@Sereques:
My issue with Becca is currently, she doesn't offer much to the story. Viola got less panel than her and she's been miles useful. I don't know what Oda will do to het in future but so far she's been a waste of space and I will never understand why some like her so much.
It's one thing if people say they dislike Rebecca and/or find her annoying like for example because she didn't won Block D on her own and she just got past it thanks to Rommel ( Personally i think she was able to Dodge most of the Attack thanks to her Speed/Haki but thats another discussion and hasnt really to do with the point i want to make) , or that she was hiding behind Bart & his Barrier … so that are Situations which might let her look weak compared to the other Contesters etc. i can kind of understand it , as those people got a point here. So far she isn't exactly one of my Favorites Characters/Persons of the current Arc either..which might or lets say knowing Oda most likely that will change as the Story continues. And i do get why some People/Reader's do like her , eventhough like i said before , so far she isnt really my favorite Character/Person of the current Arc but it's not like i dont like her infact i do like her , i think she doesent nearly deserve as much hate as she gets from certain Manga Readers, all over the internet/forums/etc.
However how can you seriously say that she doesen't offer much to the story and is a waste of Space/Useless.., sorry but in my opinion that's a totally dumb statement.
I mean Come on are you serious? Are we even reading the same Manga? or havent you read the Manga properly/havent payed attention to the important detail's while reading at all? I dont get it , on what facts do you judge Rebecca the way you did , looking at Rebecca and what we saw& got to know about her until this point of the story, and knowing Oda and the way the Story could continue for her, your statement doesent really make any sense to me. I guess i'll explain Rebecca , her Role and what she is good for in Detail ,extra just for you(of course for all other People who think so aswell) , so you eventually will see how wrong most part of your Statement about her is.. :
First of all Rebecca currently is inside of the Corrida Colosseum , so its not like she is able to do anything outside of the Arena right now , like for example the way Vio did (Saving Sanji , helping Luffy & Zoro to reach Flamingos place , giving them usefull info , etc.). Right now she obviously is bound to the Colosseum as she is in Tournament's Final Match.
Secondly she is a Gladiator so its not like she is contesting for the first time in the Arena just because of the current Tournament.
As we know apparently she play's a bigger Role (in the Colosseum and in the current Arc) on top of that she wears the Title of the "Undefeated Woman". Oda cleverly used her to get the needed backround story infomations and alot infomation about the Colosseum and also abit about the kingdom & royal family that we , the Readers needed to know, that's what i call good Story telling by Oda-Sensei. So thats just one of her Role's in the current arc.
Another Main Reason why Rebecca is contesting , is that she exactly knows that the way she is right now (Strengthwise) she inst strong enough yet and thats why she wants to get stronger , as we know the prize of the current tournament, she of course wants to win & eat the Mera Mera no Mi. She wants to become Stronger for Thunder Soldier, Her Mother's Death most likely also plays a bigger Role on why she wants to get rid of Flamingo. And most likely the Kingdom aswell(if i am not mistaken , we the readers dont exactly know how much rebecca is awere of about the manipilation & brainwashing from Flamingo & Co. and i am to lazy to reread all those Chapters just for that Info right now) So no matter what , she needs/needed to get stronger as there wasnt anybody strong enough to win a fight against Flamingo & Co. She couldnt possibly know(and still if i am not mistaken dont really know) that suddenly there would appear a bunch of strong People (Strawhats & Co.) and on top of that , those will end up helping her & her Family to rescue the Kingdom from Flamingos Hands. Which by the way in my opinion that's the Reason why Becca isnt the one who at the end will eat the Mera Mera no Mi , because now there are People around which are Strong enough to mess with Flamingo & Co. so i dont really see a point anymore why Rebecca would/should be the one eating it , unless Oda really Plans her to become a Strawhat Member or has another important plan/task that she would need that kind of power for it, however thats not what i want to talk about right now.
