Strawhat Crew Theories and Prediction Thread
-
Hahahahaha those are priceless XD
-
Eh I guess so, but even when he was still a bounty hunter he didn't really take down anyone much of importance to be known around the world as a "pirate hunter"
Supposedly he did you never really found out who all to much, but he was fairly famous at the start of the manga. When they were in the east blue he was fairly well known people did recognize the name.
-
Supposedly he did you never really found out who all to much, but he was fairly famous at the start of the manga. When they were in the east blue he was fairly well known people did recognize the name.
That's right, the marines at Lougetown really recognized Zoro's name in ch 99, both Smoker and Tashigi were surprised to hear he was in town. Smoker actually yelled out "What's that bounty hunter doing here of all times!?" A ormal marine grunt broke out in sweat at the news.
-
East Blue though, the weakest sea where the strongest pirates were just arlong and don krieg. It just doesn't seem that impressive in the New World to have your nickname boast about hunting pirates with a bounty far less than his current one.
It made sense to be called a pirate hunter back in the grand line or east blue where he actually took down pirates that may have been well known there, but now in the New World I don't think anyone would be really aware or impressed of the pirates he used to hunt.
-
East Blue though, the weakest sea where the strongest pirates were just arlong and don krieg. It just doesn't seem that impressive in the New World to have your nickname boast about hunting pirates with a bounty far less than his current one.
It made sense to be called a pirate hunter back in the grand line or east blue where he actually took down pirates that may have been well known there, but now in the New World I don't think anyone would be really aware or impressed of the pirates he used to hunt.
Well he will most likely stick with the current 1 or only other name I could think of is demonic swordsmen or something along the lines of the theme of his main attacks.
But the most likely thing that will happen is that he will stay as Pirate Hunter.
-
About Jinbe. Is his title "Knight of the Sea" or "First Son of the Sea"? I've seen both being used before.
16 chars of Knight of the Sea.
-
The rest of Strawhats are gonna get body-swapped too.
Except Brook, he'll detach his soul and GET OUTTA THERE FAST.
-
-
Zoro/Usopp, Luffy/Robin.
Luffy and Robin swapping would be too priceless with them getting to use the others respective powers.
Oh and Usopp in Zoro's body would be scary with Zoro's strength and endurance
-
Robin > Luffy > Usopp > Zoro > Robin.
If it happens. it's definitely not gonna be two pairs of people switched with each other.
-
what if in the end, one piece is one of those "it was always in you, right here" points to heart thingys? Wouldja b mad?? i would :getlost:
! Someone should make an I spy thread where we upload pictures of those hidden hints oda puts in the anime. cuz I CANT POST NEW THREADS…:sad:
-
Robin > Luffy > Usopp > Zoro > Robin.
If it happens. it's definitely not gonna be two pairs of people switched with each other.
Oh yeah, I forgot how it worked for a second.
Your theory sounds the most plausible.EDIT: Although, it could also be…
Luffy > Robin > Usopp > Zoro > Luffy.
Assuming ">" means "soul to body". -
what if in the end, one piece is one of those "it was always in you, right here" points to heart thingys? Wouldja b mad?? i would :getlost:
! Someone should make an I spy thread where we upload pictures of those hidden hints oda puts in the anime. cuz I CANT POST NEW THREADS…:sad:
I believe there's already a sort of thread for the manga. Or even a website if I remember correctly (something about keeping track what's happening in One Piece; all the interesting stuff).
As for the anime, I don't know. I'd advise to search the manga or hidden clues, if you want to find some. That's Oda's creation after all.
-
I believe there's already a sort of thread for the manga. Or even a website if I remember correctly (something about keeping track what's happening in One Piece; all the interesting stuff).
As for the anime, I don't know. I'd advise to search the manga or hidden clues, if you want to find some. That's Oda's creation after all.
Thanks! I'll try to look it up.
-
I'm liking the look of Monet, the samurai and Jinbei joining.
