So was I supposed to cry with this new "fallen from the sky" drama??? You see ladies and gentlemen this is exactly what you need to avoid when you tell a story; out of the blue shittiness.
Fairy Taint Discussion II
-
-
I wonder…..is Hiro gonna follow down the Kubo path now ? Seems to be with his level of planing .
-
That was so bad. So so bad. I'm not gonna lie, the execution of it was pretty decent but it couldn't make up for such a craptastic reveal.
-
Why would Lisanna say she had to hide her magic?
I thought Earthland mages couldn't use theirs in Edoras unless they took that pill thing Gerard 4.0 gave to Lucy and the others.
-
chapter just created a whole lot of plot holes
-
You know if Mashima really had to take this route then he coud have handled it so much better. Give a flashback on her "demise" to make her death seem ambiguous, give the real Lizanna in Edolas some character development while people stil think she's the edo version, have the reveal be a plot twist in the Edolas arc which will really help save the gang. Not this ass pull to make everyone happy.
-
If we had swiched the roles that Edo-Lucy had with Lissana in the Edolas arc, this would had made a little more sense.
-
Wait you mean pointless background character who did nothing ?
-
You just described the entire FT guild.
-
Why would Lisanna say she had to hide her magic?
I thought Earthland mages couldn't use theirs in Edoras unless they took that pill thing Gerard 4.0 gave to Lucy and the others.
Stop paying attention to details.
A wizard
gave her the pilldid it. -
Why would Lisanna say she had to hide her magic?
I thought Earthland mages couldn't use theirs in Edoras unless they took that pill thing Gerard 4.0 gave to Lucy and the others.
Boom. Again, this reeks of a lack of direction.
-
"This is no ordinary Earthland magik. It's demonic magiks with different scientific properties"
You'll hear this sooner or later. Was it revealed on what her powers were? I'm guessing something similar to transformation like Mira and Elf. We'll see.
-
I'm feeling kinda quote lazy but No way Mira thought her sis was just ascending to heaven, There's no precedent for that in Fairytail. I don't think It could have happened they way the Mini flashback shows it. Noway Mira wouldn't have mentioned it.
I wonder where Hiro is going with all this now? Hope this somehow ties into another arc or whatever.
-
I liked the chapter but it was indeed out of the blue bullshit. Edo-Fairy Tail knew Lisanna was dead and when Lisanna just waltz into the guild they all just accept it and give her a hug. "Yaaaay!" They knew nothing about Earthland at that point so essentially they believed their Lisanna just came back to life no questions asked.
Then there's the already mentioned concept of Lisanna just floating off into the sky while in front of her sister's face. Why didn't the Anima suck up the older sister too? They were both right next to each other. Eh…well I enjoyed the emotions of the chapter and it was heartwarming to see them reunite like that and see Edo-Fairy Tail let go of Earthland Lisanna.
Lol, and what Vanessa mentioned. Exactly, there was no point for Lisanna to hide her magic because she shouldn't have been able to use it in the first place.
-
"This is no ordinary Earthland magik. It's demonic magiks with different scientific properties"
You'll hear this sooner or later. Was it revealed on what her powers were? I'm guessing something similar to transformation like Mira and Elf. We'll see.
She uses Take Over Magic, too. The only canon use of it so far was to turn into a Chicken to help warm Happy's Egg. We don't know how skilled she is, but she was able to do it at a young age, which makes her more skilled than Elfman but less than Mira Jane, I'd guess.
-
Doesn't she use Animal Take Over, while Elfman uses Beast and Mira Jane Demon or Devil or something like that?
-
Doesn't she use Animal Take Over, while Elfman uses Beast and Mira Jane Demon or Devil or something like that?
All three of them use the base magic Take Over. Mira Jane's variant is called "Satan Soul". Elfman's is called "Beast Soul". Lisanna's only shown so far is called "Animal Soul". In Addition, Mira Jane can also use Transformation Magic. She also put Lucy to sleep during Phantom Lord.
-
Well finaly read the last two chapters .
198 : Thank God the cats are going away . Wendy and Charles are a match made in heaven , they are both equaly stupid .
199 : Plotholes , stretches of fancy and…...holy shit don't tell me it's the aniversary of her "death" or something .
-
On one hand I'm glad the cat arc is finally over.
On the other hand this Lisanna bullshit is ridiculous.
Loving Gazille and his cat, though.
-
Will you add Faily Fail to your review list, gabz?
-
Nah, I'm not really interested in it. Sometimes I read it, but I stopped taking it seriously after the Gerard arc.
-
Which ?
-
The first one.
-
I just came in here to grab the checklist so I could make a Naruto version, and I see that Lisanna is alive and actually the dead one from earth and other stuff.
I think I stopped reading just in time.
-
@RobbyBevard:
I just came in here to grab the checklist so I could make a Naruto version, and I see that Lisanna is alive and actually the dead one from earth and other stuff.
I think I stopped reading just in time.
I keep on reading out of sheer boredom, but this might be the last straw for me.
-
You guys are no troopers. bunch of cowards
COWARDS I SAY.
I'm the real trooper here i've been reading this weekly since chapter 1 and i'll continue to do so until this ends.
-
You guys are no troopers. bunch of cowards
COWARDS I SAY.
I'm the real trooper here i've been reading this weekly since chapter 1 and i'll continue to do so until this ends.
I think the word you're looking for is masochist.
