@RobbyBevard:
Music is such a personal, intimate reaction, that there aren't really any rights or wrongs. Movies are kind of the same, personal experience will vary. You can compare and contrast all the elements that make things up, and its really easy to agree that, on a technical level, X is better than Y, but that doesn't automatically mean you'll like X.
I'm not a big fan of the Godfather. Its a perfect movie, not a flaw, many things to love about it… but I don't care for it. And I like the Beatles, but I don't love them, and I downright dislike a lot of the druggier, more experimental second half of their career. (Revolution 9, what the hell was up with that? ) But to some people they're the greatest and most influential band of all time and didn't have a single miss, and that's hard to argue with.
Yeah, pretty much. Me, I'd say I'm actually a pretty big fan of The Beatles and I think I actually prefer their later stuff over their earlier stuff (but Revolution 9, yeah, that's just…what?). Although, I have to admit, I'm actually not a huge fan of The White Album. Don't get me wrong, it's great and there are several songs on it that I just love, but it's pretty heavy length-wise, has a lot of tunes that are either quirky or just don't stand out to me, and I'm still not sure how I feel about their take on the country folk genre. Sgt. Pepper, however, I just adore.
For another example, I've really gotten into Yes recently after listening to their 90125 album, but I was soon after told to listen to Close to the Edge, Fragile and The Yes Album to get the true Yes experience. At first I didn't think too much of the albums (except for Yes Album, which I almost immediately loved) as they seem kind of long, tedious, and unremarkable, but as I've listened to them more and more they've definitely grown on me. But even so, considering the length and feel of the songs they can be a bit intense, whereas 90125's songs are shorter and just plain fun to listen to. So yeah, if I'm making my 10 minute commute to or from work and want something short and sweet to put me in a good mood, I'd definitely listen to this.