The Nostalgia Critic, I think he's stuff is probably the best on the site and its easy to see why he draws in the crowd. But does the first 5/22 slots of the sites first page have to be Doug? He rarely updates Ask That Guy, and Video Games Confessionals isn't that good.
I know he pretty much owns the site, but that's a little too much. I think he should have it by User (i.e. Merge The Nostalgia Critic, Ask That Guy, Bum Reviews, Sketches and VG Confessionals into one, That Guy With the Glasses). To get more people who deserve to be on the front page, on the front page.
I enjoy Brad Jones or the Cinema Snob a lot. And I really like Linkara's Power Rangers reviews, and his comic book ones are good too. Well this is leading me on a subject I don't like about the site;
They all have pretty much the same gimmicks, I mean I don't mind if they take a movie and make fun of it. But why does everyone have to act like they HATE doing it. I'm really sick of the "Oh god, please don't make me review ____!?" The Cinema Snob does it, Nostalgia Critic does it, Linkara does it, the british guy does it, The Amazing Athiest does it, and like everyone else.
I don't think I mind it so much when the Angry Video Game Nerd, Nostalgia Critic, or the Cinema Snob does it, cause its more apart of their character. Its not someone who just popped open a camera and was and "I'm making reviews!" now they thought out a character. The Nerd does it cause that's what he was always compiled to do, the Nostalgia Critic makes it his job so we don't have to, and the Cinema Snob well he just seems so much of a character.. its got to be his voice.
I did enjoy the NChick for a while. Cause she was breaking out of her shell. She was doing movies and voicing her opinion on things that she cared about. The thing about the most recent Hercules review is that she choose a movie with a lot of fans. It's a movie seen by most/many to be good.
I know other reviewers have tackled movies liked by many, but people like the Nostalgia Critic actually worked in what makes the movie likable and gave us reminder that some movies can have hilariously bad parts and still be a favorite.
The Nchick just kind of attacked Hercules for things we already knew. It isn't like Disney changes characters, changes plots, and has Jim Cummings in every film. Oh wait. But these are things are actually work for Disney.
While I don't care for Benzai so much, I enjoy his Master Bates's alter ego on Game Fap. Its just that over the top-ness that makes him likable.