeard, this was a common theory=
Buggy was the one to give Shanks the 3 scars.It started shortly after Buggy first encountered Luffy in East Blue. Buggy was shown wielding multiple knives in his fist at once. He had attacked and hit Luffy in the face (seriously, there were people posting that for 'support', and causing rips in the strawhat at another.
[qimg]http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110717030158/onepiece/images/thumb/8/8f/Cut.png/180px-Cut.png[/qimg]
Never saw or ascribed to that theory but always wondered if it wasn't a case of Oda intending it to be part of their backstory and then changing it up when he saw the dramatic potential in BB doing it. Can't remember BB using anything except his power & pistols but whatever. It's canon now, the theory is very dead.
Cool. Has Oda become a cyborg yet?
I heard from Grandpa that spoilers are bad thing in 2014.
To bad that he died without finishing One Piece :cwy: (i'm talking about Grandpa)
Monet is gonna be the Straw Hats astronomer because of a book that appeared in one panel.
The desperation was getting pathetic at that point, was very entertaining.
I'm sorry but "Crocodile is a woman" is in fact the best theory in this board's 70 year history and I'll have no one disparaging it.
Sunkist having to power up by eating the fire fruit was some pretty awful fan wank
Robin turning into a toy caused Usopp to lose character development
This one will always be my favorite
Surprised anyone rememberd that classic. Best theory ever! Seriously though, what idiot came up with that? :rolleyes:
-Burgess will eat the Mera mera no mi.
-Sanji's will eat the mera mera no mi
-Moria was turned into a toy.
-Kaido is Sabo
-Doflamingo's controlling Kaido.
-Vergo has a metal df
-Ace used to be part of the top executives.
-Burgess will eat the Mera mera no mi.
-Sanji's will eat the mera mera no mi
-Moria was turned into a toy.
-Kaido is Sabo
-Doflamingo's controlling Kaido.
-Vergo has a metal df
-Ace used to be part of the top executives.
Luffy will be turned into a toy and Ussop will step up.
Some of these are current, really current as in current arc. Yeah they are still wrong, but oh so new I remember taking part of dismissing some.
Anyone remember-heard any some oldies? I'm almost out of ones I remember off top of my head, and I know there were some doozies from years ago that I've not heard yet. I'd love to hear those tarnished (well if they're wrong they ain't golden!) oldies?
Like how the 7 shichibukai will represent the 7 deadly sins?
Zoro killed Mihawk in his sleep during the timeskip.
I remember reading through my lurker days here when there was one person who was trying to convince everybody that Perona would join the Straw hats at all costs.
I remember the Luffyko incident too. That was hilarious.
Usopp will unleash CoC and defeat Sugar
Metal Devil Fruit should have had it's own thread.
16 characters of what for???
Because the absence of Vergo for 50 chapters didn't prevent Vagabond from posting new evidence every day in the chapter thread.
My favorite: Vergo withstood Law's counter shock thanks to his metal devil fruit.
Poor Enel, both conductor and insulator are immune to elektricity.
whitebeard dies but ace survives and ace will be the new captain.
franky family will join luffy.
duval is krieg.
Never saw or ascribed to that theory but always wondered if it wasn't a case of Oda intending it to be part of their backstory and then changing it up when he saw the dramatic potential in BB doing it. Can't remember BB using anything except his power & pistols but whatever. It's canon now, the theory is very dead.
He was shown with claws attached to his arm in a flashback. Was it in Chapter 0 or during Marineford?
Dragon is a former admiral! How could I forget that. I read it first on Vegapunk Forums like 10 years ago. It sounded awesome back then. Dragon as someone who was in marines thanks to Garp's influence and then became WG's greatest enemy… But there are things that didn't add up even then.
Vergo's carefully hidden Metal DF and Sanji eating the Mera Mera no Mi for a much needed power up have to be my favourites.
Some of these are current, really current as in current arc. Yeah they are still wrong, but oh so new I remember taking part of dismissing some.
