Basically, if you could have had any other character join the StrawHats who would you want?
Me, I definitally would have liked Buggy to come. Second would be a tie between Arlong and Chuu. I think they need to get a mermaid next.
Basically, if you could have had any other character join the StrawHats who would you want?
Me, I definitally would have liked Buggy to come. Second would be a tie between Arlong and Chuu. I think they need to get a mermaid next.
I think that Usopp's friends Pea, Carrot, and Onion should of joined the Straw-Hats and be their cabin boys.
Originally posted by Cap'n Bermuda@Apr 18 2005, 10:14 PM
I think that Usopp's friends Pea, Carrot, and Onion should of joined the Straw-Hats and be their cabin boys.
[snapback]33719[/snapback]
His name is Pepper.
Or… Isn't it really Tamanegi, Ninjin, and Piiman?
Anyways, if you've paid ANY attention to my fanboyish posts... Vivi. All the way. I still haven't lost hope that she'll rejoin.
waha. A hopeful Vivi fanboy. Cool. I wouldn't have minded either if she did stay around, but she wouldn't be the Vivi we knew and grew to love if she went with them…
Not sure if it counts, since he's not really an official manga chara, but ever since I saw Dead End Adventure, I've been thinking about how life would be like if Shurai joined the SH crew.
wasn't going to happen, know that, but still. a girl can dream...
Smoker. He needs to get that jitte outta his ass.
People I would like:
Hatchan
Crocus
Dalton
Cricket Monbran (or is it Montblanc?)
Boodle (I guess)
Gedatsu
Foxy
Kapoty
Hamburg
Tubifex & Tweetums (having commentary during all of Luffy's fights would be awesome)
Let's see, who has Luffy asked?
Gaimon, Iceberg, Vivi, Crocus (I think), did he ask Zeff?, Dr. Kureha…who else?
Did he ask anyone in Skypeia?
Dr. Kureha would've been awesome I think.
Originally posted by VildaHawk@Apr 18 2005, 09:34 PM
**Let's see, who has Luffy asked?Gaimon, Iceberg, Vivi, Crocus (I think), did he ask Zeff?, Dr. Kureha…who else?
Did he ask anyone in Skypeia?
Dr. Kureha would've been awesome I think.
[snapback]33732[/snapback]**
He asked Iceburg
Yes, he asked Iceburg. Ch.327, page 15.
No one else SHOULD have joined the Straw Hats. After all, who am I to say that Oda should changes his works for my entertainment?
That said, I wished that Luffy would pick Gina from Foxy's crew instead of their flag.
Yeh, I'm also content with the crew they have at the moment. But hey, Bon Clay would've been fun to have onboard as a permanent member. :P
I think it would have been so awsome if Wiper had joined. xD That guy would have made an awsome addition.
hmm i think…Bon Clay shoulda joined XD
TOMODACHI (friends) forever!! lol
Hah man if Dalton joined that would be something ^^, but I think it would be a party if Jango did XD
the guy with the fro who was stuck in the treasure chest on that island with all the animals
Originally posted by taboo@Apr 19 2005, 07:09 AM
I think it would have been so awsome if Wiper had joined. xD That guy would have made an awsome addition.
[snapback]33765[/snapback]
id like him to join to.
Noone, I havnt seen anyone who will fit with em… Though I wouldl like if Wiperand Mr.5 got a bigger role.
Mr.5 had a cool design and all but his devil fruit powers were not mastered thats why i didnt like him
Bon Clay would have been fun, then maybe we could have seen a rematch between Sanji and him. :D
vivi shouldnt had left the crew
Bon Clay joining Luffy would be cool
Actually I think the crew shouldn't get much bigger than this. It's already hard to split the page/screen time between 7 of them as it is. That said, Bon Clay would be a fun addition, absolutely agree on that. As someone pointed out, merman would be an useful aquisition (guess I'm tired of having Sanji dive for Luffy most of the time and now there are 3 DF users who tend to drown)
but there are four (well three)that could help them. (Nami wont thats why i said 3)and hey zoro helps alot when luffys drowns.
