How is the anime for Sket Dance? Is it faithful to the manga? Is Gintama's anime faithful to its manga too?
The "Shueisha" Thread
-
-
Thanks for the info, Aohige.
I read a couple pages of sket dance and went crazy, how long do you have to stay with it to really enjoy it?
Like most manga, it doesn't really start with a bang. There are some really good chapters early on (the seventh chapter introduces one of the more consistently hilarious characters, and the ninth gives a good sense of how well it handles more serious moments), but I didn't really get hooked until Tsubaki became a more important character. Then Bossun's backstory arc (Chapters 82-90) pretty much established it as my second-favorite currently-running manga.
-
i hope stars isn`t going to get canceled, the last chapter was realy interesting
-
Yeah, latest chapter of ST&RS gave me major 2001 flashbacks.
-
Dont know if this right place to put it,i just saw the cover,some people might be interested.
V Jump issue 12
http://www.imagebam.com/image/f24e40154563852 -
Magico's not at the bottom? Hells to the yeah!
Looks like Enigma's out now. Oh well.~
-
Jump cover 46:
Issue 46 Bottom 5:
Kuroko no Basket
Kochikame
Hunter x Hunter
Enigma
St&rsIssue 47:
Lead CP: Toriko
CP: Bakuman, Kurogane -
Jump cover 46:
http://s3d4.turboimagehost.com/t1/9452537_IMG_3841.JPG
Issue 46 Bottom 5:
Kuroko no Basket
Kochikame
Hunter x Hunter
Enigma
St&rsIssue 47:
Lead CP: Toriko
CP: Bakuman, Kurogane -
Yeah, seriously. Why the fuck is HxH at the bottom five?
-
Jump cover 46: Issue 46 Bottom 5:
Kuroko no Basket
Kochikame
Hunter x Hunter
Enigma
St&rsShould I assume it's doomed?:sad:
-
Jump #46 (24/10) :
Bleach (Cover & Lead Color Page)
Naruto
One Piece
Toriko
Gintama
Sket Dance
Kurogane (First Rank)
Reborn!
Welcome to the Competitive Dance Club (Color Page, One Shot, 47 pg.)
Bakuman
Medaka Box
Inumaru Dashi
Beelzebub (Color Page)
Magico
Nurarihyon no Mago
Harisugawa in Mirror world
Kuroko no Basket
Kochikame
Hunter x Hunter
Enigma
ST&RS#47:
Lead CP: Toriko
CP: Bakuman, Kurogane (25 pg.)
Extra Pages: Kuroko no Basket Magico gets higher, me likes.
Top 5 is awesome, except Naruto. -
Kurogane started great!
And I agree with you, Reborn could be in the top five instead of Naruto…
Toriko, Gintama and One Piece are my favorite series on the Jump. And Sket looks cool. -
Reborn should be on bottom 5.
As for HxH I already said this, I think this is just a way to the fans to express that they are tired of this hiatus… Togashi still will probably not give a shit and in two months will be back to Dragon Quest.
P.S: Yes I'm repeating this every week.
-
@!Volpe:
Kurogane started great!
And I agree with you, Reborn could be in the top five instead of Naruto…
Toriko, Gintama and One Piece are my favorite series on the Jump. And Sket looks cool.Wtf how do you get the idea that i want to see this fucking junk called Reborn in the Top 5?
-
Ideal Top 5 would be :
One Piece
Hunter x Hunter
Gintama
Toriko
Beelzebub -
Look on the bright side. If HxH gets canned, Togashi can finish his Dragon Quest Let's Play.
-
@Cyan:
Look on the bright side. If HxH gets canned, Togashi can finish his Dragon Quest Let's Play.
So true..so true..
Btw; I was wandering if any manga was canned due to HxH return from hiatus(es) or do they increase the number of manga in WSJ while HxH is on?
-
@Bad:
So true..so true..
Btw; I was wandering if any manga was canned due to HxH return from hiatus(es) or do they increase the number of manga in WSJ while HxH is on?
idk about how they usually do it, but from what I've heard hunter x hunter is all about the volume sales, that are ridiculous, it probably doesn't matter if he gets bottom 5 for life cause one volume of his will probably outsell 3 - 4 volumes of Bleach, that man makes bank
-
Of course the chapter where sasuke returns gets the first spot…
-
Lol, how that ranking will for sure change again next week…having a bullcrap Naruto chapter after having "higher expectations" and an rly good OP chapter after having "lower" expectations this week.
-
Fuck yeah Magico, fuck yeah!!!
-
Ideal Bottom Five:
Enigma
Naruto
Bleach
Reborn
Inumaru -
Ideal Bottom Five:
Enigma
Naruto
Bleach
Reborn
InumaruD
Dont know this one,whats story like? -
D
Dont know this one,whats story like?A gag manga with an perveted kindergarten kid that doesn't wear pants.
