So with Carrot not being the traitor Imnow give her small chances.
Even if I still think she is boring as hell
Throughout this month, we will be testing new features (like search) so you may experience some hiccups from time to time. We'll try to not be too disruptive...
Next Straw Hat Crewmates (Vol. 7 - Wano)
-
-
Honestly, I had the feeling that she was gonna join in at the moment she appeared. Too bad I wasn't around back then, I would have pinned my post
-
So with Carrot not being the traitor Imnow give her small chances.
Even if I still think she is boring as hell
We still don't know if the traitor 20 years before current time line is the same as the one in current story.
I find it hard to believe Carrot is the traitor though. Would love it if she was to join. -
Why would Carrot have more chances to join if she was the traitor?
-
Carrot being the traitor has been a great meme for a long time
-
Still betting on unseen character from one of the three races big mom doesn't have (scratch that make it two, we know one of those races is Giants)
-
Carrot being the traitor has been a great meme for a long time
Not as great of a meme as her being a main-character material lol.
-
Not as great of a meme as her being a main-character material lol.
Aaaaayy lmao, classic stuff.
And the Youtube people are the funniest to look at.
Theyre like; "uuh what, heee, Com' on Odaa why isnt Hancock joining??" Fuck this series.XD
-
The same individuals that said Carrot joining made no sense, jumped at the traitor meme that Artur made. Can't take those people seriously.
-
I never believed she was the traitor because that in itself requires the character to be…... more than a generic female bunny.
But nice way of deflecting the idea of her not joining the crew.
Also who the heck is Artur? Some YouTuber?
-
I never even Remotely thought carrot was the traitor
but I don't think she'll join, but if we had to have a mink join I wouldn't mind her or Pekoms or Catviper
-
Neko doesn't make sense to me. Seems like someone had his time in some way. Pekoms makes much more sense. Despite his lack of focus, he makes more sense than Neko by a lot
-
Neko doesn't make sense to me. Seems like someone had his time in some way. Pekoms makes much more sense. Despite his lack of focus, he makes more sense than Neko by a lot
Oh don’t get me wrong both Pekoms and Carrot actually have a chance at joining the crew and Catviper doesn’t, I just love the character
-
Pekoms makes zero sense there is zero build up for becoming mugiwara from him. How on earth is anyone speculating Pekoms.
-
Yeah, and there's already a better Mink in the Strawhat crew.
-
Nah, Pekoms definitely got a lil somethin somethin.
-
Pekoms makes zero sense there is zero build up for becoming mugiwara from him. How on earth is anyone speculating Pekoms.
Well at the very least we know he will appear again, since I assume lots of the big mom plot threads will be addressed either in this arc or Elbaf we have to find out what happened to him
plus we’ve never seen his Zoan hybrid form or his true Suulong form or a Zoan turtle mink lion hybrid in Suulong form
But my guess is now that he betrayed big mom he might join carrot as a member of the nox pirates as a member of The Straw Hats Grand Fleet
-
Lots of characters are going to show up again. And we haven't seen the various zoan or sulong forms for lots of zoan users and minks. Nox pirate for sure, but I don't get why either of those things would suggest he's a potential crewmate.
-
I like Carrot, even was Team Carrot joining the crew. But now I see her having the same chances Paulie had back in Enies Lobby. First we get a rather interesting approach, then the character is set to play a secondary role.
-
The only characters I like are Streussen, Orochi and Charlotte Madara. I doubt that means any of them will join. I don't understand how that "who i'd prefer" logic applies for nakama possibilities
-
The only characters I like are Streussen, Orochi and Charlotte Madara. I doubt that means any of them will join. I don't understand how that "who i'd prefer" logic applies for nakama possibilities
Wait those are the only characters in the entire series you care about?! First of all those characters are like second tier in terms of character development or importance to the plot or even likability, hell outside of Orochi the other two have done close to nothing the entire series, even in there arc
And why are you still reading the series if you don't like any of the main characters there companions or even there villains?
Like seriously why are you even reading this series?
-
I think you just got wooooshed
-
Pekoms makes zero sense there is zero build up for becoming mugiwara from him. How on earth is anyone speculating Pekoms.
Some arguments that are also used for Carrot, like the whole Pedro-Mentor-Dawn-Thing.
