something as this:
! http://i.imgbox.com/abnzu8Qn.jpg
but I didn't yet find them all.
Could someone tell me where the unnamed marines appear in the manga?
Specifically:
File 1; Ranks 9,14,15
File 2; Ranks 2,3,6,7,9,10,11
File 3; Rank 2
File 4; Ranks 7,11,13
File 5; Rank 1
File 6; Ranks 8,9,10
(Files are vertical and counted left to right, ranks are horizontal and counted top to bottom.)
I agree with Bins being the guy next to bear zombie.
something as this:
! http://i.imgbox.com/abnzu8Qn.jpg
but I didn't yet find them all.
Yarisogi is I think four down in the column second from left. Sicily is next to a wrong picture, he should be one up.
Also, anyone else notice Mr. T guy down there ?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Also the supposed female giant looks far older then she did recently and has a different chin :O
Could someone tell me where the unnamed marines appear in the manga?
Specifically:
File 1; Ranks 9,14,15
File 2; Ranks 2,3,6,7,9,10,11
File 3; Rank 2
File 4; Ranks 7,11,13
File 5; Rank 1
File 6; Ranks 8,9,10(Files are vertical and counted left to right, ranks are horizontal and counted top to bottom.)
all the file 1 and 2 are from Enies Lobby, when the 200 captains attack Luffy's crew in order to take robin back.
the file 3's one is one of giant squad and appears when Jozu throw the huge iceberg
File 4:
Could someone tell me where the unnamed marines appear in the manga?
Specifically:
File 1; Ranks 9,14,15
File 2; Ranks 2,3,6,7,9,10,11
File 3; Rank 2
File 4; Ranks 7,11,13
File 5; Rank 1
File 6; Ranks 8,9,10(Files are vertical and counted left to right, ranks are horizontal and counted top to bottom.)
File 3; Rank 2 Chapter 554, page 4
!
File 4 Rank 1 is somewhere in Shabaody, when Luffy, Law and Kidd are fighting the marines in front of the auction house. Can't remember the chapter number.
File 5 rank 10 is when Sengoku gets the report about Boa Hancock I think. I'll give you a chapter no. in a few minutes.
The rest are jambled across the Marineford war arc.
That colorspread, man. I can't even remember what I was going to say about the chapter (except, what Law did to Vergo gave me chills). I'm so thankful everyone here is listing who the marines are, because I didn't even remember half of these guys existing, let alone knew they had names. Oda is so amazing. Amazing amazing.
Looking at the colorspread, I don't want to start any kind of stupid discussion, but… Isn't Nami's skirt like really low? It's almost as the top of her buttcheeks are exposed :ninja:
That caught my eye, too. The skirt thing is definitely way lower, at least from the main promo ad I've seen, but I wouldn't be surprised if this is more true to form, since most of the stuff she wear these days is halfway down the butt.
EDIT:
chapter 523
!
Wow, just have to say–Arlong Parkers, you're all amazing. I couldn't even pin down Tsuru and Drake on my first glance through and you've gone and named over half of them already in less than a day! 
What I ask myself… Will Vergo really go back to DoFla? He failed with his mission so maybe he will get the same treatement as Monet, who said she would be killed if she fails
What I ask myself… Will Vergo really go back to DoFla? He failed with his mission so maybe he will get the same treatement as Monet, who said she would be killed if she fails
Something tells me Doflamingo would see Vergo's dismembered body and still think that's not a fair punishment for failure.
I was thinking… Do Oda understood that now the SBS'll be filled of "What the name of that marine" mails? XD He'll just name all of them in the next databook XD
Also we saw the Mr. T guy on Strawberry's ship after Oimo, Kaashi and co are revealed to be alive, but not sure if he was in the manga too.
I was thinking… Do Oda understood that now the SBS'll be filled of "What the name of that marine" mails? XD He'll just name all of them in the next databook XD
Oda doesn't write the data books.
Oda doesn't write the data books.
