This post is deleted!
Last Two Nakamates (vol. 5)
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
I voted 4 the "nobody above"-option, but if I had to choose one of the 3 candidates, I'd tend to Perona. Yet she has the biggest chance to join.
Hancock couldn't get along with Nami and Robin, and Jinbei wouldn't fit in the crew with his amount of wisdom. 4 me Jinbei is so much outta the join-question as Rayleigh, but thats just my opinion. Yet it was Robins slot to be the smart experienced wise person in the crew. That shouldn't change.
I'd like to see another fishman than Jinbei in the SHs' crew, somehow I'd love it if it was Oktapako (Hacchi's great love, but yet she is too mean, she needs a personal twist in her character that she could join the SHs!). -
Hancock couldn't get along with Nami and Robin, and Jinbei wouldn't fit in the crew with his amount of wisdom.
This. This is the kind of opinion that is horrible.
Yes, both Hancock and Jimbei would be awesome in the crew, personality-wise. Both would add to the dynamic of the crew, and any conflicts that could arise would just be amusing for us readers (I see no one saying that Zoro and Sanji should get out of the crew because they have a rivalry).
There are a thousand acceptable reasons as to why Hancock or Jimbei couldn't join, but "wouldn't get along" or "wouldn't fit" are not among them.
Wano predictions: There will be 5 acts; All Straw Hats will get fights, some in Act 4; Big Mom Pirates will arrive; Carrot will have her moment, but won't join; Yamato will be a Kouzuki samurai and Wano's Guardian; Shanks will visit Luffy in Act 5; Next arc is Mary Geoise.
-
For a second there, I perceived it as Jimbei wouldn't fit on Sunny's doors. XD
-
This. This is the kind of opinion that is horrible.
Yes, both Hancock and Jimbei would be awesome in the crew, personality-wise. Both would add to the dynamic of the crew, and any conflicts that could arise would just be amusing for us readers (I see no one saying that Zoro and Sanji should get out of the crew because they have a rivalry).
There are a thousand acceptable reasons as to why Hancock or Jimbei couldn't join, but "wouldn't get along" or "wouldn't fit" are not among them.
Nevertheless it's useless to punch around with arguments (doesn't matter if good or bad). We're talkin about Oda. Hell, he could Duval let join and bring up good reasons 4 his joining later. Every character could be a benefit 4 the dynamic of the crew.
My reasons why I prefer Perona are just personal. What I don't like bout Hancock and Jinbei is…
-Jinbei was my biggest disappointment so far in OP (I imagined him 10 timer more badass than Arlong b4 he got revealed).
-Hancock is funny with all the luv 4 Luffy and yellin @ everyone else, but I just can't imagine her being with him totally happy and in luv on the Sunny, I'm sorry, I can't imagine that! But maybe Oda will do it exactly the Hancock way and I will be stunned and laughing my ass off when I read the interactions between Hancock and the crew. Same goes 4 the Jinbei way: if Oda does that, I know it will be brilliant, cause Oda is f*ckin brilliant! I'm sure he will blast our minds and asses! -
We'll find out this chapter.
I wasn't distracted by Lucy being half naked.
You won this week Fairy Tail.
-
We'll find out this chapter.
I don't know bout this.
If Jinbei joins 'em, the SHs first have go to fishman island and especially the older fans will know that this could take another year, if Kuma did sth horrible @ SA (and I am afraid he did sth like that 2 the Sunny!).
Well, if we go by crazyness (each SH has a unique "crazyness": zoro's sense of direction; nami's greed 4 money; sanji's "love" 4 women; brook's overall "skull crazyness"…) Hancock would be my personal first place:
A former slave full of pride and arrogance who treats everyone just like trash except the person she loves - a real wacky character
Perona is somehow my personal second in crazyness:
a rather grown up girl who loves pet toys and her stance is funny. The rest of her crazyness is just "on the surface" (looks somehow like Miza or Mizu from DeathNote).