So if we are looking at her the way she currently is right now(Strengthwise) i wouldnt say that she seems to be Super strong like one of the Bigshots we saw during the Battles ( Jesus Burgess , Sabo(Lucy2) ,Diamante , Bartolomeo , Don Chinjao , Cavendish/Rommel , Luffy, etc.) , i cant see her winning against either one of them , atleast not in a Normal 1vs1 Fight... , however i wouldnt say that Rebecca is weak either or that its impossible for her to win at all , as the Colosseum's Tournament got certain Rules & Possibilitys ( Ring size & form's ) so there is atleast a chance that in fact she might end up winning the whole thing, there is always a way to pull it off. Hell i even think she would be able to win against someone like..Hmmm.. for example Bellamy , or lets say i think she would have a chance to win against him, atleast it seems possible if not in a normal 1vs1 i totally see it happen in a Tournament Battle (Ring out= lose, etc.)
My point is just because someone isnt or dont seem as strong as some others doesent make this Person/Character automatically a waste of space/useless at all. In One Piece(or lets say in good Storys overall) Strength alone isn't what defines how usefull someone is or isnt(uneless its the only important thing and nothin else matters for whatever reason), during the Story so far there are plenty examples which showes that strength alone isnt everything, i will give atleast one good example for that later on. Also If it wasnt for Law , which got annihilated by Flamingo right infront of Luffys , Zoro's & Kinemons eyes. I am pretty sure Rebecca would be just another Reason for Luffy & Co. to go after Flamingo & his underlings , which they more or less were going after to begin with. It really depends how the current match in the Colosseum will end , but its very likely that in the end: Sabo , Bart & Koala(+those of the Rev. Army which might be around or come to join the Party) will end up helping Rebecca (or let's say she will just be another Reason why they will do so). We also got Riku and the other contestants which are currently Toy's but once that spell is gone i am pretty sure almost all/if not all of them will help Riku & his Family aswell as we saw most of them really respect him & the way he was ruling over his Kingdom and the effort he put into other Kingdom's aswell , to keep the peace alive. Another reason why they most likely will be glad to help is to get revenge for being turned into a Toy-Worker-Slave. That also would explain why Oda introduced so many Character's during the Tournament , why most of them are so unique and the uniqueness wont be wasted at all. Damn Oda is just a brilliant Story-teller / Mangaka , he just know what he is doing.. :)!
Secondly Comparing Viola and Rebecca at this point isnt really fair either.They are both doing what they can in their current Situations , which means fulfilling the Roles Oda gave them there.
Some say that by the look of it Vio seems(dont have to be) stronger thn Rebecca , which right now is kind of hard to say because Vio most likely only defeated Sanji due to the well-known fact that he would never injure a woman , and we probably didnt saw her going all out yet , which mean's she could also be capable of using Haki, and in fact she might be a strong/very strong fighter. In my eyes Vio also got a kind of Haxx-like Devil Fruit(Giro Giro no Mi) when it comes to certain Situations, i mean thanks to it she is able to see through everything (X-ray vision) and she is able to read the minds of others, as well as allow others to see into her memories in return. She can even Attack with her Eyes by forming Tears ( just some of the reasons why she also is a good candidate for becoming the next strawhat crewmember , but like i said thats not what i want to discuss right now) . So Thanks to her Devil Fruit Abilitys and thanks to the fact that unlike Rebecca , Vio is outside of the Colosseum , which allows her helping right now it seems that she is more usefull thn Rebecca. Because she had the Opportunity to do so. However that doesent make Rebecca Useless or a waste , we dont know how much of a help or lets say how good of a Support she would be for the Strawhats or the others outside , or what she would be capable of doing there. So lets move on & concentrate to the Infomation's we actually got about her so far instead of talking about nonsense what if's..:
By the look of it Rebecca apparently plays one of the Key- Figures/Roles in this Arc as one of the main Protagonist's. She is a Member of the (former) Royal King's Family and has plenty of Reason's to Crush Flamingo & Co. to Save "her" Kingdom ( i am not sure how much she actually might know and i am to lazy to reread it at the moment to be able to analyze and tell it correctly).