-
I thought this was really cool. It's not really a predictions but it is an picture of a real life Fata Morgana, which is Nami's attack where she creates mirage copies of herself. I just thought it was cool that it was on the APOD website
-
Yeah, I love astronomical anomalies!
!
-
I have a hunch that something bad is going to happen to jinbei before he officially joins the crew.
He'll be incapicitated at the very least and won't be able to travel w/ everyone once he's done with whatever he's doing.I say this b/c the sh crew would be way too big once they hit double digits. Sure there's plenty of room for jinbei on the ship, but 9 crew members seems perfect.
4 joined in east blue and 4 more joined in the grand line.Not that I wouldn't mind the SHs to have the worlds strongest fishman in their crew, but there's no room for another character.
-
I have a hunch that something bad is going to happen to jinbei before he officially joins the crew.
He'll be incapicitated at the very least and won't be able to travel w/ everyone once he's done with whatever he's doing.I say this b/c the sh crew would be way too big once they hit double digits. Sure there's plenty of room for jinbei on the ship, but 9 crew members seems perfect.
4 joined in east blue and 4 more joined in the grand line.Not that I wouldn't mind the SHs to have the worlds strongest fishman in their crew, but there's no room for another character.
I thought the same. That if Jinbei was meant to join he would have already. The fact that Oda "postponed" his joining must mean something. To me it would be anti-climatic if he's joining is delayed for too long. Oda is up to something with the Sun Pirate arc. I have a whole other theory about this in the theory thread but no one gave a response.
-
Lame logic.
If there was any reason for Jinbe not to join right away aside from the deliberate story implications was probably so the Straw Hat's can make waves in the new world without the aid of an ex warlord right away. I don't think it's necessary but at least that makes some sense.
Also what about Luffy's "10 men should do." Or Data book green saying we'll get at least 1 more crew mate in the new world?
What about being able to match black beards crew?
Jinbe being delayed for an epic struggle to clearly demonstrate that Luffy, Sanji, Zoro and the others are completely on his level makes a lot of sense to me.
-
Jinbe may feel obligated to stay in Fishman Island until Luffy defeats Big Mom.
-
Jinbe may feel obligated to stay in Fishman Island until Luffy defeats Big Mom.
I agree, if he joined now then Big Mom could take her revenge on Fishman Island. Jinbe serving her is part of Fishman Island's protection, so far the only major threat to that protection was the failure of delivering the candy … whihc Luffy took the blame for, so Big Mom spared FI as Luffy was the bigger annoyance to her. If Jinbe joined now before Luffy confront/defeat her, Big Mom could attack FI, so now he is still protecting his homeland.
-
From that color page where we saw all the supernovas after the timeskip, Bonney seems to have become a wanderer or maybe what appears to be a runaway and is evident by the cloak in which shes wearing. She hates Blackbeard, Akainu was abhorred at her "escape" from wherever dafuq, and she has apparently lost her entire crew. Oh plus she eats a lot and is a pretty girl-swan so plenty of lulz for both luffy and sanji over food. Ill just go ahead and scream Bonney 4 nakama!!!!!
Anything humans can imagine is a possibility in reality-Physicist Willy Karen
-
From that color page where we saw all the supernovas after the timeskip, Bonney seems to have become a wanderer or maybe what appears to be a runaway and is evident by the cloak in which shes wearing. She hates Blackbeard, Akainu was abhorred at her "escape" from wherever dafuq, and she has apparently lost her entire crew. Oh plus she eats a lot and is a pretty girl-swan so plenty of lulz for both luffy and sanji over food. Ill just go ahead and scream Bonney 4 nakama!!!!!
Got the link to that color page? Can't find it anywhere :(
Supporter of the "Fire-Cutting Style" theory. Sympathizer of the "Cerberus" theory.
-
you mean this one
!
it's on vikia -
Oh yeah, I forgot how it worked for a second.
Your theory sounds the most plausible.EDIT: Although, it could also be…
Luffy > Robin > Usopp > Zoro > Luffy.
Assuming ">" means "soul to body".Usopp in Luffy's body because remember both of them had the same first bounty.
