Arlong Park Forums

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    • Groups
    1. Home
    2. BinSquarr
    B
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 0
    • Topics 2
    • Posts 218
    • Best 0
    • Controversial 0
    • Groups 0

    BinSquarr

    @BinSquarr

    0
    Reputation
    1
    Profile views
    218
    Posts
    0
    Followers
    0
    Following
    • Joined
    • Last Online
    • Website www.ro-comic.tumblr.com
    • Age 23

    BinSquarr Unfollow Follow

    Latest posts made by BinSquarr

    • RE: Theories That Don't Deserve Their Own Thread v.2

      Here's another theory that is missing a few features to make it wholly robust, but work with me here.

      Green Bull has a radioactive devil fruit (a 'Radioactive Man', if you will).

      I will get to the specifics, later, but now I draw a comparison between scientific thinking prior to and following Columbus' journey to the Americas, the New World.

      Prior to this, science was, largely, an attempt to explain the actions of God; whereas, as the Renaissance lurched forward, so did ideas of the Enlightment and rationalism. Effectively, science had become a practice of understanding how the world works. Admittedly, this is a painfully reductive summary of what took place; however, I want you to take the spirit of thoser statements on board.

      To roughly translate this into One Piece, pre-timeskip consists of a pre-Columbian thought and perception; post-timeskip refers to the Enlightenment era following the discovery of the New World on the Grand Line, which, obviously, shares its name with its real world counterpart.

      The example is best shown through the admirals. Aokiji, Akainu, Kizaru have powers that resemble godly power or fury: Aokiji possesses a DF power that most closely resembles a great deluge, much like in the story of Noah; Akainu, seemingly, summons the fires of Hell; Kizaru embodies the light of God. Moreover, their fleet Admiral is a massive, shining, representation of a godly figure.

      It is a very rough translation, but the interplay of powers between Akainu and Aokiji reminds me of the Classical Elements (Fire/Water/Earth/Wind), which embodies that idea of classical thought; whereas, Fujitora's gravity DF represents one of the four fundamental forces (Gravity/Magnetism/Weak and Strong Radiation), which, clearly is a very recent development in the history of science.

      Obviously, there are some holes: Akainu becomes Fleet Admiral and Kizaru remains an Admiral, which suggests a continuation of Classical Thought; the Classical Elements DF users do not exist solely amongst the ranks of admirals; the only other Fundamental Force user, Kidd, is a pirate. Let me address these concerns one-by-one.

      Regarding Kizaru, I think the perception of light has changed rapidly over the centuries. Once, it was the light of God and now it is a particle and wave, which has led to new developments in Quantum mechanics; effectively, Kizaru's power has come to represent something totally different.

      This is supported by Akainu's promotion, or perhaps, Sengoku's resignation/retirement. Essentially, the representation of God, faith and worship stepped away for a walking volcano. On one hand, this could be a symbol for God giving way to the fires of hell; however, it also shows how our perception and understanding of volcanoes has developed. Akainu's power is that which creates new lands and pushes and pulls continents. With greater scientific understanding, magma is no longer something daemonic, but something radically creative and essential to the rock cycle. Fundamentally, once gods stepped aside, we began to understand the true potential or power of magma, we began to become rational, enlightened, scientific. In effect, rational thinking has taken hold of the Navy, as opposed to god worship.

      Due to the water weakness of DFs, I am aware how flimsy the 'original admirals represented the Classical Elements' may seem. Explicitly, we haven't encountered a wind user (although, Dragon seems to be the guy); the closest thing to earth would be Caribou with his swamp logia. Therefore, wind bears a question mark; however, I would like to offer Whitebeard as a candidate for 'earth', from his earth shattering DF. I say this because he, like Sengoku, were eclipsed, in one way or another, by a new generation of characters, themes, representations. Despite not being an admiral, Whitebeard typified this classical way of thinking. This is a wild diversion, but he always reminded me of a Confucian 'father of the house' figure, which, of course, is an ancient, pre-Columbian philosophy, although, I am aware that throwing chunks of Western and Eastern ancient philosophy is flawed and perhaps, dangerous, I think that Oda has combined a lot of different cultural perspectives in his work, with differing levels of success, of course.

