I'm thinking female with close to mid range fighting abilities(possibly someone with a weird devil fruit?)
Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)
-
-
if anyone after jinbei would join, i would like a former marine and one viking-themed (doesnt matter if boy or girl) and one of them is logia and one is an expert haki user.
-
He is boring because you don't like him.
I guess Sanji was a boring kicking guy till he learned to create fire for you.
Starting to think you are one of those banned Perona supporters or something, all this butthurtness and now recent douchebagery just sounds like more then hate for Jinbe character.
You pretty much hit the nail on the head.
The man will spout anything and I mean ANYTHING to prove why Jinbe wont join the crew,
anything short of his boxer shorts being the wrong color.Too Japanese as well.
-
Jinbei promise Luffy so its 100% correct
-
@Money:
Jinbei promise Luffy so its 100% correct
He also promised he would: Be a schichibukai, protect ace, protect whitebeard, etc.. he's got a bad track record. Don't get me wrong I still think he'll join though.
-
I generally don't acknowledge Jin be detractors because… All strong arguments against him have been refuted, sans one, which is never brought up. Probably because JINBE AND LUFFY ALREADY PROMISED EACH OTHER HE WOULD JOIN.
So the argument is mostly... Oda is unpredictable! Jin be could totally die or... Something! Just like after they beat NFP and Jinbe told them that they might be executed, some people were all, "Luffy won't like that, Jinbe is in trouble!"*
I'd be willing to listen to counter arguments... they'd just need to make sense in context. As far as Jinbe is concerned, he has to deal with Big Mom and that's it.
*I don't think this happened on this forum, but a lot of smaller One Piece forums had the same symptoms.
-
Grasping at straws to come up with reasons for Jimbei not joining won't stop it from happening. He IS joining. If you find him boring, you're just going to have to deal with it because he WILL be a Straw Hat. Luffy asked him to join. He wants to join. He told Neptune he wants to join. He's joining as soon as Big Mom ordeal is over.
I think it's way soon to make any serious theories about Baby 5. It's because she's female that people find her oh so interesting and likely to join. Could she? Maybe. I don't think so personally. Her quirk is on the extreme end for the Straw Hats in my opinion. I just don't see any reason to think she's a candidate at this point beside the fact that she's female. Same reason people jumped on Monet.She hasn't even met Luffy yet. There's NO basis for any theories at all until she at least meets Luffy. I think it's the same deal as Monet. Interesting female villain, nothing more.
Jimbei, Vivi, Momonosuke, Kinemon, Smoker
Maybe 1 more….
"Straw Hat" Luffy
"Pirate Hunter" Zoro
"Cat Burglar" Nami
"King of Snipers" Usopp
"Black Leg" Sanji
"Monster" Chopper
"Demon Child" Robin
"Cyborg" Franky
"Humming" Brook
"Knight of the Sea" Jimbei
"Fox Fire" Kinemon
"White Chase" Smoker
"Dragon" Momonosuke?
"Princess" Vivi?I think Chopper will be recognized as the crew doctor and given the name "Monster" in place of "Cotton Candy Lover". Chopper wants to be acknowledged as a man and he's come to terms with and accepts the title monster. I think it would be fitting for the World Government to recognize who Chopper is and give him a real bounty and real title. It's something Chopper wants and ultimately something I think that needs to happen. Momo will be considered the crew's pet in his place. I think in a way Oda foreshadowed the crew getting an actual "Pet" by giving Chopper that position in the eyes of the Marines.
-
I still find it funny so many poeple use the "he's too boring" arguement against Jinbe joining.
I heard the exact same thing about Robin.
It ran the gaunlet from "She's boring" to "her personality is as plain as carboard" (yes someone actually said that). They still said "Robin's too boring to be a Strawhat after she joined and they were heading to the Sky Islands. Many stopped arugin after her fight against Yama or her standing with the Strawhats agaisnt Enel, but a few die-hards didn't stop their moaning until Eneis Lobby arc. -
This post is deleted!
-
The more I think about it.. the more I get confused..
Well, the crew really needs another female but Oda won't risk of giving Luffy another "non-hardcore fighter". I think Baby 5 or Monet are good examples for hardcore fighters. -
The more I think about it.. the more I get confused..
Well, the crew really needs another female but Oda won't risk of giving Luffy another "non-hardcore fighter". I think Baby 5 or Monet are good examples for hardcore fighters.Indeed they are good examples of a physically strong female role, but I think we're all so anxious to have a new lady join the crew that we forget that we're going to other Islands. Islands that may be filled with other, AWESOME, lady leads that the SH can choose from.
