I fell inlove with luffy all over again. <3 I dont' think I've laughed this hard since g-8. xD "can you take a crap?" " But of course, Have you ever seen elephants at the zoo?"
Oda is teh manga god! <3
@raj:
Aren't most of you jumping the gun a wee bit? We've seen a total of 5 pages of this guy and suddenly he's the new Paulie.
Brooke>>Paulie>>Wiper. We're going to have alot ogf these, so I think everyone should just calm down on him joining.
Well, Wiper and Paulie both suck, so you aren't making a very good case for Brooke. I think Brooke has captured the hearts of OP fans faster than any manga/anime charecter ever in the history of time.
@Impel:
Well, Wiper and Paulie both suck, so you aren't making a very good case for Brooke. I think Brooke has captured the hearts of OP fans faster than any manga/anime charecter ever in the history of time.
The power of the fro.
Seriously, a skeleton with a fro? and he drinks tea? best original character design ever.
Brooke defiantly looks the goods.
Brooke definetly looks good but I get a sinking feeling he won't stay with the SH for long. I love the way he looks and all but still both Brooke and Sanji wearing almost the same thing is weird.
FWIW, the first HQ raw link (SS) is weird– it redirects like 3 times with "link has been updated, error #2" or something before finally getting to a valid server. The URL changes the subdomain several times. Maybe someone else was getting it at the same time? Or it was edited? 
FWIW, the first HQ raw link (SS) is weird– it redirects like 3 times with "link has been updated, error #2" or something before finally getting to a valid server. The URL changes the subdomain several times. Maybe someone else was getting it at the same time? Or it was edited?
I had that problem with it too B1B – maybe we were accessing it at the same time and that's what killed it! Hahaha!
Brooke definetly looks good but I get a sinking feeling he won't stay with the SH for long. I love the way he looks and all but still both Brooke and Sanji wearing almost the same thing is weird.
I agree. He will be like Zoros friend, Jhonny and the other bounty hunter douche. Hell stick around as a guide too help them get through that part of the sea and help him fight, and then tell Luffy that he cant leave because hes traped by a curse or some other shit like that.
Blah Blah Blah bone joke related to Nami, Blah Blah Blah Cover mini story about his past life before he died and we never see him again.
Oda, you are a mad genius. Brook is already one of my favorite characters and I've only known him for one chapter. It's too bad he does seem like the "arc helper" type though, I would love to see him as a full member.
This Florian Triangle arc is shaping up to be more like a classic pirate story, and that's pretty cool if you ask me. This arc will probably be short, then we might get a bigger arc at Merman Island.
Speaking of Wikipedia, I wonder when will he be added into Uncyclopedia One Piece entry?
It occured to me a couple of hours ago that Brooke has not answered in the negative to any question put to him yet. I'm sure he'll say 'no' to something eventually, but still…
...
...maybe Brooke OD'd!
I'm like Hisotensoku: Not here to preserve peace, nor to destroy it. I certainly can't move mountains. Mostly, I'm just full of hot air.- Meh
Question: Has there ever been a time that Luffy has directly asked someone to join his crew and they didn't become a permanent member? From what I remember, only Luffy only tells SH's that they can join his crew. You get people that tag along (arc-helpers) but they are never asked by Luffy to join the crew.
You might refuse at first, Sanji tried.
If Luffy says you have to join him you are a Straw-Hat -end of story
Did anyone put the theory about Brook is a Devil Fruit user ?!!
Seriously !! a skeleton !! living walking and drinking Tea !!!! and Pervert !!!
Maybe an old sailor who 've eat the Skeleton Fruit !!
Dear Oda !! Burn in Hell !! S@# of ~£45
That theory has been put up too many times, because people refuse to accept the fact that undeads can be in OP.
If you talking ships, angels, fish people, and moon people can exist in OP, then zombies and ghosts are no surprise. Just get over it and accept the fact that Brooke is a walking living skeleton.
My guess is that Brook is part of the reason most people never get through the Florian triangle.
@_Meh_:
It occured to me a couple of hours ago that Brooke has not answered in the negative to any question put to him yet. I'm sure he'll say 'no' to something eventually, but still…
...
...maybe Brooke OD'd!
It's that and the fact that he accepted himself into the crew easier than anyone else by far that makes me doubt him completely. For all we know one of the Shichibukai or Yonkou roam this area and that's why no ships make it through, and this is his method.
Warning awsome reading awsome this awsome chapter awsome may awsome cause awsome side effects.
That theory has been put up too many times, because people refuse to accept the fact that undeads can be in OP.
If you talking ships, angels, fish people, and moon people can exist in OP, then zombies and ghosts are no surprise. Just get over it and accept the fact that Brooke is a walking living skeleton.
I totally agree with that. But that's also the way people in the world of One Piece think : look at Franky. At the first time, Luffy thought he had eaten a fruit, but he was "just" a cyborg. So zombies can exist, but it's possible there's a fruit story too. But I prefer the zombie theorie.