I know, but he decides the names of characters reveald in the books, right?
Not sure where to ask this, but would the lead cover of this chapter make at least Z, Bins, and Ain canon, if not the film?
liked the chapter . lots of talking and seeing where everyone is. I had hoped that CC would have putup a better fight than this but he is a scientist.His followers got on my nerves blindly believing in CC all the time.
And how BADASS was the color spread every major marine in marinford war and some ones we saw in the past. New screen saver
Something tells me Doflamingo would see Vergo's dismembered body and still think that's not a fair punishment for failure.
Yeah, Vergo's dead meat if he goes to Doflamingo. He probably tries to avoid him for now. I don't know about Monet tough. As much as I hated how she was hyped and how she was supposed to be all good girl and stuff, something just tells me that her part isn't over yet. Maybe I'm just a gentleman and find it a little too grude if she was downright killed by Doflamingo already, but something still bugs me about her.
think of it this way; ur a person that hates thieves. one day u see a robbery take place and ur upset. u know if u call the cops the thieves will get caught then and there but for w/e reason u dont. the next day u see them again robbing another place and u get even more upset and now u call the cops. why didnt u call them the first time? by u not dealin with the problem when it arose u are know partially responsible for what happens there after.
Not really. You see metaphorically speaking, the person who hates thieves called the cops but said burglars were smart enough to outsmart the police squad or strong enough to beat them. Luffy was fighting seriously with Ceasar, but he didnt deliver enough damage to close the deal. How would he know that Ceasar would kill his own henchmen? Please dont say COO.
Stating that Luffy is partially responsible is very subjective from my point of view. Sure it looks pretty straightforward once you look into the past and an action carries onto another; however Ceasar does what he does and he should take full responsibility for it alas Luffy has no responsibility whatsoever over Ceasars actions. Hes a pirate remember? Ceasars men are dead because of Ceasar.
It would be interesting to hear your thoughts about who killed firefist. Was it Blackbeard, Akainu or Luffy? choose your venom.
Would you like a Blast?
100000000000000 Berries please.
Blasting Destinations: Gotham city, Jaya, central perk, E. R.
It would be interesting to hear your thoughts about who killed firefist. Was it Blackbeard, Akainu or Luffy? choose your venom.
I think the better question is, who does LUFFY hold responsible?
Holy sweet ass cover spread batman! It's like spot the marine o.o. Let's see, whoever identifies as many of the marines as possible without the wikia's help, should get a prize. Also, yeah, Nami's skirt isn't much of a skirt, as it is a commando butt flap-v-;;.
Edit: Nami Film Z figure underbutt, that is all.
Am i the only one who notices Usopp's hammer has a 700 ton mark on it? Last time (against Perona) it had 10 tons: a slight increase …
H T C - Hoje Tive Cá
@HTC:
Am i the only one who notices Usopp's hammer has a 700 ton mark on it? Last time (against Perona) it had 10 tons: a slight increase …
Pretty sure that's supposed to read 100 tons.
Hmm, the chapter was fine, but not one of the better ones in the arc I don't think. Mostly due to some confusion.
The color spread is ridiculously awesome, though. It might be the best one I've ever seen, and it makes the chapter for me by itself. We've never seen Garp before he had a beard before, so it's safe to say it's not all a flashback to one time. I'm really impressed with all the minor character marines that have been established making an appearance. It's the addition of guys like Nezumi and Morgan that really impress me about the thoroughness of it. The one glaring omission to me would have to be Kong. I can't find that guy anywhere.
Honestly, it probably wasn't until the third time I looked through this chapter that I realized the top half of the mountain lands back in place in the first panel. There were a lot of things I was having a lot of difficulty explaining until I realized that. Mostly where the gas was coming in and where it wasn't, and why it wasn't a problem in certain areas. I had serious concerns about this chapter before catching that. I'll admit that it's my fault for not looking closely, but Oda also takes some blame for not supplementing it with a little supporting dialog, but rather giving us "the ceiling is floating up" from Sanji after the fact for some reason, assuming that translation is even correct. It might actually be past tense, which would mean all my complaints instead go to the translators.