After all, adding someone a part of the crew is like a marriage. They'll be there till the end. Let's not rush into this!
-
The crew doesn't NEED another female. It is just that some people think it is needed for different reasons
-
The crew doesn't NEED another female. It is just that some people think it is needed for different reasons
Actually, the crew does not need anything at this point, including Jinbe
-
Well Luffy said something different
-
Well Luffy said something different
Yeah, he wants 10. The Shs does not need 10 though, that´s the difference.
-
Still a difference cuz Luffy hasn't said they have to be 3 females with oversized boobs (As nice as they are)
-
You are not wrong. True.. the crew don't need another female but still we want that to happen. It's not about the number nor about the ability. It's all about different crew members. I want a normal female human-being. I'm tired of Luffy inviting weirdos such as Chopper (Animal), Franky (Cyborg), Brook (Skeleton) and Jinbie (Fishman)… that's my personal opinion.
-
You are not wrong. True.. the crew don't need another female but still we want that to happen. It's not about the number nor about the ability. It's all about different crew members. I want a normal female human-being. I'm tired of Luffy inviting weirdos such as Chopper (Animal), Franky (Cyborg), Brook (Skeleton) and Jinbie (Fishman)… that's my personal opinion.
One Piece isn't the normal world, oh and btw a weird girl would actually be cool since the other two are normal besiders the gigantic boobs.
Jinbe is just from another race I don't see how you can call him weirdo for that.
-
A weird girl is a good choice ofc.
What I meant by weirdo = not completely human. =) -
…I want a normal female human-being. I'm tired of Luffy inviting weirdos […] and Jinbie (Fishman)…
-
Guys we already have two women that is plenty, besides there is another group that needs representation on the crew that has none.
Hermaphrodites. The crew has zero and it is clear that at least one is desperately needed.
This character would also obviously need to have a logia, because if the crew doesn't have one it is needed right? -
Guys we already have two women that is plenty, besides there is another group that needs representation on the crew that has none.
Hermaphrodites. The crew has zero and it is clear that at least one is desperately needed.
This character would also obviously need to have a logia, because if the crew doesn't have one it is needed right?Let's make him/her also a Dwarf while we're at it.
-
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-7E4V0XiHJxs/TdVn8VM7VjI/AAAAAAAAARc/wq8rQpgEb2Y/s1600/2.png
LoL….
Dude.. you posts always make me laugh. -
You are not wrong. True.. the crew don't need another female but still we want that to happen. It's not about the number nor about the ability. It's all about different crew members. I want a normal female human-being. I'm tired of Luffy inviting weirdos such as Chopper (Animal), Franky (Cyborg), Brook (Skeleton) and Jinbie (Fishman)… that's my personal opinion.
pp
I get the feeling that if Oda has a girl join she will be a weirdo. Nami and Robin are normal looking so having a regular hot girl with big boobs would be boring. It be nice to see something different. A female that is unique looking is probably something that would catch Luffy's attention. Some weird looking chick from a tribe or someone who ate a smile would be cool. -
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-7E4V0XiHJxs/TdVn8VM7VjI/AAAAAAAAARc/wq8rQpgEb2Y/s1600/2.png
I like yours due to the audience there, but I'm going to use this asn an excuse to post a color verison of the Angry Queen=
[HIDE]
[/HIDE] -
or someone who ate a smile would be cool.
Having two Zoans on the crew would be a bit too boring.
After all, Chopper is our Monster.
Having another animal zoan would take away from that.
-
Having two Zoans on the crew would be a bit too boring.
After all, Chopper is our Monster.
Having another animal zoan would take away from that.
We have 3 Paramecias, Chopper will always be the Reindeer with a Human fruit, there is nothing that can take the uniqueness of him.
I would enjoy a member with a Logia but I'm afraid Oda migth never add that for the SHs and yeah I don't really have a reason, its just a feeling(pretty stupid explanation I know).
-
We have 3 Paramecias, Chopper will always be the Reindeer with a Human fruit, there is nothing that can take the uniqueness of him.
That may be true, but the 3 Paramecias have powers that are completely different to each other, probably because the Paramecia category is a lot less defined/strict on what powers it can bring. Logia has elements, Zoan has animals.
Actually I'd prefer the final crewmate (it isn't Jinbei) to not have a Devil Fruit.
-
We have 3 Paramecias, Chopper will always be the Reindeer with a Human fruit, there is nothing that can take the uniqueness of him.
Yes we do have three paramecias, but they're ALL different!
A Rubber man vs. A Limb sprout woman vs. A "Ghoul"
Paramecias add a variety. Can the same be said to Zoans?
