Questions That Don't Deserve Their Own Thread

Chopper Madness

I'm not sure where the difference is relevant. If he's the strongest person with a sword or the best swordplay, he's going to win against any other swordsman in theory until his title is taken by whoever defeats him. And up against someone not using a sword, it's already a given that his comparative strength is uncertain as of yet. Top tier, but uncertain. So as long as he's not up against like Wapol, he could win or lose. And just because Kizaru and Aokiji made swords doesn't limit them to swordplay, and neither are swordsmen, so neither distinction would matter.

And I think this will be moved to a thread with a broader topic. It seems small and irrelevant, not a novel idea like the Kuma theory or a popular topic like Moria's fate used to be. Although, to be honest, if we just broadened it to our own takes on what "strongest swordsman" entailed, it could be worthwhile, for a short time. I doubt people would debate it for long, but who knows.

i agree we should change it to be what does it mean to be the strongest swordsman?

u can even debate hes only the greatest known swordsman others could be greater they just havent had the fame

mr.jack

mihawk can handle kizaru i'm sure.. he had legendary duels with shanks..

Cowcatbear

It could be he's the most muscular of all people who just happens to use a sword, his swordplay is just sub-par.

Retsudo

@smurfx:

mihawk is the best swordsman period. shanks would most likely beat him in a fight since he is most likely a great swordsman and a fighter as well. i imagine shanks being zoro and sanji rolled into one. well he would obviously have to fight with his legs since his one hand is busy with the sword. although i'm sure he would still be a great fighter with his sword gone. i don't know if mihawk would be able to still beat a good fighter without any sword or knife.

Are you joking.

Mihawk would certainly be very strong without his blades. His physical fitness would remain the same.

Kishido

@Chopper:

if their are fishman do u think there will be turtle men?

and if so do u think they are ninjas?

perhaps teenage ninjas?

That would be awesome. Turtle-Man for nakama xD I hope he has a staff…, but he will be slow as hell xD

smurfx

@Retsudo:

Are you joking.

Mihawk would certainly be very strong without his blades. His physical fitness would remain the same.

sure he is strong without his swords but i said he could not beat a good fighter without his sword. you think he could beat lucci without his sword?

@mr.jack:

mihawk can handle kizaru i'm sure.. he had legendary duels with shanks..

i don't know about him handling kizaru. sure mihawk had legendary duels with shanks but is shanks just a swordsman? if shanks is a complete fighter meaning he uses both the sword and martial arts then that really makes him special. almost matching the strongest swordsman in the world but still holding back your abilities means you are at entire other level. i put the admirals at yonkou levels meaning they are about even and i put shanks level above mihawk so kizaru should be able to defeat mihawk.

rubia_ryu

@KiShiDo:

That would be awesome. Turtle-Man for nakama xD I hope he has a staff…, but he will be slow as hell xD

Slower than Luffy or Chopper? Or do you mean the other slow?

Kishido

@rubia_ryu:

Slower than Luffy or Chopper? Or do you mean the other slow?

the other slow.

paranoik0s

what if sb beats mihawk on 1vs1 fight but without using any kind of sword?

it wouldnt make him N1 swordsman ofc

to my mind a duel between swordsmen should be "official" by those two

also after the duel finishes the one who lost should not be able to win against his opponent in another duel without further development of his skills or abilities.

meaning that the duels result wasnt due to other factors like luck,special circumstances,past injuries etc but just due to skill with a sword

Poseidon

This post is deleted!

Darkstorm

The strongest swordsman in the world not surprisingly means he's the strongest swordsman in the world.

As for people who use other techniques in tandem or completely different ones, it would obviously depend on how skilled they are with those and how they mesh with a swordsman.

Fairly obvious stuff.

Retsudo

Because he is on the level of the Yonkou?

Justaway

Do you think that Oda is risking this series with this timeskip?

MasterKingJC

@Justaway:

Do you think that Oda is risking this series with this timeskip?

