Well U dunno… I think all SHs are acting well together and all fit the crew
Which Strawhat doesn't seem to fit in well with the rest?
-
-
I think Zoro and Chopper has a special bond with each other.
My favorite scene with them is when Zoro claimed he's an atheist, therefore he doesn't pray to a God.
Chopper thought that was the coolest thing ever… so did I…I love that scene. :wub:
-
Franky and Brooke (especially Brooke) don't fit in right now. Most of it is due the the limited screen time (frame time?) they've had, we don't get to see much interaction with the rest of the crew. Most of the time since they joined the crew there hasn't been much downtime where you can see them kick back, relax and be stupid around the rest of the crew or split off into separate groups. Shabondy Park just didn't cut it for bonding time. Though I do think that Oda is finished adding crew members, since he doesn't want to marginalize his character development. (Don't know what the heck he's going to do with Hancock after this…)
-
Not that I think she doesn't fit in well with the rest, but to me the odd one is Robin. Her interactions still are reserved and well thats how her character is so I don't think it will change very much. This struck me the most when she refused to join the tactics whatever. I like her, but she is still an anomaly.
-
I'm roll with Brooke
Love the crew but Brook is the odd man out for sure! -
Franky is like those people that you hire to make your party/celebration more lively.
I agree, it wouldn't be the same without him.
I don't think anyone is a misfit on the crew, I think they all have their own seperate personalities, strenghts and weaknesses as every family does. They're all different and that's what makes them great.
-
I dunno, for some reason it feels like we got Brooke too soon after Franky. We got to get to know all the other characters better then all of the sudden there is Franky and Brooke
-
I dunno, for some reason it feels like we got Brooke too soon after Franky. We got to get to know all the other characters better then all of the sudden there is Franky and Brooke
I thought that Franky got along well with the crew during the CP9 arc, especially at the part when he joined the strawhats. After that, he's been mostly invisible, other than those "Believe in the ship" moments.
-
What the f… did Franky to you? My favourite one, pure exuberant pervert japanese style!!! SUUUUUPAAAAA!!!!!
The one who doesn't fit is Brooke... I mean "the 2nd swordsman"...
I hope he's going to diferantiate from Zoro in his fighting style becoming like a bard for example... Using both rapier and violin -
I think all of them fit in pretty well with each other to be honest. Out of all of them I'd say Franky is the least fitting. If only for the fact that he's pretty new and we've only really seen interact a great deal with Brook and to a lesser extent Robin and Usopp. His character seems rather different and he doesn't really have much in common to any of the crew in particular except perhaps Usopp.
Brook IS pretty new but we've already seen him interact a great deal with Luffy, Chopper, Robin, Franky and Nami. And he does seem to have a lot in common with Zoro too.
But thats just my opinion things.
-
usopp. what an annoying long nose bastard. i just wanna punch him in the face repeatedly.
-
I thought that Franky got along well with the crew during the CP9 arc, especially at the part when he joined the strawhats. After that, he's been mostly invisible, other than those "Believe in the ship" moments.
C'mon, how can you forget his interactions with the crew during Thriller Bark? He fighting alongside Robin? Asking Brook's past? Teaming up with Usopp & Chopper to make the "Big Emperor" docking move?
-
C'mon, how can you forget his interactions with the crew during Thriller Bark? He fighting alongside Robin? Asking Brook's past? Teaming up with Usopp & Chopper to make the "Big Emperor" docking move?
you forgot about
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/452/02/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/452/03/ -
When his highlights need to include "ask Brook's past", you know he really didn't do much.
-
When his highlights need to include "ask Brook's past", you know he really didn't do much.
Do you really need to ignore all the rest of the post just to try to make a point?
There were plenty of "Franky with crew" moments in Thriller Bark:
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/447/06/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/452/02/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/452/03/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/454/13/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/455/05/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/455/07/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/456/15/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/457/19/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/472/06/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/472/07/ -
Personally, I wanted One Piece to have a lot more adventures with just Luffy, Zoro, and Nami. Those three together have such a great chemistry. Then they added Usopp, who doesn't really fit in well between the other 3. Then Sanji was added and the Chemistry was again back in place. We had the strong 3, and then the 2 who can relate on each other for being weak.
Then we got Chopper who never got a chance to see if he fit in the chemistry because of Vivi, and the addition of Robin immediate after Vivi left. The odd-ball was now Robin. The rest of the crew was pretty much carefree and energetic, besides Zoro and Robin, but for some reason Robin seemed so much more out of place out of the two.