Imagine if Lucci, Jabra, and Drake were to join. Essentially, what would be the difference? We'd have four beast in the crew. Four monsters. All of these new additions would cut into what makes Chopper uniquely special.
-
Yes we do have three paramecias, but they're ALL different!
A Rubber man vs. A Limb sprout woman vs. A "Ghoul"
Paramecias add a variety. Can the same be said to Zoans?
Imagine if Lucci, Jabra, and Drake were to join. Essentially, what would be the difference? We'd have four beast in the crew. Four monsters. All of these new additions would cut into what makes Chopper uniquely special.
Two are modern predators and one's a dinosaur! :ninja: j/k
A flying zoan or an ancient zoan wouldn't be same as Chopper ..esp if the ancient zoan IS a flying one! I'd doubt one will be introduced but it would be great to see a pterosaur!
I see your point, though adding Drake throws it some. Lucci, & Jabra have fighting style is similar they have a mammal predator zoan and with same 'higher skills' from beign trained as CP9 agents. Drake is a predator but isn't a mammal and uses a different style of fighting.
I'm more on the fence about for/against another zoan joining. I think they can be different than Chopper but making them stand out would be tough at first. It would not be redundant tough.
Some have argued that the crew doesn't need another fire user (whether to argue about Kinemon or Zoro geting a fire sword) since there are three already and it would be redundant to add yet another fire attack.
Usopp was the first, while not seen often he does have various fire attacks. He was first seen using fire as far back as Arlong Park.
I think Franky used fire before Sanji (franky at Eneis Lobby to burn the blueprints, Sanji at Thriller Bark…or was it against Jabra? either one still comes after Franky) -
pp
I get the feeling that if Oda has a girl join she will be a weirdo. Nami and Robin are normal looking so having a regular hot girl with big boobs would be boring.What about a Girl with comically small boobs?
-
Yep, Franky used fire even way before he incinerated the blueprints
!
I'm confident that Oda can make another Zoan work if he wants too. I mean we could already call Jinbe a "Fish Zoan" and he still wouldn't clash with Chopper in any thinkable way. Actually they compliment each other perfectly. The moment he joins the crew the Straw Hat's will be able to communicate with humans, animals and marine life! -
Yep, Franky used fire even way before he incinerated the blueprints
! http://c.mhcdn.net/store/manga/106/35-336.0/compressed/ONE_PIECE_336_05.jpg?v=11192686003
I'm confident that Oda can make another Zoan work if he wants too. I mean we could already call Jinbe a "Fish Zoan" and he still wouldn't clash with Chopper in any thinkable way. Actually they compliment each other perfectly. The moment he joins the crew the Straw Hat's will be able to communicate with humans, animals and marine life!Thanks Jabra
Ah forgot that Franky used fire in Water 7 before Enies Lobby. I need to reread some parts … okay arcs :getlost: -
What about a Girl with comically small boobs?
That joke has been played out since Slayers.
-
I was watching Marineford and I was thinking, Marineford would have been so much cooler if all the Straw Hats were there. Imagine Sanji and Zoro wrecking everbody, and a cool ass entrance too.
-
Yes we do have three paramecias, but they're ALL different!
A Rubber man vs. A Limb sprout woman vs. A "Ghoul"
Paramecias add a variety. Can the same be said to Zoans?
Imagine if Lucci, Jabra, and Drake were to join. Essentially, what would be the difference? We'd have four beast in the crew. Four monsters. All of these new additions would cut into what makes Chopper uniquely special.
i agree. strawhats' diversity covers almost every major/prominent groups in the series, as well as each character represents every target market in the buying public or someone they can relate to in the crew.
! EXAMPLES:
ussop represents: elbaf, skypiea, superhero persona
chopper gets: giant, chibi, children, pet, zoan, monster etc. etc.
brooke represents: longarm tribe. ghost theme
nico robin:revolutionaries
sanji: okamas, fishman etc. etc.
seriously, all the crew needs are a former marine, a logia type and maybe newly themed guy that has never been represented by a strawhat (im thinking a viking or something) and a tsundere (non-romantic) to the main character (i think every shounen got this….gokou-vegeta)
for the other potential/predicted crewmembers:
! momonosuke….almost ALL of his qualities (and target market) is occupied by chopper. plus the crew would be too pink with him and chopper.
! kinemon….i just cant see him joining after zoro mentioned he wanted a firesword (i think three times already)
! monet…... (-_-;)
! baby 5….. franky + sanji. loyal to doflamingo, her quirk is obviously a joke and she wont fall for sanji (its been shown she's attracted to ugly guys)
! brownbeard….. the soldier dock system is full so....