I really like how on the first two pages inside the B block, you can see where the place got cut apart. It rose up and fell down, but without knowing that it looks like it slid like the Enies Lobby Tower of Justice. We already knew that the B block was connected to the outdoors, so the gas coming in makes total sense. Of course, that may be a "well duh" type of statement, but it's important thanks to the later alternatives. It's also a nice touch that the big kid has a bump on his head from the falling debris. It adds to the feeling of panic that the kids especially should be in.
Zoro had the gas right on his heels last chapter, but since then he passed everyone else and got lost? lol. Chopper's emergency treatment didn't get any extra panel time, but I didn't really expect it to. It's not like it ever has before. The real challenge was always the long term portion to begin with. I'm not sure what to think about that.
Ok, Vergo having all his body parts attached to the railing neatly in a row looks hilarious. And I had to laugh when him talking shit resulted in his face getting cut in half on top of it. It sounds like Dofla's past is important, but that's not unusual. The real question is how long we have to wait to learn about it. With some villains like Kuro, Wapol, and Lucchi, we get it in the same arc. But there are also cases like Morgan, Arlong, and Crocodile in which it's saved for the future. But at least we know this is one to look forward to, which is nice.
At first I was miffed that the outer walls of the room seemed to be in tact, but that was before I realized that everything came back together again pretty close to where it had been. But what bothered me more was the lack of killer gas entering the room. But now I think I understand. To put it simply, the D block is in the back of the lab, and as such is likely dug into the mountain itself. Cutting the wall exposes it to the mountain, rather than to the outside air filled with gas. So it makes sense. I also find it interesting that the room is going to blow up, so I guess the SAD must be unstable or something. I suppose that's what really explains Law's 2 hour time limit.
I spent a fair deal of time last week wondering exactly where Law's cut hit the R block, and mostly how that would affect Usopp. But now it appears that it hit the top of the first floor (which can be seen on at least one of the pages), and those on the second floor (Usopp, and probably Chopper) would have been tossed up a bit and dropped back down to wonder wtf just happened. The R block would also be dug into the mountain, which explains why the vents were needed to bring the gas in. I can't help but wonder what the status of Kinemon and Brook is.
Caesar is his usual dickish self, but actually fails to hide it for once, so he's clearly getting desperate. Usopp assumes that Caesar's minions won't follow his orders now that he's shown his true colors and plots his next move. But, predictably to readers yet not to the characters, some doofus keeps his faith in the guy and does what he's told. It feels cliche, but I don't really mind. And I guess I'm not surprised that Caesar absorbed the shinokuni, but I wonder if there's a point, because he plainly states that he didn't get it all, or even probably very much of it. I have a feeling it's just there for Luffy to show off. And I guess him attacking his own subordinates finally proves his true nature to the rest of them once and for all. That's probably worth something. Caesar's ultimate form is sufficiently hideous, but that crown looks kinda weird to me.
I really like Usopp's speech there at the end. Oda does a good job of balancing his character between cowardace and bravery, with slow but steady progress. People also seem to get the most out of him when they insult Luffy in some way. He has absolutely no hesitation about facing all of them in order to get to the switch if he has to, but he's also trying diplomacy first. His days of being a liability seem like a distant memory right about now. I'm sure he'll still have those moments, but I expect a better balance now.
Luffy running down the hall is confusing. I guess he could have been building momentum, but I like the idea that he's vulnerable while he charges gear 3 so he felt the need to open some distance first. I laughed when he asked Momo to watch Brownbeard. Like wtf is he gonna do. Finally, Caesar crying in the last panel before Luffy even hits him? Priceless. That thing Vergo said about having more to hit being a liability against a haki user isn't going to work out so well for him.
The cover page…! The freaking cover page!
OMG. This is simply EPIC. fangasm
Nice chapter. Man, Caesar gets more and more disgusting... and Luffy is pissed. This will be great.
