This post is deleted!
Chapter 633: Friend or Foe
-
This post is deleted!
-
I listened to Guile's theme when Luffy attacked Hody. That theme really does go with everything!
And when Luffy kicke Hodi: SONIC BOOM!
-
Ummm if it was sent by hands we would see the hands transporting keys I didn't see that. So by your logic you are wrong as well. I could be wrong too but it would be cool if Robin can clone objects now too :D Also I think it was drawn in different panels because the locks are small and and if Oda drew the whole scene it would have been too much work.
If she could clone items it would be an entirely different fruit. I believe that she might have taken the keys wityh her hands off of one of the new Fishmen Pirates, then transported them through her hand.
-
If she could clone items it would be an entirely different fruit. I believe that she might have taken the keys wityh her hands off of one of the new Fishmen Pirates, then transported them through her hand.
If she can clone her clothing then it's not a far step for her to clone what she is touching.
-
Clothing is 'special' in One Piece. It follows it's own rules, as Oda once mentioned. The actual reason is the target group of the manga.
-
If she can clone her clothing then it's not a far step for her to clone what she is touching.
I'm sorry If I missed something, but when does she clone her clothing?
-
Good chapter but if this was Jinbes plan, what was the point of him and Luffy fighting? I thought Jinbe didn't want Luffy to fight Hodi! Did I miss something?
-
Good chapter but if this was Jinbes plan, what was the point of him and Luffy fighting? I thought Jinbe didn't want Luffy to fight Hodi! Did I miss something?
They probably talked it over after their little clash and Jinbe had the idea.
-
If she can clone her clothing then it's not a far step for her to clone what she is touching.
Actually, if you take a look at the page again, give the panels a closer look. The keys are not identical. Besides, as Urouge mentioned, she would have freed Jinbe at the same time if she did clone the keys.
On a related note, Nami's mirages can pass on to cover others beside herself. (If Robin is also covered, it explains why she can pass the keys around without detection.) And we really need an explanation to how that new Clima Tact works. I don't see any openings in it.
I'm sorry If I missed something, but when does she clone her clothing?
Why would you expect her to make a full-body clone without clothes?
-
Last page i would say sanji looked the coolest.
-
-
Cnet 's translation of chapter 633:
http://mangahelpers.com/t/cnet128/releases/30677 -
**did luffy use full gear 2nd or not ?????
**
-
Ummm if it was sent by hands we would see the hands transporting keys I didn't see that. So by your logic you are wrong as well. I could be wrong too but it would be cool if Robin can clone objects now too :D Also I think it was drawn in different panels because the locks are small and and if Oda drew the whole scene it would have been too much work.
It would be cool but she can't "clone" the things she touches.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Totally agree with you mate i brought this up earlier on in this thread Hody was correct in calling the princes stupid because it was stupid the truth didnt belong to her it belonged to the island so instead of the island hating hody they disliked the humans even more, also i notice this level of stupidity in naruto aswell. and as a said earlier if the people of the island knew that it wasn't a human that killed there queen they would be a good chance they would be living with the humans right about now.
If my sister or daughter secretly knew who killed my mum but didn't say anything even while i was interacting with the killer i would be pretty pissed.Ditto bro, I find this whole Shira's issue to be…quite retarded. Yeah, it was kind of a plot device that can be attributed to Shira's naiveness (and uberstupidness) but, it was just too much and quite illogical.
-
Ummm if it was sent by hands we would see the hands transporting keys I didn't see that. So by your logic you are wrong as well. I could be wrong too but it would be cool if Robin can clone objects now too :D Also I think it was drawn in different panels because the locks are small and and if Oda drew the whole scene it would have been too much work.
That's not even the suggestion I quoted. The suggestion was that she threw them.
And it wasn't even drawn in different panels. There's ONE PANEL in which the princes are already free and Neptune is currently being freed at the same time. http://www.mangareader.net/one-piece/633/13
-
Is there a chance that all the locks have different keys and she just took all the keys?
-
Anybody else read the look on Ryuuboshi and Manboshi's faces as "You knew?! Then we didn't have to act like fools for the past seven years?!" The first time I read this chapter, that's exactly what I saw.
-
First of all, I just want to say that I would hate if Jinbe joined the SHs. Personally, I like it when potential members are more like an underdog in the present situation and we all know Jinbe is no underdog. I'd rather they be relatively unknown to the rest of the world, not someone who was in charge of his own crew and worked with the WG. I know that that is more difficult now more than ever since the SHs have become so infamous, but it's always possible. I don't believe Jinbe belongs with them.