Originally posted by devil^^kid_@Apr 19 2005, 04:12 AM
but there are four (well three)that could help them. (Nami wont thats why i said 3)and hey zoro helps alot when luffys drowns.
[snapback]33891[/snapback]
Sorry. But i think it's more like Sanji who always saves Luffy when he's drowning
Originally posted by Starlight+Apr 19 2005, 12:16 PM–>QUOTE(Starlight @ Apr 19 2005, 12:16 PM)
LOL Devil_Kid, everybody saw through that one. Though Zoro comes handy since usually you need to drag out Usopp as well. Meaning you have really 4 hammers and 2 lifeguards (Nami is busy with manicure…)
so this leaves poor sanji to do all the work. 2:4 ratio is not that good they should get a merman to help them out
DORA THE EXPLORER!!!!lol…
Vivi was supposed to join...It sucked that she didnt
Originally posted by PortgasDeAycee@Apr 20 2005, 08:51 AM
DORA THE EXPLORER!!!!lol…
Vivi was supposed to join...It sucked that she didnt
[snapback]34557[/snapback]
Remember she is very dedicated to her country and she even pissed of when dolton said Wapol leaved his Country (Drum Arc) It would be cool if she had joined but I think that is a little difficult to happen…. :huh:
Any one of the Arlong Pirates joining is impossible, me thinks. Nami would go ballistic. I mean, they're the ones who killed Bellemere and enslaved her village.
Who should join…er... Maybe another girl?
Meh, this topic is misnamed, it would be "who else would you have liked to join the strawhats?" or something.
Hatchan on the crew would rock, in my opinion. I forgot about Tonjit annnd… someone else. Patty and Carne would be funny.
I hated vivi, so i wouldn't really like it if she was a permanent member. I would've liked to see Ace on the Going Merry for maybe one arc, then meet blackbeard at Jaya and start chasing him, but blackbeard would lose him somehow, then the normal jaya stuff would happen.
I liked Early-Vivi - when they arrived at Little Garden and Vivi went to explore the island with Luffy while Usopp and Nami were scared and stayed on the ship. Then she seemed to have a lot of potential and to be a good foil for Nami - using her brain less but being more fun and far more daring. I would have liked it if she had been allowed to have fun in the snow in Drum and more things like that. But unfortunately after Mr. 5 turned up in Little Garden she seemed to spend all the time crying and being in distress that I did not miss her when she left. (Well, now in Water 7 Nami seems to have to be the one crying all the time, so I don't know if that's better.)
I think it would've been cool if Zeff,Gin,or Pell joined. :P
yeah gin could have joined with the strawhats but he decided to stay with stuped krieg
Gin would have been cool. But the little man in the Treasure chest with an Afro (name?) definetly would be been excellent!
but if hed hed left kreig and joined up with the strawhats he wouldnt have been the gin i love i find his so incredibly cool cause hes so loyal even thought all that kreig did to him
yeah i get what you mean but krieg diesnt care about gin so gin should understand and leave krieg but as you said loyalty is something great.
Originally posted by devil^^kid_@Apr 25 2005, 04:11 PM
yeah i get what you mean but krieg diesnt care about gin so gin should understand and leave krieg but as you said loyalty is something great.
[snapback]37300[/snapback]
You can say that again, though i wish Gin had realised that Don Kreig isn't worth it. Luffy and his nakama would have treated him a lot better. <_<
I guess Gin's loyalty to Krieg is just as great as Zoro's loyalty to Luffy (at least to me anyway), though Luffy deserves Zoro's loyalty, Krieg does'nt. But then again, this is One Piece, go figure.
I think 7 (with Vivi and Chopper) is a nice round, but anymore would be too much.
Ace would have been nice in the team, and Bon Clay would'nt be bad either.
Originally posted by Right Click@Apr 25 2005, 04:08 PM
But the little man in the Treasure chest with an Afro (name?) definetly would be been excellent!
