Arlong Park Forums

    • Register
    • Login
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups

    Chapter 862: The Intelligent Ones

    Past Chapter Discussions
    173
    598
    170803
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Kaido King of the Beasts
      Kaido King of the Beasts @Shadow5963
      @Shadow5963 last edited by
      Kaido King of the Beasts
      spiral
      Kaido King of the Beasts
      spiral

      @Shadow5963:

      Two chapters ago he saw a guy pull out gun and shoot two of bege subordinates, I think he can see clearly enough, even if he had only seen sangi dodging a bullet he would have seen the direction of the bullet, would he not? So he would have know he was going to dodge his jelly bean.

      I don't think he - or anyone - could be so precise as to determine the direction of a bullet in that time span. Remember, Katakuri has to act in a very short time, because like Bege, Big Mom needs everything to go smoothly within seconds in order to execute her assassination plan and not cause any unnecessary chaos. Sanji needed to be dead right then and there, and when Katakuri saw that he'd dodge a bullet headed his way, there wasn't much he could do in that time other than assume the bullet would come from the gun-unholstering minister and that he would be the one to make the mistake. Very different circumstances than when he was casually lazing about on top of the wall and being able to pay mind to anything that interested him.

      so he may have shoot to were sangi was going to be after the priest's shot( probably not ,but would have been more impressive)
      He wouldn't, because he shot at the place where Sanji was at right then, before Sanji even reacted to the priest's move to attack.

      Spoiler:

      S 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Rocko52
        Rocko52
        last edited by
        Rocko52
        spiral
        Rocko52
        spiral

        This has been quite the heated discussion lol. I'm still pretty conflicted on how Oda can handle Luffy escaping Big Mom without underselling her own threat in order to build up Kadio's, but also how he could have Luffy possibly beat her & make it either convincing or have the other Yonko remain dangerous. It's quite a pickle. I'm still excited and fairly confident for this climax, but I don't quite get how Oda will still give a satisfying action-packed climax without either sacrificing Big Mom's credit as a villain, (though her horrid security already sorta has) or Kaido's. It's a shame because I find Big Mom far more interesting as a character and villain, (At least so far) and also really don't want Oda to squander his most powerful female character.

        I really like a lot of this arc so far, from the fantastic designs and villains, to the intricate plotting, and exciting setting. Though I do still take issue with Sanji's kinda inconsistent character, the bland "evil-ness" of the Vinsmoke's, and now Pudding's fall for Sanji's charms. People have already commented on how weird it feels for Pudding to be bullied for a third eye not only on WCI but in the weird-ass world of One Piece, so I won't go too in-depth. But it definitely feels abrupt and has too little build up. It also continues Oda's annoying trend of giving female comatants excuses not to fight, as well as the trend of quelling female villains with "love/empathy/sexual" related means - Hancock, Viola, that girl Franky kissed, now Pudding. All that said, I'm still hopeful for this arc, and I feel it's been the strongest of the New World & one of my favorites in spite of some real missteps. A lot weighs on where it goes from here though.

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • S
          Shadow5963 @Kaido King of the Beasts
          @Kaido King of the Beasts last edited by
          S
          spiral
          Shadow5963
          spiral

          @Kaido:

          I don't think he - or anyone - could be so precise as to determine the direction of a bullet in that time span. Remember, Katakuri has to act in a very short time, because like Bege, Big Mom needs everything to go smoothly within seconds in order to execute her assassination plan and not cause any unnecessary chaos. Sanji needed to be dead right then and there, and when Katakuri saw that he'd dodge a bullet headed his way, there wasn't much he could do in that time other than assume the bullet would come from the gun-unholstering minister and that he would be the one to make the mistake. Very different circumstances than when he was casually lazing about on top of the wall and being able to pay mind to anything that interested him.

          If he can't be that precise because of such circunstance then his ability is useless in battle, you seem to be
          downplaying his ability, I think he sees as clearly in any situation.

          dlo62282 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • dlo62282
            dlo62282 @Shadow5963
            @Shadow5963 last edited by
            dlo62282
            spiral
            dlo62282
            spiral

            @Shadow5963:

            @Kaido:

            I don't think he - or anyone - could be so precise as to determine the direction of a bullet in that time span. Remember, Katakuri has to act in a very short time, because like Bege, Big Mom needs everything to go smoothly within seconds in order to execute her assassination plan and not cause any unnecessary chaos. Sanji needed to be dead right then and there, and when Katakuri saw that he'd dodge a bullet headed his way, there wasn't much he could do in that time other than assume the bullet would come from the gun-unholstering minister and that he would be the one to make the mistake. Very different circumstances than when he was casually lazing about on top of the wall and being able to pay mind to anything that interested him.

            If he can't be that precise because of such circunstance then his ability is useless in battle, you seem to be
            downplaying his ability, I think he sees as clearly in any situation.

            If you are battling somebody and try to see the future too much. You are going to miss what's happening right in front of you. Plus he gets flashes of the future, it's not a continuous stream. If it was, he wouldn't be able to function in the present.

            yeah im here

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • S
              Shobu Yoruichi @_Hayato
              @_Hayato last edited by
              S
              spiral
              Shobu Yoruichi
              spiral

              @_Hayato:

              Big Mom having great intel (just from Luffy's short interaction with her) due to comparison with the Four Heavenly Kings. (http://forums.arlongpark.net/showthread.php?t=42110&p=3500232&viewfull=1#post3500232)

              Me bringing up over and over in this forum about the food in the series and their exaggerated health benefits (it's a lot more emphasized during Luffy and Brook's "gag" scene).

              Prediction of the next arcs using Samsara. Zou arc being next (animal realm; though to be fair this was an easy guess from when I made it), whole cake island (honestly, I'm still trying to make the connection with the human realm), most likely Wano next (Asura realm; check my Haki thread, mostly about Zoro stuff) then God realm next, which you know… the arc is kinda obvious -hint- Vivi -hint-

              Then of course, the use(rs) of CoO. Maybe some of you remember but I was the one who tried to explain what Haki is (the kind that isn't said in the manga clearly itself), due to being inspired by a post off another user from another forum. However, my definition of CoO came from my own deductive abilities and guesswork. Pretty much, what I said was CoO is that the GREAT users are "caring" individuals. My old Haki thread http://www.arlongpark.net/showthread.php?t=42907 under "Observation"–though it's a thread that is still not proven wrong in any way so don't be afraid to read it).

              As I mentioned earlier, GREAT CoO users are caring individuals, I still don't know how it could possibly evolve since I haven't thought about the series in a while but maybe we'll see a glimpse of it in this arc (besides you know seeing into the future).