Then after a long long time of having just the 7 members we got Franky and not too soon after Brook.
My favorite thing to do is look at all the groups that are forme within the group;
Monster Trio
Luffy, Zoro, & Sanji
Monsters (Skypea)
Luffy, Zoro, Sanji, & Robin
Monsters (Franky Raid/Alabasta)
Luffy, Zoro, Sanji, & Chopper
Weak Trio
Nami, Usopp, & Chopper
Goofing off Group
Luffy, Usopp, & Chopper- Additional: Sanji (before Chopper), Brook (replaces Usopp)
Girl Group
Nami, Robin - Additional: Chopper hangs out with them.
Information Group: The ones who explain alot.
Nami, Robin, Chopper, Franky
Pairings: Seen together alot, IMO
Ussop + Chopper
Robin + Nami
Sanji + Nami/Robin
Robin + Chopper
Franky + Usopp
Franky + Robin
Zoro vs. Sanji
Chopper + Luffy
Nami + Usopp
Nami + Luffy
Sanji + Usopp
I think there are plenty of dynamics. Plus;
Luffy likes the entire crew (alot, and equally imo)
Zoro: Openly admits he dislikes Sanji, Robin, and Nami. Or atleast don't trust the later.
Nami: IMO, Likes Sanji, Robin, and Usopp. Sanji for manuliplation, and the other two so she can relate to them.
Sanji: Openly admits disliking Zoro.
Usopp: Judging by the time he spends with Luffy and Chopper, he likes them alot.
Chopper: Judging by the time he spends with Luffy and Usopp, he likes them alot.
Robin: Neutral with all
Franky: Neutral ?
Brook: Neutral?
I think I guess it would have to be Zoro, Robin, Franky, or Brook who don't fit in the most. Robin is generally the most reserved, which is kind of the oppisite of the majority. Franky and Brook don't completely fit in at the moment just because of how new they are to the crew. Zoro is also very reserved. Robin, Franky, and Brook are all arguable much more older then the rest of the crew.
So I'd argue more towards Zoro and Robin. Because of their personalities.
- Additional: Sanji (before Chopper), Brook (replaces Usopp)
-
Franky has some chemistry with Robin and Usopp.
Brook had some quite nice interactions with Luffy and Zoro.
The problem with the newcomers is that the crew is quite big right now, so each character has less screen time. Back in east blue, everyone had plenty of chances to shine. Right now, there are nine characters, so they can't really shine as much.
However, I do urge everyone who thinks Franky or Brook don't fit to re-read both Thriller Bark and Flying Fish Riders/Sabaody arc. There a plenty of small but significant moments for both of them during these arcs.
I hope that, if the team reforms slowly, that the ones to join last will be the ones to rejoin first, so we can have a few adventures without the "classic" Strawhats.
-
Question: Which Strawhat doesn't seem to fit in well with the rest?
Answer: Luffy -
Question: Which Strawhat doesn't seem to fit in well with the rest?
Answer: LuffyHe's the glue that binds them.
-
They all work great together I don't think they could survive with out Usopp though; if you take him out the majority of what you get is fighting. Usopp interacts with everyone so well I think it would be awkward with him dead or separated from the crew. Zoro doesn't like Sanji; Nami beats on everybody and Luffy just throws in a funny joke or does something stupid. So to hell with all the Usopp hate. I mean b4 him all you got was arguing and fighting.
Think about it there wouldn't be a single laugh throughout the whole enis lobby brawl without Usopp. Little emotion from the strawhat crew during the water 7 arc and no joking around in Alabasta without Usopp. Usopp throws in opposition too; with his negative ass comments.
-
Vivi, if she stayed I probably would have quit this show by now.
-
I think the reason that people think Franky doesn't fit in is probably because he has been pretty serious this entire saga (Sabaody-Marineford), and he was only in Sabaody, which was a very short and serious arc.
-
I hope Luffy doesn't pick up a new member anytime soon. I think everyone will appreciate Franky better if he has more interaction in the next arc.
-
and he was only in Sabaody, which was a very short and serious arc.
And The Thriller Bark arc?
-
If Franky is wrong, then I don't want to be right.
I think the odd duck is Chopper. He's just too short, always messing up the group shots.