It's that and the fact that he accepted himself into the crew easier than anyone else by far that makes me doubt him completely. For all we know one of the Shichibukai or Yonkou roam this area and that's why no ships make it through, and this is his method.
I'm with theinvisibleworm on this : even though Luffy doesn't seem too frightened by Brooke – and Luffy's instinct is usually correct about people -- there's just too much here (the storm, the offering to God that's been ""defiled", Brooke's inability to say "no", and so on) that leads me to believe we've met our new enemy. So even though he'll be a lot of fun for a while and firendly for a while -- Brooke will eventually show us his true intentions.
Brooke may be at the entryway to "New World" in the same way that Baroque Works were at Whiskey Peak and Smoker was at Loguetown (if your goal is to sink as many pirates as possible, where better place to station yourself than at the entry to the next segment of Grand Line? [This could even be how Crocodile got the idea for placing Baroque at Whiskey Peak – after encountering Brooke himself, or hearing stories about Brooke through the other pirates who'd survived a run-in].
Brooke is probably also the key (excuse the pun) for getting through the Florian triangle without harm, so their adventures with him won't be a complete loss ; they'll get through, but they'll have to find some way to chase him off either just before, or just after they do.
So no. Brooke's design is fun and all – but I don't want another super-skinny, skirt-chasing, joke-making pirate on Sunny. We already have one -- and, unlike Brooke -- he's a first-rate cook too.
I don't think Brooke NEEDS a DF. He can just use the power of the dead.
@Saii:
Question: Has there ever been a time that Luffy has directly asked someone to join his crew and they didn't become a permanent member? From what I remember, only Luffy only tells SH's that they can join his crew. You get people that tag along (arc-helpers) but they are never asked by Luffy to join the crew.
You might refuse at first, Sanji tried.
If Luffy says you have to join him you are a Straw-Hat -end of story
Um…yeah. Gaimon and Dr. Kureha. Both asked by Luffy, both refused and never became SHs.
@Saii:
Question: Has there ever been a time that Luffy has directly asked someone to join his crew and they didn't become a permanent member? From what I remember, only Luffy only tells SH's that they can join his crew. You get people that tag along (arc-helpers) but they are never asked by Luffy to join the crew.
You might refuse at first, Sanji tried.
If Luffy says you have to join him you are a Straw-Hat -end of story
didn't he ask Iceberg to join his crew?
Um, no. No he did not. And he's asked a lot of people to join his crew, but they deny. When they accept, they are immideatly permanant SHs. But, would it really be so bad if Brooke was an SH? I think not! Brooke rules!
This was a great chapter. I can't remember the last time I laughed so hard while reading one.
Okay, I checked, and including the Thousand Sunny, Brooke does make 10 crew members, the amount Luffy wanted when he entered the Grand Line.
@Impel:
Okay, I checked, and including the Thousand Sunny, Brooke does make 10 crew members, the amount Luffy wanted when he entered the Grand Line.
Okay, enough of this crap about Vivi or the ship being crewmembers. Oda clearly stated that there are only 8 strawhats right now, with 7 people having joined Luffy. If Brook DOES permanently join, then he will be "The 8th Person", 9th Strawhat.
I'm not counting Vivi. I AM, however, counting the ship and Luffy, so with Brooke there are 10 SHs.
Why is some people counting 1000 Sunny as one of the crew members?
Yeah, i understand what you all are getting at about 1000 Sunny, but it's "probably" not counted in Luffy's 10 crew idea…..
Just a theory, but does anyone think that Brooke could be a marionette?
@Impel:
Um, no. No he did not. And he's asked a lot of people to join his crew, but they deny. When they accept, they are immideatly permanant SHs. But, would it really be so bad if Brooke was an SH? I think not! Brooke rules!
Does "no he did not" refer to Luffy asking Iceburg to join, or does it refer to Iceberg's refusal to accept Luffy's offer to join?
Because if it refers to Iceburg's refusal of Luffy's offer, then it still doesn't change the fact that Luffy asked him to join … as others have pointed out, Luffy is very casual about asking people to join his crew. The difference is in how far Luffy is willing to go to convince those people to join. For some – like Nami or Sanji, Luffy is willing to go quite far, but for others -- like Iceberg and Gaimon -- Luffy isn't willing to go very far to convince them to join.
Just a theory, but does anyone think that Brooke could be a marionette?
Good Idea ! First encounter with Don Flamingo 
He also asked the old guy inside of Laboon to join too.
Anyone else think Brooke can't be trusted?
Anyway, I hope the rest of OP doesn't turn into one big battle against Blackbeard, lest we forget who the real enemy is- The WG.
Holy hole in a doughnut, Batman!
Anyone else think Brooke can't be trusted?
Anyway, I hope the rest of OP doesn't turn into one big battle against Blackbeard, lest we forget who the real enemy is- The WG.
I disagree. The WG was a major enemy in the Enies Lobby arc, but I think that they are just one of the major enemies that the SHs will face.