              Interesting… i would swap Shanks and Kaidou, and Zoro's explanation about 'breath' is flawless, his swords are also very nice, including Asura. Chopper's theory is rather outsmarting... which is just a fruit and i've not seen that kind of development in Chobro. The awakening in general is also a thing that i disagree, mostly for Crocodile... your advancing skills on your fruit power are sole enough to catch it; as he said when fighting Luffy, plus the jailers, Aokiji and Akainu, i do not feel a vibre on their spirit -except Akainu- in order to accept the power at all considering the sins of the worlds.

              Noting that feature of Kenbunshoku users is also wonderful, just looking at Potato-kun this chapter denotes it.

              If arrogance was Dressrosa, humanity's Totland, brutality's Zou, rapture's Mariejois, hell's Punk Hazard, hunger's Fishman Island and asura's Wano... i think One Piece post timeskip is kinda short 😧

              Teach being Indra and being the god of storms, war and thunder... i would rolf'd over the entire floor of my house if he kills Enel and Dragon, dude. That's funny and wondrous.

              Nice post ovhathere.

              Nothing exists; even if something exists, nothing can be known about it. Even if something can be known about it,

              knowledge about it can't be communicated to others. Even if it can be communicated, it cannot be understood.

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • HeartOfDarkness
                HeartOfDarkness @GetsugaZoro
                @GetsugaZoro last edited by
                HeartOfDarkness
                spiral
                HeartOfDarkness
                spiral

                @GetsugaZoro:

                Pudding is the only human or whatever race she is with the 3 eyes, who gives a crap about the diversity, she has a third eye, people teasing her specially kids is perfectly acceptable.

                "oh she has living cakes and clouds", yeah but those things are Big Mom creations not one of her kids.

                I liked the plot twist once again(just like I liked when Oda did it the first time), seems to some people ever since the timeskip nothing is fucking good, "derp Naruto went to shit after the timeskip" that means I have to say and act the same way for One Piece.

                As someone who has continually defended post-timeskip One Piece, this Pudding stuff is terrible. No way of getting around the fact that her character has been lazy, aside from the she-is-evil-twist, and this chapter had only made her worst, and it seems like Oda doesn't have a clue as to where he wants her plot-thread to go.

                –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                @carcanclaw:

                Of fucking course. Of course sexist Oda couldn't follow through with a beautiful evil female character getting what she deserved.

                Just like Hancock before her, Pudding was defeated by love. Such is the fate of all pretty female antagonists in OP.

                Sigh Look Pudding stuff is not great and it's pretty damn terrible, but please don't open that sexist bullshit over here.

                Long John Silvers Rayleigh 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • Long John Silvers Rayleigh
                  Long John Silvers Rayleigh @HeartOfDarkness
                  @HeartOfDarkness last edited by
                  Long John Silvers Rayleigh
                  spiral
                  Long John Silvers Rayleigh
                  spiral

                  @HeartOfDarkness:

                  As someone who has continually defended post-timeskip One Piece, this Pudding stuff is terrible. No way of getting around the fact that her character has been lazy, aside from the she-is-evil-twist, and this chapter had only made her worst, and it seems like Oda doesn't have a clue as to where he wants her plot-thread to go.

                  –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                  Sigh Look Pudding stuff is not great and it's pretty damn terrible, but please don't open that sexist bullshit over here.

                  Well at least you are consistent, some people have been decrying pudding being frozen as ruining her as a great villain when she was just a sadistic 2D one. The buildup could have been done a lot better but I think depending on if its given enough nuance it will make the climax better than if she just stayed evil and blew herself up

                  Chapter 437 Discussion after franky decides to join the Strawhats:

                  So who think Usopp is inside that duffelbag?

                  H x H Chimera Ant Arc / OP Manga Spoiler

                  Spoiler:

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • HeartOfDarkness
                    HeartOfDarkness @akagami7
                    @akagami7 last edited by
                    HeartOfDarkness
                    spiral
                    HeartOfDarkness
                    spiral

                    @akagami7:

                    I too think Pudding's memory powers are important on this issue. There are too many incoherences for her powers to not be the cause of a few of them. I specially like your theory about her ability to read poneglyphs being made up. Do the three-eye tribe actually exists?

                    Yea, but how much of that implication is true, and not just a by product of lack of planning? I am gonna go with Oda's track record, and say that he fucked up with Pudding, tried to give her a memory fruit, and now everything is all over the place.

                    It would be good if memory fruit is really behind this, but judging by what i have seen in the past chapters, and this chapter, i am gonna assume the worst.

                    –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                    @Long:

                    Well at least you are consistent, some people have been decrying pudding being frozen as ruining her as a great villain when she was just a sadistic 2D one. The buildup could have been done a lot better but I think depending on if its given enough nuance it will make the climax better than if she just stayed evil and blew herself up

                    That evil-twist did give her character a little spark ( far far far better than that crappy lovey-dovey character), but it still wasn't enough to ultimately make Pudding an interesting character.

                    Regardless of how Oda deals with the memory powers, Pudding's character simply at this point is a waste of time.

                    Md-Martin 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • Md-Martin
                      Md-Martin @HeartOfDarkness
                      @HeartOfDarkness last edited by
                      Md-Martin
                      spiral
                      Md-Martin
                      spiral

                      @HeartOfDarkness:

                      Regardless of how Oda deals with the memory powers, Pudding's character simply at this point is a waste of time.

                      Ah yes, because everyone knows the most subjective way to judge a character that has been raveled in mystery the entire arc is to judge it as a waste of time based on a single chapter in the very beginning of the climax.

                      Maybe a waste of your time, but in general that's a load of horse shit. People need to stop over reacting over a few pages of this chapter

                      Originally Posted by Monkey King

                      A magical strange Twilight Zone episode where no other education is offered, and the only option is Bill Nye the Science Guy videos

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • HeartOfDarkness
                        HeartOfDarkness
                        last edited by
                        HeartOfDarkness
                        spiral
                        HeartOfDarkness
                        spiral

                        If I was talking just this chapter then you might have had a point , but I was referring to her character since the introduction.

                        I mean you can slice it however you want, doesn't change the fact that her character is weak and a general waste of time.

                        K Md-Martin 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • K
                          Koliber @HeartOfDarkness
                          @HeartOfDarkness last edited by
                          K
                          spiral
                          Koliber
                          spiral

                          @HeartOfDarkness:

                          If I was talking just this chapter then you might have had a point , but I was referring to her character since the introduction.

                          I mean you can slice it however you want, doesn't change the fact that her character is weak and a general waste of time.

                          What do you even mean by a waste of time? Because to my understanding, the character who has been central to the arc's main conflict, and will likely be one of the most important players during it's resolution can hardly be named a waste of time. And generally calling someone that when you have no idea what consequence her actions will have in the story overall is pretty weird.

