-
Garp revealed as Luffy's Grandpa (I remember first hearing the spoiler and thinking it was some very crazy theory, boy was I shocked when I read the chapter! XD)
-
Dragon is Luffy's father (again, is shocked but I could believe that more than Garp!)
-
Franky's speedo getting stolen
-
Robin grabs Franky (ouch!)
-
Brook's first appearance (I mean, come on, it's not everyday you see a walking talking skeleton with an afro!)
-
Brook and Laboon
-
Oz being revealed and then goes off rampaging
Biggest "WHUH??"
-
-
The fact that Robin joined out of the blue, which got me giddy since I loved her DF power.
Usopp quitting was a shocker
Pell appearing alive after his very effective "sacrifice"
Luffy's impalement at the hands of Crocodile
That sexy babe hanging out with Buggy turns out to be Alvida
Nami convincingly "stabs" Usopp and sends him to a watery grave
Dragon and Garp revalations in Water 7
Kaku's DF power is revealed
The fact that the Going Merry would no longer be the Strawhat's ship
The revalation of what kind of mushroom Chopper fed Hirluk(sp?)
The revalation of what Skypiea's Vearth turned out to actually originate from
Robin betraying Crocodile
-
Off the top of my head…
-
Crocodile impales Luffy
-
Crocodile defeated Luffy in round 2 (I figured Luffy would probably win. Totally shocked me)
-
Pell's "death" (good shock)
-
Pell surviving (bad shock)
-
Nami furiously stabbing her Arlong emblem tattoo off.
-
Captain Kuro's awesomely evil "I endured it" speech.
-
Smoker's powers (he was the first Logia, after all, and the series' hero couldn't lay a hand on him).
-
The defeat of Crocodile (not so much of a shock, as it was so muthafuckin' epic and beautiful I still can't get over it).
-
-
Sanji's fire leg
-
Robin joining instead of Vivi.
I don't think there's any contest.
It's COMPLETELY out there and yet….it made perfect sense. If Oda was saving that up since he first introduced her....good for him.
I also think it's a shame that a twist of that magnitude is lost on new fans because of....well....basically any picture of the crew since then.
-
- CP9. (I don't think it gets more surprising than this)
- Jaya's connection to Skypiea.
- Chopper's remedy being poison.
- Pell's death.
- Pell's survival. (Movie 8 gets merit just for ignoring this)
- Brook's promise.
- Coby and Helmeppo's return.
- Berserk Chopper.
- Luffy being invulnerable to Enel's powers.
- Gear 3. (the 2-page spread of the giant fist was pretty shocking when it was first seen)
-
- CP9. (I don't think it gets more surprising than this)
- Jaya's connection to Skypiea.
- Chopper's remedy being poison.
- Pell's death.
- Pell's survival. (Movie 8 gets merit just for ignoring this) - Brook's promise.
- Coby and Helmeppo's return.
- Berserk Chopper.
- Luffy being invulnerable to Enel's powers.
- Gear 3. (the 2-page spread of the giant fist was pretty shocking when it was first seen)
I haven't seen the movie, but according to people he is shown alive in the credits.
-
I can't still forgive Robin for some actions of her during Alabasta Arc, that's why I don't really bite her join in the Straw Hats. Even if I already knew she would join and she is well-accepted by the fans… still...
-
-The Strawhats get a "talking reindeer" as their doctor. (I didn't know anything about Drum at the time and figured the main crew was just the original five for good)
-Robin joining post-Alabasta
-Ushi-Ushi no Mi, model Giraffe
-Sanji turning Wazne into a bishonen (that was just wrong)
-Monkey D. Garp (unlike Dragon, which was sort of coming even though we didn't know how or the relation, that was just shocking)
-Thriller Bark = giant ship (even I thought it was a floating island)
-Mermaid Kokoro (again…that was just wrong...but it got them out of a cliffhanger) -
- Garp being Luffy's grandpa
- Blueno being a part of CP9 (the Galley-La people didn't surprise me because I always suspected them of hiding something, but Blueno just looked like a harmless, weird extra)
- Franky being the other student of Tom
- Brooke's past with Laboon
Can't think of much more right now.
-
Bellamy Punch, anyone? Was I the only one who got disturbed by his mom only to watch that rubber go through his brain? :x
The start of chapter 434, when on the first 2 panels you see Shanks' and WB's flags. I didn't read the spoilers that time, I was like "OH GOD OH GOD OH GOD."
Judging by the other posts, I seem to have a strange feeling for being surprised. :\ None of the stuff you said worked on me.
