Theories That Don't Deserve Their Own Thread

Muda Muda no Mi

@Uzumaki_D_Kenichi:

Too old? Are you talking about BB or the theory itself.
This is honestly the first I've heard of this theory.

Yeah, it's been brought up before. Not much, but by using a search function, you can see it's been mentioned a few times since early last week by people like kenzo hartman (Mar 9th - 577 Spoiler thread), el chupa negro (Mar 10 - Chp 577 thread), and Smigu (Mar 12 - Gen Blackbeard thread); the latter post sparked some debate regarding said theory…...

So, yeah....it's not news....

Akumu

There's the reason why I haven't heard of it.
I don't check the spoiler thread except after a break, and even then it's once in a blue moon. I don't really bother with the Chapter threads anymore, because they turn into nonsensical discussions, and I've never even read anything in the General Blackbeard thread. So it's new to me, and new to other people who don't read those threads.

Don Quichotte De Flamingo

@Muda:

Yeah, it's been brought up before. Not much, but by using a search function, you can see it's been mentioned a few times since early last week by people like kenzo hartman (Mar 9th - 577 Spoiler thread), el chupa negro (Mar 10 - Chp 577 thread), and Smigu (Mar 12 - Gen Blackbeard thread); the latter post sparked some debate regarding said theory…...

So, yeah....it's not news....

that you remmeber who brought it up..wow
i heard of this theory but couldnt have telled who exactly it was and where… well, it isnt the best theory so i never thought that it would be needed...

choperman

well i've thought this for a while now….. dragons the 4th yonkou

nuff said

mickgreen58

@choperman:

well i've thought this for a while now….. dragons the 4th yonkou

nuff said

Interesting theory.

If Dragon is the 4th Yonkou, why does Oda keep the 3rd and 4th Yonkou's faces dark when Garp first introduced them, even though we had already seen what Dragon looked like?

Also, Dragon doesn't look like anyone in the picture below:

Zik

@mickgreen58:

Interesting theory.

If Dragon is the 4th Yonkou, why does Oda keep the 3rd and 4th Yonkou's faces dark when Garp first introduced them, even though we had already seen what Dragon looked like?

Also, Dragon doesn't look like anyone in the picture below:

http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20071216142215/onepiece/images/9/94/Yonkou.jpg

That's why it's not an interesting theory.

Unless I should be expecting another wave of Dragon is two ppl/has two bodies despite Oda(speaking through his characters) specifically saying Dragon was a revolutionary unlike pirates because he directly targets the WG.

choperman

@mickgreen58:

Interesting theory.

If Dragon is the 4th Yonkou, why does Oda keep the 3rd and 4th Yonkou's faces dark when Garp first introduced them, even though we had already seen what Dragon looked like?

Also, Dragon doesn't look like anyone in the picture below:

http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20071216142215/onepiece/images/9/94/Yonkou.jpg

well….. umm........ he's clearly the fat guy

runs away from argument

Muda Muda no Mi

The real question is which one of the 2 is Kaidou?

The one in the lower left corner with a skull on his forehead, or the fat looking one with the huge ass grin and thick poofy hair?

Get_It_Memorized

I think Kaidou would be the skull one. I think the fat one is Lola's mom. :ninja:

Johnny B. Decent

@Get_It_Memorized:

I think Kaidou would be the skull one. I think the fat one is Lola's mom. :ninja:

I still think Lola's mom is a ally of Whitebeard. There's a difference between 'great pirate' and one of the strongest in the world.

Get_It_Memorized

@S.C.:

I still think Lola's mom is a ally of Whitebeard. There's a difference between 'great pirate' and one of the strongest in the world.

That's true, though I would imagine that the situation could be like Luffy and Shanks. Luffy didn't know that Shanks was a Yonkou or one of the strongest pirates in the world, he just knew he was a great pirate. Though at this point there's nothing to really confirm it either way.

I just did some simple math anyway. Fat + gross hair = Kokoro. No wait…something is amiss.

De Ruyter

@AdmiralYonkouMt.Bandit:

That's why it's not an interesting theory.

Unless I should be expecting another wave of Dragon is two ppl/has two bodies despite Oda(speaking through his characters) specifically saying Dragon was a revolutionary unlike pirates because he directly targets the WG.