                          All hail Machvise-sama, Arlong Park Character Tournament 2016 Champion!

                          HeartOfDarkness 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • Md-Martin
                            Md-Martin @HeartOfDarkness
                            @HeartOfDarkness last edited by
                            Md-Martin
                            spiral
                            Md-Martin
                            spiral

                            @HeartOfDarkness:

                            If I was talking just this chapter then you might have had a point , but I was referring to her character since the introduction.

                            I mean you can slice it however you want, doesn't change the fact that her character is weak and a general waste of time.

                            By that logic you could say every character like Connis, Kohza, Pell, Foxy, etc are all just wastes of time right?

                            She's been a staple of this whole arc, you not liking the way a character's story is going doesn't validate the statement that she's a waste of time, considering she was built up since the end of Fishman Island, introduced in the first few chapters of this arc, and served as the first child of Big Mom to really show the lying and distrust throughout the entire family.

                            Originally Posted by Monkey King

                            A magical strange Twilight Zone episode where no other education is offered, and the only option is Bill Nye the Science Guy videos

                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • HeartOfDarkness
                              HeartOfDarkness @Koliber
                              @Koliber last edited by
                              HeartOfDarkness
                              spiral
                              HeartOfDarkness
                              spiral

                              @Koliber:

                              What do you even mean by a waste of time? Because to my understanding, the character who has been central to the arc's main conflict, and will likely be one of the most important players during it's resolution can hardly be named a waste of time. And generally calling someone that when you have no idea what consequence her actions will have in the story overall is pretty weird.

                              No i am talking about her from a character stand-point, and not as a plot-device. She maybe important for plot-threads to move along, but that doesn't mean that she is automatically an interesting character. As of now, she is nothing more than a crappy, uninteresting, and overall lazy device. Nothing more.

                              –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                              @Md-Martin:

                              By that logic you could say every character like Connis, Kohza, Pell, Foxy, etc are all just wastes of time right?

                              She's been a staple of this whole arc, you not liking the way a character's story is going doesn't validate the statement that she's a waste of time, considering she was built up since the end of Fishman Island, introduced in the first few chapters of this arc, and served as the first child of Big Mom to really show the lying and distrust throughout the entire family.

                              Except you know those characters were still somewhat interesting, and not a shitty device that only existed for events to happen. They were still somewhat individual characters. Pudding is not.

                              And I don't care if Pudding is important when i have literal no shits to give about her in any way whatsoever.

                              How was she build up? We saw her once, and that's it. Barely any real dialogue or screen time, and then we saw her in the most mediocre, and the lamest character introduction in the series.

                              I mean you are free to preach this crap if you want. It will not really change the fact that Pudding is a crappy character that has nothing of substantial, despite having so much screen-time.

                              Md-Martin 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • Md-Martin
                                Md-Martin @HeartOfDarkness
                                @HeartOfDarkness last edited by
                                Md-Martin
                                spiral
                                Md-Martin
                                spiral

                                @HeartOfDarkness:

                                Except you know those characters were still somewhat interesting, and not a shitty device that only existed for events to happen. They were still somewhat individual characters. Pudding is not.

                                I mean you're just wrong objectively in saying she's not interesting. These forums alone have shown with months discussing her ambiguous role in the story and what her deal is. You can not like it, that's fine. But to say she isn't interesting considering she had a big twist involved with her, was introduced as a mysterious 3 eyed girl with a weird blob on her, sitting right next to Big Mom got a ton of peoples attention, and then seeing her, eye covered, as the bride-to-be for Sanji is interesting. Again, you can dislike how it has played out, but to say it isn't interesting is just as stupid as saying "Yeah, nothing interesting about Kuma showing up on Thriller Bark, just some Warlord we already saw coming by. Nothing interested about Kizaru being introduced literally riding a cannon ball into Saboady, we've seen a quirky Admiral before".

                                How was she build up? We saw her once, and that's it. Barely any real dialogue or screen time, and then we saw her in the most mediocre, and the lamest character introduction in the series. .

                                Jimbei was built up by being mentioned once in one of the earlier parts of the story. We didn't see him or really here anything of him until Impel Down. Was he not built up? He certainly was because in that short dialogue they mentioned how he let Arlong lose, pretty much stating he was much stronger, and said he was a Warlord like Mihawk, who we just saw performing very hype-inducing actions. It was all comparative, Mihawk set the bar, and we threw a name right at that level. And that obviously progressed with seeing characters like Crocodile and Moriah. With only a few panels of dialogue, and just framing he was built up pretty thoroughly. We knew he would be important and show up eventually.

                                Well the same thing happened with Pudding, whether you like it or not. She was introduced in a mysterious way that drew the attention of pretty much the entire fandom. Who was this mysterious girl? Why did she have 3 eyes? What is that on her shoulder? Is she a child of Big Mom?

                                We knew she would be important because we specifically saw her in directly next to Big Mom during BIG MOM'S INTRODUCTION! In the first chapter that we directly met the first two members of her crew, Pekoms and Tamago, the first time we see Big Mom in person, as she devoured some sentient being Pudding is right there. 651 is THE chapter that started the set up for this arc, and in the same one that has all these notable and defining aspects that have been highlighted in this arc, Pudding is right there.

                                So let me ask you, what is your definition of "Built up"? What makes this not an interesting and thought provoking introduction but a "lame one" as you put it?

                                You said you were looking at this from a character perspective and not a plot point, but we literally have so much of what would encompass her story this arc in a few panels over 200 chapters ago. We see her, with Nitro, with her 3 eyes, sighing and looking annoyed as her mother, one of the 4 greatest pirates eats someone as she casually talks with Bobbin about destroying islands over food like it is nothing.

                                Originally Posted by Monkey King

                                A magical strange Twilight Zone episode where no other education is offered, and the only option is Bill Nye the Science Guy videos

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • Razh
                                  Razh @Kaido King of the Beasts
                                  @Kaido King of the Beasts last edited by
                                  Razh
                                  spiral
                                  Razh
                                  spiral

                                  @Kaido:

                                  I really don't understand why Sanji dodging a jellybean is being seen as so significant. Yes, it came against a guy like Katakuri, but we know where Katakuri went wrong - he foresaw Sanji dodging a shot, and he thought he'd dodge the priest's shot, but he took initiative too early and ended up being the one to make his prediction come true. Sanji is a proficient Observation Haki user, so his dodging the jellybean is something to be expected. To me it's no more of a feat than him blocking Judge's spear with Armament. I have no reason to believe he's capable enough to engage Katakuri in a head-on confrontation based on what I've seen so far.

                                  It's possible, but I doubt Potato would make a mistake like that. He's supposed to be really good at it.