! vivi…............... cobra is ailing, whether or not she meets the strawhats at the reverie, she is still the princess and her main goal is to be the princess of alabasta.
! --- Update From New Post Merge ---
! @Katzztar:
! > Some have argued that the crew doesn't need another fire user (whether to argue about Kinemon or Zoro geting a fire sword) since there are three already and it would be redundant to add yet another fire attack.
Usopp was the first, while not seen often he does have various fire attacks. He was first seen using fire as far back as Arlong Park.
I think Franky used fire before Sanji (franky at Eneis Lobby to burn the blueprints, Sanji at Thriller Bark…or was it against Jabra? either one still comes after Franky)
! though ussop's attack is varied, i think his orientation or what is dominant in his character is his plants, and though franky used fire, he is mainly associated with the mecha-stuffs.
! so basically, sanji is still the main fire (element) user in the crew, thats whats associated to him generally.
! –- Update From New Post Merge ---
! seriously, a zoan and a fishman would be enough for the crew. -
Oh no we do not need another Devil Fruit User, too much Devil Fruit Users is a big problem because of there inability to swim.
We need Jenbei, i wish Jenbei joins the crew
-
That may be true, but the 3 Paramecias have powers that are completely different to each other, probably because the Paramecia category is a lot less defined/strict on what powers it can bring. Logia has elements, Zoan has animals.
Actually I'd prefer the final crewmate (it isn't Jinbei) to not have a Devil Fruit.
I'm actually not that set on the 11 members thats something Oda said, I defiently think we will get 3(counting Jinbe) member atleast in the NW, ofc this is just dumb speculation since I have no proof.
Edit: I just realized 8+3= 11…anyway my point is I don't believe Oda has really a set number of SHs if he eventually thinks he can add a new one I think he would.
Yes we do have three paramecias, but they're ALL different!
A Rubber man vs. A Limb sprout woman vs. A "Ghoul"
Paramecias add a variety. Can the same be said to Zoans?
Imagine if Lucci, Jabra, and Drake were to join. Essentially, what would be the difference? We'd have four beast in the crew. Four monsters. All of these new additions would cut into what makes Chopper uniquely special.
You just gave 3 examples of Zoans that are completelly diferent, a Tiger man for example won't be or figth the same way of an Elephant man, its diferent enough and if by same you mean, they all transform, thats how the fruits works and that doesn't really make them equal.
-
but having many zoans in a crew…the main concept of having a zoan in the crew is the power of transformation, chopper got the unique distinction of having 7 different forms...adding another zoan (or animal) is pointless imo...chopper can even talk to animals.
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
its not like having many melee fighters or swordsman in the crew, they can be variated. however, unique crewmembers like chopper, franky and brook (and jinbei) dont need other copycats to go along with.
-
but having many zoans in a crew…the main concept of having a zoan in the crew is the power of transformation, chopper got the unique distinction of having 7 different forms...adding another zoan (or animal) is pointless imo...chopper can even talk to animals.
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
its not like having many melee fighters or swordsman in the crew, they can be variated. however, unique crewmembers like chopper, franky and brook (and jinbei) dont need other copycats to go along with.
Not exactly asking for it I'm just refuting the fact that a Zoan is a Zoan and having more then one takes the uniqueness from Chopper, which in reallity really doesn't.
-
Not exactly asking for it I'm just refuting the fact that a Zoan is a Zoan and having more then one takes the uniqueness from Chopper, which in reallity really doesn't.
How doesn't it?
~First Point~
As of now Chopper is the only one who can morph himself like an Animorph. Not to mention that he's literally the only one on the crew who is an animal.
~Second Point~
Just how different could you make two zoans be battle wise?Zoans fight based on their ferocious tenacity and brute force. They can't turn into doors, stretch, or shoot fire out of their mouths. Oda would have to put in some serious creative work just to be able to make two zoan SHs have distinctive fighting styles. With Chopper being the only zoan, Oda doesn't have to try and "share the wealth" or spread that out.
After all, why do you think Oda had an army of Zoans vs having an army of Paramecias? Zoan users are essentially identical with only different aesthetics.
It's easier to duplicate an army of Zoans (because of their identical framework) compared to duplicating an army of any other fruit type.
-
I'm thinking Oda might incorporate a Viking character, he said the series "Vicky the Viking" was a huge inspiration to OP.. and we haven't seen much beyond the giants regarding the Vikings.
!
-
I'm thinking Oda might incorporate a Viking character, he said the series "Vicky the Viking" was a huge inspiration to OP.. and we haven't seen much beyond the giants regarding the Vikings.