He bonded with Luffy, "sacrificed" himself for Luffy, he betrayed a Yonkou for Luffy .
He can't control his Sulong-form yet, Luffy is the perfect reason for Pekoms to overcome his weakness and gain control over Sulong.And of course this:
!
This is more than zero build up.
-
Wait those are the only characters in the entire series you care about?! First of all those characters are like second tier in terms of character development or importance to the plot or even likability, hell outside of Orochi the other two have done close to nothing the entire series, even in there arc
And why are you still reading the series if you don't like any of the main characters there companions or even there villains?
Like seriously why are you even reading this series?
No, characters that I like from the most recent arcs. Did you not just name a character that you liked from the most recent arcs? My top 5 is
5 Sanji
4 WB
3 Teach
2 Akainu
1 ZoroThanks for going off the deep end tho. Going by the logic you assumed for me, the only character you like is Carrot and you should drop the series if that's the only character you like.
-
Some arguments that are also used for Carrot, like the whole Pedro-Mentor-Dawn-Thing.
He bonded with Luffy, "sacrificed" himself for Luffy, he betrayed a Yonkou for Luffy .
He can't control his Sulong-form yet, Luffy is the perfect reason for Pekoms to overcome his weakness and gain control over Sulong.And of course this:
! [qimg]https://image.myanimelist.net/ui/OK6W_koKDTOqqqLDbIoPAvEQeF2kjj-fwdr0P-swpgM[/qimg]
This is more than zero build up.
it just feels like most if not all of those statements could be applied to many characters. I haven't seen him show any genuine significant reason for heading out to sea with Luffy.
-
No, characters that I like from the most recent arcs. Did you not just name a character that you liked from the most recent arcs? My top 5 is
5 Sanji
4 WB
3 Teach
2 Akainu
1 ZoroThanks for going off the deep end tho. Going by the logic you assumed for me, the only character you like is Carrot and you should drop the series if that's the only character you like.
It wasn't going off the deep end at all, you literally said "the only characters I like are…" So I assumed you meant that those are the only characters you like
Btw those 5 you listed. are all pretty awesome
-
-
it just feels like most if not all of those statements could be applied to many characters. I haven't seen him show any genuine significant reason for heading out to sea with Luffy.
At the very least he has a cool design that looks better than the other characters on the list, he has places to go with his power needing to be mastered and forms unseen and he has to eventually reappear to bring closure to the plot
And he kind of bonded with Luffy (okay that's a bit of a stretch)
And he'd be another race represented in Luffy's crew (which is also true if he joins the grand fleet)
Granted chances of him joining are extremely thin
Yes, my wording didn't help. I'm a Zorotard at my core
No probs, also Zoro's a great character and one of my favs
-
If Carrot has as many chances as Paulie, then Pekoms has the chances Iceburg had.
-
You're looking at it the wrong way. It's not that Carrot has as much chance as Paulie, it's just that Paulie is just the Carrot of Water 7.
-
I never know if taking Paulie's chances into account and comparing them to Carrot's is a sutil diss, or an earnest comparison.
Hidden:
Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku
Hidden:
-
If Momo was at least 13, I'd honestly say he would be a very serious candidate, especially after seeing the recent flashback.
….......But he ain't, and he's not much compared to his old man.
-
@K.:
I never know if taking Paulie's chances into account and comparing them to Carrot's is a sutil diss, or an earnest comparison.
It's just a comparison taking into account the role of both characters in a connected saga. Both of them have a protagonist role in the first arc, while they are less important than the landscape in the second. I liked the synergy between Carrot and the band, so I wanted her to join, but it's just illogical.
-
Would love to see 5 moments where Paulie is away from the Galley La group and having any moments with the crew
This happens every time I win the Carrot arguments
-
Claiming that you've won just by mentioning some imaginary moments that you think somehow highlight Carrot as a SH isn't particularly something to brag about. Particularly when you have spend more time saying that you have proved something somehow instead of actually proving anything. And even then, it's been ripped apart and shat on like crazy.
I mean I find all Carrot arguments to be complete garbage and been-there-done-that type deal but even by those standards, your posts tends to be reaching some new lows.
-
@K.:
I never know if taking Paulie's chances into account and comparing them to Carrot's is a sutil diss, or an earnest comparison.