                                  Originally Posted by Outerspec

                                  Trying to understand Bleach is like trying to drink a bottle of bleach.

                                  It makes no sense and you'll be dead before you're finished.

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • E
                                    E7x
                                    last edited by
                                    E
                                    spiral
                                    E7x
                                    spiral

                                    Pudding is interesting for the fact that she will play an important part in the plot. Ppl just want her to be a one dimensional character that lives and dies with big mom and use her crying damsels as an excuse not to like her. Being an evil cunt isnt fun if shes only like that because her family raised her that way. People think her only choice is to sude with Mom or side with Luffy. Who knows what she'll do. Othe than robin shes the only one with the possibilty of reading the poneglyphs. A strong target for Kaidou or the marines.

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • Monquito
                                      Monquito
                                      last edited by
                                      Monquito
                                      spiral
                                      Monquito
                                      spiral

                                      Since there will be another break after this upcoming chap, i got the feeling the WSJ managed to accommodate things nicely to give us an impressive chapter before making us wait two weeks again, so I'd say we will see more or less where stuff is going after Bege's plan fails, or Pudding gets setup to reveal some nasty and massive memory-modification, either way, since BM will be going nuts on everyone, an alliance to stop her, could be the most unexpected one, with pretty much everyone present trying to do something about it or run.
                                      the Tamatebako is now.. just there…

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • Jabra
                                        Jabra @Kaido King of the Beasts
                                        @Kaido King of the Beasts last edited by
                                        Jabra
                                        spiral
                                        Jabra
                                        spiral

                                        @Kaido:

                                        I really don't understand why Sanji dodging a jellybean is being seen as so significant. Yes, it came against a guy like Katakuri, but we know where Katakuri went wrong

                                        It really isn't considering that Sanji had a briefing from Bege beforehand. He knew exactly what to expect and what to look out for, unlike Katakuri. In a battle of CoO this is obviously a huge advantage.

                                        Would be cool if they continue the CoO skirmish for the next couple chaos chapters. No need for a direct confrontation, just those two messing each other up when it comes to predicting the course of the wedding.

                                        K. Kira XXIII 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • Kaizoku_Ou
                                          Kaizoku_Ou @carcanclaw
                                          @carcanclaw last edited by
                                          Kaizoku_Ou
                                          spiral
                                          Kaizoku_Ou
                                          spiral

                                          @carcanclaw:

                                          Miss Valentines Day got oneshotted with zero aftermath, Miss Doublefinger and Kalifa fought Nami, who isn't a physical fighter (they get a little scuffed-up looking when she defeats them, they aren't outright beaten), and Monet was spared by Zoro for being a woman in one of the most infamously controversial fights of the series.

                                          I think the expectation, upon seeing Luffy declare that he would kick Pudding's ass, was a punch to the face similar to what every other arc antagonist gets (or what Sir Charloss got for shooting Hachi). Oda seriously can't show women getting into a physical fight, the kind the guys get into constantly, where they end up looking really fucked up and unattractive by the end.

                                          Yep, pretty girls in OP don't get their face caved in!

                                          !
                                          ! http://www.mangapanda.com/one-piece/680/16

                                          Zoro vs. Caesar

                                          Don Noflamingo vs. Robowarden

                                          Luffy vs Akainu (fan made manga)

                                          The Birth of Frank aka FFotSDMDBeB: First fist of the Sea, DonMarimo DoBuggino exploring Bonesbeard.

                                          Count Mario HeartOfDarkness 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • Count Mario
                                            Count Mario @Kaizoku_Ou
                                            @Kaizoku_Ou last edited by
                                            Count Mario
                                            spiral
                                            Count Mario
                                            spiral

                                            @Kaizoku_Ou:

                                            Yep, pretty girls in OP don't get their face caved in!

                                            ! http://i8.mangapanda.com/one-piece/680/one-piece-3571909.jpg
                                            ! http://www.mangapanda.com/one-piece/680/16

                                            That still wasn't a full-on fight. That was pretty much exactly what Claw meant by Oda having women get beaten without ever wanting them to have to physically struggle to win or at least decently push a male opponent. If anything, Oda seems to like saving moments where "beautiful" women get hit on panel for when he wants a bad guy to look ultra despicable, as if they have no moral limits. Like when Spandam kept beating up Robin, or when Niji pulverized Cosette off-panel. It's that, or they get defeated one hit (like with Luffy and Vivi/Miss Valentine's Day) without any real vivid injuries shown or through psychological means (Sugar and Perona. Although the former is a kid physically).

                                            Spoiler:

                                            "Life's not about finding out which card is yours, but finding out which cards you're not."

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                            • HeartOfDarkness
                                              HeartOfDarkness @Kaizoku_Ou
                                              @Kaizoku_Ou last edited by
                                              HeartOfDarkness
                                              spiral
                                              HeartOfDarkness
                                              spiral

                                              @Kaizoku_Ou:

                                              Yep, pretty girls in OP don't get their face caved in!

                                              ! http://i8.mangapanda.com/one-piece/680/one-piece-3571909.jpg
                                              ! http://www.mangapanda.com/one-piece/680/16

                                              !

                                              I mean shit i don't even like that topic, but still know that Oda doesn't like a pretty-face to get rough.

                                              –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                                              @Md-Martin:

                                              Sigh…..

                                              I don't care about this conversation to start bringing up my argument nor i find Pudding to be all that worth it so yea you "win", i guess.

                                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                              • Screwtape
                                                Screwtape @Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                @Kaido King of the Beasts last edited by
                                                Screwtape
                                                spiral
                                                Screwtape
                                                spiral

                                                @Kaido:

                                                So once Big Mom and her crew gets taken down by a dainty little last-second alliance like you two are describing, are you ready to root for the gripping struggles of a massive army that's still being built as they fight against another Yonko?

                                                Beating Mom now is growth to prepare for Kaido.

                                                Kaido King of the Beasts 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                • K. Kira XXIII
                                                  K. Kira XXIII @Jabra
                                                  @Jabra last edited by
                                                  K. Kira XXIII
                                                  spiral
                                                  K. Kira XXIII
                                                  spiral

                                                  @Jabra:

                                                  It really isn't considering that Sanji had a briefing from Bege beforehand. He knew exactly what to expect and what to look out for, unlike Katakuri. In a battle of CoO this is obviously a huge advantage.

                                                  Would be cool if they continue the CoO skirmish for the next couple chaos chapters. No need for a direct confrontation, just those two messing each other up when it comes to predicting the course of the wedding.

                                                  Sanji didn't know of Katakuri, at least he wasn't told on panel. Was that the briefing you were talking?