Jimbei is the third craziest of em all:
A fishman, yeah, but @ FI there are an @$$ full of fishmen. And all his "Let me die proudly" and "I will die without regrets"-lines sound crazy in the first place, but in Japan that's almost normal (you know with the honor-stuff and the proud-stuff, nobody wants to live in shame, such lines as those from Jinbei are quite "regular"). But he sure will be good as helmsman and that slot isn't given away yet! -
Your mistaken. We'll see all the straw hats this chapter most likely, if Perona doesn't follow Zoro, she's out. If Luffy leaves AL without Hancock, she's out. It's that simple.
-
Nevertheless it's useless to punch around with arguments (doesn't matter if good or bad). We're talkin about Oda. Hell, he could Duval let join and bring up good reasons 4 his joining later. Every character could be a benefit 4 the dynamic of the crew.
You're right. I am sure Chinmey, Pagaya or even Chaka could be a benefit for the crew. It's useless to use arguments because if Oda wants, Gonbe will be the next crewmate, if he wants, Luffy will die without finding the One Piece and Blackbeard will be the main character.
Everything is possible.
-
Your mistaken. We'll see all the straw hats this chapter most likely, if Perona doesn't follow Zoro, she's out. If Luffy leaves AL without Hancock, she's out. It's that simple.
Yeah, but that will not work 4 Jinbei, because he is @ FI!
BTW I hope we will see ALL the SHs in the next chap!
@Tsukishima:You're right. I am sure Chinmey, Pagaya or even Chaka could be a benefit for the crew. It's useless to use arguments because if Oda wants, Gonbe will be the next crewmate, if he wants, Luffy will die without finding the One Piece and Blackbeard will be the main character.
Everything is possible.
Is there a lil bit sarcasm in your post?
Yeah, it's Oda, and you can't predict what Oda's got in store.
Hell, shortly after ThrillerBark I bet no one would have guessed or even predicted that the SHs would be seperated by Kuma and that this seperation would last for over a f*ckin year!
Back in EL there were fans who still thought that Pauly would be SHs' shipwright instead of Franky although he already got his FB (and his unique "travel round the world"-dream revealed) at that time. In the end of Franky's FB it was so clear that Franky would join, but there were still some morons who thought that Pauly could win the race!
Now it's completely different! Jinbei, Hancock or Perona could join (I wonder that nobody wants heraclesn in the crew :sad:!)
What I could predict is that Robin and Chopper will have problems in the crew (will leave the crew/will be abandoned), because those two haven't got their "5th person" and "6th person" chapter. And I guess Chopper will get trouble with monster point /drug abusement inside the crew, maybe during the Vegapunk-Arc. Great chance 4 Oda to bring up the topic "drugs" in the OP-world.
Yeah, I am a follower of the "if the nakama hasn't his/her '…th person'-chap, that nakama will get trouble in the crew"-theory. -
Is there a lil bit sarcasm in your post?
Just a little bit.
Yeah, it's Oda, and you can't predict what Oda's got in store.
Some things are predictable. Do you really believe there is a chance Blackbeard join the crew for example?
Back in EL there were fans who still thought that Pauly would be SHs' shipwright instead of Franky although he already got his FB (and his unique "travel round the world"-dream revealed) at that time. In the end of Franky's FB it was so clear that Franky would join, but there were still some morons who thought that Pauly could win the race!
I never thought that Pauly had a chance to join. But he was a better candidate than Perona. So it's funny that you call those guys morons when you still think Perona has a chance. And by the way, how did you and those other fans knew Franky was going to join if you can't predict what Oda's got in store?
-
This post is deleted!
-
Some things are predictable. Do you really believe there is a chance Blackbeard join the crew for example?
In One Piece, most of the things that do happen are unpredictable, but plenty of the things that don't happen are perfectly predictable.
What Oda does is throw in things that nobody saw coming. For example, before he started fighting with them at Enies Lobby, who thought Franky would join? Even if anyone did, there sure as hell weren't many people.
But does that mean that everyone thought "oh, he'll never join as a crew member?" when he was first introduced? NO! The thought didn't even cross our heads that it was an option for this guy who was effectively the leader of a small mob-like organization to join the straw hats. There were no huge arguments about it.
Same with Brooke, though that might be even more unfair to point out :P Who on earth would have had an argument with someone about "Will they find a skeleton to join their crew while sailing haunted waters?!" Well?
