It wasn't my intention to bash anyone
If I did I'm sorry, I just wanted to stated that it might be considered ofensive by some people calling one theory good and others weird stuff (even if there are wacky ones)
About the "Complete Theory" there isn't such thing if it was complete it would be truth and not a theory
Also the anti-theory arguments are based off assumptions rather then any sort of evidence the same thing can apply to the other side too
Almost all arguments (was long was they're take for Oda's work) are valid, was long was there is so much to be clarified in One Piece yet
Zephos you said the anti-theory arguments are based in assumptions, and your arguments aren't ?
Most theories arguments and contra-arguments are based in assumptations
I also never said I'm against the theory that Gol D. Roger might have been captured I just said that:
Until Oda himself doesn't reveal the truth, I would like to think that Gol D. Roger the Strongest man, the man that did everything wasn't captured by the same guys that are now afraid of a Shanks and WhiteBeard aliance
If WhiteBeard is now the Strongest man alive and they have captured Gol D. Roger why are they so afraid of him ?
Also I'm think that there here Pirates that would ally with Gol D. Roger in case he made the decision to strike against the W.G. , so even the Shanks factor isn't enough to explain the fear factor
I respect theories that go against mine was long was they are good and have good arguments to survive
Now a little theory that I made (althought I think some aspects of it might be wrong)
About the relation D.'s/Ancient Kingdom I thought about it and came up with this D.'s might have been some sort of High Guardians of the Ancient Kingdom that when the kingdom was destroyed scattered around, leaving clues (Poneglyphs) around the World and giving civilizations they trusted the task of guarding them
With time the D.'s started to forget about their past history until one of them (Gol D. Roger) that had been taught about the ancient language decided to search for the clues
That would explain why some D.'s don't understand Poneglyphs, that counting with Gol D. Roger being the one to have writen the little thing at Skypiea
But I'll be pleased to ear any other theory that goes against mine was long was it's based in good arguments
I hope this thread goes to the right path again
A little sidenote:
Just to to clarify things some of my theories can go against some of my other theories and that's why I call them theories
And to end I'm sorry to make such huge posts (I myself don't like the size of them)