                                                  Hidden:

                                                  Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                  Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                  Hidden:

                                                  Jabra 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                  • Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                    Kaido King of the Beasts @Screwtape
                                                    @Screwtape last edited by
                                                    Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                    spiral
                                                    Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                    spiral

                                                    @Screwtape:

                                                    Beating Mom now is growth to prepare for Kaido.

                                                    So you think Big Mom is a stepping stone to Kaido, even though she holds just as much power and influence as he does?

                                                    Spoiler:

                                                    C Screwtape 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                    • K. Kira XXIII
                                                      K. Kira XXIII
                                                      last edited by
                                                      K. Kira XXIII
                                                      spiral
                                                      K. Kira XXIII
                                                      spiral

                                                      It doesn't help Big Mom that she was squeezed in before Kaido. i don't think we will have a full SH vs BM pirates. I am not advocating her defeat by Luffy's hand because he isn't focused on that but there is no way we will see Big Mom as an antagonist again. Also we are seeing her at her strongest, her tea parties are feared everywhere. So the SH escaping, messing her plans, not to mention they have already taken down one commander. As far as reputation goes, Big Mom will get hit the hardest. Some might even think she has lost her touch, and like when Whitebeard died and many pirates started grabbing his territory, Big Mom might have to deal with the same.

                                                      Hidden:

                                                      Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                      Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                      Hidden:

                                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                      • C
                                                        cloudrivera @Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                        @Kaido King of the Beasts last edited by
                                                        C
                                                        spiral
                                                        cloudrivera
                                                        spiral

                                                        @Kaido:

                                                        So you think Big Mom is a stepping stone to Kaido, even though she holds just as much power and influence as he does?

                                                        Why are we assuming each Yonkou has the same power as the next? Just like the Warlords, they come in all shapes and sizes (literally lol).

                                                        Wasn't it stated (By Law?) that the hardest thing about fighting a Yonkou was actually reaching them? Well…...they're right in front of her lol.

                                                        I don't see all of her allies here (only guests). Meanwhile, it seems like to even get a glimpse of Kaido they would have to go through an army of smile users, enemies in Wano, etc.

                                                        Now I don't think she'll be defeated here ( I still think her and Luffy will ally to take on Kaido) but I wouldn't be shocked if she was. Oda did introduce Gear 2 and 3 around the same time. I don't think Gear 5 is far away lol. Just my 2 cents

                                                        Count Mario 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                        • K. Kira XXIII
                                                          K. Kira XXIII
                                                          last edited by
                                                          K. Kira XXIII
                                                          spiral
                                                          K. Kira XXIII
                                                          spiral

                                                          If any sort of truce is made by Luffy and Big Mom, it will be easily dissolved with the bomb.

                                                          Hidden:

                                                          Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                          Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                          Hidden:

                                                          C 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                          • C
                                                            cloudrivera @K. Kira XXIII
                                                            @K. Kira XXIII last edited by
                                                            C
                                                            spiral
                                                            cloudrivera
                                                            spiral

                                                            @Tamiel:

                                                            If any sort of truce is made by Luffy and Big Mom, it will be easily dissolved with the bomb.

                                                            She'll be ok. Bombs don't kill people in One Piece lol

                                                            K. Kira XXIII 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                            • K. Kira XXIII
                                                              K. Kira XXIII @cloudrivera
                                                              @cloudrivera last edited by
                                                              K. Kira XXIII
                                                              spiral
                                                              K. Kira XXIII
                                                              spiral

                                                              @cloudrivera:

                                                              She'll be ok. Bombs don't kill people in One Piece lol

                                                              Of course, but she might be a bit upset.

                                                              I wonder if Pudding will go with the SH like Ceasar did, but never joining, maybe looking for her father/people.

                                                              Hidden:

                                                              Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                              Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                              Hidden:

                                                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                              • Count Mario
                                                                Count Mario @cloudrivera
                                                                @cloudrivera last edited by
                                                                Count Mario
                                                                spiral
                                                                Count Mario
                                                                spiral

                                                                @cloudrivera:

                                                                Why are we assuming each Yonkou has the same power as the next? Just like the Warlords, they come in all shapes and sizes (literally lol).

                                                                The thing is that all of the Yonko have been in a stalemate for years. They don't have to be EXACTLY equal in power, but the margin shouldn't be as big as it was for the Warlords (who simply consist of any convenient decently strong pirate who impresses the World Government, seeing as how Teach thought he could make it in by just handing in a 100-300 Million bounty like Luffy's before meeting Ace again). And the fall of one Yonko, unlike the Warlords, leads to a huge power vacuum in territories and factions. The impact of defeating Kaido loses plenty of its hype if we already see this sort of effect happen with Big Mom beforehand. This is a game change that shuffles the board and leads to utter anarchy. When it happened with Whitebeard, we got a timeskip to off panel most of it so it could be a fresh new start we gradual get used to in the New World.

                                                                And it doesn't make sense for Luffy to just invent Gear 5 out of nowhere. 4 made sense because we could assume we didn't see everything he learned during the timeskip, and Oda can't get away with pulling that card twice. And with Gear Second and Gear Third, we at least had that tidbit from Luffy on the Sea Train right before Enies Lobby about wanting to test out a new technique he's been working on off-panel.

                                                                It doesn't really make any narrative sense to have Big Mom fall right now. The minute Big Mom goes down, Kaido loses his image of looking so invincible and intimidating regardless of if he's stronger than Big Mom because she should be around his level. The trials the Straw Hats have met in this arc have been great in terms of showing how intimidating a Yonko in their home turf can be. That needs to be maintained if Oda wants to stick to his usual status-quo of Luffy looking like a suspenseful underdog. That, and it's just really weird to imagine the tone of a scene where where the Straw Hats reunite in Wano Country and Luffy breaks the news that an espionage and retrieval mission with half the crew ended with a Yonko getting taken down while Kaido demands a whole war with other Supernovas and Yonko allies present on Luffy's side lol.

                                                                Spoiler:

                                                                "Life's not about finding out which card is yours, but finding out which cards you're not."

                                                                K. Kira XXIII C 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                • Jabra
                                                                  Jabra @K. Kira XXIII
                                                                  @K. Kira XXIII last edited by
                                                                  Jabra
                                                                  spiral
                                                                  Jabra
                                                                  spiral

                                                                  @Tamiel:

                                                                  Sanji didn't know of Katakuri, at least he wasn't told on panel. Was that the briefing you were talking?

                                                                  Bege is the straight man of the group, the one with the plan, the one who tells the others how difficult the execution will be.
                                                                  Bege and the others discussed the details of the plan offpanel, especially the juicy part we're witnessing now.
                                                                  Bege considers Katakuri the biggest danger to the plan due to his CoO.

                                                                  I think we can safely assume that he told them about Katakuri and why he's an issue.