Luffy in Robin's body because he always gets the hot girls.
Zoro in Usopp's body because he does not use ranged weapons making him weaker however usopp's body should be strong enough now to carry the swords so he can give Usopp his weapon!
Robin in Zoro's body to support Zoro+Robin pairing lol. -
i'd agree with luffy in robin's body if it wasn't for the fact that sanji got nami's body, there was always a purpose to make sanji jealous without willing to do so but now there's no real point, i'd rather see luffy trying to snipe or use swords, and i'd support ussopp in luffy's body to try and master his abilities in the short gap they'd have to test them out, and i think ussopp would enjoy being the strongest for a while :P. i like the robin/zoro duo, i think swords would suit her well. and zoro creating hands to slap people instead slashing them.
-
I have a hunch that something bad is going to happen to jinbei before he officially joins the crew.
He'll be incapicitated at the very least and won't be able to travel w/ everyone once he's done with whatever he's doing.I say this b/c the sh crew would be way too big once they hit double digits. Sure there's plenty of room for jinbei on the ship, but 9 crew members seems perfect.
4 joined in east blue and 4 more joined in the grand line.Not that I wouldn't mind the SHs to have the worlds strongest fishman in their crew, but there's no room for another character.
What about Luffy claiming he wants at least 10 members? and the fact that he still asks every interesting person (or animal) that they come across to join the crew. I think its pretty well established that there will be 1 more crew member.
PS and the fact that the Green Databook says that there will be a new crewmember. case closed.
-
I agree, if he joined now then Big Mom could take her revenge on Fishman Island. Jinbe serving her is part of Fishman Island's protection, so far the only major threat to that protection was the failure of delivering the candy … whihc Luffy took the blame for, so Big Mom spared FI as Luffy was the bigger annoyance to her. If Jinbe joined now before Luffy confront/defeat her, Big Mom could attack FI, so now he is still protecting his homeland.
That and if Jinbei was with the SH's when they faced Big Mom his presence would have his crew automatically change sides - remember his crew being with BM - so rather then have to deal with that issue - make the SH's go defeat BM - his Sun Pirates crew returns to FI and Jinbei free to join the SH crew.
Pell survived because he is a Falcon - Stop using him as a bad example.
The Peregrine Falcon reaches faster speeds than any other animal on the planet when performing the stoop,which involves soaring to a great height and then diving steeply at speeds of over 320 km/h (200 mph)
-
That and if Jinbei was with the SH's when they faced Big Mom his presence would have his crew automatically change sides - remember his crew being with BM - so rather then have to deal with that issue - make the SH's go defeat BM - his Sun Pirates crew returns to FI and Jinbei free to join the SH crew.
I do agree somewhat, it's just I don't see how Jinbe's guys could go back to FI after they deal with BM if they are not able to now. I imagine a few of them have bounties at least.
At least according to Jinbe they would protect the island if they weren't wanted, what would change later? I'm really interested in how Oda handles this, if they do end protecting FI(assuming it still exists) I can't wait to see how it's explained.
Folks who read One Piece… Just better people. ¯\(ツ)/¯
-
I do agree somewhat, it's just I don't see how Jinbe's guys could go back to FI after they deal with BM if they are not able to now. I imagine a few of them have bounties at least.
At least according to Jinbe they would protect the island if they weren't wanted, what would change later? I'm really interested in how Oda handles this, if they do end protecting FI(assuming it still exists) I can't wait to see how it's explained.Well if Shirley never fails to predict the future then well …. they can't protect it. But thats only from a reader point of view - from a character point of view it seems they are all telling themselves that Shirley was wrong and Luffy will not be responsible for the destruction of FI. But in order to keep a level of neutrality up Jinbei can't really leave until his crew is freed without FI angering BM.
I would say Jinbei will join either during the Big Mom arc when it is shown he can beat her - or right after and the Sun Pirates return. Besides the Sun Pirates can always live in the distict where Noah is.(Can't remember the name)
Pell survived because he is a Falcon - Stop using him as a bad example.