With the Shirahoshi case, people need to remember she was SIX! Imagine having a little sister like that, or maybe a niece. Her mother told her not to hate whoever her killer was. Maybe if Shirahoshi saw the murderer herself, she would tell everyone, but she didn't. She understood her mother and followed her wishes like the innocent girl that she is. Only a little later did Megalo probably decide to tell her, and by then, she had had time to ponder what her mother had said. As you can see, I don't think this was bad storytelling.:happy:
And finally, with the Robin replicating items thing, I really like the idea of whoever said the item disappears once she lets go of it. It would definitely fix the problem of having the crew repeatedly selling their treasure for profit. The problem is that I don't think Oda would go down this route, but I like it. It's definitely possible. Maybe once she holds something, the DF considers it part of her and allows her to make copies of it as well. Or maybe, since her ability is based off of plants, the replication of items can allude to the idea of plants reproducing asexually or something (with her body part and the key being the "parents"), but that usually results in something that has characteristics of both parents, in which case you would get a fusion of Robin's arm and the key, which makes no sense and is actually starting to confuse me. Anyway, I just wanted to get that off my chest. Goodnight!
-
First of all, I just want to say that I would hate if Jinbe joined the SHs. Personally, I like it when potential members are more like an underdog in the present situation and we all know Jinbe is no underdog. I'd rather they be relatively unknown to the rest of the world, not someone who was in charge of his own crew and worked with the WG. I know that that is more difficult now more than ever since the SHs have become so infamous, but it's always possible. I don't believe Jinbe belongs with them.
With the Shirahoshi case, people need to remember she was SIX! Imagine having a little sister like that, or maybe a niece. Her mother told her not to hate whoever her killer was. Maybe if Shirahoshi saw the murderer herself, she would tell everyone, but she didn't. She understood her mother and followed her wishes like the innocent girl that she is. Only a little later did Megalo probably decide to tell her, and by then, she had had time to ponder what her mother had said. As you can see, I don't think this was bad storytelling.:happy:
And finally, with the Robin replicating items thing, I really like the idea of whoever said the item disappears once she lets go of it. It would definitely fix the problem of having the crew repeatedly selling their treasure for profit. The problem is that I don't think Oda would go down this route, but I like it. It's definitely possible. Maybe once she holds something, the DF considers it part of her and allows her to make copies of it as well. Or maybe, since her ability is based off of plants, the replication of items can allude to the idea of plants reproducing asexually or something (with her body part and the key being the "parents"), but that usually results in something that has characteristics of both parents, in which case you would get a fusion of Robin's arm and the key, which makes no sense and is actually starting to confuse me. Anyway, I just wanted to get that off my chest. Goodnight!
I very much agree with your Shirahoshi reasoning, she was a little girl who didn't know squat about the world, and not only that Megalo told her long after the anitial shock of it all.
As for Jinbe he is an underdog. In the grand scheme of the One Piece worlds race relations he is a major underdog.
-
Hehe, that's a fun idea, but not quite how the fruit works. Even if she did clone the keys using her power the cloned copy ceases to exist the moment she stops using her power. Although, if she can clone objects, what would happen in the scenario where the cloned object was destroyed. Such as when Kizaru destroys the key in Luffys hand. Going by the rest of her power she would lose the original as well.
Actually in theory she should be able to clone the keys. If she knows the shape of the key she could clone her bones in this shape thus making a nice pair of bone keys. Also in theory if she trains her DF ability to an absurd degree she could not only heal herself but also restore any part of her body by simply cloning enough of her cells although of course I doubt Oda will go for this(still hoping he goes for a Robin being able to turn into a giant thing though. This would be awesome and pretty much the only way the SH can have a giant on their crew)
-
-
First of all, I just want to say that I would hate if Jinbe joined the SHs. Personally, I like it when potential members are more like an underdog in the present situation and we all know Jinbe is no underdog. I'd rather they be relatively unknown to the rest of the world, not someone who was in charge of his own crew and worked with the WG. I know that that is more difficult now more than ever since the SHs have become so infamous, but it's always possible. I don't believe Jinbe belongs with them.
I agree, but I also think Jinbe won't join the SHs because he is twice their age and crews seem to all be about the same. Brook being an exception. I would think if they get a Fishman/Merman(woman), they would be around 20-ish like everyone else.
-
Also anybody else notice how similar Luffy introducing himself to Hody Jones is to to Arlong?
