Rank Piece

[MrPecans]

Been a hot minute since I tried my hand at posting a new topic.
Let's rank our personal top 5s, 10s, 20s and what have you of different One Piece manga topics. We'll start with one and then I'll supply a new prompt in a day or two if people take to it.

First idea, rank the best characters INTRODUCED since the Time-Skip. I'm gonna do 10, but make your list as long as you like.

10.) Carrot
9.) Fujitora
8.) Pekoms
7.) Katakuri
6.) Vergo
5.) Cat-Viper
4.) Kaidou
3.) Bart
2.) Caesar Clown
1.) Big Mom

[Could be Meadows...]

10. Pedro
11. Perospero
12. Fisher Tiger
13. Jack
14. Monet
15. Vergo
16. Senor Pink
17. Big Mom
18. Caesar Crown
19. Meadows

[Koliber]

1. Bartolomeo
2. Senor Pink
3. Katakuri
4. Fisher Tiger
5. Tamago
6. Caesar Clown
7. Nekomamushi
8. Sai
9. Baby 5
10. Koala

(sorry for breaking the convention, by I rally don't like writing stuff in this order and I'm not that sure about the ordering in the first place)

[andre]

1. Caesar Clown
2. Bartolomeo
3. Zeo
4. Kaido
5. Fujitora
6. Katakuri
7. Big Mom
8. Nekomamushi
9. Kinemon
10. Lucy

Damn, totally forgot about Rosinante. Put him at six and slide everyone else down and Lucy out.

[Blissed]

10. Senor Pink
9. Big Mom
8. Fujitora
7. Corazon
6. Kaido
5. Fisher Tiger
4. Pudding
3. Caesar Clown
2. Carrot
1. Katakuri

[.access timeco.]

1.Big Mom
2.Tamago
3.Caesar Crown
4.Perospero
EDIT:5.Ryunosuke

A list of 4 because from the 5 down things started getting blurry. I am optimistic regarding Katakuri's next developments, though.

[Kaido King of the Beasts]

10. Corazon
9. Momonosuke
8. Fisher Tiger
7. Cavendish
6. Nekomamushi
5. Bartolomeo
4. Kaido
3. Fujitora
2. Caesar Clown
1. Big Mom

HONORABLE MENTIONS: Pudding, Katakuri, Caribou

[Furisu]

1. Big Mom
2. Caesar Clown
3. Nekomamushi
4. Charlotte Perospero
5. lssho
6. Cavendish
7. Charlotte Cracker
8. Charlotte Mont-d'Or
9. Monet
10. Dellinger

[FelRes]

1. Katakuri
2. Pudding
3. Kyros
4. Rebecca
5. Otohime
6. Carrot
7. Gastino
8. Koala
9. Perospero
10. Zeo

[K466]

This post is deleted!

[MrBits]

Funnily enough, I was actually just thinking about who my favorite Post-TS characters were.

1. Katakuri (Might just be recency bias, but he's definitely top 3 at least)
2. Corazon
3. Caesar

GAP

4. Pudding
5. Cavendish
6. Perospero
7. Tamago
8. Big Mom
9. Jack
10. Pedro

Honorable mention: Kaidou, who will probably climb up once he gets screentime. Also Judge, because I'm the only person I know who still kind of likes the guy.

[KageKageKing]

1. Jack.
2. Katakuri.
3. Niwatori.
4. Perospero.
5. Nekomamushi.
6. Bartolomeo.
7. Hakuba.
8. Big Mom.
9. Senor Pink.
10. Corazon.

[MrPecans]

Feel free to keep listing your Top 10 Characters Introduced Since the Time-Skip Lists if you haven't yet, but here's the next one - and it's a companion list: Top 10 Characters from Part 1 of One Piece, Based Off of Part 2 Actions Only. Catchy ain't it?

10. Law
09. Bellamy
08. Doflamingo
07. Jinbe
06. Smoker
05. Franky
04. Bege
03. Brook
02. Nami
01. Luffy

[andre]

1. Luffy
2. Franky
3. Brook
4. Jinbe
5. Brownbeard
6. Bege
7. Usopp
8. Buggy
9. Kuzan
10. Sanji

[.access timeco.]