Ah, btw Greg, say those stuff about Robin again to anyone who watched the anime first. =(
-
BEST PAGE IN THE ENTIRE SERIES
-
- Luffy Beat Crocodile
- Luffy invites Brooke to be new member
- Robin 1st appearson Merry and wants to become a member
- CP9 unmasked
- Skypedia revealed
- When Luffy beat Bellamy with one punch
- When the Going Merry came to Enies Lobby
-
Probably the big CP9 reveal. I had the moment spoiled before getting there, but I forgot part of it and thought that they were all shipwrights. So when Kalifa and Blueno pulled off their masks…
-
You know what's a good recent "WHUH"?? Brooke's connection to you-know-who.
[hide]LABOON IS RELEVANT, BITCHES!![/HIDE]
And Usopp's "advantage" against Perona. -
Captain Brook you should really change your sig, it wides the whole page.
-
When Luffy decked Vivi…lol!
-
@Ao:
When Luffy decked Vivi…lol!
Well, that wasn't shocking, I would have surely knocked some sense in her if I had been in the place of Luffy, even tough her big forehead is freaky. :P
Uhmm..
Most shocking moment?
Smoker being revealed as a Logia of…
Smoke...
Gasp
And Ace being revealed as Luffy's Natural enermy. Bad Shock
And Luffy, Zoro and Sanji being captured so easily by some spiders.
And then, they returning to action...
And Usopp surviving after the Tower of Justice was blasted by the Buster Call, that looked like a promising sacrifice....
-
Basically, the only moments where I went "WHUH??" were when:
- Robin "impaled" Vivi with one of her hands
- Zeff ate his own leg
- The CP9 revealed themselves in Iceburgs room.
-
After looking at the page Rixter posted i got a new "WHUH??" moment…
How the hell did Franky family steal Frankys speedos? They seemto be surgecally attached to his body or something...
I cant really recall any big Whuh?? moments for me. i just read and accept most things (or get pissed about details like robin not beating up the ratspiders)
Guess the biggest whuh?? moment for me would be Alvidas comeback.
(I might come off as an ass about this but everytime i see someone listing Brooks past i cant help but to smile a little =P )
-
Oh yeah, Robin squeezing Franky's balls… He has them? I was thinking they got removed...
-
http://mangarun.com/one_piece/one_piece_372/One_Piece-372-09.png
BEST PAGE IN THE ENTIRE SERIES
That page makes me wonder if Rodin was actually crushing his balls.
1.Nico Robin joining the crew out of no where.
2.Gol D roger went to skypeia.
3.Luffy getting owned by Crocodile twice.Add more later
-
hm… my big "WHUH?!?!" moments... (in chronological order)
1. Luffy is made of rubber?!
2. (Usopp/Kaya arc) The butler really did do it?!
3. The whole Nami Arlong saving the village and stealing money....thing.
4. Wapol eating the boat.
5. Luffy vs. Crocodile Pt. 1 (I was thinking, "Luffy can't die!!")
6. Robin jumping on the boat and asking to join the crew. And then being ACCEPTED.
7. Gan Fall is God?!
8. NOBODY on SkyPier died?!
9. Usopp's LEAVING?!
10. Merry has a soul?! And she came back to life after being thrown off a cliff, while already broken?!
11. The Laboon thing is actually going to be resolved sometime?!...I'm sure there is one or two more, mostly with Water 7 being a really long arc.
-
Mine? Brook being able to poop. Oh, and when Franky was revealed.
-
My biggest "WHUH!?!?" moment was probably what happened to Bellamy. It was so… Quick.
My second biggest was probably (Yes it is Water 7 related)
! The relationship between Franky and Iceberg. I was not expecting that at all.
-
Well, that wasn't shocking, I would have surely knocked some sense in her if I had been in the place of Luffy, even tough her big forehead is freaky. :P
It was to me. When I first saw Luffy start to pummel Vivi, I had no idea what he was thinking!
The Bellamy thing, Robin joining, and Uso Vs. Luffy were all way up there too.
I agree, alot of the story is spoiled because of fans and artwork showing things like Luffy defeating Croc with Storm or Robin as part of the crew. I saw alot of those when I was first introduced to OP. By the time I reached those points in the story, I had forgotten about them,though so not every surprising moment was spoiled.I think if I hadn't seen group shots, Usopp joining would've been a HUGE surprise. I mean he seems really weird looking and doesnt have a special talent for use in the ship or an awesome fighting technique to rely on. It was still kinda surprising when he joined the crew even though I knew he would. Especially since Luffy wanted a super crew and Usopp is anything but super..
-
Luffy saw the potential in him though, and told Kuro as much, IIRC.
For me Mermaid Kokoro is the biggest "Whuh?" moment for me. Also most recently I'd have to say learning Thriller Bark was a big-arse ship.
-
When i discovered that Moria is a shichi' (he is weak and and this saga don't looked so impotent).
When usopp turned out more negative than the negative ghosts XDD
all the zoan fruits on CP9
Capitan Kuro isn't dead?
Vibi doesnt join the crew? -
probably when iceberg went from "Hey I'm just here to see where you are, sand I'ma help these people out with you," to " I guess I should kill her right now"
Then when Luffy's gears first appeared I didn't know what to think. except..