-
So who is dead in this series? As in who has died and haven't came back to life.
-
Lucy's mom…......yet .
-
Simon, that turban-wearing guy with the metal jaw from the Tower of Paradise arc.
Also, we haven't gotten any hints that Racer survived.
-
-
Just got around to reading the most recent chapter…
puke. tastic. How are we supposed to feel catharsis or relief or happiness or whatever, for this character we know next to nothing about! It's terrible storytelling.
Also, there is no way this was the mangaka's original intent. Retcon everywhere.
-
I think I may drop the series if the fandom is always this irritating. That may be soon.
-
Is this series any good? you guys seem to hating on it so i want to know for sure.
-
I think I may drop the series if the fandom is always this irritating. That may be soon.
I stopped dealing with the fandom after I read a comment saying how Fairly Tail was better than One Piece because it was simpler and easier to read, while still having deeper characters.
-
-
@Tamaki:
Is this series any good? you guys seem to hating on it so i want to know for sure.
! v6BL6QvKljo&autoplay=1
-
Is this series any good? you guys seem to hating on it so i want to know for sure.
It's not a particularly deep series, or at points well thought-out, but there are still some neat moments every now and then, and the action's usually decent. It can be very cheesy, and the fanservice oftentimes gratuitous. It's not all that great, really, but it's generally inoffensive enough to keep me occupied for the six or seven minutes it takes to read the chapter each week.
-
You have to admit Fairy Tail is better than Bleach at least. I'm not so sure if it's better than Naruto though; both go up and down with good and bad every week.
I definitely agree the Lisana thing is really cheap. Even if the scene with Mirajane and Elfman was a little touching, it doesn't change anything. It's the equivalent of a dead character in One Piece coming back to life and meeting the Straw Hats again. It'd defeat the whole purpose of their character development.
I'll wait and see how she is handled interacting with the guild before making any more judgments on her actually being here now.
-
I stopped dealing with the fandom after I read a comment saying how Fairly Tail was better than One Piece because it was simpler and easier to read, while still having deeper characters.
There is a NF user called $Naruto$ . You just described all of his posts .
He's like the Mider T of Fairy Tail . Well him and Jugger (whenever he can say something which aproximates english) .
Anyways yeah this is a huge ass retcon . And Gokuyusuke is right , we know jack shit about Lisanna .
Well….....if Hiro at the very least prety much openly has her and Natsu have sex I would say he actualy went off with this somewhere .
-
I stopped dealing with the fandom after I read a comment saying how Fairly Tail was better than One Piece because it was simpler and easier to read, while still having deeper characters.
He meant people whine for eveyrthing that isnt One Piece i believe even if its not justified…
In 2 years everyone will be bashing Toriko and Belzeebub just wait for it.
-
Just got around to reading the most recent chapter…
puke. tastic. How are we supposed to feel catharsis or relief or happiness or whatever, for this character we know next to nothing about! It's terrible storytelling.
Also, there is no way this was the mangaka's original intent. Retcon everywhere.
thank goodness i'm not the only one who feels that way. when Lisanna appeared i was like "who is thaaaat?!" i felt really weird when all Natsu and the rest were crying and hugging her. and i thought i'd been keeping up pretty well with all the characters and plots.
i generally enjoy Fairy Tail as light reading, it had many comedic moments in the earlier chapters that made me really like it. even the recent arc wasn't that bad for me. but Lisanna appearing just came out of nowhere. i have no idea what's going on now.
-
I couldn't care less about Lisanna, tbh.
-
I couldn't care less about Lisanna, tbh.
Right? We can just add her to the rest of the fodder magicians in the guild.
-
Romance, oh romance…
Seasoned with boobs, hips and duckfaces
-
oh please no romance.
the lack of it has been one of FT's few saving graces so far.
-
Right? We can just add her to the rest of the fodder magicians in the guild.
That all depends on the next few chapters .
We¨ll see if she will be someone like Wendy who (to our boundless regret) is prety much a main character now .
-
You have to admit Fairy Tail is better than Bleach at least. I'm not so sure if it's better than Naruto though; both go up and down with good and bad every week.
I definitely agree the Lisana thing is really cheap. Even if the scene with Mirajane and Elfman was a little touching, it doesn't change anything. It's the equivalent of a dead character in One Piece coming back to life and meeting the Straw Hats again. It'd defeat the whole purpose of their character development.
I'll wait and see how she is handled interacting with the guild before making any more judgments on her actually being here now.
To tell the truth, I think I get more enjoyment reading/watching Bleach then I do from Fairy Tail. Bleach has been constant in what they doing and doesn't raise my hopes only to bring them down crashing (or I have learn not to let them raise my hopes after the Chad thing). Though with Fairy Tail I sometimes would compare it to One Piece at times (especially in the beginning) where I can see mirror images of some things from One Piece. Thus adds the idea that this is just a One Piece rip off. I know now that it isn't but that feeling is there. Bleach I am willing to read/watch it each week but with Fairy Tail it sometimes feel like a chore to do. Right now with the Fairy Tail anime I am not feeling forced but a few episodes ago I was doing it just because I had to because eventually Crunchyroll is going to take it off.
Also Bleach has such unique designs for some of their colorful characters. haha
-
oh please no romance.
the lack of it has been one of FT's few saving graces so far.
If romance happens those little cat people thingies may start making out, so yeah.. No thank you.