Both times Luffy sent their asses crashing into a building.
Whether it's intentional or not I thought it was pretty neat.Wow, just wow. Thats about all I can say.
I knew Oda's art progressed a lot throughout the series, but after seeing those 2 pages I now see how much and its simply astounding. The amount of detail he puts into everything is just insane and this goes to show you just how much he cares about One Piece and how much hard work and dedication he puts into this series.
Man this series has grown so damn much its mind blowing.
-
Jinbei is 46, he's not that old. Franky's 36 now, which makes him the second oldest (of course, it's hard to beat a 90 year old man, even though He's only 52 in his second life).
-
Good chapter but if this was Jinbes plan, what was the point of him and Luffy fighting? I thought Jinbe didn't want Luffy to fight Hodi! Did I miss something?
You didn't "miss" anything, but we are not privy to why/how Jinbe and Luffy came to an agreement as of yet. I imagine that it will be dealt with in a flashback in an upcoming chapter.
My personal assumption is that Nami gave them both a good whack over the head and brokered a deal that resulted in their current strategy…
-
Regarding the princses its one thing not holding any resentment towards the killer but when you let the killer go scott free and not tell anyone then thats another thing what her mum said was to not hate the killer. Not to let him go unpunished and unchecked and having a proven killer lurking around citizens fair enough you chose not to hate him but don't go deciding on who deserves to no the truth she she held the truth that did not belong to her to cover for a murderer where i come from thats a criminal offence.
And finely just to let you no how stupid it was instead of hating the real killer she let everyone hate a innocent human that did not kill her mother thus making human and fishmen tension even higher to the point where they decided not to attend the reverie To be honest i believe if she told on hody the fishmen and humans could be living together.–- Update From New Post Merge ---
It would be cool but she can't "clone" the things she touches.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Ditto bro, I find this whole Shira's issue to be...quite retarded. Yeah, it was kind of a plot device that can be attributed to Shira's naiveness (and uberstupidness) but, it was just too much and quite illogical.
Glad to no someone agrees.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
I agree
Who do you think'll fight Hody??Not a clue he so uninspiring i can't imagine luffy fighting him. Probabaly jimbei.
-
Jinbe's 46? god he's old…...
anywho I'm really bothered by Caribou;;; him and his Logia abilities..
-
But Jinbe has a big reason to stick with Luffy. Ace's last wish. Ace told him to take care of Luffy and that was kind of a testament to Jinbe. And we all know he is nothing pride. It wouldn't be out of character if he goes: "I can't forgive myself if something were to happen you while i am alive"
And as a fishman he's got background linking with Nami. He might wanna sacrifice his life from now on to heal the wounds Arlong and his crew made. I actually think if we don't get to see these two sentences from Jinbe. That would be weird. I actually think this way.I think Luffy will decide if Jinbe is going to join or not. Unless he gets stubborn with the first reason.
But there are reasons why Jinbe shouldn't join and they are very legit. We all agree that he is so powerfull to join the crew. And we all want our Monster Trio to stay solid. Unless they all surpassed Jinbe but that would be weird too. They might have been on par with him. But I don't see Sanji right now more powerfull than Jinbe.
And about Caribou… I wonder if his ability holds the power to suck Noah. Noir.
-
Maybe at the end of the arc Jimbei does joins the Strawhats and Luffy anounces that the island is now protected by the Strawhat pirates, so Jimbei stays there to protect it ;)
-
I wouldn't be opposed to Jinbe joining the crew. If Oda has shown anything pre-timeskip, it is that while Shichibukai are strong, they tend to get their asses kicked by the Yonkou or their commanders. Luffy turning a former Shichibukai into his nakama - I think it would perfectly set the tone for the New World. During the war, all the higher up marines going 'Omg, Luffy is going to be a danger! Kill him before he gets stronger!' sorta felt as an over-exagguration when you've got a full Yonkou fleet in front of you. With the New World putting the spotlight on the Revolutionaries and the Yonkou, and hell, even add Vegapunk and his mecha army to that, and you can quickly see that Luffy's crew needs the extra pair of hands to appear as a serious threat to warrant all the extra attention. Add in that Jinbe has been portrayed as a follower/protector for the entire manga (compared to other Shichibukai who were all very enterprising), and that after this arc he'll very likely run out of things to protect (being in Fishman Island will just invite the Marine's to invade to get back at him!) he'll most likely join Luffy.