The WG just has secrets, and maybe they changed the world in the past. However, they currently tie with some of hte more powerful pirates in the world. The WG isn't bar none the strongest at least–they have serious competition.
We're just thinking that way cause the government tends to be a powerful force in our lives, and thus apply it to OP. However, the world in OP is so big and vast, that unlike earth, man hasn't gained full control of it yet.
And yes, too many people are trusting Brooke. While he has nice quirks, as time goes on things can change. You normally don't trust the undead.
However, I now love the idea of the SHs getting a ghost or something on the crew. Imagine how fights with a skeleton would be like....
However, I now love the idea of the SHs getting a ghost or something on the crew. Imagine how fights with a skeleton would be like….
Yeah, we haven't seen him fight, but I know he'd be a blast to use in Grand Battle.
On a side note, I'm suprised that noone has said anything about Brooke's laugh. He has his own unique laugh, so maybe theories of him being the villian are true. Which would suck, 'cause he'd be a great Straw Hat. I bet he plays the xylophone on his ribs.
@Fire Fist:
Okay, enough of this crap about Vivi or the ship being crewmembers. Oda clearly stated that there are only 8 strawhats right now, with 7 people having joined Luffy. If Brook DOES permanently join, then he will be "The 8th Person", 9th Strawhat.
I agree with this!
BTW, this seems like a slow week, a thread that keeps talking about bones and a fro.:wassat:
Maybe this chapter was not up too par with all the excitement level that most of the members had this week.
I don't think Brook is evil. Evil undead, thats so cliché. Oda is above that:happy:
Anyone else notice that grinning ghost in the lower left hand corner of this panel?
Anyone else notice that grinning ghost in the lower left hand corner of this panel?
I did just now. Nice find. With all this nonsense of Brook being an homage to Jack Skellington, that could be his ghost dog that he plays fetch with by breaking off a piece of his rib-cage.
I am going to laugh my ass off if Brook ends up saying something like "just kidding, I'm already part of a crew" in the next chapter.
We need a Brook V Aokiji Height contest.
STAT.
Anyone else notice that grinning ghost in the lower left hand corner of this panel?
More than that, Zoro is still with 3 swords?
He did keep the hilt and all, but the way it appears in that panel just seems a little wrong.
Anyone else notice that since the StrawHat's entered the grandline, a bunch of freaks have been joining the crew? lol
Think about it:
When they came from the east blue there was Zoro, Nami, Usopp and Sanji who joined and they were just normal people
But once we entered the grandline, we get a talking half human reindeer, a woman who can grow multiple body parts and is only one to read the ancient text, a cyborg and now a skeleton!
Anyone else notice that since the StrawHat's entered the grandline, a bunch of freaks have been joining the crew? lol
Think about it:When they came from the east blue there was Zoro, Nami, Usopp and Sanji who joined and they were just normal people
But once we entered the grandline, we get a talking half human reindeer, a woman who can grow multiple body parts and is only one to read the ancient text, a cyborg and now a skeleton!
It's a testament to just how different and abnormal the Grand Line is compared to the 4 blue seas.
you guys think zoro will get his new sword in this arc or the next arc? since dozens of pirates disappear at that place every year then there must be a bunch of swords for the taking. it would be nice if zoro fought a skeleton with one of the best swords ever made and ended up keeping it after he defeats him.
you guys think zoro will get his new sword in this arc or the next arc? since dozens of pirates disappear at that place every year then there must be a bunch of swords for the taking. it would be nice if zoro fought a skeleton with one of the best swords ever made and ended up keeping it after he defeats him.
Guess you are right or maybe even a seastone sword or fire sword.
can someone pleaser translate what it says on the last page. The writing near the bottom.
you guys think zoro will get his new sword in this arc or the next arc? since dozens of pirates disappear at that place every year then there must be a bunch of swords for the taking. it would be nice if zoro fought a skeleton with one of the best swords ever made and ended up keeping it after he defeats him.
maybe Brooke will say "Wait, I remember seeing a katana somewhere on my ship. Wanna have a look?"
yeah, I agree with melee128, this part need some translating!
Pro-Main Cast Evangelist. In Oda We Trust. TheJackAss Crew. AMC = Anti-main Cast. Luffy x Nami.
maybe Brooke will say "Wait, I remember seeing a katana somewhere on my ship. Wanna have a look?"
http://img201.imageshack.us/img201/5080/clipboard01ed9.png
yeah, I agree with melee128, this part need some translating!
something like 'gaikotsu joining as a nakama!?" im not that good with jap but i can recognise some characters
maybe Brooke will say "Wait, I remember seeing a katana somewhere on my ship. Wanna have a look?"
[qimg]http://img201.imageshack.us/img201/5080/clipboard01ed9.png[/qimg]
yeah, I agree with melee128, this part need some translating!
It says
Eh! Ga-Gaikotsu suddenly becoming a nakama ???