@MrPecans:

Top 10 Characters from Part 1 of One Piece, Based Off of Part 2 Actions Only. Catchy ain't it?

Wow, that's… specific...

1.Doflamingo (went from "joker wannabe character" to one of my most favorite characters in the franchise. Just love everything about him now)
2.Bege
3.Franky (I think he is the only SH I still like as much as before the timeskip)
4.Jinbe (I still think he is kinda boring, but at least now I think he is a lovely boring guy. I can't help but sympathize with him now and wish for his best)
5.Brook

[Koliber]

1. Brook
2. Franky
3. Jinbe
4. Bege
5. Kuzan
6. Tsuru
7. Urouge
8. Sakazuki
9. Sengoku
10. Usopp*
*he might have one of the best post-TS scenes but also the worst one, so yeah…

[Kaido King of the Beasts]

10. Urouge
9. Kuzan
8. Buggy
7. Blackbeard
6. Franky
5. Brook
4. Doflamingo
3. Law
2. Capone Bege
1. Jinbe

[andre]

@Kaido:

10. Urouge
9. Kuzan
8. Buggy
7. Blackbeard
6. Franky
5. Brook
4. Doflamingo
3. Law
2. Capone Bege
1. Jinbe

No Kaido? But Blackbeard…???

[KageKageKing]

@andre:

No Kaido? But Blackbeard…???

Kaido wasn't in Part 1.

[MrBits]

1. Law
2. Brook
3. Luffy
4. Jinbei
5. Sengoku
6. Bege

[andre]

@KageKageKing:

Kaido wasn't in Part 1.

You're right. My blunder.

[FelRes]

Well this got harder.

1. Brook
2. Zoro
3. Bege
4. Robin
5. Buggy
6. Franky
7. Tsuru
8. Law
9. Doflamingo
10. Kuzan

I was tempted to put Bellamy in, but part 1 is important to his character development and why I love him so much.

[MrPecans]

@andre:

No Kaido? But Blackbeard…???

Uh Blackbeard is one of the best characters in the whole series easy.

[Kaido King of the Beasts]

Don't you worry, Kaido was quite high on my Post TS-introduction list, with plenty of room to grow :happy:

[andre]

@MrPecans:

Uh Blackbeard is one of the best characters in the whole series easy.

I had a mental miscue when I saw him without Kaido and compared his appearances post time skip to Blackbeard's. I believe we have only experienced Blackbeard on the phone this far so it's hard for me to understand his placing if the criteria is based on ones performance since the time skip, but I only brought it up because of my hiccup and his name.

[thegab]

Since the TS,
1. Gangster Gastino
2. Cavendish
3. Sabo (was he pre TS?)
4. Bartolomeo
5. Katakuri
6.Fujitora
7. Perospero
8. Senor Pink
9. Pudding (yes I dig her)
10. Baby 5
Least fav gotta be Caesar clown

[MrPecans]

Sabo is grey (terminal) area, since he was introduced in a flashback as a child. I'd say he's pre-ts personally but, whatever.

Ok so TOP (3, 5, 10, 20?)

1. POST TIME SKIP CHARACTERS
2. PRE TIME SKIP CHARACTERS SINCE TIME SKIP
3. BATTLES….go!

TOP 20 ONE PIECE FIGHTS

20. Luffy vs Crocodile, final round
19. Franky vs Senor Pink
18. Chopper vs Gedatsu
17. Luffy vs Enel
16. Luffy vs Blueno
15. Nami vs Kalifa
14. Usopp vs Choo
13. Zoro vs Mr. 1
12. Usopp vs Perona
11. Franky vs Fukoro
10. Straw-Hats vs Pacifistas and Marines
09. Usopp and Chopper vs Ms. Merry Christmas and Mr. 4
08. Zoro vs Baroque Works at Whiskey Peak
07. Luffy vs Magellan, round one
06. Zoro vs Kuma
05. Luffy vs Usopp
04. Nami vs Ms. Double-Finger
03. Luffy vs Crocodile, round one
02. Straw-Hats (ft. Night-Mare Luffy) vs Oars and Moria
01. Luffy vs Lucci

[No swords style best style]

I just realized how long it's been since I've re-read most of OP, I can barely remember most of the fights lol

