What about merging the remaining series with the Reborn thread instead?
Naruto and Bleach: Let's put this thread to bed I
-
-
Hello all. New article! It features Ichigo getting stangled by his mom.
http://theappliedlogic.blogspot.com/2012/02/attack-from-behind-filler-arc-review-4.html
-
What about merging the remaining series with the Reborn thread instead?
Here's a better question.
What was the point of merging the threads to begin with?
One Piece, Bleach and Naruto are like blood relatives.
The supposed big-3.
The merge is a supposed to be a joke.
A joke to mock "the other two" series.
That's about it.
It's not all about taking every awful thing in this damned sub-forum and combining them into one huge shitpile.
That's just an awful general thread in the making. -
It's not all about taking every awful thing in this damned sub-forum and combining them into one huge shitpile.
Good idea. After this thread hits page 500, it'll become the Naruto/Bleach/Reborn/Fairy Tail/Air Gear/Undead Negima/The Sea thread.
-
@RobbyBevard:
The Sea thread.
I am NOT doing a Play-by-Play of that!
-
It's not all about taking every awful thing in this damned sub-forum and combining them into one huge shitpile.
Why not? Trash is trash.
-
@RobbyBevard:
Good idea. After this thread hits page 500, it'll become the Naruto/Bleach/Reborn/Fairy Tail/Air Gear/Undead Negima/The Sea thread.
It's my idea.
Don't you try taking credit for this. -
Why not? Trash is trash.
Because even though most of those series are trash, there are people who still want to have organized discussion of those series in their own thread, even if most of those threads are nothing but rage.
If you read and keep up with all of those series, that's all well and good, you'll be able to join in any discussion at anytime. But if you don't read/care about a particular series, you have to wade through post after post of nonsense until your particular series becomes relevant again.
I'm personally not a big fan of the merged threads either. I do read and keep up with Naruto, but couldn't care less about Bleach. With this the thread the way it is now, I have to wade through discussion I don't care about to get to the discussion I DO care about.
-
I never read Fairy Tail, what's so bad about it?
It has sucky plots, too many cliches and ass pulls every now and then.
On the other hand, the art is pretty good, the jokes are usually enjoyable and characters are mostly well-written (IMO).
Also, fanservice. Lots and lots of it.
-
I'm personally not a big fan of the merged threads either. I do read and keep up with Naruto, but couldn't care less about Bleach. With this the thread the way it is now, I have to wade through discussion I don't care about to get to the discussion I DO care about.
I'm the same, except I don't care about Naruto but I still keep up with Bleach for its insanity. I'm one of the ones hoping the threads will split back up once this one maxes out. :/
-
I used to be an advocate of adding Fairy Tail (for sheer lulz), but now that I've dropped that series (out of sheer boredom) and with Naruto on the way out I think we should split the threads back up again.
-
So, like, I never commented here but I've been lurking.
The third FT thread just started while Naruto and Bleach had many threads before merging. We should give it time and when the moment comes, if it's the best decision to take, merge it too. Until then, leave it alone.
-
@Cuddles:
I am NOT doing a Play-by-Play of that!
What is The Sea?
-
What is The Sea?
A macrocosm of Not.
And with that that will be the only thing I say about that matter here.
-
-
I guess he's a user.
Not a very popular one, I presume.
The Sea?
Who the hell is that?
There's no such member on the forums.
-
I vaguely remember that name. But not what sort of poster they were…I think.
-
Children of the Sea? City in the Sea? Genghis Khan: To The Ends Of The Earth And The Sea?
That's what I found when I tried looking. I'm really curious now. :[
-
Children of the Sea? City in the Sea? Genghis Khan: To The Ends Of The Earth And The Sea?
That's what I found when I tried looking. I'm really curious now. :[[/QUOTE]
He was nominated for some categories in the AP Awards section. That's all I know.
-
Tsukishima sama, who is this sea they speak of?
-
I distinctly recall "Sea" (short for Seabiscuit, I believe) being the codename given to a Vietnamese philosopher who struggled to end racial apartheid, smuggling clown midgets out of Berlin….only to take his last breath in a brutal confrontation with a particularly angry badger....one of the many historical legends passed down the family tree during my grandfather's time (along with a dusty, 5¢ piece of licorice).....
but WHO WAS PHONE?
-
Hello all. New article! It features Ichigo getting stangled by his mom.
http://theappliedlogic.blogspot.com/2012/02/attack-from-behind-filler-arc-review-4.html
Hearing that brings me such joy.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Because even though most of those series are trash, there are people who still want to have organized discussion of those series in their own thread, even if most of those threads are nothing but rage.