The Peregrine Falcon reaches faster speeds than any other animal on the planet when performing the stoop,which involves soaring to a great height and then diving steeply at speeds of over 320 km/h (200 mph)
-
Well if Shirley never fails to predict the future then well …. they can't protect it. But thats only from a reader point of view - from a character point of view it seems they are all telling themselves that Shirley was wrong and Luffy will not be responsible for the destruction of FI. But in order to keep a level of neutrality up Jinbei can't really leave until his crew is freed without FI angering BM.
I would say Jinbei will join either during the Big Mom arc when it is shown he can beat her - or right after and the Sun Pirates return. Besides the Sun Pirates can always live in the distict where Noah is.(Can't remember the name)
fishman district.
-
-
Well Jinbe will join after Luffy will save him, his crew and take fishmen island under his name… Jinbe flat out stated that with his "name" he can't do anything... maybe it will be a bit anticlimatic but it will happen
And maybe not the dumbest way
Even if at least the monster trio was shown af FI to be at his level of skills, his name and bounty would overshadow even Zoro and not even speaking about the others. Till Big Mom the SHs will have there own big name and will still progress and learn about the NW. After beating Big Mom's Yonkou crew Jinbe won't overshadow anyone anymore and will be a mere member of the SHs
Or Oda will use Jinbe in another way after all. We will see. It's a long way till Big Mom
-
Well if Shirley never fails to predict the future then well …. they can't protect it. But thats only from a reader point of view - from a character point of view it seems they are all telling themselves that Shirley was wrong and Luffy will not be responsible for the destruction of FI. But in order to keep a level of neutrality up Jinbei can't really leave until his crew is freed without FI angering BM.
Isn't Jinbe bringing straw hats back to FI?
So, one of those kids who gets a straw hat, could be the destroyer that Shirley saw in her vision. -
Isn't Jinbe bringing straw hats back to FI?
So, one of those kids who gets a straw hat, could be the destroyer that Shirley saw in her vision.Great Shout! Can't believe that thought never occured to me at the time, that idea's really made me re-think how I saw One Piece going in the future.
-
I hope Kinemon is the NN, he seems like a really powerful character and has a really interesting and useful DF. He's already starting to become friends with the Strawhats and I think he has a funny and cool personality. He was able to fight Brook without his head and legs.
I hope Luffy gonna become taller and ore muscular durning the journey in the new world.
-
Jinbei will die before joining the crew.
-
Jinbei will die before joining the crew.
This. Jimbeis too old to join, I know Brook is even older but Brook is immature and is a skeleton. Jimbei isn't unique enough to join besides I can't picture him in the crews daily life, just try and do it yourself.
Option 2 is that he "joins" but Luffy tells him to stay and guard his new turf/territory (FI).
Supporter of the "Fire-Cutting Style" theory. Sympathizer of the "Cerberus" theory.
-
This. Jimbeis too old to join, I know Brook is even older but Brook is immature and is a skeleton. Jimbei isn't unique enough to join besides I can't picture him in the crews daily life, just try and do it yourself.
Option 2 is that he "joins" but Luffy tells him to stay and guard his new turf/territory (FI).
You'll love him just like you love everyone else in the crew. Or maybe you should just stop reading now. Then you won't have to deal with that big fat Fishman in the group.
Maybe after Jinbe joins you will actually understand One Piece.
Edit:
I'll retract my statement if you give me a real answer to why he won't join, rather than, he should die and he isn't goofy enough.Folks who read One Piece… Just better people. ¯\(ツ)/¯
-
You'll love him just like you love everyone else in the crew. Or maybe you should just stop reading now. Then you won't have to deal with that big fat Fishman in the group.
Maybe after Jinbe joins you will actually understand One Piece.
Fair enough, that's your opinion but you could advice me to stop reading by the time he joins. That would make more sense as the manga isn't showing any signs of his immediate joining.
-
But die? In this comic where dying has to be a monumental event in the present time?
Too old? He's only 10 years older than Franky. As far as uniqueness, he is as unique as Fishmen come, talking with the whale sharks, design wise he's a fatso, and his fighting style is super unique among the crew… Ok i'll stop there before this thread get's closed too.