The only scanlated chapter: http://www.mangafox.com/manga/inumarudashi/v01/c001/1.html -
A gag manga with an perveted kindergarten kid that doesn't wear pants.
The only scanlated chapter: http://www.mangafox.com/manga/inumarudashi/v01/c001/1.htmlDEAR GOD…How did this .....okay.
Thanks for the answer.
-
Inumaru has a pretty much guaranteed "gag" spot, in the tradition of Sexy Commando Masaru-san and Jaguar, so putting it in the bottom five simply makes it a bottom four.
You should disregard it, along with HxH from rankings. :ninja:
-
Are there any scans of Welcome to the Competitive Dance Club? If so, links?
-
Kurogane got a good start, also CP and 25 pg next week? Hmm, that's not a standard TOC welcome package for new series, or is it? It's still too early but I like the series and hope WSJ is serious about cultivating another sport manga.
So we probably should count HxH, Inumaru and Kochikame out of ranking, seeing how they are immune from cut, for different reasons.
But speaking of the whole bottom 5 and risk cutting business, I'm not sure if I buy it anymore: Nurarihyon and Madaka Box are both frequent visitors to the bottom floor, yet the latter is getting an anime adoption next Spring and the former just got a 2nd season. I don't care about Nura and loathe Madaka, yet I don't see either of the two going anywhere.
-
idk about how they usually do it, but from what I've heard hunter x hunter is all about the volume sales, that are ridiculous, it probably doesn't matter if he gets bottom 5 for life cause one volume of his will probably outsell 3 - 4 volumes of Bleach, that man makes bank
I'm not asking if HxH is in danger from getting canned as I'm sure it's safe.
I'm asking if another series was canned (when HxH returned from hiatus) to allow HxH a spot or was it added to the current line of running manga?
-
@Bad:
I'm not asking if HxH is in danger from getting canned as I'm sure it's safe.
I'm asking if another series was canned (when HxH returned from hiatus) to allow HxH a spot or was it added to the current line of running manga?
Oh sorry, I have no clue
-
Kurogane got a good start, also CP and 25 pg next week? Hmm, that's not a standard TOC welcome package for new series, or is it? It's still too early but I like the series and hope WSJ is serious about cultivating another sport manga.
So we probably should count HxH, Inumaru and Kochikame out of ranking, seeing how they are immune from cut, for different reasons.
But speaking of the whole bottom 5 and risk cutting business, I'm not sure if I buy it anymore: Nurarihyon and Madaka Box are both frequent visitors to the bottom floor, yet the latter is getting an anime adoption next Spring and the former just got a 2nd season. I don't care about Nura and loathe Madaka, yet I don't see either of the two going anywhere.
Both Nura and Medaka Box did not get cut due to their good volume sales. Just because a series is ranked at the bottom does not mean that it is unpopular. As long as they continue to sell well, they would most likely be safe.
-
Why are people surprised that HxH is on the bottom? It hasn't been in the magazine for over a year, and the last time it was there it only had like 20 chapters, there are a ton of readers who don't have any fucking clue what it is, why it's there, or what's going on in it. And I bet the hardcore Togashi fans don't read much Jump, they just buy the volumes, so the vote you have represented right now is a bunch of confused 12-year olds.
This happened last time. Unless HxH truly comes back and sticks, I don't think it will climb out of the bottom. But like people said, that doesn't matter, because the volume sales are good, and no editor wants to be the "one who canned HxH".
-
Remember also that the JUMP demographic has changed drastically in recent years. But yeah, Lith is right on the money.
A lot of folks probably don't have any idea wtf it is.
-
@!Volpe:
Kurogane started great!
And I agree with you, Reborn could be in the top five instead of Naruto…
Toriko, Gintama and One Piece are my favorite series on the Jump. And Sket looks cool.I'll take Naruto over Reborn any day.
-
Opinion is opinion, anyway. Reborn isn't a great series, but for me, it's better than Naruto. I repeat, for ME.
-
@!Volpe:
Opinion is opinion, anyway. Reborn isn't a great series, but for me, it's better than Naruto. I repeat, for ME.
Well, that´s no saying much. It´s like you´re saying that you prefer molestation to prison rape or something like that.
-
Well, that´s no saying much. It´s like you´re saying that you prefer molestation to prison rape or something like that.
Nothing is better than prison sex..
!
-
I coulda erased that nightmare fuel from the memory of my life if I could. -_-;
That, and that Black Hole Sun music video. Oh god.
But speaking of the whole bottom 5 and risk cutting business, I'm not sure if I buy it anymore: Nurarihyon and Madaka Box are both frequent visitors to the bottom floor, yet the latter is getting an anime adoption next Spring and the former just got a 2nd season. I don't care about Nura and loathe Madaka, yet I don't see either of the two going anywhere.