Exactly my thoughts, just organised better :D
But still, Bleach is hilarious in how bad it is, wouldn't you enjoy that too ?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
I never read Fairy Tail, what's so bad about it?
What King Cannon says, plus Hiro's retcons are on part with Kubo.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Children of the Sea? City in the Sea? Genghis Khan: To The Ends Of The Earth And The Sea?
That's what I found when I tried looking. I'm really curious now. :[[/QUOTE]
He was/is called The Sea. He's a guy from Vietnam and I think people disliked some of his more extreme opinions and I believe he's banned.
-
This is The Sea
….......... -
I support the idea of splitting this thread once it reaches 500 pages. It was some great fun but one version of it should be enough for now.
-
Thank you guys for elucidating the Yellow Flash parenting skills. Seems a bit like circular logic with the whole destined child thing. Minato just has a hunch Naruto is the destined child, and therefore gives him the Kyuubi-which is what has made him the destined child.
I don't really see the point of a unified thread, since any actual "cross talk" or comparisons between Bleach and Naruto is few and far between. At most people will just make a post in two parts:
"Naruto was….And Bleach was..."
It doesn't contribute much more than a lot of posts that need to be skipped for the people who only want to discuss one of the series.
-
I'm all for the thread merging. It helps clear up space and more importantly it greatly cheapens the value of the respective series to the level they deserve. Because neither of them deserve a thread because they haven't earned one. Get Fairy Tail in here too because that series is terrible and shouldn't be given the privilege of having its own thread.
-
I cast my vote keep threads merged until one of series ends. I love how we can mock them together. And if someone wants discussions of one manga in more coordinated tone I saw no problems so far. Besides, having such thread on forum I frequent makes me feel "special" and "unique snowflake".
-
I've given my say a few times already in this thread about merging with the Fairy Tail discussion. So I won't go any further into why I think that's a bad idea.
Not that we have to worry about that yet anyways. Both Naruto and Bleach are in their final arcs (with Naruto likely ending sooner than Bleach) but neither are over just yet. If there's still a strong feeling about thread merging when a series ends let's cross that bridge once we get there.
So the entire Madara vs Kages fight is going to be entirely offpanel like the Swordsmen then? How disappointing.
-
guys I think juju is kishi, who else could love naruto so much as to not see it's flaws, and be so in love with sasuke
the way he gets back at us for banning him is by doing absurd things we made fun of like the ten tails or not showing rock lee
no one could love naruto that much
-
I forgot, is the fight with swordsmen already done, or it's still going offscreen? And that ginormous sealing statue - is it still there on the beach, or has it suddenly warped to madara to deal with bijuu, leaving Shikamaru and others in dust and mystery?
-
So about naruto, I was thinking about kishi's execution of the war and one thing that could have made it better is if the other villages were shown a little more prior to the war… We got the sand village for the beginning of part 2, but I mean something similar to how the fillers do, an arc or 2 centered around new villages would have been cool. I feel like the ninja world went from leaf village to worldwide without any exposition.
We got the rain with Jaraiya but still... This is a world war going on in the manga but it feels like there new character and villages just came out of nowhere.
-
I know the Naruto thread has delved into some crazy topics in the past but this is ridiculous.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
So about naruto, I was thinking about kishi's execution of the war and one thing that could have made it better is if the other villages were shown a little more prior to the war… We got the sand village for the beginning of part 2, but I mean something similar to how the fillers do, an arc or 2 centered around new villages would have been cool. I feel like the ninja world went from leaf village to worldwide without any exposition.
We got the rain with Jaraiya but still... This is a world war going on in the manga but it feels like there new character and villages just came out of nowhere.
Yeah, someone mentioned before how only 2 villages got any real exposure before Part 2 (Konoha and the Sand Village). The Hidden Mist village got moderate exposure thanks to the Haku and Zabuza Arc. The rest of the villages we only heard about and then they were thrusted into the limelight halfway through Part 2 and we still don't know as much about them. That's why they just seem so hamfisted even though they're supposed be so important to the politics and nature of the world.
-
@Thousand:
I'm all for the thread merging. It helps clear up space and more importantly it greatly cheapens the value of the respective series to the level they deserve. Because neither of them deserve a thread because they haven't earned one. Get Fairy Tail in here too because that series is terrible and shouldn't be given the privilege of having its own thread.
This is a message board for general manga. What the hell is this?
-
This is a message board for general manga. What the hell is this?
Only good manga should get threads. Bad manga should be left to rot in obscurity. Where they can't hurt people with their stupid.