3.Luffy vs. Lucci
2.Final Luffy vs. Crocodile battle
1.The whole crew vs. Oars and Moria

[Kisoto]

1. Favs introduced since the TS:

1. Corazon
2. Baby 5
3. Charlotte Katakuri
4. Fujitora
5. Hyozo (because BLUE-RINGED OCTOPUS)
6. Reiju
7. Charlotte Pudding
8. Koala
9. Zeo
10. Bartolomeo

[Kaido King of the Beasts]

Just a bit of advice, you may be going too fast with these lists. I think a couple of days, 2 or 3 to be specific, will give more people time for answers and not tire people out, plus you can't go through all your ideas too soon haha.

Battles…Top 15 this time.

15. Luffy vs. Usopp
14. Gan Fall vs. Shura
13. Luffy vs. Don Krieg
12. Smoker vs. Vergo
11. Luffy vs. Foxy
10. Bartolomeo and Cavendish/Hakuba vs. Gladius
9. Franky vs. Fukuro
8. Luffy vs. Bellamy (Jaya)
7. Usopp and Chopper vs. Mr. 4 and Miss Merry Christmas
6. Zoro vs. Pica
5. Luffy vs. Katakuri
4. Luffy vs. Arlong
3. Luffy vs. Crocodile (Final Battle)
2. Straw Hats vs. Oars
1. Luffy vs. Enel

[MrPecans]

When you're right, you're right! I'm on vacation and I just keep getting bored. I'll wait longer from here on!

[MrPecans]

If I haven't already ruined the thread, here's one more stab at a list:

Top Ten Favorite World Government Affiliated Characters

10. T-Bone
09. Hannyabal
08. Vergo
07. Sengoku
06. Akainu
05. Kaku
04. Garp
03. Aokiji
02. Kizaru
01. Magellan

[MrBits]

1. Kizaru
2. Garp
3. Akainu
4. Rosinante
5. Sengoku

[Chams]

TOP 5 fights

1. Luffy vs Crocodile, second part
2. Luffy vs Rob Lucci
3. Zoro vs. Mr.1
4. Nami vs. Miss Double Finger
5. Robin vs. Yanma

I thought of proposing another ranking:
Top 5+ Battles that never happened!!

1. Nami vs. Monet
2. Usopp vs. Trebol
3. Robin and Kyros vs. Diamante
4. Nami and Robin vs… anyone at fishman island

[Starrk]

1. Top 10 Pre Time Skip Characters (Since Time Skip)

! 10. sabo
9. smoker
8. zoro
7. brook
6. bege
5. nami
4. jinbe
3. law
2. doflamingo
1. luffy

2. Top 10 Post Time Skip Characters

! 10. big mom
9. pudding
8. senor pink
7. carrot
6. fujitora
5. pedro
4. katakuri
3. rosinante
2. nekomamushi
1. bartolomeo

3. Top 20 Battles

! 20. Luffy vs Arlong
19. Nami vs Califa
18. Nami vs Ms. Double Finger
17. Law vs Smoker
16. Luffy vs Wiper
15. Franky vs Senor Pink
14. SHP vs Pacifista
13. Zoro vs Kuma
12. Luffy vs Katakuri
11. Zoro vs Baroque Works
10. Franky vs Fukurou
09. Usopp - Chopper vs Mr.4 - Ms. Merry Christmas
08. Luffy vs Crocodile, final part
07. Zoro vs Mr.1
06. Sanji vs Jyabura
05. Zoro vs Kaku
04. Luffy vs Usopp
03. SHP vs Oars - Moria
02. Zoro vs Ryuma
01. Luffy vs Lucci

[Game And Guy]

I don't remember off the top of my head but I can assure myself it's none of the characters before Zou.

[FelRes]

OP if you're over making list subjects, I'd like to have everyone rank their top 10 One Piece hairstyles.