                                                                  K. Kira XXIII 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                  • Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                                    Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                                    last edited by
                                                                    Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                                    spiral
                                                                    Kaido King of the Beasts
                                                                    spiral

                                                                    Plus we know that Kaido is an opportunist who was ballsy enough to go after Whitebeard when he had just the slightest sliver of vulnerability. If Big Mom were weaker than him, he would have destroyed her.

                                                                    Spoiler:

                                                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                    • K. Kira XXIII
                                                                      K. Kira XXIII @Count Mario
                                                                      @Count Mario last edited by
                                                                      K. Kira XXIII
                                                                      spiral
                                                                      K. Kira XXIII
                                                                      spiral

                                                                      @Count:

                                                                      And it doesn't make sense for Luffy to just invent Gear 5 out of nowhere. 4 made sense because we could assume we didn't see everything he learned during the timeskip, and Oda can't get away with pulling that card twice. And with Gear Second and Gear Third, we at least had that tidbit from Luffy on the Sea Train right before Enies Lobby about wanting to test out a new technique he's been working on off-panel.

                                                                      It doesn't really make any narrative sense to have Big Mom fall right now. The minute Big Mom goes down, Kaido loses his image of looking so invincible and intimidating regardless of if he's stronger than Big Mom because she should be around his level. The trials the Straw Hats have met in this arc have been great in terms of showing how intimidating a Yonko in their home turf can be. That needs to be maintained if Oda wants to stick to his usual status-quo of Luffy looking like a suspenseful underdog. That, and it's just really weird to imagine the tone of a scene where where the Straw Hats reunite in Wano Country and Luffy breaks the news that an espionage and retrieval mission with half the crew ended with a Yonko getting taken down while Kaido demands a whole war with other Supernovas and Yonko allies present on Luffy's side lol.

                                                                      Well, the flashback with Rayleigh showed Luffy had developed King Kong Gun when Ray was around. Considering he was 6 months alone, he should have something even greater than King Kong Gun, but if the drawback for Gear third was bad for him, and Gear 4th exhausts him that much, then this new gear, when shown might be a 1 time thing. Anyways…

                                                                      Don't you think that Luffy and Big Mom becoming neutral/buddies doesn't affect the emperor's intimidating image? I think both scenarios are as bad. On the other hand if they just escape, and do it barely, then we all can be "holy shit! Can they even stand up against Kaido"?

                                                                      Hidden:

                                                                      Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                                      Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                                      Hidden:

                                                                      Count Mario 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                      • C
                                                                        cloudrivera @Count Mario
                                                                        @Count Mario last edited by
                                                                        C
                                                                        spiral
                                                                        cloudrivera
                                                                        spiral

                                                                        @Count:

                                                                        The thing is that all of the Yonko have been in a stalemate for years. They don't have to be EXACTLY equal in power, but the margin shouldn't be as big as it was for the Warlords (who simply consist of any convenient decently strong pirate who impresses the World Government, seeing as how Teach thought he could make it in by just handing in a 100-300 Million bounty like Luffy's before meeting Ace again). And the fall of one Yonko, unlike the Warlords, leads to a huge power vacuum in territories and factions. The impact of defeating Kaido loses plenty of its hype if we already see this sort of effect happen with Big Mom beforehand. This is a game change that shuffles the board and leads to utter anarchy. When it happened with Whitebeard, we got a timeskip to off panel most of it so it could be a fresh new start we gradual get used to in the New World.

                                                                        And it doesn't make sense for Luffy to just invent Gear 5 out of nowhere. 4 made sense because we could assume we didn't see everything he learned during the timeskip, and Oda can't get away with pulling that card twice. And with Gear Second and Gear Third, we at least had that tidbit from Luffy on the Sea Train right before Enies Lobby about wanting to test out a new technique he's been working on off-panel.

                                                                        It doesn't really make any narrative sense to have Big Mom fall right now. The minute Big Mom goes down, Kaido loses his image of looking so invincible and intimidating regardless of if he's stronger than Big Mom because she should be around his level. The trials the Straw Hats have met in this arc have been great in terms of showing how intimidating a Yonko in their home turf can be. That needs to be maintained if Oda wants to stick to his usual status-quo of Luffy looking like a suspenseful underdog. That, and it's just really weird to imagine the tone of a scene where where the Straw Hats reunite in Wano Country and Luffy breaks the news that an espionage and retrieval mission with half the crew ended with a Yonko getting taken down while Kaido demands a whole war with other Supernovas and Yonko allies present on Luffy's side lol.

                                                                        I feel you. But the same thing can be said after kaido is defeated as well. How tough will Big Mom look after Kaido is defeated? After Crocodile was beaten, did it make the other Warlords seem weak?

                                                                        Also, if Gear 4 was invented after Raileigh left Luffy alone I wouldn't say anything. But it wasn't. I'm sure Luffy has more tricks up his sleeve. Plus, there's always awakening.

                                                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                        • K. Kira XXIII
                                                                          K. Kira XXIII @Jabra
                                                                          @Jabra last edited by
                                                                          K. Kira XXIII
                                                                          spiral
                                                                          K. Kira XXIII
                                                                          spiral

                                                                          @Jabra:

                                                                          Bege is the straight man of the group, the one with the plan, the one who tells the others how difficult the execution will be.
                                                                          Bege and the others discussed the details of the plan offpanel, especially the juicy part we're witnessing now.
                                                                          Bege considers Katakuri the biggest danger to the plan due to his CoO.

                                                                          I think we can safely assume that he told them about Katakuri and why he's an issue.

                                                                          Eh the details of the plan were discussed on panel, but I guess you meant the other details. Because when they all talked, they said: we got to go, it's about time..

                                                                          [hide][/hide]

                                                                          Don't get me wrong, I am the first to advocate: "oda doesn't have to spell everything out for us", just wondering if it was from that.

                                                                          Hidden:

                                                                          Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                                          Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                                          Hidden:

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                          • Count Mario
                                                                            Count Mario @K. Kira XXIII
                                                                            @K. Kira XXIII last edited by
                                                                            Count Mario
                                                                            spiral
                                                                            Count Mario
                                                                            spiral

                                                                            @Tamiel:

                                                                            Well, the flashback with Rayleigh showed Luffy had developed King Kong Gun when Ray was around. Considering he was 6 months alone, he should have something even greater than King Kong Gun, but if the drawback for Gear third was bad for him, and Gear 4th exhausts him that much, then this new gear, when shown might be a 1 time thing. Anyways…

                                                                            If he couldn't get rid of Gear Fourth's recharge limit in six months, I can't really see why he should have learned some other secret power aside from Gear Fourth. The whole point of learning Gear Fourth was to make up for the limits of Gear Second and Gear Third. Having the time and state of mind to build a contingency for his contingency is way too needless complicated and convenient.