      If Whitebeard represents the 'old way', then Kidd's magnetic DF represents the 'new'. He was always widely tipped as Luffy's greatest rival from his generation; although he was introduced in Paradise, it was at the very end, almost signalling a new chapter. Also, recall the time he crucified those pirates in the New World - they begged to return to Paradise and he chastised them for trying to return to that place, and by extension, that old way of thinking.

      To return to Green Bull, however, I want to envision Akainu's navy as a 'house of science', with Fujitora's gravity and Kizaru's quantum mechanical light as constituent figures; whereas, Sengoku's was a 'house of faith', with his admirals able to perform acts of God. Following the fundamental forces reasoning, gravity and magnetism have been taken, so what's left? Strong and weak radiation. I highly doubt these will be fleshed out as individual DFs, and instead rolled into one. I think this would be a totally brutal DF, and that's one of the reasons why I'm sceptical: would Oda really have a character suffer from radioactive poisoning? Of course, there would myriad ways to overcome this and to make this a viable DF. Whatever you say though, it would be very powerful.

      This post went on far longer than anticipated. I hope I've addressed most of the holes with relatively reasonable answers, although, trying to balance quantity and quality is really difficult sometimes. Please let me know what you think.

      posted in Manga
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: Hiatus x Hiatus III: Goodnight, Sweet Princes

      @Nilitch:

      Only the mother matters.
      Tserriednich didn't take Benjamin's bodyguard because they have the same mother.

      It seems Duazul is depressed since she's probably gonna lose some of her children. I like her.

      Thanks man, that clears a lot up, but what about inter-sibling power dynamics? For instance, is Haltenberg (no.9) higher in rank than Zhang Lei (no.3) due to his mother being of higher rank? I mean, beyond the bodyguard situation. A couple chapters back, there was some inference that Tsenderrich could do so; however, the circumstances are forgotten, though it was more related to sibling relationships than that of bodyguard placement. Effectively, is the order of importance as follows: Benjamin (1), Tsenderrich (1), Camilla (2), Tubeppa (2), Luzurus (2), Haltenberg (2), Zhang Lei (3), Thaithon (4), Sale-Sale (5), Kacho (6), Fugetsu (6), Momonze (7), Marayam (7), Woble (8)? The bracketed numbers refer to queen order, though the order itself refers to birth order.

      I think that all of the Duazul children will die, except for Haltenburg. Camilla's a bitch and therefore few will mind; whereas, Tubeppa, Luzurus seem too well-intentioned to survive against the wrath of Benjamin/Tsenderrich. Maybe Bashou couldf protect Luz; however, red flags surrounding his ability to survive this succession war appeared before he was even physically introduced, so I doubt it.

      posted in Other Manga/Anime
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: Hiatus x Hiatus III: Goodnight, Sweet Princes

      Alright, how many characters were introduced into that chapter? Truly, something like twenty…

      Although the following may seem overtly nerdy, I'm tryna' plot a prince hierarchy graph with queens on the y axis, order of birth on the x. Mostly, this is for my own understanding; so I can actually visualize what's going on and who orders 'round who. Now, what with the queen hierarchy, would that leave Tsedderrich (I tried to spell that, I'm sorry) above or below Camilla in terms of influence due to the former being son of Unma, 1st queen, whereas, Camilla's mum is Duazul, 2nd queen?

      posted in Other Manga/Anime
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: Chapter 870: Parting

      Never been this quick! Off to read lads - closed me eyes as I scrolled down the page - don't know if I'm spelling anything correctly right now

      POST: Speaking of quick, that chapter seemta breeze by… Not as fleshy as I'd wish after a 2 week break, but at least Sanji is definitely gonna redeem himself in battle soon.