-
Robin doesn't really fit in at all, but somehow it works, I'm torn between wanting a new member now yet feeling that the SHs need to stay the same for awhile so we learn more about Franky and Brooke, and maybe have Robin crack a joke
-
I hope Luffy doesn't pick up a new member anytime soon. I think everyone will appreciate Franky better if he has more interaction in the next arc.
I agree, a little break from the whole recruiting process would fit in well now. It was a good way to learn about Robin although we have got a better introduction to Franky then we got from Robin I still want some more interraction from his side with the crew before the overshadowing loops once again :happy: But the fact of the matter is that I love how Oda still makes the ´old´ crewmembers still feel fresh and I dont get tired of them so I hope it doesnt change later on in the series. That Franky will have the same ´feeling´ as well as the others.
-
And The Thriller Bark arc?
Ahem.
@Me:he has been pretty serious this entire saga (Sabaody-Marineford), and he was only in Sabaody, which was a very short and serious arc.
He was only in Sabaody for this saga.
-
> this entire saga (Sabaody-Marineford)
Actually The "Whitebeard Saga" goes from (Thriller Bark - Sabaody - Impel Down - Marineford) (The wikia agroups it that way)and he was only in Sabaody, which was a very short and serious arc.
I can't find the sense here… He wasn't only In SA arc dude... We had Franky the whole Thriller Bark arc.
-
Actually The "Whitebeard Saga" goes from (Thriller Bark - Sabaody - Impel Down - Marineford) (The wikia agroups it that way)
The wikia isn't really an official source all the time. They got good info but there's not much credibility since anyone can edit it.
TB has nothing to do with this saga except for when Kuma mentioned BB being a shichi and the end when Hogback got the newspaper.
Also, I feel AL should be recognized as an arc just as much as the SA arc is.
-
The wikia isn't really an official source all the time. They got good info but there's not much credibility since anyone can edit it.
TB has nothing to do with this saga except for when Kuma mentioned BB being a shichi and the end when Hogback got the newspaper.
Also, I feel AL should be recognized as an arc just as much as the SA arc is.
Damn, sorry, forgot Amazon Lily…
I accept the argument about the wikia, but we can't assume Thriller Bark as a whole Saga, It's not right. A saga with one Arc?
And, it has something related to the war... ( but in a lesser extent)The whole thing about Lola telling luffy about Ace's VivreCard, plus what you said...And aniway, that argument is wrong cause Franky wasn't present in just 1 Arc after Joining the SH.
-
I see TB more as a transitional arc not a saga. It doesn't completely fit in the EL saga or the War saga imo.
If it has to get put in a saga I guess it's be the War even though I don't care for it.
-
Franky fits perfectly in the SH!
His ship is great!
It's great that he doesn't use any DF ability!
It's great how he fights!
He is as funny as the others!
He is whiny!
With him on board Usopp can concentrate with inventing new stuff and beeing the crew sniper!
He has a dream as the others!
-
Franky fits perfectly in the SH!
His ship is great!
It's great that he doesn't use any DF ability!
It's great how he fights!
He is as funny as the others!
He is whiny!
With him on board Usopp can concentrate with inventing new stuff and beeing the crew sniper!
He has a dream as the others!
One of the main reason Franky doesn't fit with the others is he was sorta a selfish person, a classic jerk even though he wasn't a bad guy and he can also be cruel as how he treated Usopp in the past. All the other strawhats are nice and kind-hearted despite their different personalities. This is what separates him from the rest.
The quickest way to get me to change my mind about Franky is if he brings his two square-hair females groupies with him.
-
@AdmiralYonkouMt.Bandit:
The wikia isn't really an official source all the time. They got good info but there's not much credibility since anyone can edit it.
TB has nothing to do with this saga except for when Kuma mentioned BB being a shichi and the end when Hogback got the newspaper.
Also, I feel AL should be recognized as an arc just as much as the SA arc is.
Any one can edit it sure but most wiki's cite their sources at the very bottom. So as long as you make sure there is backing information it's usually legit. The official Wikipedia uses MLA format.
So just because it's not written in a book doesn't mean its not reliable information even if it isn't "official".
Actually The "Whitebeard Saga" goes from (Thriller Bark - Sabaody - Impel Down - Marineford) (The wikia agroups it that way)
I can't find the sense here… He wasn't only In SA arc dude... We had Franky the whole Thriller Bark arc.
And with that being said i kind of disagree with this wikia's grouping of the saga.
-
Dunno why people think Franky doesn't fit. I think he fits perfect. Only problem. Franky and Brook didn't have much time to shine till now.