I see some people just have this bias toward him, I can only assume they were disappointed by his design and that initial feeling never left. I guess after years of wondering what Arlong's "old pal" must have looked like, one could only set them up for disappointment.
Folks who read One Piece… Just better people. ¯\(ツ)/¯
-
But die? In this comic where dying has to be a monumental event in the present time?
Too old? He's only 10 years older than Franky. As far as uniqueness, he is as unique as Fishmen come, talking with the whale sharks, design wise he's a fatso, and his fighting style is super unique among the crew… Ok i'll stop there before this thread get's closed too.
I see some people just have this bias toward him, I can only assume they were disappointed by his design and that initial feeling never left. I guess after years of wondering what Arlong's "old pal" must have looked like, one could only set them up for disappointment.
I guess you're right and I just don't like his design & personality but then again I didn't like the idea of the crews separation AT ALL but it still happened. So yeah, I guess Im just kinda disappointed overall and now that I am thinking about it you got a point on his uniqueness being a ticket to the SH Crew as the crew is literally a bunch of unique exceptions among exceptions.
-
Jinbei's joining is not confirmed because it has not happen yet. Yes he already had the invitation to join but the bottom line is, he didn't. Anything can happen before they meet again so it's only confirmed when the chapter title "The Ninth" is released. Before that, its fair game and people have the right to have an opinion of Jinbei not joining. Everyone's opinions are different. Don't tell people to stop reading OP just because their opinions differ from yours.
-
You should go back in time a bit and find the lengthy discussions we've had on this over the years.
Me telling Waboshi to stop reading is more a joke than anything. I said that in regards to the extreme stance that "Jinbe will die before he gets to join the crew." Seriously in this comic? Well if one is that apposed to him, then maybe that person would feel better about quitting the series all together./joke
You've been lurking maybe for years, and only finally decided to join this forum. So maybe you don't know my posting habits well. But don't get on me about morals and how everyone has the right to their opinion. I'm the last person you need to be giving that speech to.
Folks who read One Piece… Just better people. ¯\(ツ)/¯
-
But die? In this comic where dying has to be a monumental event in the present time?
Too old? He's only 10 years older than Franky. As far as uniqueness, he is as unique as Fishmen come, talking with the whale sharks, design wise he's a fatso, and his fighting style is super unique among the crew… Ok i'll stop there before this thread get's closed too.
I see some people just have this bias toward him, I can only assume they were disappointed by his design and that initial feeling never left. I guess after years of wondering what Arlong's "old pal" must have looked like, one could only set them up for disappointment.
I know some will not change their minds about Jinbe, even if they get to see more of his personality -lets face it, we have NOT gotten to see much of his personality. 75% of time we've seen of him is in serious moments, so he was serious, and less of when he was relaxed. But i've always wondered how many people would change their minds if he looked different, if he looks more like this
-
I know some will not change their minds about Jinbe, even if they get to see more of his personality -lets face it, we have NOT gotten to see much of his personality. 75% of time we've seen of him is in serious moments, so he was serious, and less of when he was relaxed. But i've always wondered how many people would change their minds if he looked different, if he looks more like this
I remember seeing a few Jinbe concepts, is this one of them? Just done up by a fan? Had he looked like that people would be all over him in a heart beat. People just don't like fat fishmen with big round noses.
I remember one looking like Namol/Namor from White Beards crew, thinking I wished he looked like that. But now his design has completely grown on me.
Folks who read One Piece… Just better people. ¯\(ツ)/¯
-
I know some will not change their minds about Jinbe, even if they get to see more of his personality -lets face it, we have NOT gotten to see much of his personality. 75% of time we've seen of him is in serious moments, so he was serious, and less of when he was relaxed. But i've always wondered how many people would change their minds if he looked different, if he looks more like this
I would not want that Jimbei within 50ft of the strawhat crew.
-
in the OP world people actually have incredible hearing/sight so it would have to be like 50 kilometers.