Anyone remember-heard any some oldies? I'm almost out of ones I remember off top of my head, and I know there were some doozies from years ago that I've not heard yet. I'd love to hear those tarnished (well if they're wrong they ain't golden!) oldies?Like how the 7 shichibukai will represent the 7 deadly sins?
Yeah, it's disappointing how current this thread is.
Because the absence of Vergo for 50 chapters didn't prevent Vagabond from posting new evidence every day in the chapter thread.
My favorite: Vergo withstood Law's counter shock thanks to his metal devil fruit.
Poor Enel, both conductor and insulator are immune to elektricity.
Thing is that Vergo had some damage from Counter Shock with his "blood bleh" so even if V would have DF we would not be able to say that its immune.
Also metal can get damaged/ melted with amps high enough so no immunity here - just to keep facts straight
I liked that theory..
I seen far worse theories like with Sanji eating mera mera..
Everybody is Sabo train was entertaining in funny way.
I also liked how everybody were unsure on who is behind half of body running around on Punk Hazard(Kinemon) like its not obvious that Law did that.
Luffy being capable of eating 2 devil fruits was worst kind of theory I seen on other hand.. "because he is a D" or "because… because reasons!" arrgghhh
Doflamingo is Law's dad :ninja:
Paulie or Kaku for nakama were the first I ever encountered on a board. Glad they're pretty dead.
Fave of my own failed ideas is that Fujitora was going to be Jewelry Bonney. I was young cough. At the time it wasn't clear, to me, Oda was continuing the actor theme & seemed a great way to explain why she was suddenly free: agreeing to serve for a chance to hunt down Blackbeard. And she wore pink/purple… Alas, it was cut down in it's prime and buried somewhere on Punk Hazard.
Fave not-quite-dead-yet one: Meadows. He'll come good :ninja:
Fujitora… that reminds me of his introduction, where a LOT of people thought he was Dressrosa former king or one of Shichibukai, even despite all the evidence screaming he was an admiral.
My favorite is the Mom Mom Fruit theory. It's too ridiculous to be true, but good for a laugh.
How could I forget that. I read it first on Vegapunk Forums like 10 years ago. It sounded awesome back then. Dragon as someone who was in marines thanks to Garp's influence and then became WG's greatest enemy… But there are things that didn't add up even then.
I'd prefer to think he was in Cipher Pol, hence his obscurity and apparent wealth of information.
My favorite is the Mom Mom Fruit theory. It's too ridiculous to be true, but good for a laugh.
Lol, that's awesome.
Big Mom is like Yhwach, only with moms instead of Quincy.
I'd prefer to think he was in Cipher Pol, hence his obscurity and apparent wealth of information.
Yeah, he would be too known if he were an admiral and Oda not dropping that kind of info earlier would be hard to swallow by even a most fanatical reader.
He had to realize everything he knew in some way, so I wouldn't exclude CP connection. Especially since his dad was such a persistant marine recruiter.
Back on Sabaody Archipelago lots of people thought Luffy would 1hko Kid. Now I think about it, lots of people thought the SH'S were going to defeat t all the supernovas. People seem to take great offensive to there been other powerful crews out there. I think it comes from posters thinking after Enies lobby only the Yonko were stronger than the SHs' how wrong were they.
Back on Sabaody Archipelago lots of people thought Luffy would 1hko Kid. Now I think about it, lots of people thought the SH'S were going to defeat t all the supernovas. People seem to take great offensive to there been other powerful crews out there. I think it comes from posters thinking after Enies lobby only the Yonko were stronger than the SHs' how wrong were they.
…and then came Marineford.
Akainu/the marines/World Government/Elder Stars will be the final villain.
Perona will join the crew, here's a fifty page thesis on why with a list of MLA citations.
Caribou will join the crew because I am an illiterate boob.
Theories are pointless because Oda will do literally anything.
Sabo is dead and Bluejam was obviously saved by Dragon.
