lol expected Mashiro holding off for something trivial like that.
What I don't see is saying "yay our LAST volume out sold one volume of Eiji's series, so now we're the number one most popular manga duo in Japan!"
It's the same Death Note to One Piece comparison I was talking about last week.
I agree w/ Robby it depends on how they really want to end the series.
What I wouldn't like is them somehow acting like they thoroughly surpassed Niizuma Eiji. I mean, hell Mashiro even said it two pages before Takagi declared to Hattori, that surpassing Eiji for a short time doesn't matter much.
Say volume 12 of Death Note outsells volume 12 of One Piece…great.....One Piece volumes 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62 all set new print records, One Piece gets plastered on the side of buses, generates a 500+ episode anime, 12+ movies, tons of video games, etc.
Death Note may be popular but it just doesn't come close to OP....or Dragon Ball....or even Naruto really.
When you think "Pillar of Jump", you think a long lasting series that sustains the magazine.
I do think it's a weakness that Takagi can only write short series, considering their goal as a manga duo is to compete with Bakuman's closest equivalent to Eiichiro Oda or Akira Toriyama.
When you do have series that can maintain high quality and run a long time, saying you can ONLY write something short is a weakness. Takagi also can't write anything that involves battles. I mean, it's one thing if that's not what you want to write, but we've seen he simply can't. The thing is, there are ways to write an action series that involves actual fighting without making it mainstream shonen. As much as it was stupid, look at the manga Panty Flash Fight that was written by Nanamine's corporation. It involved battles and didn't follow mainstream shonen formula.
Really, even look at Hunter x Hunter. There are some typical shonen aspects, but the series follows a pretty irregular story pattern and most of the characters are crazy or dysfunctional in some way or another.
Fullmetal Alchemist had a lot of fights at the end and action throughout, but it wasn't really a manga set up just to have a string of battles (like Bleach or KHR!)
I just think hat saying "Takagi can't do battle, can't do mainstream, etc." is a cop out. I know they're calling the psychological chess game that is Reversi a non-mainstream battle manga, but I just think that they're doing little to improve Takagi's shortcomings as a writer.