But I think all of them are perfect so far.
-
Do you really need to ignore all the rest of the post just to try to make a point?
There were plenty of "Franky with crew" moments in Thriller Bark:
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/447/06/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/452/02/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/452/03/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/454/13/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/455/05/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/455/07/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/456/15/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/457/19/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/472/06/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/472/07/And even you left out a few moments:
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/448/06/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/448/07/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/461/11/Yeah, I think the only problem with Franky and Brook is the small amount of time they've been in the crew. Well, Franky is they kind of guy who works well on his own. Being with the crew seems to calm him down a little. I mean, the instant he was separated from the rest of the crew he became like this again:
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/523/17/ :P
But I'm sure he'll fit in the crew just fine after a while. -
@AdmiralYonkouMt.Bandit:
I see TB more as a transitional arc not a saga. It doesn't completely fit in the EL saga or the War saga imo.
If it has to get put in a saga I guess it's be the War even though I don't care for it.
It does, because it all started there, with Ace being in danger the last part of the arc..
Well everyone has a personal opinion I guess…
-
Everyone fits into the crew… Saying Franky and Brook don't fit after having nowhere as much time to shine isn't fair
-
Except for my arguments about Brook earlier in the thread, I have noticed that Franky and Brook are the only ones who don't seem to be part of any smaller "groups" during the crew's free time.
Luffy, Usopp and Chopper always fool around together.
Zoro and Sanji rivalises.
Nami and Robin are the girl group.Franky and Brook just butts in at random times, especially Brook.
-
What groups are you talking about
Sanji is with usopp all the time as well. Or Zoro with Chopper.
Robin with Franky and so on. Look at the current cover stories^^
People don't get it that they didn't have time to show that much.
-
I think Franky is the odd one out.IMO he doesn´t fit in the crew.His interactions with the crew are poor and he still calls Luffy "Straw Hat".As someone said before, the chemistry isn´t there.
-
Man, Franky fits very well within the crew.
I won't go and reel through the crew stating likenesses between each Strawhat and Franky but there are a couple scenes where Franky has totally seeled himself as a SH, IMHO.
During TB, when the SH ('cept Luffy) are trying to take Oars down, he's stood along side of the rest of the crew and his presence seems so essential, his input was effective and played perfectly with the efforts of the rest of the crew.
The second scene is in Saobondy, where he, Usopp, and Sanji decide to stay and watch the ship. This trio made me hark back to their attempt to retrieve Robin on Puffing Tom. However, this time on the Thousand Sunny, he's Nakama, and it's so right.
Franky compliments each SH and contributes positively to the crew.
Franky's a SH. No two ways about it.
-
i dont know y this is a thread its stupid
oda is the master mind that made one piece yeah he could make mistake but no as big as puting a character in the SW's that didnt fit in come on maneverybody has a bond with each other, if it started when a character just join or came overtime… how brook luffy usopp and chopper play around all the time, robin and nami are together alot, to franky and usopp trying new inventions, or how sanji left nami to save zoro from kuma( but failed).come on guys theres a connection to all of them... and im sure there ill be to the next nakama as well
-
Pandaman.
Wait, you didn't notice?
-
Franky doesn't fit . Paulie should have been in the crew instead of him.
-
The thing for me is that before W7, Usopp was the inventor of the group and though he still does invent things franky also invents. Do we need to inventors? No sir we do not. But don't get me wrong, I like franky as a character but after W& he doesn't seem to connect with the others and is tonned down a little.
A good scenario would have been if franky and iceberg built the ship and the men at the galy taught Usopp how to repair ships. The crew goes off meets Brook after a saddened loss of leaving franky (like vivi) Franky has a cover story and comes back on a collosal battleship ready to take them to a major plot point.
-
@El:
Franky doesn't fit . Paulie should have been in the crew instead of him.
The thing for me is that before W7, Usopp was the inventor of the group and though he still does invent things franky also invents. Do we need to inventors? No sir we do not. But don't get me wrong, I like franky as a character but after W& he doesn't seem to connect with the others and is tonned down a little.
A good scenario would have been if franky and iceberg built the ship and the men at the galy taught Usopp how to repair ships. The crew goes off meets Brook after a saddened loss of leaving franky (like vivi) Franky has a cover story and comes back on a collosal battleship ready to take them to a major plot point.
Thank god neither of you write this manga!
-
Luffy doesn't fit in with the crew. Oh wait…
-
jinbei:ninja: .