-
@Thousand:
Only good manga should get threads. Bad manga should be left to rot in their obscurity.
Says the hapless Negima fan.
-
Says the hapless Negima fan.
Negima isn't bad by any stretch of the imagination and it's about a thousand times better than Fairy Fail so my point still stands.
-
I know the Naruto thread has delved into some crazy topics in the past but this is ridiculous.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Yeah, someone mentioned before how only 2 villages got any real exposure before Part 2 (Konoha and the Sand Village). The Hidden Mist village got moderate exposure thanks to the Haku and Zabuza Arc. The rest of the villages we only heard about and then they were thrusted into the limelight halfway through Part 2 and we still don't know as much about them. That's why they just seem so hamfisted even though they're supposed be so important to the politics and nature of the world.
I feel like that's one of the things that separates kishimoto from the greats, in my opinion, he doesn't show the scope of the world that he created effectively. For the sake of comparison, Oda would have spent a couple chapters establishing these villages Arcs before the war even happened, Not necessarily giving us a shit
Ton of characters to cause confusion, but just to show what's what and give the reader an idea of where these villages stand in the ninja world.To go from -hidden village in the leaves- to -holy crap world war!?- doesn't do the manga any good, I give his credit for the execution of the Kage world summit arc but it would have been way better if we had prior knowledge of these kages and ninja coming from these different places.
-
@Thousand:
Negima isn't bad by any stretch of the imagination and it's about a thousand times better than Fairy Fail so my point still stands.
Says the hapless Negima fan.
-
Ad hominems don't help your point and only make you look stupid and lazy.
-
Well the thunder village was mentioned in Neji's flashback.
-
@Thousand:
Ad hominems don't help your point and only make you look stupid and lazy.
I've stated my point countless times already. Want me to be tedious and unbarring like yourself?
-
Says the guy who threw the first stone. If you've got nothing but pointless diatribes and silly, oudated images to post, then don't post anything. Otherwise go ahead and make some worthwhile points. This is what this thread is here for after all.
-
Hiroy. Lion. Both of you shut up.
Says the mod, not the nice guy.
-
edit: Whoop. My bad Robby. I'll play with my lion elsewhere.
@Thousand:
Says the guy who threw the first stone. If you've got nothing but pointless diatribes and silly, oudated images to post, then don't post anything. Otherwise go ahead and make some worthwhile points. This is what this thread is here for after all.
I asked what's the point of merging threads in a forum made for general manga.
And as it still stands, it's not all that convincing.
Personally, I think it's completely unnecessary. Just like several other members including myself have already stated.
To you, it's probably a "why not?" idea.
Afterall, the Naruto and Bleach threads are merged. As a joke no less.
We might as well exhaust this joke to a point where it's completely unfunny.Oh yeah! That's probably why you are convinced that this is the great idea. Everything else is just grasping at the straws.
-
@Thousand:
Only good manga should get threads.
This sounds like a brilliant idea. I'm all for throwing Naruto, Bleach, Reborn, Fairy Tail, and Negima in the same thread.
What's that? You say Negima is good? Could it be… an opinion!? Nah, there's no such thing as subjectivity. Let's let one guy determine what's good and what's bad and lump everything they don't like into one thread.
Because there certainly aren't any good, intelligent, and respectable members that like Fairy Tail or Negima, that manage to make those threads more than just constant and tedious mockery of the series in question.
-
Please, don't merge the Fairy Tail with this one.
@Thousand:
Only good manga should get threads. Bad manga should be left to rot in obscurity. Where they can't hurt people with their stupid.
The Naruto and Bleach threads were merged for very good reasons, but there's a large group of us that would like to discuss Fairy Tail without having to go through what's in this thread.
And haven't we already sufficiently proven it wasn't a popular idea twice already?
Maybe when there's a better reason than a few vocal readers wanting to make a point about taste. When the Fairy Tail THREAD is as bad as the Naruto and Bleach THREADS, maybe then it's time to talk mergers.It's not like the Narublech threads where NOBODY liked the manga. I don't think the manga is good, but that isn't cause to ruin it for the members who do.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
It's a Triple Tech!
-
Hey, I'm all for opinion. But when you have a manga with the general consensus of being horrible due to its terrible chapters rife with ass pulls, bland characters, poorly executed ideas to the point that it gets its own worst chapter poll well…why the hell not?
But go ahead, merge it too, actually that would have been interesting if it wasn't ending in 3 weeks anyway.
-
@RobbyBevard:
Hiroy. Lion. Both of you shut up.
Says the mod, not the nice guy.
Can I still ask something about this ? What the hell is up with Hancock and Colonel Sanders ? O_O