And if that does not convince you, let me put it this way. Revival-man. Man-deer. Cyborg. Hell, even an archeologist, a princess and a liar. Luffy's a sucker for the weirdos, and a former Shichibukai fishman is a nice addition to the collection.
-
Ditto bro, I find this whole Shira's issue to be…quite retarded. Yeah, it was kind of a plot device that can be attributed to Shira's naiveness (and uberstupidness) but, it was just too much and quite illogical.
Except it's not a plot device at all, as it doesn't alter the plot in the slightest. The obvious alternative, nobody seeing anything, leaves the plot in the same place that it is now. It was just characterization.
-
I wouldn't be opposed to Jinbe joining the crew. If Oda has shown anything pre-timeskip, it is that while Shichibukai are strong, they tend to get their asses kicked by the Yonkou or their commanders. Luffy turning a former Shichibukai into his nakama - I think it would perfectly set the tone for the New World. During the war, all the higher up marines going 'Omg, Luffy is going to be a danger! Kill him before he gets stronger!' sorta felt as an over-exagguration when you've got a full Yonkou fleet in front of you. With the New World putting the spotlight on the Revolutionaries and the Yonkou, and hell, even add Vegapunk and his mecha army to that, and you can quickly see that Luffy's crew needs the extra pair of hands to appear as a serious threat to warrant all the extra attention. Add in that Jinbe has been portrayed as a follower/protector for the entire manga (compared to other Shichibukai who were all very enterprising), and that after this arc he'll very likely run out of things to protect (being in Fishman Island will just invite the Marine's to invade to get back at him!) he'll most likely join Luffy.
And if that does not convince you, let me put it this way. Revival-man. Man-deer. Cyborg. Hell, even an archeologist, a princess and a liar. Luffy's a sucker for the weirdos, and a former Shichibukai fishman is a nice addition to the collection.
I agreed, Jinbe being a protector towards Luffy….reminds me of that promise that Ace asking Jinbe to look after Luffy during the Impel Down arc or is it, during the Marineford arc.
If Jinbei "did" joined the Straw Hat Pirates, then possibly he would be the 2nd Straw Hat crewmember who has been a first mate and also a 2nd captain of his former crew, also lose a loved one (Fisher Tiger) in his flashback, the first being Brook.
Also, if Jinbe is in, I don't know what Oda is going to talk about him in SBS when someone ask him about what family status is he like? An uncle or a godfather?
-
No1 asked what are they going to choose friend or foe?
-
I'm so ready for adventure now! So much that it's almost sad… I think I'll go down to the beach a kick some waves now (even though they are only baby waves)!
-
Regarding the princses its one thing not holding any resentment towards the killer but when you let the killer go scott free and not tell anyone then thats another thing what her mum said was to not hate the killer. Not to let him go unpunished and unchecked and having a proven killer lurking around citizens fair enough you chose not to hate him but don't go deciding on who deserves to no the truth she she held the truth that did not belong to her to cover for a murderer where i come from thats a criminal offence.
And finely just to let you no how stupid it was instead of hating the real killer she let everyone hate a innocent human that did not kill her mother thus making human and fishmen tension even higher to the point where they decided not to attend the reverie To be honest i believe if she told on hody the fishmen and humans could be living together.But being the young and naive girl that she is, she found that the best way to make sure the killer is not hated is by not telling anyone. I agree with the idea of the incident ruining relations between humans and fishfolk, but it was a difficult choice that Shirahoshi had to make that worked with HER character and made sense with HER character. I think it was perfectly believable that someone like Shirahoshi did this, and just because you wouldn't do the same doesn't make the decision any more wrong. I don't know what you mean by "the truth that did not belong to her". Who does it belong to then? It's not some valuable prized possession, it's an intangible knowledge that she is allowed to have if she wants it. Basically, I'm trying to say that "not hating" the criminal and "convicting" the criminal are very much connected. This was one exception to a murder where the guilty party was to be forgiven for their actions and it perfectly outlines her character. Forgiveness is sometimes needed, and I guess she felt that her mother was right by this. And remember, no one knew what Hody was planning. She may have thought that it was easier to forgive him because he probably doesn't usually act the way that he did.
If Jinbei "did" joined the Straw Hat Pirates, then possibly he would be the 2nd Straw Hat crewmember who has been a first mate and also a 2nd captain of his former crew, also lose a loved one (Fisher Tiger) in his flashback, the first being Brook.