Luffy declared war to the WG too. So is he some kind of pirate revolutionary?
I know he did this for Robin but diclairing war is declairing war.

(And no Dragon is not one of the Yonkou)

Mortea

You know why Vista has such wide, hairy and delicious manchest? He's from Manchester.

Akumu

@De:

Luffy declared war to the WG too. So is he some kind of pirate revolutionary?
I know he did this for Robin but diclairing war is declairing war.

:ninja:http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=25852:ninja:

Just sayin.

Shichibukai

My theories:

Boa Hancock and Jimbei do NOT join the crew
The strawhats will meet and fight Kaidou and the 4th yonkou
They meet Dr.Vegapunk and learn many unbelievable secrets
Strawhats will meet Shanks and his crew in the new world
Dragon starts a war against the world goverment and wins
Zoro fights Mihawk and wins
Luffy will fight Blackbeard on raftel
Allblue is in the middle of the island raftel
Brook remeets with Laboon
Luffy will be executed after finding one piece

Akumu

@Shichibukai:

My theories:

Allblue is in the middle of the island raftel

This. I've never actually considered this before though, so it'll be interesting.

Luffy will be executed after finding one piece

Well if we take what WB said about there being a war that consumes the world, I think the World Government that we know today won't be around in the end. The people of the OP world will learn the truth of the Void Century, and in the foreshadowed War the Revolutionaries, Supernovas, and all the people Luffy has met along the way will unite, and Luffy as the Pirate King will lead them in battle.
Our heroes will of course win.
Therefore, who's going to execute Luffy?
I honestly believe that One-Piece will NOT end with Luffy dying.

hurrricane

arlongpark-forums will destroy itself after op ending

_pauL0wns

@Uzumaki_D_Kenichi:

This. I've never actually considered this before though, so it'll be interesting.

Well if we take what WB said about there being a war that consumes the world, I think the World Government that we know today won't be around in the end. The people of the OP world will learn the truth of the Void Century, and in the foreshadowed War the Revolutionaries, Supernovas, and all the people Luffy has met along the way will unite, and Luffy as the Pirate King will lead them in battle.
Our heroes will of course win.
Therefore, who's going to execute Luffy?
I honestly believe that One-Piece will NOT end with Luffy dying.

I dont think it is supposed to be someone executing him but more like Luffy dying of a disease or just him having no more life in him with all the "body damages" he has taken. Whatever way he dies, im sure it`ll be epic.

Hawkolf

Not really a theory since I'm 100% sure it will happen…
Luffy will fight Vegapunk while Vegapunks in a robot suit kinda thingy. It always needs to happen. And I hate it... Why?
Because I always get stuck in bosses like that in Final Fantasys.

Shichibukai

@Uzumaki_D_Kenichi:

Well if we take what WB said about there being a war that consumes the world, I think the World Government that we know today won't be around in the end. The people of the OP world will learn the truth of the Void Century, and in the foreshadowed War the Revolutionaries, Supernovas, and all the people Luffy has met along the way will unite, and Luffy as the Pirate King will lead them in battle.
Our heroes will of course win.
Therefore, who's going to execute Luffy?
I honestly believe that One-Piece will NOT end with Luffy dying.

It's forshadowed so much that Luffy is going to meet the same fate as Gold Roger so i think the one who caputures is Corby since he's the kind of rival like Garp was to Roger.

choperman

@Muda:

The real question is which one of the 2 is Kaidou?

The one in the lower left corner with a skull on his forehead, or the fat looking one with the huge ass grin and thick poofy hair?

it looks like a skull on the chin of the fat one to me

@Shichibukai:

It's forshadowed so much that Luffy is going to meet the same fate as Gold Roger so i think the one who caputures is Corby since he's the kind of rival like Garp was to Roger.

smoker's like the garp with luffy

Shichibukai

@choperman:

smoker's like the garp with luffy

Nope, Smoker is to Luffy what Sengok was to Roger.
Luffy -> Corby -> Smoker = Roger -> Garp -> Sengok

MetaMario

@Shichibukai:

Nope, Smoker is to Luffy what Sengok was to Roger.
Luffy -> Corby -> Smoker = Roger -> Garp -> Sengok

It's Coby, not Corby.