So the point is, Oda isn't known for doing things that a lot of people claim will never happen. He's known for doing things that no one would have expected in the first place :P
-
Every new crew member brings something huge to the crew dynamic so I'm not sure anyone we know about fits the bill.
-
None of the above.
Thinking on it, one of them has to be a logia, right? And then a mythical Zoan would round out the crew nicely, i think.
-
@Dan:
None of the above.
Thinking on it, one of them has to be a logia, right? And then a mythical Zoan would round out the crew nicely, i think.
Why? lol for 16 chars
-
Sweet God, no.
161616161616161616 -
This post is deleted!
-
Why? lol for 16 chars
I just can't see the future crew of the Pirate King not having at least someone with one of the super rare devil fruits types.
That would be such a waste.
-
A logia and mythical zoan would be cool but I think that's o.d. on the super rare DF side of things.
Probably either or between the two. Unless a logia user also has a mythical zoan weapon.
-
Yeah, both would probably be overkill.
-
This post is deleted!
-
This post is deleted!
-
In One Piece, most of the things that do happen are unpredictable, but plenty of the things that don't happen are perfectly predictable.
What Oda does is throw in things that nobody saw coming. For example, before he started fighting with them at Enies Lobby, who thought Franky would join?
Alot of goddamn people, what with the huge flashback and all.
ODA AINT PREDACTABLE is completely dumb bullshit people tell themselves when they get upset about the others of us who have 10th grade reading levels.
Even if anyone did, there sure as hell weren't many people.
But does that mean that everyone thought "oh, he'll never join as a crew member?" when he was first introduced? NO! The thought didn't even cross our heads that it was an option for this guy who was effectively the leader of a small mob-like organization to join the straw hats. There were no huge arguments about it.
Were you even around back then?
Same with Brooke, though that might be even more unfair to point out :P Who on earth would have had an argument with someone about "Will they find a skeleton to join their crew while sailing haunted waters?!" Well?
That's not a prediction it's a random guess, you're talking before we even met the fucking character. You seriously don't comprehend this whole thing do you.
So the point is, Oda isn't known for doing things that a lot of people claim will never happen. He's known for doing things that no one would have expected in the first place :P
No he's not.
-
In One Piece, most of the things that do happen are unpredictable, but plenty of the things that don't happen are perfectly predictable.
What Oda does is throw in things that nobody saw coming. For example, before he started fighting with them at Enies Lobby, who thought Franky would join? Even if anyone did, there sure as hell weren't many people.
But does that mean that everyone thought "oh, he'll never join as a crew member?" when he was first introduced? NO! The thought didn't even cross our heads that it was an option for this guy who was effectively the leader of a small mob-like organization to join the straw hats. There were no huge arguments about it.
Same with Brooke, though that might be even more unfair to point out :P Who on earth would have had an argument with someone about "Will they find a skeleton to join their crew while sailing haunted waters?!" Well?
So the point is, Oda isn't known for doing things that a lot of people claim will never happen. He's known for doing things that no one would have expected in the first place :P
I have to agree on some level with Jerk Disease. Oda is somewhat predictable on the short term. Franky was easily predicted to join. And there were huge arguments about it.
I don't agree with all the derogatory remarks at all, of course.
There were other times that Oda lead us astray in predictions, such as Wiper's flashback in Skypiea, and even "Let's meet in 3 days" in SA. Robin joining was also comparatively random (it caught me off guard).
Brook's entrance was not predictable (no one can predict entrances of new characters in any story), but right after Luffy went to meet Brook, it was so obvious he would join that Oda had Luffy inviting Brook in the same chapter he appeared.
-
Why do people have this fantasy that OP is nothing but anarchy.
Do they hate art having structure?
-
Really, the only member joining that was completely random was Robin.
Was Wiper a popular, serious choice to become a crewmember during Skypeia? I joined AP at the start of the DBF, so I missed that debate.
Retsudo: To cover their mistakes when they're wrong as well as the 'holy shit I called something correctly!!1!' factor.
-
Wiper should have been at least considered, he had some of the makings of a potential crew member.
-
I don't see how Wiper's fb could be considered misleading. It was never really "his" flashback to begin with. It was entirely about Calgara and Norland.