Paulie was a serious contender back in the day. Granted, that was before Franky really got screentime, but most people initially assumed he'd be the guy and that held for a long while. The community was pretty evenly split at the time.
That should have gone out the window the moment Franky's flashback started, and it REALLY should have been out when he was in a color spread listed as a Strawhat, but that's how it goes.
-
Paulie was a serious contender back in the day. Granted, that was before Franky really got screentime, but most people initially assumed he'd be the guy and that held for a long while. The community was pretty evenly split at the time.
That should have gone out the window the moment Franky's flashback started, and it REALLY should have been out when he was in a color spread listed as a Strawhat, but that's how it goes.
Who do you think is going to join? Or do you think we haven't met the last crewmember yet?
-
Reminds me of last year when he said it didn't happen and someone posted a whole collage. He chose to disappear for a while after that lol
-
It's just a comparison taking into account the role of both characters in a connected saga. Both of them have a protagonist role in the first arc, while they are less important than the landscape in the second. I liked the synergy between Carrot and the band, so I wanted her to join, but it's just illogical.
Paulie was a serious contender back in the day. Granted, that was before Franky really got screentime, but most people initially assumed he'd be the guy and that held for a long while. The community was pretty evenly split at the time.
That should have gone out the window the moment Franky's flashback started, and it REALLY should have been out when he was in a color spread listed as a Strawhat, but that's how it goes.
The joke is that Paulie did not join, so his chances, were actually 0 from the start.
-
Ah, yes the collage of entire Carrot's moments across 50+ chapters…...compare to other characters who received just as much, if not more, moments.
Though you forgot to post one for Law or Kinemon or Momo or Hachi or Camie or any other character that spend time with the crew lol.
But cherry-picking and ignoring all the other examples and choosing to believe that a mere generic bunny character SH worth material when she, in her so called role that is rather basic, ended up failing to do even that much, is a good choice.
But yea, who needs facts when you can rely on emojis and imagery moments
Insert generic emoji
-
Oh dear you two certainly don't get along
-
Who do you think is going to join? Or do you think we haven't met the last crewmember yet?
Outside of Vivi or Mr.2, no one we've currently met really fits the bill.
And even Vivi is a really really weird situation. If she showed up today for the first time I'd say no, too Nami clone, but since she showed up in year 3 and Oda kept putting her in covers long after she left and bringing focus back to her, she's an unusual case.
I think the data cards made her an unnoficial one.
And Mr. 2 was out forever when Oda handpicked his VA to be Franky, so.
-
He remembers, I see lol
-
Eh, I just love fucking around with people that use some extreme level of mental gymnastics.
Always fun to see when people know they are wrong, but decide to bring out some outta-the-box argument and think that what is being said is somehow original and new…..even though that's basically been the argument that millions of other people have used and failed in different situations.
-
Just for the sake of imagining. Considering that Franky would be much longer than Mr. 2 with the Straw Hats, why not use the VA for a more frequent role?
-
Outside of Vivi or Mr.2, no one we've currently met really fits the bill.
And even Vivi is a really really weird situation. If she showed up today for the first time I'd say no, too Nami clone, but since she showed up in year 3 and Oda kept putting her in covers long after she left and bringing focus back to her, she's an unusual case.
I think the data cards made her an unnoficial one.
And Mr. 2 was out forever when Oda handpicked his VA to be Franky, so.
Do you still think we'll get a last member after Jinbei? Some people seem to think he'll be the last, but I honestly believe we'll have one more member
because Oda had Luffy promise us 10 members on the very first chapter, and Black Beard has 10 members to, and I remember something about Oda saying he wanted to have 11 members like a Soccer team in some interview
-
Might have a case with Momo, but you're trolling with the others. Carrot hate is blinding you from using logic
-
Hiyori would be interesting and I think would be fun personality wise but I don't think she really has any fighting ability. Carrot is probably the most likely out of those in the poll but at the same time the crew members so far have all had their individual talents that added to the crew. What does Carrot really have outside of just being able to fight? I can't even really think of any more positions off the top of my head that need to be filled. And while Jinbei's the helmsman I'm pretty sure (if he ends up officially joining the crew and being on the ship) that job is already done by Chopper most of the time.
-
She can be a lookout….. You know the thing that she failed at consistently in WCI arc...