Shichibukai

@MetaMario:

It's Coby, not Corby.

In my country they translated his name as Corby.

MetaMario

@Shichibukai:

In my country they translated his name as Corby.

Oh, my bad. :P

Sorry about that.

Shichibukai

Watch this: http://de.opwiki.org/wiki/Corby

MetaMario

@Shichibukai:

Watch this: http://de.opwiki.org/wiki/Corby

Wow, it's there all right.:blink:

choperman

@Shichibukai:

Nope, Smoker is to Luffy what Sengok was to Roger.
Luffy -> Corby -> Smoker = Roger -> Garp -> Sengok

…... no coby might bring luffy in but he won't ever be his garp

smokers determined to catch him

we've never seen the relationship between sengoku and roger but we know

Smoker has some respect for luffy, and is determined to catch him, coby has never shown real drive to catch luffy rather he has a drive to show luffy he can become great too

coby wouldn't want luffy captured they say they'll fight and have but do you really think that if coby caught him he'd send him to impel down

the smoker = garp relationship was set up early and is fairly easy to see, i can understand your point but coby and luffy will always be more friends then rivals

and we've only seen complete hate for roger from sengoku that's not how smoker feels about straw hat or at least how it's going to stay

Ivotas

@choperman:

…... no coby might bring luffy in but he won't ever be his garp

smokers determined to catch him

we've never seen the relationship between sengoku and roger but we know

Smoker has some respect for luffy, and is determined to catch him, coby has never shown real drive to catch luffy rather he has a drive to show luffy he can become great too

coby wouldn't want luffy captured they say they'll fight and have but do you really think that if coby caught him he'd send him to impel down

the smoker = garp relationship was set up early and is fairly easy to see, i can understand your point but coby and luffy will always be more friends then rivals

and we've only seen complete hate for roger from sengoku that's not how smoker feels about straw hat or at least how it's going to stay

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/569/03/

Apparently it's not like there can't be more important things than the bond of friendship Luffy and Coby share. It might just aswell be that Coby would one day be put in a situation where he has to chose something important over the friendship with Luffy.

And as far as Smoker is concerned, I guess that at Arabasta he has quite well displayed to not be willing to capture Luffy at all costs.

choperman

@Ivotas:

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/569/03/

Apparently it's not like there can't be more important things than the bond of friendship Luffy and Coby share. It might just aswell be that Coby would one day be put in a situation where he has to chose something important over the friendship with Luffy.

And as far as Smoker is concerned, I guess that at Arabasta he has quite well displayed to not be willing to capture Luffy at all costs.

i remeber this scene but still after arabasta i've always figured smoker = garp

Shichibukai

@choperman:

…... no coby might bring luffy in but he won't ever be his garp

smokers determined to catch him

we've never seen the relationship between sengoku and roger but we know

Smoker has some respect for luffy, and is determined to catch him, coby has never shown real drive to catch luffy rather he has a drive to show luffy he can become great too

coby wouldn't want luffy captured they say they'll fight and have but do you really think that if coby caught him he'd send him to impel down

the smoker = garp relationship was set up early and is fairly easy to see, i can understand your point but coby and luffy will always be more friends then rivals

and we've only seen complete hate for roger from sengoku that's not how smoker feels about straw hat or at least how it's going to stay

You got it switched around. Corby is Luffys Garp and Smoker is Luffys Sengok. Just like Sengok, Smoker just wants to catch a dangerous pirate while both Roger/Garp and Luffy/Corby have deeper bonds nearly something called friendship. That Corby is the one who captures him, this was set as early as chapter 2 of the manga. In Water 7 he tells Luffy about the new world and also tells them that the next time they met, it will be in the New World, and then he will be an admiral and he will have to fight and capture Luffy. Luffy just says he'll look forward to their fight. Oda isn't one who set things up like that and then says screw it. Corby is very similar to Garp both following moral justice and he was even trained by Garp. Corby wil be the one who captures Luffy, not Smoker.