Ha!
I never knew this, so I went to YouTube to search for Vicky the Viking and lo and behold the top two comments are from OP fans giving their graces to the show. I'm gonna have to watch an episode of this one day.
:)
!
-
the strawhat crew really needs a viking on the crew. oda liked pirates because of them anyways. a viking girl/guy who got strong haki. that would be great.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Not exactly asking for it I'm just refuting the fact that a Zoan is a Zoan and having more then one takes the uniqueness from Chopper, which in reallity really doesn't.
yeah it will, just like having another kid in the crew would take away chopper's identity. as said, brook, franky, chopper–--unique members of the crew that adds diversity....if we see another animal, kiddo, skeleton or robot in the crew, it would take away their uniqueness.
its very different than having multiple melee or swordsmen fighter on the crew, its not too rare, so its fine just as long theyre kinda varying from each other.
-
i agree. strawhats' diversity covers almost every major/prominent groups in the series, as well as each character represents every target market in the buying public or someone they can relate to in the crew.
EXAMPLES:
ussop represents: elbaf, skypiea, superhero persona
chopper gets: giant, chibi, children, pet, zoan, monster etc. etc.
brooke represents: longarm tribe. ghost theme
nico robin:revolutionaries
sanji: okamas, fishman etc. etc.
seriously, all the crew needs are a former marine, a logia type and maybe newly themed guy that has never been represented by a strawhat (im thinking a viking or something) and a tsundere (non-romantic) to the main character (i think every shounen got this….gokou-vegeta)SMOKER SEE'S WHAT YOU DID THERE.:ninja:
-
How doesn't it?
~First Point~
As of now Chopper is the only one who can morph himself like an Animorph. Not to mention that he's literally the only one on the crew who is an animal.
~Second Point~
Just how different could you make two zoans be battle wise?Zoans fight based on their ferocious tenacity and brute force. They can't turn into doors, stretch, or shoot fire out of their mouths. Oda would have to put in some serious creative work just to be able to make two zoan SHs have distinctive fighting styles. With Chopper being the only zoan, Oda doesn't have to try and "share the wealth" or spread that out.
After all, why do you think Oda had an army of Zoans vs having an army of Paramecias? Zoan users are essentially identical with only different aesthetics.
It's easier to duplicate an army of Zoans (because of their identical framework) compared to duplicating an army of any other fruit type.
Like I said Chopper isn't human, hes a freaking Human Zoan and even then, we saw diferent Zoans figth diferently, aspect wise Chopper doesn't lose the uniqueness and figthing wise a diferent animal can figth diferently from Chopper, I know Chopper points give him diferent battle styles and abilities already but like I said we have seen diferent Zoans and they don't all figth like each other.
How is that hard? Oda already made all the Zoans besides maybe the CP9 ones because they shared some abilities, pretty diferent from each other.
Again I'm not asking for anything, since I don't ask for shit, I predict based on the story, not based on wishes or in a pair of boobs, I'm just saying that nothing can take Chopper uniqueness away not a Zoan not a Kid.
-
SMOKER SEE'S WHAT YOU DID THERE.:ninja:
Aokiji fits that bill better, since he is actually a former marine now.
But I see only jimbei joining at some point. I feel we are complete. I don't see a logia ever joining, I think Oda feels they would be too powerful. Haki attacks or not. As for a Zoan joining. Only one I can possibly see is like Momo for the sole fact that he ate a SAD fruit or whatever it exactly was and be interesting to see how its different? Is it incomplete? Better/worse? Doflamingo has some power over it? Can he change back to human or is he stuck in some hybrid form? ect.
But otherwise the strawhats have enough devil fruit users as it is. I would prefer to have a non fruit user join if any new people did. But with jimbei we have Luffy's 10 people right?
1. Zoro
2. Nami
3. Usopp
4. Sanji
5. Chopper
6. Robin
7. Franky
8. Thousand Sunny
9. Brook
10. Jmbei -
If we count Thousand Sunny, we should count Vivi and Carue even more
-
If we count Thousand Sunny, we should count Vivi and Carue even more
Why?
The thousand sunny is sailing with them on their adventures. It openly fly's a pirate flag unlike hiding its affiliation with the strawhats and still a princess.
I thought for sure people would recognize the strawhats ships as a PERSON ever since we learnt what we did about their prior ship the Going Merry. The strawhats I'm sure see the thousand sunny as a "nakama"
There was lots of talk in this thread about how strange half the crew is from Brook, Franky, Chopper and so on, so what's so strange about a ship being a "person"
-
I havent updated my status for over a year and half
it says everything