                                                                            Don't you think that Luffy and Big Mom becoming neutral/buddies doesn't affect the emperor's intimidating image? I think both scenarios are as bad. On the other hand if they just escape, and do it barely, then we all can be "holy shit! Can they even stand up against Kaido"?

                                                                            Not really, considering that Big Mom's whole image is based off of making deals with people and both Whitebeard and Shanks being cool people. Now if this was about Kaido, the guy who's built up as the unyielding suicidal savage ends up on neutral terms with Luffy, then I would think it would be bad. Ending up on decent terms of a truce is still a credit to both sides. The resolve of the Straw Hats and how they were technically able to get a defeat out of Big Mom without overpowering her physically through their wits and bonds. An escape can do the trick, but there are entanglements like Fishman Island's fate and Zeff's safety that have to be dealt with before the Straw Hats leave or else they'll just end up looking selfishly idiotic. Not that they have a choice, it's just how the story will make them look since they have no realistic way to save either unless they end on good terms with Linlin.

                                                                            @cloudrivera:

                                                                            I feel you. But the same thing can be said after kaido is defeated as well. How tough will Big Mom look after Kaido is defeated? After Crocodile was beaten, did it make the other Warlords seem weak?

                                                                            That's exactly why I don't think Luffy will really ever beat Big Mom. This arc will leave her weak enough afterwards for a third-party like the Marines or Blackbeard Pirates to come in and usurp her power. That way, Big Mom does not become a future dehyped arc antagonist and the Marines or Blackbeard get more hype for the series' endgame. I doubt it's possible to get an antagonist portrayal on, say, Elbaf as intimidating and complex as it has been on her home turf in this arc.

                                                                            The Warlords are a bit tricky. Because before Moria, the second Warlord Luffy would defeat, came into the picture, we learned about the existence of the Yonko. So we already knew that the Warlords weren't all too godly. And then there is Mihawk, who showed up in the Baratie looking invincible is the epitome of Zoro's dream. So the Warlords didn't really look like they became weak. And Doflamingo got built up for years, so he didn't just have Warlord hype, but hype as a character in general.

                                                                            Also, if Gear 4 was invented after Raileigh left Luffy alone I wouldn't say anything. But it wasn't. I'm sure Luffy has more tricks up his sleeve. Plus, there's always awakening.

                                                                            I wouldn't say anything either. But there's so only so many times that Oda can get away with saying "Hey, this character has a cool new trick from the timeskip I conveniently didn't show yet" before it gets old. Maybe Gear Fourth has other forms like Tankman, but anymore than that would feel cheap. Because then Oda can technically write any convenient power-up he wants without trying just because the timeskip wasn't on-panel. Even though we've already seen Luffy pushed to his breaking point against Doflamingo and Cracker+Sanji+Enraged Army. Zoro and other crewmates can maybe get away with new power ups from the timeskip because we haven't really seen them go all-out like Luffy has.

                                                                            Luffy is bound to learn Awakening. It just probably shouldn't be this early when we've already seen him been driven to the max and get defeated. I can see him learning it as a power-up against Kaido in the next arc though.

                                                                            Spoiler:

                                                                            "Life's not about finding out which card is yours, but finding out which cards you're not."

                                                                            K. Kira XXIII 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                            • M
                                                                              Megaman
                                                                              last edited by
                                                                              M
                                                                              spiral
                                                                              Megaman
                                                                              spiral

                                                                              Honestly after they destroyed the wedding cake, destroyed mother caramels photo, tried to kill and poison big mom, then blow up the treasure in her face, I just can't see her agreeing to ally with or sparing their lives or Zeffs willingly. I think the only way out is to take pudding as a "hostage". Of course they won't hurt her and with pudding getting redeemed she would agree to it but it should work as a bluff. Big mom won't risk something as valuable as the third eye ability for her own revenge.

                                                                              G 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                              • K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                K. Kira XXIII @Count Mario
                                                                                @Count Mario last edited by
                                                                                K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                spiral
                                                                                K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                spiral

                                                                                @Count:

                                                                                If he couldn't get rid of Gear Fourth's recharge limit in six months, I can't really see why he should have learned some other secret power aside from Gear Fourth. The whole point of learning Gear Fourth was to make up for the limits of Gear Second and Gear Third. Having the time and state of mind to build a contingency for his contingency is way too needless complicated and convenient.

                                                                                It is not about a contigency of a contigency. I agree with you to some extent. Luffy probably took the 6 months and made his Gear Fourth limit to what it is now, I imagine him using it for the first time and only lasting a minute or so. At least to believe credible challenge and growth. And within those 6 months, he might have developed Tankman and other variations for gear fourth. However, as powerful as the transformation is, I think it was barely enough to make him a contender in the New World, maybe among the top ones.

                                                                                I am talking about something he discovered during the breaking of this limit, maybe something that happened once and he has absolutely no control over. Something that might need awakening to be complete. Anyways, the flashback with Rayleigh could just be a prelude to the different versions like Tankman. Which is why I stand by this ~new techinique~ a bit less. However, I have already seen Luffy be humbled and telling his crew to escape. I don't see how someone whom went through that, would go against an admiral knowing the technique he used to barely defeat Doffy is not enough(considering he also mentioned the emperor's when he talked about not running away anymore.) I say it like that because I know that Doffy never stood a chance, but that is a conversation for another day.

                                                                                Luffy is bound to learn Awakening. It just probably shouldn't be this early when we've already seen him been driven to the max and get defeated. I can see him learning it as a power-up against Kaido in the next arc though.

                                                                                Well considering how powerful the devil fruit users are in this arc. I wouldn't be surprised if he doesn't get at least a clue in on how to learn awakening. I think awakening by Kaido is a given almost~

                                                                                Not really, considering that Big Mom's whole image is based off of making deals with people and both Whitebeard and Shanks being cool people. Now if this was about Kaido, the guy who's built up as the unyielding suicidal savage ends up on neutral terms with Luffy, then I would think it would be bad. Ending up on decent terms of a truce is still a credit to both sides. The resolve of the Straw Hats and how they were technically able to get a defeat out of Big Mom without overpowering her physically through their wits and bonds. An escape can do the trick, but there are entanglements like Fishman Island's fate and Zeff's safety that have to be dealt with before the Straw Hats leave or else they'll just end up looking selfishly idiotic. Not that they have a choice, it's just how the story will make them look since they have no realistic way to save either unless they end on good terms with Linlin.