@Cyan:
Sabo is dead and Bluejam was obviously saved by Dragon.
Seriously? This was a real thing!?
Seriously? This was a real thing!?
Unfortunately, yes.
http://onepiece.wikia.com/wiki/User_blog:JustSomeDude…/If_Sabo_is_dead,_who_did_Dragon_save%3F
One of many examples.
Right, Caribou as SH. They have great chemistry, doesn't matter he's a psycho killer.
All the theories about Sabo before Sabo actually showed up. I was catching up with the series at the time but to my knowledge it pretty much became a running joke where every new character was speculated to be Sabo. I wish I was around for that.
As far as my own theories are concerned, I thought that Kid was going to be the antagonist of Sabaody. Now I doubt if he'll even be an antagonist at all. A rival, probably. But not an antagonist.
Well, at first I expected Fujitora to be former coliseum champion or the old king of dressrosa.
Remember when we thought Fishman Island was the next arc after Enies Lobby?
Every new character is Sabo.
And then when he actually met Luffy and donned the Lucy persona, it was Sabo is not Sabo.
Also,
Nobody will die outside of flashbacks.
Since I haven't been around very long I tried to remember theories I made myself, but I come up with more questions than ideas. What did people think the Shichibukai would be like, or the admirals, figuring out devil fruits like the Ope Ope or seeing Sanji bubblified, what were those giants in the clouds prior to the Skypiea arc, etc, etc.
@Galaxy:
Any "random female who appeared, and therefore must be a Straw Hat" theory fits this bill.
.
This is wrong, it's more like random ridiculous disproportioned pair of boobs, Hancock, Shirahoshi, Monet, Rebbeca, Violet, Three eyed girl while Wicca… well no boobs no chance of joining the crew apparently.
Good thing, Jimbe has some big tits even being a male, #JimbeConfirmedForNakama
All the theories about Sabo before Sabo actually showed up. I was catching up with the series at the time but to my knowledge it pretty much became a running joke where every new character was speculated to be Sabo. I wish I was around for that.
Meet Cyborg Sabo, lol.
Right, Caribou as SH. They have great chemistry, doesn't matter he's a psycho killer.
Or that Hody Jones would join. Or most of the other "We'll get a Fishman other than Jinbe" ones. I remember people suggesting that we'd get some random and unseen Fishman Karate Disciple to join in Jinbe's place.
My personal favorite is probably the "Doflamingo is after Momonosuke for his DF" theory.
My personal favorite is probably the "Doflamingo is after Momonosuke for his DF" theory.
Keeps popping out every couple of months.
Oh, one of my favourites must be that Blackbeard "it's not him, it's they" theory from Jaya. It's immortal.
Beat this:
Dragon is both the father and mother of Luffy. With the help of Ivankov's DF he let himself pregnant with luffy.
And I'm sure someone said Ivankov made Dragon a women and Garp left him pregnant with luffy, so he is both grandfather and father at the same time….
There was a theory that Luffy would learn Haki of Boa Hancock before they go to Impel down. When luffy and Hancock were communicating with each other, they were doing it through Haki.
Another one was after Enies Lobby. Lots of posters were theorising that luffy would never use Gear's ever again, as he would die. To be fair. I think that was more down to wishful thinking than a theory. As I recall the Gears was not met with much approval, some absolutely hated the concept of Gears and hoped to never see it again. Not sure what people feel about it now like.
There was a theory that Luffy would learn Haki of Boa Hancock before they go to Impel down. When luffy and Hancock were communicating with each other, they were doing it through Haki.
Another one was after Enies Lobby. Lots of posters were theorising that luffy would never use Gear's ever again, as he would die. To be fair. I think that was more down to wishful thinking than a theory. As I recall the Gears was not met with much approval, some absolutely hated the concept of Gears and hoped to never see it again. Not sure what people feel about it now like.
If people didn't like the gears, I wonder what they think now about Haki…
Just wait till Luffy dishes out new Haki empowered Gear.