@Eteal:
I like Toriko but it's actually worse than Naruto. It has potential but it's still too young.
I won't say that Toriko is a masterpiece or anything, by my own tier list (see below) I consider it only roughly above average, and even then I'm probably being generous to it. But years a series has ran or the amount of chapters in a series has nothing to do with quality.
Naruto is dull lifeless hollowed out shell of it's former self that has long since stomped out anything remotely likable with thematic elements not only contradicted but outright reversed, a hilariously overpowered main character, and the entire cast that isn't a distant descendant or relative of the Uchiha or the Uzemaki being almost entirely worthless. Not to mention Naruto's severe issues with the entirety of it's female cast or the degrading art quality etc etc.
By contrast, Toriko while not particularly deep is really just fun. Great art, a fantastic premise, and a strong sense of world building that I think only One Piece and Hunter X Hunter manage to top in terms of shonen.
@Eteal:
Naruto was always awesome, the war was kinda boring at the beginning, that's true, but it got great lately.
I'm really not trying to be a facetious woman when I say the war arc has undoubtably been the worst arc yet in Naruto. Which is a shame because I think it was something that had a ton of potential.
@Eteal:
I have to go now but if anyone doubts that Naruto is an awesome manga and OP is the best thing ever written then be free to message me, I'll explain when I get back.
Actually I prefer quite a few series over One Piece in terms of quality and/or entertainment. In no particularly specific order, my tier list is more like this:
Great
Berserk, Naussica, Hunter X Hunter, One Piece, Full Metal Alchemist, Vagabond
Good
Toriko, Magico, Wandering Son (aka Hourou Musuko), JoJo's Bizarre Adventure (only read parts 1-3), Bakuman, Dragon Ball, Sand Land, Gintama (from what little I've read)
Average to Mediocre
Blue Exorcist, Beelzebub, Tegami Bachi, Death Note (overall), Bobobo, Rurouni Kenshin, Yu Yu Hakusho, Rave, Silver Spoon
Bad
Naruto, Shaman King, Ultimo, Hetalia, Zombiepowder, Yu-Gi-Oh!
Exceptionally Awful
Bleach, Reborn, Fairy Tail
Bear in mind these are my rough estimates. I do prefer some series over others even in their own tiers (such as I prefer Hunter X Hunter over One Piece) so I just consider these loose levels of quality.