She is the granddaughter of Riku Dold III , which is the former king of Dressrosa before he was dethroned by Donquixote Doflamingo & his Crew.
She is the daugther of Scarlett [ (F.King)Riku Dold's daughter and the elder sister of Vio.]
She is the daughter of Thunder Soldier [which was/is a commander of the Riku Royal Army , he is also the son-in-law of (F.King)Riku Dold III.]
And Viola [which is another daughter of (F.King) Riku Dold III] making her Rebecca's Aunt . It is currently unknown what Rebecca thinks or if he even know of her aunt since no interaction has been shown between the two as of yet.
Apart from Scarlett which was most likealy killed by the Donquixote Pirates all of them play/or will play an important Role in the Current Arc. All of them have the same Goal and it's pretty obviouse that one way or another they all are/or will be usefull , hell so far all of them have been usefull in atleast one way and i am pretty sure they still will be even more usefull as the Story will continue.
In a way you can compare Rebecca to Vivi ( Princess 2.0 ) as there are alot of similarities between those two, and more or less they both play the same Role in their arc's/Kingdoms , there are some diffrences for example Vio is another or let's say the former Princess (which unlike in Vivi's case might be the reason why one of them will be capable of becomeing a Strawhats Crewmember as this time around there are 2 Princesses , so if one stays to take care of the Kingdom the other one is able to leave it as she knows that the Kingdom is in good hands , but thats just my shot in the dark about what could happen and that has nothing to do with the point i want to make with this Post , so i'll keep it for another discussion ;) ).
However… Rebecca and Vivi , both of them may not be the Strongest Fighter's compared to the Top Tier Fighter of each of their Arcs , that alone doesent make them useless at all or how you said it "a waste of space".
Both are extremly brave and they are both willing to risk their own life for their Goals.
Both (want to) stand up against the one Responsible (Crocodile , Flamingo) to clear their (grand)fathers name [the diffrence here is that Vivi wanted to stop the War , while Becca want to get rid of Flamingo, i am not sure about how much she actually knows about the current situation (brainwashing & manipulation) and i am to lazy to reread all chapters just for that info] and by doing that (crushing the main antigonist aka. Crocodile/Flamingo) restoring the peace of their Kingdom's once and for all.
Both going up against powerful enemies despite more or less "clearly" being outmatched in term's of Strength against certain People - The Diffrence here is that by the look of it Rebecca got way more fighting experience, also Becca is very fast and most likely (according to Luffy's/Lucy's Statement) got Kenbunshoku Haki , i almost forgot she even got a Title as the "Undefeated Woman". Just another Reason why i dont get why so many people think she is super weak while in fact she isnt weak she just may/seem/is not as strong as certain other people, that's all.
Both of them are Members of the Royal Family and if i am not mistaken both of them are a Princess of their Kingdom's [eventhough techniclly Rebecca isnt a Princess atm, she should be one once Riku or his Son in Law take the position as the King . not 100% sure how exactly the Royal Family Status/Rank System works but i guess it should be something like that]
Both of them never gave up and both of them mostly dislike expressing their weaknesses around certain others/in certain situations, for example crying ( at some point/situation they of course both did) etc.. The diffrence between those two here is that while almost everybody respected/loved Vivi…Thanks to Flamingos Manipulation's/Brainwashing , almost everybody in the Kingdom dislike/hate Rebecca, and wish she would finally show some blood or that she finally get's killed.
I could've continue this list , but that should be more thn enough to make my point clear.
I am pretty sure in the end Rebecca will have more or less the same Role as Vivi's of course here and there , even though the circumstances are kind of diffrent this time around, for example there are more Royal Family members in the current Arc and of course there are some other diffrences aswell.
Jeez i ended up writing waaaaay more thn i planned to , however that should be more thn enough to make my point clear and to show you that Rebecca actually offers enough to the story , what her Roles are , and that she isnt a waste of space/useless at all.
It should also help you to understand why Some Readers/People do like or even love Rebecca. Because there are enough reasons for doing so ;).
Well that are just my 2 cents about Rebecca & that Situation.