Roger. When Brook first joined I really didn't like him, nor did I want him to be part of the crew. He seemed too outlandish and fantastical, a living, singing, skeleton of around 80 years old, who fights with a sword (like Zoro) … I've grown to accept him more, and dislike him a lot less, but I think Roger should win this match with the focus he's gotten lately, on his life, his family, etc
Yeah I was like this too.
Really? I was so happy to see another swordsman on the crew. Oda knew it was time. Zoro being the only one to use a sword on the crew was lame; why do you think there are so many pics fan fic or by Oda himsef with the strawhats having Swords? Pirates need to have multiple swordsman. Of course because pirates are swordsfighters. Oda did it right though, instead of flooding the crew with swordsman he just add one more awesome swordsman!!
Who is the exact opposite of Zoro personality wise and there styles are way apart. Vote Brook for joining the crew the right way and showing Luffy the respect he deserves!