<fanboy>" OMG D: That's Pwness in it's true and pure form!"</fanboy>and then when I saw Zoro being held by Arlong, and Zoro started smiling
(( that's when he became my fave character)) And Arlong was like. " wtf @ this cut O_o "I was like "Whuh?" at first, then I remembered Hawk Eyes and and so it was funny so see arlong look sort of weirded out. :3
-
Oh yeah. I know I'm being ridiculously slow here but it took me like a dozen re-readings to notice the "survivor" of the marine ship Kuro attacked was Morgan and that that's how he got his axe arm, his steel jaw and his high rank. :[
-
When Ms. Wednesday turned out to be a good guy and a princess.
And when I found Pandaman in the baratie supply boat. -
1. Nami being a bitch during the Arlong arc, stealing the boat, the zoro issue etc.
2. Robin joining.
3. Robin leaving.
4. Robins reason for leaving.
5. Merry saving the crew at Enies. -
1.Finding out that luffy had a brother.
2.THE CP9 talking of there mask
3.Robin joining the crew
4.Gear 2 -
1:luffy loosing againts crocidile(first time he lost i thought something like oda was dying and was trying to end the seiries)
2:usopp being sanji,zoro,and franky's only hope against persona.
3:paulie not joining(i figured he and franky would join ex:franky joins like he originaly did and as they leave water 7 paulie uses ROPE ACTION to get on the ship to escape debt collectors.
4. luffy's grandpa being ViceAdmril Garp(thought for sure it would be saul.)
5.Dragon being Luffy'd daddy(even more suprised luffy didnt know his own dad.
-
1. Mermaid Kokoro
2. Kaku's Devil Fruit. Was not expecting a giraffe, but I loved it.
3. Lucci knowing Life Return. This annoyed me as much as it surprised me.
4. Funkfried being a sword
5. Brook. I never expected a talking skeleton, not even on a ghost ship.
6. Enies Lobby's appearance
7. Gear 3I didn't start reading until the Sea Train part, so nothing before that was surprising because I'd read it on sites before I saw the chapters.
-
not exactly WHUH?
the episode where GEAR 2 first appeared and the background music i was like ZOMG WOW!
-
Emm, why the hell are so many people here saying Zeff ate his own leg?!
Maybe I was wrong but I'm pretty damn sure he cut off his leg when he tried saving Sanji and he simply didn't eat anything when they were on that island.EDIT: Alright, I checked now and I'm sure, go watch ep 26 and you can see twice that he cut off his leg to save Sanji (around the 10th minute and then again on the 18th.)
-
theres different versions between the anime and manga. in one he eats his own leg (i think its the anime) thereof the confusion…
-
theres different versions between the anime and manga. in one he eats his own leg (i think its the anime) thereof the confusion…
Alright, I see, I only started reading the manga after Water 7 so.. yeah.
Anyway that pretty damn creepy, I really don't mind the anime version of this thing :/ -
theres different versions between the anime and manga. in one he eats his own leg (i think its the anime) thereof the confusion…
Actually he ate his leg in the manga by hitting off with this big ass rocking. In the anime he gets stuck under water and uses an anchor chain to rip it off.
-
AH yeah i figured i got it wrong when i read what KimiSan wrote. but i didnt think it was important enough to make a note about =P
-
- Usopp; his existence, lack of growth, cowardice which is now being celebrated with his fight against Perona and his overt uselessness, especially now that simple things like "Usopp awhwhwhwhahahahahah" has been made obsolete by Franky Bridge (a full detail, Victorian design bridge available in thirty seconds from any Franky store).
-
stares at sabretooth in disbelif…
quickly takes cover in the closest body of water before the usopp fans begin their flameing =P
-
For me it was when
! we found out that Brook was Laboon's long-lost master!
-
For me it was when
! we found out that Brook was Laboon's long-lost master!
Not master, Nakama.
-
Sadly I was all over the place when I found out the identities of the CP9… so it wasn't a huge "WHUH?!", more of a "OMG! That long nosed guy! He's bad?! NOO! Dang! WTF?! I liked him! I wanted him to join the crew!" (and a bit of OMGOMGOMG!WTF?!)
Biggest "WHUH?!" for me... (considering I wasn't really following the story until about Enies Lobby)... Garp and his relation to Luffy and then Dragon's relation. Definetly.
I'd give almost anything to have experienced the CP9 revealing themselves the way it was meant to be seen...
-
The bounty of Chopper and the bounty posters
Ussop fight Vs Luffy
Afro Luffy
The New body of Coby
Garp being the grandfather of Luffy
Kororo being a… well I cant remember the word "sirena" -
Just remembered a good one:
! Shanks and Buggy were Gol D. Roger's subordinates.
-
10 ton hammer! =P
-
None, nothing was that suprising.