I might be wrong, but i don't remember Brook ever being the first mate of his crew or even taking over the role of captain, but I don't remember the back story that well either, so I don't know.
-
Am i the only one that thinks this line is a foreshadowing having something to do with Nami character development…...
http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/71794722/5 (Jimbe top 2 panels)
-
Am i the only one that thinks this line is a foreshadowing having something to do with Nami character development…...
http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/71794722/5 (Jimbe top 2 panels)
I don't see it..
-
I might be wrong, but i don't remember Brook ever being the first mate of his crew or even taking over the role of captain, but I don't remember the back story that well either, so I don't know.
I find when I am in doubt of something quickly fact checking helps - there are many sites that can assist with this - even the One Piece Wiki will give you a grain of truth regardless of its presentation. Yes Brook was believed to be First mate and did end up being captain of the Rhumbar Pirates after Yorki's illness.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
I don't see it..
While the similarities are there - I am not sure Nami could not hate Arlong if that is where he is going - pretty heavy stuff there but yeah it could be forshadowing especially when Jinbei asks "Who could possibly even try to be like her"
-
I agreed, Jinbe being a protector towards Luffy….reminds me of that promise that Ace asking Jinbe to look after Luffy during the Impel Down arc or is it, during the Marineford arc.
If Jinbei "did" joined the Straw Hat Pirates, then possibly he would be the 2nd Straw Hat crewmember who has been a first mate and also a 2nd captain of his former crew, also lose a loved one (Fisher Tiger) in his flashback, the first being Brook.
Also, if Jinbe is in, I don't know what Oda is going to talk about him in SBS when someone ask him about what family status is he like? An uncle or a godfather?
That is one of the bigger arguments against Jinbe I think, but just as you said it can be as simple as uncle.
-
Am i the only one that thinks this line is a foreshadowing having something to do with Nami character development…...
http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/71794722/5 (Jimbe top 2 panels)
I'd agree, if it wasn't for the fact that no one asked Nami to forgive Arlong. He was a complete a-hole, and I don't see Nami forgiving him.
I find when I am in doubt of something quickly fact checking helps - there are many sites that can assist with this - even the One Piece Wiki will give you a grain of truth regardless of its presentation. Yes Brook was believed to be First mate and did end up being captain of the Rhumbar Pirates after Yorki's illness.
Oh, okay, so he did become captain, but I found multiple sources that refer to him only as "a musician" when Yorki was still alive. It doesn't matter though, it has nothing to do with the chapter so I'll just stop talking about it.
-
I'd agree, if it wasn't for the fact that no one asked Nami to forgive Arlong. He was a complete a-hole, and I don't see Nami forgiving him.
me neither,she already siad that doesn't matter what happens, she won't feel and shrend the compassion towards Arlong.
http://www.mangafox.com/manga/one_piece/v59/c620/13.html -
But being the young and naive girl that she is, she found that the best way to make sure the killer is not hated is by not telling anyone. I agree with the idea of the incident ruining relations between humans and fishfolk, but it was a difficult choice that Shirahoshi had to make that worked with HER character and made sense with HER character. I think it was perfectly believable that someone like Shirahoshi did this, and just because you wouldn't do the same doesn't make the decision any more wrong. I don't know what you mean by "the truth that did not belong to her". Who does it belong to then? It's not some valuable prized possession, it's an intangible knowledge that she is allowed to have if she wants it. Basically, I'm trying to say that "not hating" the criminal and "convicting" the criminal are very much connected. This was one exception to a murder where the guilty party was to be forgiven for their actions and it perfectly outlines her character. Forgiveness is sometimes needed, and I guess she felt that her mother was right by this. And remember, no one knew what Hody was planning. She may have thought that it was easier to forgive him because he probably doesn't usually act the way that he did.
I might be wrong, but i don't remember Brook ever being the first mate of his crew or even taking over the role of captain, but I don't remember the back story that well either, so I don't know.
I said withholding evidence about a murder is a criminal offence um i wrong. So when i say the truth dosen't belong to her in that inccident it dosent someone was killed and that someone happened to be her mother she is obligated to give evidence as she was not the only party effected by the event her brothers were effected her dad the citizens and of course her mother. Her mothers final wish was to not hate the killer she did not say to let the killer go scott free and unchecked so at the end of the day instead of hating hody fishman island ended up hating a innocent human so all she did was to take the hate of someone who deserved it and give it to someone who didnt.
She effectively help ruin a innocent humans life. -
The human was dead long before Shirahoshi even knew about Hodi. She aint ruined no innocent humans life. The human was killed the day of the incident.
