Constructively criticize the poster above you. The obvious goal in the long run is to improve the overall posting of this forums members. Just be sure not to intentionally hurt of offend the above member.
Constructive shiticism.
-
-
What if you have no idea at all how the person above you posts? Are you just supposed to judge them on the criticism that they themselves gave to the people above them?
-
What if you have no idea at all how the person above you posts? Are you just supposed to judge them on the criticism that they themselves gave to the people above them?
Well you see you do have the option not to post at all until you see a member you recognise, or at least recognise has faults.
-
You sure this thread won't end up being offensive to some, smudge?
-
Maybe a while back, but I've noticed a fair amount of decent posters descend upon the forum that might just turn a possible run-of-the-mill flamewar into a functioning thread….and with a purpose may I add.
Though I'm probably being delusional.
As for you, it'd be cool to see you debate more, or perhaps just visit the manga section more.
Side note: What happened to your comic?
-
@Zender:
Maybe a while back, but I've noticed a fair amount of decent posters descend upon the forum that might just turn a possible run-of-the-mill flamewar into a functioning thread….and with a purpose may I add.
I see. So, I guess we should get the ball rolling then?
1st criticism:
Though I'm probably being delusional.
I think you're being delusional.
-
Zender, how many, do you think, will post in your thread to get criticized, oh sorry, constructively critisized?
Zender: Tries too hard to be nice, apologizing when he's wrong and shit, while everyone knows his true self to be good old jolly Smudge.
Badass snocone: makes bad paint comics (primarily because I don't have a cameo in it.) + he has to learn to not believe anything that's written in the news without a clear source aaaand ….that's it (for now).
Seeking infinity, with all my affinities.
Finding truth, like a falling fruit, my ultimate finality.
Inside my being, the outside, all things; the finite leads the way.
-
Mugiwara no Ice: I think you're only supposed to comment on the person directly above you.
-
I'll provide it to the majority of posters whom I have some modicum of respect on this forum.
Although I will say that this thread is a really fucking bad idea.
-
Yeah, SuperJew is probably right. Sounds like a flame war volcano is rumblng softly, but clearly out on the horizon.
But meh. I don't know you well Jew, but I know you've been around here for quite some time (inactive or lurking for some, so you've said) and you seem like a solid poster and contribute nicely to many of the conversations. So I hope you stick around for awhile longer: we need more solid, non-retarded posters of the same calibre.
So not much criticism as of now, just my 2 cents to the poster above.
Sno-cone: Your avatar needs 3D glasses and should be watching The Last Airshitter.
-
The only posts I have read from you eerie (that I remember) is this one and the one in the Bink Sake thread (Singan Games??) Anyway, from these I think you are pretty decent poster trying his/ her best to be a team player while taking the role of matured advisor. We need more people like you!! Not much to criticize based on a sample set of two posts…
That was just to keep things on topic, the reason I actually am posting is I for one think if people give this thread a chance and post according to the rules set by the OP, this could be a good idea. If you disagree with someones opinion you could always take it up on PMs though I don't think most people will follow these rules.
-
^
Should stop accusing people so quickly of being scum in forum games, otherwise is just going to be voted out early…..again
Seriously though as long as people are courteous while voicing thier opinion and have fun in the forum I can't think of any way I would want someone to "improve thier posting".
-
stop having such powerfull abilities in forumgames , else arei and emolisher will be angry… again
-
@mette Lol you should be a wee bit more quiet about expressing your abilities in the game. It was the people (well Maki really) that we didn't know about who pulled out the biggest surprises in the game XD
-
^
Should stop accusing people so quickly of being scum in forum games, otherwise is just going to be voted out early…..againI told you before, that felt like a scum-accusing moment, stop judging me!!
@metteminne:
stop having such powerfull abilities in forumgames , else arei and emolisher will be angry… again
@mette Lol you should be a wee bit more quiet about expressing your abilities in the game. It was the people (well Maki really) that we didn't know about who pulled out the biggest surprises in the game XD
Why is everyone from mafia game here?? And why are we discussing about the game in this thread?
On topic, @Arei IMO you are too serious, maybe lighten up a bit and crack a joke every now and then…I know I for one enjoy light mood posts
Will give life altering advice for a cup of frothy cappuccino
-
Guys don't can threads before they've begun, flame wars are entertaining.
-
I told you before, that felt like a scum-accusing moment, stop judging me!!
Why is everyone from mafia game here?? And why are we discussing about the game in this thread?
On topic, @Arei IMO you are too serious, maybe lighten up a bit and crack a joke every now and then…I know I for one enjoy light mood posts
So how about them floods!