That doesn't mean anything.
Do you remember Busou Renkin? It got canned in WSJ first, THEN got an anime adaptation.
Because back then the WSJ's retarded "poll is everything" mentality decided to can it, despite selling decently well.Anyways, WSJ editorial has gone through some changes since then (Partially thanks to the phenomenal popularity of Death Note), and they value volume sales a lot more now than they used to.
Due to that, as long as Nura and Medaka continue to do ok in sales, its ranking won't matter as much. -
@Bad:
I'm asking if another series was canned (when HxH returned from hiatus) to allow HxH a spot or was it added to the current line of running manga?
Hunter x Hunter has returned in issue #34 or #35. Sengoku Armors got cancelled in #31, Hanasaka Ikkyu - in #38. Meanwhile, three other series started in #30, #31 and #39. Right now Weekly Shonen Jump has 20 series published in it.
-
Hunter x Hunter has returned in issue #34 or #35. Sengoku Armors got cancelled in #31, Hanasaka Ikkyu - in #38. Meanwhile, three other series started in #30, #31 and #39. Right now Weekly Shonen Jump has 20 series published in it.
I see, so the no. of series/ issue is more flexible rather than fixed. Good to hear that.
Thanks for the info.
-
Oh , Sengoku Armors got cancelled eh ? Never knew what that was about to begin with but I heard some people in this thread praise it.
-
Okay guys, serious question because I still don't understand how this ranking can change anything if we take a high profile series. So is there any realistic chance that HxH will get canceled eventually if it says in the lowest part of the ranks?
-
Okay guys, serious question because I still don't understand how this ranking can change anything if we take a high profile series. So is there any realistic chance that HxH will get canceled eventually if it says in the lowest part of the ranks?
The rankings don't do much to a successful series. So no.
-
Bottom 5
Kagami no Kuni no Harisugawa
Nurarihyon no Mago
Kochikame
Enigma
ST&RSST&RS was most likely cancelled this issue.
Issuer 48 Information
New Series/Lead CP/Cover: Nisekoi by Komi Naoshi
Center Colour: Reborn, Magico, Kuroko no Basket -
64 名前:ohana ◆IR7jauNn4E :2011/10/26(水) 21:44:36.41 ID:uPQl3kZIP
表紙トリコ
巻頭トリコ
ナルト
ワンピ
スケット
ブリーチ
バクマン C
銀魂
黒子 C
クロガネ C
リボン
めだか
ハンター
マジコ
こち亀
スターズ
べるぜ
鏡の国
ぬらり
エニグマ48号 ニセコイ巻頭
ぬらりC
銀魂 Cすごい買いづらい状態が続くかも。
Jump #47 (31/10) :
Toriko (Cover & Lead Color Page)
Naruto
One Piece
Sket Dance
Bleach
Bakuman (Color Page)
Gintama
Kuroko no Basket (23 pg.)
Kurogane (Color Page, 25 pg.)
Reborn!
Medaka Box
Hunter x Hunter
Magico
Kochikame
ST&RS
Beelzebub
Harisugawa in Mirror world
Nurarihyon no Mago
Enigma#48:
Lead CP: Nisekoi (New Series)
CP: Nurarihyon no Mago, GintamaAlso this time Ohana missed Inumaru Dashi…
-
Hmm, why Beel so low? Why Bleach so high again? Why I miss words?
-
Is that ranking for Naruto the one for the chapter where Sasuke shows off his new Haxagan?
It is, isn't it?
-
Cover:
Sigh at rankings,oh well.
-
Gintama is fifth and Sket Dance is third. Great. Hunter x Hunter and ST&RS are actually rising. Goddamn great.
All happy form seeing these, you finally notice that Naruto is first, Bleach fourth, Reborn sixth and Beelzebub in bottom five.
And then you sigh.
Is that ranking for Naruto the one for the chapter where Sasuke shows off his new Haxagan?
It is, isn't it?
A-yup.
And Bleach is fourth thanks to Why Me Sad.
-
Gintama is fifth and Sket Dance is third. Great. Hunter x Hunter and ST&RS are actually rising. Goddamn great.
All happy form seeing these, you finally notice that Naruto is first, Bleach fourth, Reborn sixth and Beelzebub in bottom five.
And then you sigh.
A-yup.
And Bleach is fourth thanks to Why Me Sad.
Don't be so happy about HXH's ranking this week. I checked out the rankings for the last 11 chapters AND the chapters before the hiatus, and HXH always ranks either in the bottom 5 (6 times 3rd to last, three times 4th to last and six times it ranked 5th to last), a few times it ranked 9th and 10th, as well as 11th and 13th (once for each).