Nope. He knows what he's doing.

/thread

Gia Sado

Usually an author can ruin it with the first few chapters and with this manga, so far so good. It feels like the original with just artistic changes to the mains, and of course, new power ups. Ive enjoyed the first 2 chapters like i would the previous. Its just funny that 100 chapters ago, they were in sabaody doing almost the same thing. Everything is still set up the same, for the same course of the same story.

Iva sama

@Retsudo:

Because he is on the level of the Yonkou?

He's Whitebeards first division commander…

Cyan D. Funk

@Justaway:

Do you think that Oda is risking this series with this timeskip?

Were Toriyama and Araki risking it?

Retsudo

@Iva:

He's Whitebeards first division commander…

Remember how the Elder Stars hyped up Marco?

kagehisa

@lufi_google:

Is Moria an fishman if so he would be like the only fishman that can't swim :))

hahahahahhaaaaHAHAHHAHhahahahHAH omg that's amazing theory u got

Kishido

What would happen if Brook would be touched by a sea-stone or if he fells down into the sea? Will he die?

Ryuunaga

@KiShiDo:

What would happen if Brook would be touched by a sea-stone or if he fells down into the sea? Will he die?

Probably not the same would happen to him that would happen to a merman/maid he would just sit there like a hammer sinking

FolhaS

He's a devil fruit user, he'll die. We've seen him sink while trying to rescue Luffy in several gags.

JellyBean

Is there any upsides/advantages in Brook's devil fruit in combat? (No, I'm not talking about being able to revive) All i see is that he has used his devil fruit's ability and is just left with the weaknesses.

Thatanas

@FolhaS:

He's a devil fruit user, he'll die. We've seen him sink while trying to rescue Luffy in several gags.

Stupid, they mean: will his powers de-activate, which causes him to die. Obviously he'll drown in time.

FolhaS

@JellyBean:

Is there any upsides/advantages in Brook's devil fruit in combat? (No, I'm not talking about being able to revive) All i see is that he has used his devil fruit's ability and is just left with the weaknesses.

No bloody fights, can be easily cured with milk.

@Thatanas:

Stupid, they mean: will his powers de-activate, which causes him to die. Obviously he'll drown in time.

Oh, but my answer still fits.

Ryuunaga

@JellyBean:

Is there any upsides/advantages in Brook's devil fruit in combat? (No, I'm not talking about being able to revive) All i see is that he has used his devil fruit's ability and is just left with the weaknesses.

Well he is a skeleton so he can live forever

asm00200

actually the answer is: he is already dead!!

Ryuunaga

@asm00200:

actually the answer is: he is already dead!!

SKull Joke! Yohohohohohoho!

Emerica4u

Random thought. Could a DF user use CoA to create an armor around themselves that protects them from sea water while submerged, allowing them to overcome the weakness?

Thatanas

@Emerica4u:

Random thought. Could a DF user use CoA to create an armor around themselves that protects them from sea water while submerged, allowing them to overcome the weakness?

I'd say no. 16 chars.

Emerica4u

@Thatanas:

I'd say no. 16 chars.

what a short and unjustified comment haha :)

Miadestroystokyo

I have some questions…. that need answers....

okay so we know that water and blood can both make Crocodile solid but... what about sweat? If blood works shouldn't sweat be able to work to? If that's the case, shouldn't Luffy's punches have worked in their first fight because they were in the middle of the desert and Luffy looked pretty sweaty. Also, can Crocodile's own blood make him solid??

also how can he stand to walk around the desert in those big fur coats?! Or more importantly... how can Nico Robin do it?! I mean, Crocodile can always dissipate into sand and fly back to air conditioning haven but Robin has to WALK through them deserts [or get a ride from a turtle or something] and she's wearing that furry white coat. HOW? FFFFFFFF.

rubia_ryu

@Miadestroystokyo:

I have some questions…. that need answers....

okay so we know that water and blood can both make Crocodile solid but... what about sweat? If blood works shouldn't sweat be able to work to? If that's the case, shouldn't Luffy's punches have worked in their first fight because they were in the middle of the desert and Luffy looked pretty sweaty. Also, can Crocodile's own blood make him solid??

also how can he stand to walk around the desert in those big fur coats?! Or more importantly... how can Nico Robin do it?! I mean, Crocodile can always dissipate into sand and fly back to air conditioning haven but Robin has to WALK through them deserts [or get a ride from a turtle or something] and she's wearing that furry white coat. HOW? FFFFFFFF.