1\. Ace (√), 2\. WB (√), 3\. BB (X), 4\. Perona (√) 5\. Boa (√) 6\. Jimbei (???), 7\. Sabo lives (√), 8\. Timeskip (√)
-
^ Should stop acting like what his screen name says.
-
I've only just today realized your existence, and it needs to stop now.
-
^
I don't know you, but would suggest giving up on Bleach already. -
yer late
-
@Zender:
^
I don't know you, but would suggest giving up on Bleach already.Why would you suggest that? I have not once have casted away my hopes on bleach and I'm certainly not starting now…
-
This post is deleted!
-
Using the word facepalm, I hate memes and stuff.
then again you're from England and I like brits
-
BananaHammock, don't you have some snitching to do?
Seeking infinity, with all my affinities.
Finding truth, like a falling fruit, my ultimate finality.
Inside my being, the outside, all things; the finite leads the way.
-
this looks like a fun thread…... you all suck...... no wait that's not right.... hmm give me a minute I'll think of something
-
@dirt:yer late
Good poster I'd say. Can be harsh when it's called for which is a plus. No capitalization gets kind of annoying, though.
-
BananaHammock, don't you have some snitching to do?
That wasn't snitching you dumb fuck.
but you know what's constructive criticism? Calling you a dumb fuck.
Try to work on it. -
That wasn't snitching you dumb fuck.
but you know what's constructive criticism? Calling you a dumb fuck.
Try to work on it.Cough SNIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITCH cough
-
Learn your terms, moron.
besides who cares lol. I got a good laugh watching JD tear his post apart.
-
That wasn't snitching you dumb fuck.
but you know what's constructive criticism? Calling you a dumb fuck.
Try to work on it.
-
@Kairouseki:
Kai, you're an awesome poster.
Don't change anything.
Although, perhaps you shouldn't pretend to know Latin when you don't
-
@Kairouseki - I think you depend too much on images that generally aren't all that funny or relevant, but all in all you're really friendly and I like you.
EDIT: too late, and this is a pretty bad idea for a thread on this forum, or any forum.
-
Well, I thought the guy on the sled looked pretty angry so…
I'm not a poet like Zephos.
-
You need to listen to more Mountain Goats. In fact, I'm giving that advice to everybody here, ever. Everyone on this forum.
Wait, why am I even posting here? I'll take my own self-loathing, thank you very much!
-
Cut your hair you hippie!
-
or what we call a saturday night.awesome pic.
-
@JERK:
So how about them floods!
Pretty nasty I'd say, but Islamabad is safe.
@BananaHammock: You get riled up too easily, I think you can learn to ignore stuff…
Will give life altering advice for a cup of frothy cappuccino
-
Kmohyudin is too sober. :ninja:
And it's sad to have a regular finn here. There were a bunch of us more reasonable fellows around, but not anyone representing the radical side of us. Down with drinking. /flame
Although I have to admit that you've given some of us good laughs. You get some points for that.In general, this thread is a bit too offensive. Constructive criticism doesn't work properly when there are such many individuals around. The sea of different opinions is just too vast for this kind of thing to work properly.
-
Dryish: I think you need to stand out a bit more. We've had this discussion before, but I think it would do wonders for you to poke out from underneath Dervish's shadow. :p
Maybe make an anti-Croc statement by chance?
I for one think it'd be an okay thread as long as things don't get too personal.
[[Follow me on Twitch!]](http://twitch.tv/kitsuneinferno/)
[[Concerto di Ali: The Battle of Solocima]](showthread.php?t=33896 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 33896") - [[Spirit Wolf]](showthread.php?t=33362 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 33362")
[[D.U.R.I.A.N.]](showthread.php?t=32416 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 32416") - [[Short and Sweet Writing]](showthread.php?t=30536 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 30536")
-
Oh I will Kitsune, I will. The level of my personal crocodile hate is so huge that I can't let a chance slip by when monday arrives. Although I wouldn't like to type a message for some 30 minutes as I did with my "I hate enel" wall of text back in the prelims.
-
@Dryish
I don't know you >:( That's what pisses me off about you. -
Chocula, you should be more active in the manga section. The last time you comment on a chapter is chapter 462.
-
Which is so not true :(
-
sea change your avatar or i will keep thinking that you are 20 years old or maybe even more
-
@metteminne:
sea change your avatar or i will keep thinking that you are 20 years old or maybe even more
How about this avatar?
-
Sea, you should stop stealing the tournament with your arts.
Unless its in the name of MANGLAZE
-
Needs less manglaze.
-
There's no such thing as too much MANGLAZE
. 