[SquallL]

Top One Piece characters

1. Nami
2. Nami
3. Nami
4. Nami
5. Nami
6. Nami
7. Nami
8. Nami
9. Nami
10. Nami

Top One Piece arcs

1. Arlong Park
2. Enies Lobby
3. WCI
4. Sabaody Archipelago
5. Marineford
6. Zou
7. Alabasta
8. Thriller Bark
9. Drum Island
10. Skypiea

Top One Piece battles

1. Luffy vs Lucci
2. Luffy/Nami vs Cracker
3. Nami vs Califa
5. Nami vs Ms. Double Finger
6. Luffy vs Dofla
7. Franky vs Baby 5 and Buffalo
8. Usopp vs Perona
9. Zoro vs Mr.1
10. Straw Hats vs Oars

[MrPecans]

@Starrk:

1. Top 10 Pre Time Skip Characters (Since Time Skip)

! 10. sabo
9. smoker
8. zoro
7. brook
6. bege
5. nami
4. jinbe
3. law
2. doflamingo
1. luffy

2. Top 10 Post Time Skip Characters

! 10. big mom
9. pudding
8. senor pink
7. carrot
6. fujitora
5. pedro
4. katakuri
3. rosinante
2. nekomamushi
1. bartolomeo

3. Top 20 Battles

! 20. Luffy vs Arlong
19. Nami vs Califa
18. Nami vs Ms. Double Finger
17. Law vs Smoker
16. Luffy vs Wiper
15. Franky vs Senor Pink
14. SHP vs Pacifista
13. Zoro vs Kuma
12. Luffy vs Katakuri
11. Zoro vs Baroque Works
10. Franky vs Fukurou
09. Usopp - Chopper vs Mr.4 - Ms. Merry Christmas
08. Luffy vs Crocodile, final part
07. Zoro vs Mr.1
06. Sanji vs Jyabura
05. Zoro vs Kaku
04. Luffy vs Usopp
03. SHP vs Oars - Moria
02. Zoro vs Ryuma
01. Luffy vs Lucci

I dig your taste in fights haha

–- Update From New Post Merge ---

@SquallL:

Top One Piece characters

1. Nami
2. Nami
3. Nami
4. Nami
5. Nami
6. Nami
7. Nami
8. Nami
9. Nami
10. Nami

Indeed, Nami is GOAT

–- Update From New Post Merge ---

@FelRes:

OP if you're over making list subjects, I'd like to have everyone rank their top 10 One Piece hairstyles.

Lol I'm game for this one if y'all are!

HAIR STYLES

10. Boodle
9. Ivankov
8. Crocus
07. Mr. 3
06. Whitebeard
05. Merry
04. Waipa
03. Franky (original)
02. Hiriluk
01. Buggy

honorable mentions: Kumadori, Mr. 2, and Oven.

–- Update From New Post Merge ---

Edit: sorry, every woman!

[FelRes]

@MrPecans:

Lol I'm game for this one if y'all are!

HAIR STYLES

10. Boodle
9. Ivankov
8. Crocus
07. Mr. 3
06. Whitebeard
05. Merry
04. Waipa
03. Franky (original)
02. Hiriluk
01. Buggy

honorable mentions: Kumadori, Mr. 2, and Oven.

–- Update From New Post Merge ---

Edit: sorry, every woman!

Where the bloody hell is Strawberry.

[FrankyFan]

@Chams:

1. Nami vs. Monet
2. Usopp vs. Trebol
3. Robin and Kyros vs. Diamante
4. Nami and Robin vs… anyone at fishman island

This list hurts.

Here's my top 20 fights:

1. Luffy vs. Crocodile
2. Franky vs. Fukuro
3. Zoro vs. Daz Bones
4. Luffy vs. Usopp
5. Zoro vs. Mihawk
6. Luffy vs. Lucci
7. Chopper vs. Kumadori
8. Sanji vs. Wanze
9. Nami vs. Miss Doublefinger
10. Usopp vs. Chew
11. Zoro vs. Pica
12. Sanji vs. Kuroobi
13. Robin vs. Yama
14. Zoro vs. Ryuma
15. Smoker vs. Vergo
16. Sanji vs. Kalifa
17. Chopper vs. Gedatsu
18. UsoCho vs. 4 Team
19. Usopp vs. Perona
20. Zoro vs. Braham

[MrPecans]

@FrankyFan:

This list hurts.

Why does that list hurt?

Here's my list of top 5 fights that never happened:

Nami vs Absalom
Nami vs Lola
Robin vs Cindry (but where Cindry is a good fighter)
Chopper vs Hogback
Robin and Usopp vs Trebol

I know that shades of those Thriller Bark fights went down, but none of them were proper satisfying duels, in my opinion.