                                                                                This is in part why I cannot fully commit to an alliance with Big Mom, or her being ~good all along~. Before Whitebeard died, the four emperors were at a stalemate, but also the world in a way. Thanks to Whitebeard whom never seeked glory the seas were balanced. If we had 3 ~honorable~ great pirates: Big Mom, Shanks and Whitebeard, then it just takes out the threat level a bit. On the other hand if it was only Shanks and Whitebeard and when the latter died and Blackbeard came in: then it makes sense that everything is so chaotic now. We have three ~bad~ emperors and only one ~good~ to balance things out. No wonder the marines moved their HQ, things are at their worst(as of now).

                                                                                So, I agree, Big Mom is all about deals, however ONLY IF she has the most to gain about it. We have been constantly been hinted that everytime she got screwed out of one, it was the worst for her. Roger becoming king and then the alliance with Elbaf. As much as a truce with Luffy could work, we obviously know that Luffy got the Glyphs and his cook back. But then what will Mama ask in return? Part of the reason why the Strawhats ~could~ save her is all because the Strawhats are messing everything up. So them saving Linlin, her family and her territory would be because they caused her to do it in the first place. So those events cancel out, what could Luffy offer Linlin that she would accept to let them go and what would she ask in return. That is the type of truce I imagine between them, and to keep the omnious presence Big Mom has. At least that is how I imagine if that route is explored.

                                                                                On the other hand, if they escape and end up weakening Big Mom's forces further, that could be enough for her to not be able to commit any troops to Fishman Island and the Baratie, because other players would start attacking her.

                                                                                Hidden:

                                                                                Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                                                Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                                                Hidden:

                                                                                Count Mario 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                • Count Mario
                                                                                  Count Mario @K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                  @K. Kira XXIII last edited by
                                                                                  Count Mario
                                                                                  spiral
                                                                                  Count Mario
                                                                                  spiral

                                                                                  @Tamiel:

                                                                                  It is not about a contigency of a contigency. I agree with you to some extent. Luffy probably took the 6 months and made his Gear Fourth limit to what it is now, I imagine him using it for the first time and only lasting a minute or so. At least to believe credible challenge and growth. And within those 6 months, he might have developed Tankman and other variations for gear fourth. However, as powerful as the transformation is, I think it was barely enough to make him a contender in the New World, maybe among the top ones.

                                                                                  I am talking about something he discovered during the breaking of this limit, maybe something that happened once and he has absolutely no control over. Something that might need awakening to be complete. Anyways, the flashback with Rayleigh could just be a prelude to the different versions like Tankman. Which is why I stand by this ~new techinique~ a bit less. However, I have already seen Luffy be humbled and telling his crew to escape. I don't see how someone whom went through that, would go against an admiral knowing the technique he used to barely defeat Doffy is not enough(considering he also mentioned the emperor's when he talked about not running away anymore.) I say it like that because I know that Doffy never stood a chance, but that is a conversation for another day.

                                                                                  Meh. That's still oddly convenient and out of nowhere, even if it isn't an ability he's mastered. That's pretty much what The Voice of All Things is for Luffy right now anyways in terms of being an ability he has no control of at the moment.

                                                                                  And that's the thing. Luffy is stupidly stubborn. He's been like this throughout the entire series. Look at how Luffy has been provoking Big Mom this arc even though he couldn't even beat Cracker without Nami's help (and let's not get into a redundant debate as to whether Luffy could defeat Cracker on his own or not, we should stick by the facts that as far as we know, Nami was a huge essential asset). He's prideful, instinctive, stubborn, and plain dumb. It's just who he is. His first impression made right before entering he New World was declaring war with a Yonko. He's not going to stand running anymore because the timeskip was meant to help everyone catchup and not get effortlessly curbstomped. It's not enough to guarantee them winning battles at all, but it's meant to at least give them a fighting chance. And in Luffy's primitive mind, that's more than enough to rely on. When things become as dire as Sabaody, he might be humble enough to recognize that everybody needs to run away. But for now, it won't happen. Because Luffy actually has a chance. Just a small indefinite chance. But it's more than enough for someone like him. Luffy's the type of guy to keep on trying to surpass himself rather than accept his limitations.

                                                                                  And Zoro wanted to fight Fujitora too. As an inferior crewmate to his captain that got attacked by Fujitora and couldn't break the Birdcage (although Fujitora couldn't either, but the guy does not know when to accept his limits due to all of the nonsense he spouted about cutting it and pulling weight), he's even more of an idiot and goes to show how he and Luffy just have an ignorant meathead perspective on battling if it isn't a completely one-sided match.

                                                                                  Well considering how powerful the devil fruit users are in this arc. I wouldn't be surprised if he doesn't get at least a clue in on how to learn awakening. I think awakening by Kaido is a given almost~

                                                                                  That's very much possible. I wouldn't mind it. It would be better to build that up soon rather than in the middle of Wano Country, where Luffy will probably decently master in time for defeating Kaido.

                                                                                  This is in part why I cannot fully commit to an alliance with Big Mom, or her being ~good all along~. Before Whitebeard died, the four emperors were at a stalemate, but also the world in a way. Thanks to Whitebeard whom never seeked glory the seas were balanced. If we had 3 ~honorable~ great pirates: Big Mom, Shanks and Whitebeard, then it just takes out the threat level a bit. On the other hand if it was only Shanks and Whitebeard and when the latter died and Blackbeard came in: then it makes sense that everything is so chaotic now. We have three ~bad~ emperors and only one ~good~ to balance things out. No wonder the marines moved their HQ, things are at their worst(as of now).

                                                                                  So, I agree, Big Mom is all about deals, however ONLY IF she has the most to gain about it. We have been constantly been hinted that everytime she got screwed out of one, it was the worst for her. Roger becoming king and then the alliance with Elbaf. As much as a truce with Luffy could work, we obviously know that Luffy got the Glyphs and his cook back. But then what will Mama ask in return? Part of the reason why the Strawhats ~could~ save her is all because the Strawhats are messing everything up. So them saving Linlin, her family and her territory would be because they caused her to do it in the first place. So those events cancel out, what could Luffy offer Linlin that she would accept to let them go and what would she ask in return. That is the type of truce I imagine between them, and to keep the omnious presence Big Mom has. At least that is how I imagine if that route is explored.

                                                                                  On the other hand, if they escape and end up weakening Big Mom's forces further, that could be enough for her to not be able to commit any troops to Fishman Island and the Baratie, because other players would start attacking her.

                                                                                  But Whitebeard is no longer relevant in the story, and he's not an easy guy to make a deal with given how he talked to Shanks. He's not a bad guy, but not entirely a good guy either. And Big Mom has all sorts of shady stuff and backstabbing going on with her modus operandi. At this point, she does not have to be a "good" Emperor. Just a bad/neutral one where Luffy, in a typical pirate fashion, makes a compromise with due to lacking options. