@myogatheflea:
Heroes has this problem where it has a lot of good ideas and a few bad ideas. Unfortunately the few bad ideas somehow last longer than the good ones and then the story begins to suffer. I'm just hoping to god they don't totally fuck themselves over by the end of the season.
Myoga really nailed it here. I haven't seen the show since the last 3rd of Season 1 but this is EXACTLY what I thought at that time. And now that devoted fans are saying these things, I can only imagine what level it's at now.
Now this isn't meant to be a Heroes VS 'Insert Show I Like' or HEROES IZ SHITY LULZ just an honest critique.
When I first heard about the concept I thought it was AWESOME!!!! As it was described to me, real humans were becoming 'super heroes' but slowly coming to the realization that that's what they were.
I thought this was an insanely cool concept that REEKED of Batman Begins where we, no question, watch a man become a hero from basically start to finish. It's a steady and methodical build-up that works because you can identify and bond with the character which makes for excellent:
drama.
I heard that the show was taking a serious and realistic approach to the concept of these individuals getting their powers.
Nope.
The first episode was essentially like barging in on the opening scene from the 90's X-Men cartoon. Jubillee (sp) busts shit and runs away from home. The first time we see Claire she's jumping off some large structure.
Shocking? Yes…okay....but, what exactly was subtle about that. I think a far more interesting way to deal with these things is in baby steps. Instead focus on her friend and make her seem like the tag-along friend supporting role. Then create an accident at a football game that results in her friend's death but miraculously she survives unscathed.
THAT'S surprising and subtle, you could build at least two episodes worth of her side material on that alone. THEN have her coming to terms with WHY she was spared, why this happened to her. Then you can get to like and learn WITH the characters instead of just about them.
Now maybe Heroes took some of these steps later down the line, I don't know, but this is how it hit me from the start.
A bunch of good ideas that were just loosely bound together by the person who conceived them.
But these ideas don't mean anything if you aren't bonding with the characters. I dunno, maybe that's just my opinion, but I've found in recent years the programs that have resparked my DEAD interest in American television programming have all been DEEPLY rooted in the characters and not just good ideas.