[Count Mario]

Top Five Fights that never happened? I'll give you a Top Ten instead.

! 1. Brook versus Big Mom (c'mon, try to prove me wrong)
2. Usopp versus Jabra
3. Usopp versus Trebol
4. Usopp versus Katakuri
5. Usopp versus Mont-d'Or
6. Usopp versus Vito
7. Robin versus Trebol
8. Zoro versus Smoothie
9. Zoro versus Amande
10. Zoro versus Bobbin

[Koliber]

Fights that never happened?

1. Usopp vs Blueno
2. Robin vs Kalifa
3. Zoro&Usopp vs Kaku&Jabra (they should have stayed cuffed 'till the end)
4. Usopp vs Trebol
5. Chopper vs Hogback

1 & 2 were actually original plan for EL.

My top fights
1. Usopp vs Luffy
2. Usopp vs Perona
3. Usopp&Chopper vs Mr. 4 Pair
4. Luffy vs Foxy
5. Oars battle (would be #2 if it wasn't for Nightmare Luffy part)

These are the only fights I actually loved.

[MrPecans]

@Count:

Top Five Fights that never happened? I'll give you a Top Ten instead.

! 1. Brook versus Big Mom (c'mon, try to prove me wrong)
2. Usopp versus Jabra
3. Usopp versus Trebol
4. Usopp versus Katakuri
5. Usopp versus Mont-d'Or
6. Usopp versus Vito
7. Robin versus Trebol
8. Zoro versus Smoothie
9. Zoro versus Amande
10. Zoro versus Bobbin

Dude, Usopp vs Mont-d'Or could be potentially really interesting.

[FrankyFan]

@MrPecans:

Why does that list hurt?

Being reminded of what could have been - Nami and Tashigi vs. Monet specifically.

[Count Mario]

@MrPecans:

Dude, Usopp vs Mont-d'Or could be potentially really interesting.

I still want to know what exactly the rules of that Book World even are besides random Alice in Wonderland nonsense.

[MrPecans]

Topic revival plz.

Everyone, let's rank our Top 10 Story Arcs!

10. Davy Back
9. Drum
8. Arlong Park
7. Baratie
6. Alabasta
5. Saboady
4. Jaya
3. Thriller Bark
2. Impel Down
1. CP9*

(*I have never liked thinking of the CP9 saga being split into Water 7, Enies Lobby, and Water 7 return. The only arc that deserves to be separated in that, to me, is the Davy Back portion. To me, the events of those arcs are way too linked for the island hop to justify it as a new arc. However if you're a purist then…
10. Drum
9. Arlong Park
8. Baratie
7. Water Seven
6. Alabasta
5. Saboady
4. Jaya
3. Thriller Bark
2. Enies Lobby
1. Impel Down)

TOP 5 Sagas

5. East Blue
4. Thriller Bark
3. Baroque Works
2. Paramount War
1. CP9

note: I used to think of Thriller Bark as the beginning of the Paramount War saga, but I've been told that's wrong and the net seems to support it. If it was the case then, Paramount would maybe get number 1 and Skypiea would take number 5.

[theackwardstation]

I'm not confortable comparing big arcs and small arcs, so I'll make two Top 5s instead of one Top 10.

Big Arcs (30+ chapters):
5. Marineford (considering the post-war chapters too)
4. Skypiea
3. Whole Cake Island
2. Alabasta
1. CP9

Small arcs (less than 30 chapters):
5. Zou
4. Drum
3. Jaya
2. Arlong Park
1. Sabaody

Top 5 sagas:
5. Skypiea
4. Big Mom
3. East Blue
2. Baroque Works
1. CP9

[FelRes]

Arcs:

1. Jaya
2. W7/Enies Lobby
3. Skypiea
4. Whole Cake Island
5. Impel Down
6. Arlong
7. Drum
8. Fishman Island
9. Davy Back Fight
10. Sabaody

I more or less agree with W7 and EL being one arc. Only change is in island and clothes, characters and conflict are largely the same, just a few extra baddies. It's like Kill Bill like that, even has one side being more action and the other more plot.

I don't even know what counts as what for sagas anymore so not ranking those.