@Count:
Toriko never got beaten? Of course the shonen series with a bland protagonist doesn't get dethroned in the popularity poll. I would think that badass stoic pretty boys like Starjun or Coco would surpass him. I'm quite surprised.
Coco was incredibly absent and bland. If someone was to surpass him I would Zebra for how he was strong and cool and pretty much great at everything(I like Zebra, less than Sani but I do) and he was in the manga for a loooong time. That or Starjun.