@The:
So after thinking about the chapter, I came up with some theories about the immortality operation of Laws fruit, mainly about how it works, and ideas of how it might be used, or possibly has been used by Law already.
We know Law has the ability to remove the heart of a person when he touches a person to remove it. It's been the heart only we've seen, which makes sense with all the heart motifs from this arc. It's safe to assume that he can remove any and all organs as well. We've seen that despite the heart being removed, the person and organ still functions. Perhaps part of the immortality operation is removal of all organs. This allows the person to still be active, but if they get physically hurt in a certain area, the organ will not be hurt, and it won't be fatal due to the organ being okay. The trick would be that the organs would need to be kept safe and hidden, that way no one could come and just stab the heart to kill the person. Doflamingo would easily in his position be able to safely put the organs away.
The next part is a bit trickier, and it depends on if the translations are solid. Before, we thought it was Laws stamina that drained when using his power. This chapter, it was said to be his life force draining. Aohige's summary states that it's his actual life. I'm going to have to go with the idea that his actual life is drained, but if this is not the case, then the argument falls about, but I'll go with it just for argument and discussion sake.
So if Law is using up his life to make and keep his room opened up, perhaps the room is made up of his life energy. Keeping it open could allow some of his life to leak out, and using attacks could probably use up his life force. Even if not the case, his use of the room is connected to his life in some way. If we look back to Thriller Bark, we saw Kuma having the ability to remove someone's pain, and transfer it to someone else. If Kuma can remove a persons pain and transfer it to someone else, then Law, who is able to switch personalities and do all sorts of medical stuff, should be able to do something similar. Perhaps like a blood transfusion, Law can do a life transfusion, only Law can only take his life and give it to someone else.
If that is the case, then it's not really an immortality operation, but something that expands a persons lifespan, and by taking out their organs, death can't apply by many ways that it could happen. There are some other theories that could come from this, but I won't go into detail, mainly that it would be interesting that people think it is immortality that happens. My best guess is that either someone had the operation, and when they were shot in the head or heart, they were fine; or it is a cover up by some one in the WG for reasons we don't know. Either way, if there was some one (or some people), that have been around for 100's of years, they might have to have the operation every so often to stay alive. In some ways, it would be like a person giving up an organ that diminishes their life, and prolongs another persons life for so long.
With this theory in mind about the operation, I have two ideas about what could happen with Law using it. Luffy has a near gear that expends his life force quite a bit. From many battles, his life has diminished to the point where he will die very soon. Law, having been with him for a number of adventures, decides that Luffy is the one who should become Pirate King. He decided to give Luffy his life, so that he may continue to go on, and become the Pirate King.
The second theory is one I think could be more likely. In Impel Down, everyone was surprised that Luffy was able to hold up for so long, and thought he was dead. He got up, but was warned that his life span had significantly decreased. Perhaps it was much more than they thought. Luffy was down badly after Aces death, and was in very bad condition. There is a possibility that his organs were in bad shape. Law, while treating Luffy, saw he was in bad shape and noticed that he had very little time to live. Seeing something in him, he decides to give a significant amount of his life to him, even though he doesn't know why he's doing it. Luffy is alive because Law extended his life so he could fight on. Perhaps this could lead Law to a point where he's back to his childhood, where he only has three years to live.
So that's my theories, with much conjecture. While it relies on a number of speculations, I feel it's plausible enough. Let me know what you think.
The only thing i can add is that just like what was mention this chapter regarding Law using is life force to sustain room, the immortality operation is base off this. Basically it requires the user while performing the operation to keep the room up to the point that it drains their life force due to strain, fatigue, energy etc., this can also be as a result of the level of operation they would need to perform that would probably take days to do.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@Razh:
I don't know. Seems to me that it's a lot easier to notice and react to a full grown man than to a fly buzzing around.
Anyway, him getting kicked isn't as much of an issue as him just standing next to Dofla and waiting for him and Law to deliver their lines before trying to do anything. It just breaks my immersion. You're gonna throw a ship at the same building your crewmate is in the second you realize you fell into a trap, but you're gonna just stand and comment while your captain is being stabbed in the chest?
Well, as long as the captain's knees don't touch the ground, everything should be fine.
Is it the first time in a movie, manga or anime, even real life that a fight is going on and somebody decide to sit it out because they have the utmost confidence in the person fighting that no matter what they will win against their opponent?. The only time Trebol try to do anything on screen was when doffy was in danger or when he tried to glue law or the last chapter when we heard a name attack from him. Not saying it is the greatest thing Oda did but in know way is it fck fck what is this shit.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@Riddler:
Huh, I enjoyed the chapter, dont see what the big problem is with Law having one big, last moment of trying to settle things with Doflamingo and coming really close to killing him. I thought it was very reminiscent of Wiper almost killing Enel and then him suddenly coming back to life and annihilating Wiper, and that moment was awesome as well. Though while the Skypiea arc is pretty well-liked and by no means seen as a lowpoint of One Piece, I
m sure if some of the members here would have been reading week-to-week back then, they would have been screaming for that arc to finally end, too. Yes, Dressrosa has been going on for a long time, maybe too long, and I think that has tainted atleast some readers subjective view of the arc as a whole. Rushing a final fight that has been a long time coming would be a huge disservice for the whole arc, however. Even if you are tired of this arc, it is nonsense to demand from Oda to end this immediately, because I`m sure, when finally reading chapters like this in volume format, the pacing will work a lot better and the final fight will a be a lot more satisfying because Oda did not just rush through it and thereby sell Doflamingo short as a villain just in order to get to a new arc.
How should this work-out anyway? Should Doflamingo just drop dead suddenly so the arc can end quickly. People complain about Doffy not getting enough credit as the villain, about Trebol not getting a full fight so far, about Fujitora not doing much in the story, about the minor villains not getting enough characterization…but at the same time, they want the arc to end already! How the hell does that mesh? You cant have both. I guess you can fault Oda for throwing so many balls in the air at the same time and then having trouble juggling them all at the same time, but you can
t just expect him to drop all the balls suddenly just to get it over with. Because hey, that really would ruin the whole act completely.
And whats with the sudden complaining about the Doffy pirates being bad villains?? It`s funny, not so long ago, the whole forum wanted a Doflamingo pirates spinoff, because they were so much fun, but now suddenly they are all lame and boring, because....what? Because their fights only got focus for one chapter each? While before that, some members here expected all of them to be defeated in one single chapter similiar to the Fishmen Pirates? Please tell me, how the hell are the villains of this arc worse then other well-liked villain groups like Baroque Works or CP9? How were characters like Miss Merry-Christmas or Kumadori that much more fleshed out than Pica or Dellinger? Reread those arcs and you will see that the current villains, despite having shorter fights, got just as much, if not more screentime and characterisation.
EDIT: Are people actually arguing if Trebol is stupid or not? Lol! OF COURSE he is, he is a complete moron. I mean, he stands around, snot hanging form his nose, laughing like a complete imbecile. Dont you remember him destroying the building Sugar, the person he was supposed to protect, was in, just because he was angry and wasn
t thinking? Him getting enraged by Doffy being attacked and making an unwise move is completely in character. Being a moron does not mean he is bad at his job, though. Look at Kizaru. Guy is to dumb to answer his phone.
I think you have some good points especially about Trebol but people will just find other arguments to disprove this, and in no way i am saying there is no fault with the arc.