Renegadesoul

An ancient weapon/s created the Grandline and the Calm Belt. The islands in the GL are once part of that huge kingdom Clover mentioned about, it was shattered into pieces that form the GL today. Those/that ancient weapon/s are/is the source of the GL's unusual magnetic anomaly, it radiates in length form, circling the entire span of the OP world, Calm Belt as its borders is also affected by this unusual magnetic anomaly that it only allows a limited amount of air pressure to move along both sides of the CB, this explains the lack of wind power in CB but allows people to breath within its area. This ancient weapon/s is located in Raftel, it is composed of the same material as the phoneglyphs.

Akumu

Corby wil be the one who captures Luffy, not Smoker

I still don't see why people think Luffy's going to be captured…...
I think it's clear that the WG as we know it won't exist at the end of the series. That means the Marines will fall also. So who's going to capture Luffy.
Coby's a great guy and all, but he is the enemy, and Luffy has proven himself to be able to fight Coby without hesitation. Sure Luffy parallels Roger in some ways, but do you honestly think he's going to parallel him to the end? This isn't Naruto guys!

As for Coby, once the new WG is established after WB's foreshadowed war, there will be new marines, and Coby will be the fleet admiral. That way his dream will be realized. I still don't think they'll capture Luffy mainly because the Will of D. will have been revealed to the World at this point, and I think Luffy will be a respected man even by the New WG.

Renegadesoul

Death will capture Luffy.

ColonelCrawfish

Crocodile only helped Luffy and the others escape from Impel Down because Iva was bribing him with something. When Luffy asked Iva how he knew Croc, he said that he met him when he was a rookie. What could have been so groundbreaking between Iva and Crocodile that Crocodile would want anyone to know? Well, I have an idea.

Guys….........

CROCODILE WAS ORIGINALLY A GIRL, AND IVA CHANGED HIM INTO A MALE WITH HOROMONES.

Silence

Lmao.

Who'da thunk?

ColonelCrawfish

@Silence:

Lmao.

Who'da thunk?

BUT ISNT IT OBVIOUS? WEVE BEEN SO BLIND ALL ALONG.

RomanceDawn

Oh boy, your going to be ripped apart for such a statement, if you really came up with that just now and had to tell us. Other wise your just being a goon.

Herr Krokodil

wow…. In before lock.

Renegadesoul

This post is deleted!

ColonelCrawfish

@RomanceDawn:

Oh boy, your going to be ripped apart for such a statement, if you really came up with that just now and had to tell us. Other wise your just being a goon.

IM DEAD SERIOUS.

RomanceDawn

I see, well it is a common theory. We have a thread for such things.

Renegadesoul

You can post it in this thread.

http://www.apforums.net/showthread.php?t=12012

Venomous Warden

now that would turn a few peoples worlds upside down thats for sure

ColonelCrawfish

@Renegadesoul:

You can post it in this thread.

http://www.apforums.net/showthread.php?t=12012

Fine. I guess I will. >:1

ColonelCrawfish

Crocodile only helped Luffy and the others escape from Impel Down because Iva was bribing him with something. When Luffy asked Iva how he knew Croc, he said that he met him when he was a rookie. What could have been so groundbreaking between Iva and Crocodile that Crocodile would want anyone to know? Well, I have an idea.

Guys….........

CROCODILE WAS ORIGINALLY A GIRL, AND IVA CHANGED HIM INTO A MALE WITH HOROMONES.

huron

@ColonelCrawfish:

Crocodile only helped Luffy and the others escape from Impel Down because Iva was bribing him with something. When Luffy asked Iva how he knew Croc, he said that he met him when he was a rookie. What could have been so groundbreaking between Iva and Crocodile that Crocodile would want anyone to know? Well, I have an idea.

Guys….........

CROCODILE WAS ORIGINALLY A GIRL, AND IVA CHANGED HIM INTO A MALE WITH HOROMONES.

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/565.5/14/
this is why we cant see her face.

Renegadesoul

Someone should closed this one now. The topic has been transferred to the Theories that dont deserve their own thread page.

ColonelCrawfish

@huron:

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/565.5/14/
this is why we cant see her face.

OH MY GOD.

GUYS, YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST.

Kami_Sama

I think this thread is a satire…or I hope this thread is a satire...