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: One Piece 864: The Vinsmoke Family Slaughter Plot

      Now, after all of these sweet-themed DFs, Daifuku was a real treat. There's something about him that reminds me of those new princes introduced in HXH, but anyway, the chapter… once again, Big Mum's crew shine, with the initiative the slaughter the Vinsmokes whilst their Mum was out for the count. This furthers the case of her toxic leadership (the Opera incident, reprimanding Katakuri for defending her, bullying Pudds into becoming a psychopath and possible dissident) - the moment she's overwhelmed in rage, her crew can focus on the task in hand, not dealing with another Muscat affair. Perospero was COLD, man. But regarding Judge, I know it seems like a forced heel-face turn to some degree, but after all the superhuman displays of resolve in this manga, it's quite refreshing to see a realistic response to having your dreams crushed and your brains blown out. Obviously, they won't die (trigger would've been pulled already, wouldn't it? They've got Luffy etc. to contend with), but it's a nice bit of drama, I guess.

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: One Piece 863: The Consumate Gentleman

      Already posted in the hot flurry of 'guys, i've just finished the chapter', but on reflection, I'd like to elaborate. When he was first predicted as Nakama, I was sleeping on Brook. I remember saying shxt like 'lol, Franky's just entered the crew - it's too soon!' and 'It's just Luffy asking every weird guy into the crew w/o thinking (as he did with that zombie tree not long after he asked Brook)'. I was younger then and completely overlooked the nigh 10 years of Brook foreshadowing via Laboon. Anyway, this arc has allowed Brook to truly put in work for the crew. Since his introduction, a lot of big things happened, the Sabaondy defeat, the timeskips (and therefore a lot of real life years spent away from the crew), the cakewalk on fishman island, the Law-centric Punk Hazard arc, and the Dressrosa split up. Effectively, Brook never had the chance to stand up and show readers why he was on board, beyond the panty jokes. Whole Cake has sent this in reverse. In a few scenes, he's shown himself to be as capable as Franky; if Luffy sends him on a mission, these d00ds no doubt deliver. Obviously, the same can be said of Zoro, Sanji, but when Franky had to blow up the SMILE factory, he did so, when Baby G and Buffalo turned up, Franky sent them to the ground. Brook has replicated such a flawless legacy - Road Poneglyph copies secured, Big Mum's soul scratched, and now Caramel cracked. Basically, great work Brook, great work Luffy in terms of recruitment, great work Oda for always having a trick up your sleeve.

      EDIT: Also, comparing Smoothie's interaction with Mont d'Or (with Monty effectively holding the power in terms of intelligence, at least, administrative control) to Katakuri's intervention, the gap between the sweet commanders seems huge. Katakuri has some real initiative, beyond clairvoyance, whereas, Smoothie has shown herself to be a bit sloppy, at least, little more than a thick juicer. I'm sure Oda has more in store for her, but so far, she's been quite uninspiring.

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: One Piece 863: The Consumate Gentleman

      Couple weeks back, err'body was all 'where's Brook?' when the other SH were napping. Guess he was busy sorting out his Luffy mask. That guy's gonna' run up the popularity ranks this year with the work he's put in during Whole Cake. Katakuri, once again, seems to be more on the ball than his Mama, which doesn't look good once coupled with her new weakness (the whole: 'if you got no fear in yo heart, I can't getcha'-thing). But Jinbei, man! Ever the gentleman, even after somebody's triedta' suck your soul out.

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: Chapter 862: The Intelligent Ones

      @sgamer82:

      How do you mean? The two events are pretty unrelated. Unless you mean does it make up for the Vergo leg snap?

      Yeah, you've got it. I'd written out 'make up for' but it felt clunky so I switched to 'account'. Shoulda followed me gut!

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: Chapter 862: The Intelligent Ones

      Does Sanji dodging Katakuri's bean bullet account for the Vergo leg snap?

      Sick chapter, after all that chat that Sanji's lady love being his Achilles' heel, it ends up saving his shit.

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    • RE: Chapter 861: The Consummate Actor

      @Seafarer33:

      I would say only if they're not powered by a piece of her own soul. If something were to happen to the big trio, or one of those weird "soul tax" collectors, she might feel it. But other than that specific case, I do subscribe to the absence of a "hive mind" network to link homies.

      You d00ds are on point today. Also, did we have proof of Big Mom using CoC on that nosey suit after he asked about Caramel? Shxt got dark and he started to foam at the mouth…. I know it's likely she has it, but does this count as legit proof?

      posted in Past Chapter Discussions
      B
      BinSquarr
    Powered by NodeBB | Contributors