Any sort of water or aqueous solution can harden sand. You could pour juice on him and it'd work, but that'd be a waste of juice (and your life). I think his own blood could affect him too. Luffy couldn't hit him then because… he wasn't sweating enough, I guess? Sweat doesn't stay on open skin for that long anyhow.

The fur coats are for style! Besides, thick clothing helps protect from the sun's harmful rays; exactly why people living there wear such thick clothing. Also, I'm sure they have various sorts of transportation with cover, such as the carriage that brought the top Baroque Work members to Spider Cafe (Paula's bar).

Chopperxoxo

I just saw the Enel mini ark when he is on the moon, but he does not suffocate from lack of air

Do Logia users have to breathe to live?

icel

If they didn't have to they wouldn't drown when thrown into the ocean.

Ever thought that maybe there's an actual atmosphere on the One Piece world's moon?

jimbeirulestheseas

one piece is not real life
anything is possible
go outside if you want real life

Redspear

There are many moons in the one piece universe so it is possible for there to be air on one of them.

Gol D. Silvers

Is anyone here kind enough to give me some good alternatives to Mangastream?? Because I want to re-read some chapters during my semestral break. Thanks in advance.

FolhaS

@Gol:

Is anyone here kind enough to give me some good alternatives to Mangastream?? Because I want to re-read some chapters during my semestral break. Thanks in advance.

I've been using mangareader, since onemanga closed.

Nami

haven-reader.net is ok, too.

eerie

icel, can you sit there and tell me with all honesty Akainu breathes?

that man is a beast. he needs no air.

nefra

@Gol:

Is anyone here kind enough to give me some good alternatives to Mangastream?? Because I want to re-read some chapters during my semestral break. Thanks in advance.

http://www.watchop.com/page/2-read_manga_online/

Gol D. Silvers

@FolhaS:

I've been using mangareader, since onemanga closed.

@Nami:

haven-reader.net is ok, too.

@nefra:

http://www.watchop.com/page/2-read_manga_online/

Thanks a lot. :happy:

IrishLuigi

Franky is regularly stated to be a pervert, but I know it's not his horniness.

So is it his exhibitionism, or his perverse delight for technology?

Thatanas

@IrishLuigi:

Franky is regularly stated to be a pervert, but I know it's not his horniness.

So is it his exhibitionism, or his perverse delight for technology?

Obviously the first one..

Lilly Jade

My apologies if this has already been asked somewhere, but … has anyone noticed that the fake Sanji from the most recent chapters looks like Sanji, while Sanji's poster looks like Duval used to?

Redspear

!É} 84╗8▒"Θ·Θ◘6<–-what i understood.

Emerica4u

@Lilly:

My apologies if this has already been asked somewhere, but … has anyone noticed that the fake Sanji from the most recent chapters looks like Sanji, while Sanji's poster looks like Duval used to?

Hi. My name is Detective Inspector Blatant with the Arlong Park Obvious Police, you're under arrest for suspicion of harbouring class-3 retarded views. You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.

HikaruYami

@Emerica4u:

what a short and unjustified comment haha :)

Shanks wouldn't be scared of eating a devil fruit if he could just be invincible underwater.

@Redspear:

There are many moons in the one piece universe so it is possible for there to be air on one of them.

Where was this stated?

Sakonosolo

In Robin's flashback there's a model of different celestial bodies. Some people say they're moons around the OP world while others say they're different planets.