Though I kinda like that theory it has a few catches:
-how would the WG know what Hody had planned with those ES? They didn't know that Noah would be destroyed too, because not even Hody had calculated VDD's "insanity".
-if Hody had been on Reverie he would have killed many kings of the WG and the only benefit the WG would have from Hody's havoc is the bad reputation of the merfolk. But they'd have lost many powerful allies against enemies like the Revs just because they "helped" Hody.
-I can't imagine that Hody would take help from any human. He even despiced Hatchen for being friend with Rayleigh. Hody obtain pills from a human sounds not really plausible to me.
Some possible explinations:
- I meant going down and basically laying waste to the whole island. I didn't mean they would have known VDD would send Noah over the island, but rather that it could be conveniently destroyed in order to "Prevent any pirates from escaping". Also, I assume the WG has enough influence to find out that a bunch of Fishman wanted to launch a coup, or possibly even gave them inspiration (i'll explain in a sec)
- I assume they wouldn't get this far. If they're planning on using Hodi as cover, they'd probably kill him the second he reached the surface. Its not like the WG has been big on procedure when it comes to criminals, and I doubt anyone would raise a fuss about it given the rather large evidence that HOdi had bad intentions. Also, don't the ES have really bad long-term consequences? It might be that the WG was betting on Hodi and crew being too weak after taking them to actually do any damage post-coup.
- There are a couple of ways they could have gotten them to him, even without him knowing precisely where they came from. Back in 644, Hodi says "The Heavens have chosen us" when presenting the ES, which could imply he "found" them at random in a sort of fell-out-of-the-sky moment, but with them really coming from the WG. In fact, the WG could have possibly picked Hodi Jones to give them too, thus enabling the entire coup in the first place.
Its just a theory anyway. This arc could go practically anywhere right now, and I'm very interested in what will happen next.