-
I said withholding evidence about a murder is a criminal offence um i wrong. So when i say the truth dosen't belong to her in that inccident it dosent someone was killed and that someone happened to be her mother she is obligated to give evidence as she was not the only party effected by the event her brothers were effected her dad the citizens and of course her mother. Her mothers final wish was to not hate the killer she did not say to let the killer go scott free and unchecked so at the end of the day instead of hating hody fishman island ended up hating a innocent human so all she did was to take the hate of someone who deserved it and give it to someone who didnt.
She effectively help ruin a innocent humans life.You're right, she didn't say let the killer go free, but if she did tell everyone, then Hody would be hated, which is what her mother said she didn't want to happen. She was 6, and at that point, she didn't know what the best decision was, she probably thought that ignoring it would make her hate him less, and therefore her mother would be happy. I'm sure that now, she wouldn't have done the same, but back then, she probably thought it was best. Remember, even now, she is extremely naive, so imagine Shirahoshi at age 6. I'm not saying that her decision was perfectly logical, and I would never do what she did, but I don't believe that Oda's storytelling was bad in this instance, because it is believable for someone like Shirahoshi to do what she did. That's my point.
-
me neither,she already siad that doesn't matter what happens, she won't feel and shrend the compassion towards Arlong.
http://www.mangafox.com/manga/one_piece/v59/c620/13.htmlShe said "I don't plan on" unless thats a translation thing. I'm just saying it isn't too late for Arlong to come back somehow. But ignoring Arlong completely, Nami was the only one physically there at outside miraged and so she definitely saw what Shirahoshi endured. I'm just saying after Hodis done, Nami might go through some change
-
Does anyone think there's a possibility that Jimbei will try to stop Luffy from fighting Hodi again? Because I'm certain that Luffy will finish Hodi but at the same time I'm not quite sure that Luffy convinced Jimbei to let him fight Hodi. Then again Luffy may have fought Jimbei again before getting Jimbei to go along with the plan to hide Luffy in Megalo's mouth. I just can't help but wonder where Jimbei will fit in this situation since Hodi is the only person I can see him fighting, unless he and Luffy get into a fight over who'll fight Hodi while Hodi is currently incapacitated.
-
Just read the chapter.
Huh, someone last week predicted that someone might be hiding in Megalo. Good for them.
In other news….I'm sorry, but I have to agree with Hodi that Shirahoshi made a terrible, stupid mistake. You don't have to hate Hodi to turn him in and protect your island from his madness. The only upside to all this is that Jinbei won't have to worry about Luffy making humans looking bad for butting in, since now they want him to come in.
As far as the chapter's plus side goes, I loved Luffy's 'You decide!' statement and that double page spread. You know, even if he doesn't join, Jinbei looks like he might just fit in there. -
Good bad, stupid smart.. Haven't we all make similar mistakes?
Making decision based on what we believe or were taught to be right.. Only to see our foolishness when we are wiser, more knowledgeable or mature.Anyway its a common plot device.
At 6 years old her mum was her world, her kind & innocent soul held on to her mother's last words.
Although her decision was the cause of the current situation, although you will FEEL that she was dumb, she is not to be blamed.If you save a man from drowning, then later the man happen to knock down & kill your girlfriend.. You will blame yourself but everyone knows its a case of "if I knew.."
Shirahoshi at 6 is the same. If she knew.. Well we wouldn't have a story yeah?Hurray for characters making decisions tat are good & pure in intent but indirectly/directly aiding the villains! Never fails to stir emotions!
-
Plus, there was the whole thing with them being caught be her being fooled by a obvious trap. Shirahoshi's a good girl, but she's perhaps ditzier then Luffy.
-
You're right, she didn't say let the killer go free, but if she did tell everyone, then Hody would be hated, which is what her mother said she didn't want to happen. She was 6, and at that point, she didn't know what the best decision was, she probably thought that ignoring it would make her hate him less, and therefore her mother would be happy. I'm sure that now, she wouldn't have done the same, but back then, she probably thought it was best. Remember, even now, she is extremely naive, so imagine Shirahoshi at age 6. I'm not saying that her decision was perfectly logical, and I would never do what she did, but I don't believe that Oda's storytelling was bad in this instance, because it is believable for someone like Shirahoshi to do what she did. That's my point.
Didnt say it was bad story telling, i accept she wasn't going to make the best decision it was a noble decision but very stupid thats all.