Honestly, Garp looks like he's 35 in the spread, at least to me, I dunno where you guys get the 20-something estimate :P
@No:
Honestly, Garp looks like he's 35 in the spread, at least to me, I dunno where you guys get the 20-something estimate :P
Dude, look at his clothes. You think he wasn't even an officer by that age? They seem to be "the day I joined the Marines" shots.
Also, there isn't even a hint of his beard yet.
@No:
Maybe it's the eyebrows ? I dunno dude just looks 30 to me.
Garp looks a bit like my older brother, so I would give him 25.
Also, Very Good's younger self reminds me a bit of Franky but also of someone else. Anyone have an idea ?
Also, thanks to everyone who pointed out the origins of the unnamed marines, AP is simply amazing.
I thought this was a good chapter. I cant wait to find out Doflamingo's past, and MAN! I.. I cant stop looking at that color page. x_x Pandaman is obviously the strongest marine on the page.
I think they're all almost 20 years old yeah
Is it me or at the last page:
! http://img.mangastream.com/m/51/14352127/2dda37ec5b7278423174dee865589584.png
At the top right panel Luffy is above CC's head but at the bottom right panel Luffy is under his head (or same height as his head.).
And also in the top right Luffy's is coming from up and on the bottom right his hand are under him.
I'd go with gravity. He's in the air, so in the later panel he's lower because he's falling down. Slowly and not maybe directly downwards, but still falling. As for the hands, beats me. The hands kinda don't follow the laws of physics, assuming Luffy is gonna hit CC with them. Unless they really weigh less than Luffy, which I have trouble seeing working. If they weigh less than a small guy like that, they must feel like giant air balloons hitting you in the face. If they indeed are as heavy as they look, they would hardly move and Luffy would just bound back to his massive hands.
I don't know if there's a logical explanation behind all this, someone correct me if this is the case.
Edit: I love how suddenly the whole forum went beige.
Just a question about the color spread, the appearance of each marine that appears is when they presumably joined the marines or is this like a picture of an specific time like saying this was "taken" 30 years ago, and everyone is 30 years younger.
One thing i noticed in the chapter, that i think no one mentioned, about luffy gear 3, people think he is gonna use the bazooka move, but unlike previous times he isn't pumping air into is hand like before, the air just flows directly to his elbow http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/14352127/19 so i think that the move we are going to see is a brand new move possibly with more strength that the elephant gun, or maybe i'm looking too much into his gear 3 being a bit different 
So in OP, if you are nameless fodder you are stupid?(ceasr henchmen).
Like the fact Law actually let Vergo in hope he dies in the SAD room(buffalo an Baby gonna save him probably).But smoker doesn't care? And finally Ceasar seems about to go down.
Didn't Don Krieg use to be a marine? Also who's the guy next to Hina?
Thanks.
Keep them coming guys, even the unnamed ones should be put on the list.
Not sure but the guy wearing that "teardrop" hat reminds of Dr. Fishbonen…Anyone else agree?
Hmm, the chapter was fine, but not one of the better ones in the arc I don't think. Mostly due to some confusion.
- Honestly, it probably wasn't until the third time I looked through this chapter that I realized the top half of the mountain lands back in place in the first panel. There were a lot of things I was having a lot of difficulty explaining until I realized that. Mostly where the gas was coming in and where it wasn't, and why it wasn't a problem in certain areas. I had serious concerns about this chapter before catching that. I'll admit that it's my fault for not looking closely, but Oda also takes some blame for not supplementing it with a little supporting dialog, but rather giving us "the ceiling is floating up" from Sanji after the fact for some reason, assuming that translation is even correct. It might actually be past tense, which would mean all my complaints instead go to the translators.
Nice catch! I've reread it but didnt' catch that
At first I was miffed that the outer walls of the room seemed to be in tact, but that was before I realized that everything came back together again pretty close to where it had been. But what bothered me more was the lack of killer gas entering the room. But now I think I understand. To put it simply, the D block is in the back of the lab, and as such is likely dug into the mountain itself. Cutting the wall exposes it to the mountain, rather than to the outside air filled with gas. So it makes sense. I also find it interesting that the room is going to blow up, so I guess the SAD must be unstable or something. I suppose that's what really explains Law's 2 hour time limit.
I thought Nami & kids, Sanji & the G-5 were in D block? Wherever they were the gas did start to come in..
[HIDE] 
[/HIDE]
OR is D Blcok where Luffy & Caeser is?? makes not to go find map of where characters are….
- I really like Usopp's speech there at the end. Oda does a good job of balancing his character between cowardace and bravery, with slow but steady progress. People also seem to get the most out of him when they insult Luffy in some way. He has absolutely no hesitation about facing all of them in order to get to the switch if he has to, but he's also trying diplomacy first. His days of being a liability seem like a distant memory right about now. I'm sure he'll still have those moments, but I expect a better balance now.
I have to agree. Usopp has his moments of the old self but he's doing a better job than what he used to do in overcomining the fear so he can act. And yes, people insulting Luffy seems to a strong ..incentive… for Usopp to react, and defeat them. Laughing at Luffy is what drove Usopp to finally find a way to defeat Ms. Merry Christmas.
That pose where Usopp's pissed at them for "insulting his captain", in a way it reminds me of Ace
@Don:
CC looks with his broken nose like Kurosawa
But what is up with all these transformations..Enel, Moria and now CC in which case it
s even as useless as it could be…he wont be able to even strike one hit with his form right now.
I guess we have to face more of those ridicilous transformations in the future, but i think they aren`t necessary at all and make the villains not even slightly more threatening.
Wouldn't ceasar be stupid he would lauch the Gas at floating Luffy or rob his oxygen. Heck he would have his henchemen trust if he wasn't so mouahaha
I find someone other, but not all yet! :<
!
I thought Nami & kids, Sanji & the G-5 were in D block? Wherever they were the gas did start to come in..
OR is D Blcok where Luffy & Caeser is?? makes not to go find map of where characters are….
Nami/Sanji/Chopper/Kids/etc are in B block. Law/Smoker/Vergo are in D block. Luffy/Caesar are in R block.
One thing i noticed in the chapter, that i think no one mentioned, about luffy gear 3, people think he is gonna use the bazooka move, but unlike previous times he isn't pumping air into is hand like before, the air just flows directly to his elbow http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/14352127/19 so i think that the move we are going to see is a brand new move possibly with more strength that the elephant gun, or maybe i'm looking too much into his gear 3 being a bit different
From what I see, he is pumping the air into his hands like he always did. Or am I missing something?
I find someone other, but not all yet! :<
Wow I can't believe all of them (except the movie ones) can be found in the manga. I've been looking for the heart shaped head Marine on the top right, but you beat me to it. Amazing how you spotted him. Seeing all the marines makes me wish there was a "guess who" game featuring them.
Overall, I wish there was color spread like this one for Pirates, but I figured that would take an eternity to do due to the ratio of pirates to marines.
Young Garp and Momonga looks awesome.
! So it's safe to say ONE PIECE FILM Z is canon now? Since both Ain and Binz are both in the colorspread.
It's entirely possible that the film itself is not canon but the characters are. But that doesn't really make any sense. I mean, we could assume that the events of the movie are canon unless otherwise contradicted, which I think is a good stance to take.
Just a question about the color spread, the appearance of each marine that appears is when they presumably joined the marines or is this like a picture of an specific time like saying this was "taken" 30 years ago, and everyone is 30 years younger.
My guess is that this is each Marine in their 20's/their youth
I find someone other, but not all yet! :<
Nicely done!
Nami/Sanji/Chopper/Kids/etc are in B block. Law/Smoker/Vergo are in D block. Luffy/Caesar are in R block.
Ah thanks for clearing that up :)