[snapback]37298[/snapback]
Gaimon. He has my vote too, as well as the following:
Bon Clay
Kung-fu Dugongs (the whole army of them)
Crocus
Pell
Zeff
Eneru (shrug)
Johnny
Yosaku
A hiking bear (for good measure)
That's a pretty good crew, really. Maybe Gaimon can start a new rival pirate crew and assemble all those guys.
Gin is awesome just because of his loyalty. True, he'd made a badassic member of the Straw Hats, but the fact that he stayed with Don gives him that much more character. It would be kinda weird otherwise. Throughout the whole arc he was as loyal as ever (he even refused to use a gas mask when Krieg gassed him), so if he had left Krieg, the whole image he had built up would crumble and go straight to hell.
I think that a debate like this one should stick to the people Luffy has asked. Now, I'm only at the end of Arabasta, so… let's see. There's Koby, Gaimon, Kureha and Ace. Ace and Kureha would probably have been the most useful to the crew, though they had their very own reasons for not joining. Ace was already part of Whitebeards crew, and Kureha had to make sure the memory of Dr. Bader would remain (that's at least my idea of why she sticks around on Drumm Island).
Then there's Bon Clay and Vivi. Vivi was never supposed to stick with the Straw Hats. If you look at it the right way, Whiskey Peak/Little Garden/Drum Island can be crammed into Alabasta, since they all lead to the same goal: Get Vivi home. And that was what she wanted herself from the very beginning, though it was hard to part with her friends. She's loyal to her country, a princess at heart and not at title (just like her father... well, not "princess," though that could fill out for Igarappo. XD)
Bon Clay would probably have sticked along with the crew if he had not "sacrificed" (I refuse to believe he has been excecuted) himself to help the Strawhats to escape from Alabasta. At least that's my opinion. He never was their enemy from the beginning, he merely did his job as a Baroque Works agent. I see his battle with Sanji more as a duel, actually. A fight for the fight, which is part of why I love it so.
I say the crew is perfectly fine the way it is. Oda knows what he is doing, and we should be happy that he spends his time telling these fantastic stories without having to bend his work to our own liking. :D
i think they should have a guy with devil fruit power that can enable him to fly and amerman and a person who fixs the ship and personally i dont care who but they need guys like that
Originally posted by devil^^kid_@Apr 26 2005, 03:07 PM
i think they should have a guy with devil fruit power that can enable him to fly and amerman and a person who fixs the ship and personally i dont care who but they need guys like that
[snapback]37652[/snapback]
Errrr… honestly, a guy with a flying ability caused by the Devil Fruit is kind of... godmoding, in lack of better word. "Oh no, I am thrown in the oceaHAAAAH! I FLY AWAY WHILE LAUGHING AT YOU!" Now, before you mention Buggy, Oda said in a fanmailthat Buggy can only control his pieces at a certain lenght. Besides, he kinda floats more than actually fly.
Though, back on subject, I don't see the point of having a merman in the group. Knowing the merman race, having one in the crew is very unlikely, since they are pretty much born up in a society telling them that humans are underlings. They are born as wild beasts looking to dominate the food chain rather than beings that socialize. As for a carpenter, that's partly Usopp's job.
err there has already been a guy who has a devil fruit that allows him to fly,
remember pell ?
and there has been mermen who was really nice and didnt hate humans at all as you will see when you get further up in the story so it isnt impossibel at all,
and there hasnt been any prof that all mermen are racists just cause arlong was.
and usopp himself said that hes not a carpenter so they will get one but thats also something thats further up ahead.
Paulie is a shipwright right?
Personally I don't think that all the merman hate humans.
yes he is but i didnt want to spoil for him since hes only at the end of alabasta <_<
Odas gonna make himself Join!
Mr.Two, Vivi, Dolton, Coby(Cabin Boy), Pell, Jango, Miss Golden Week, Ace, Conis, Buggy, Foxy, Kung Fu Doungdos, Patty, and Carne.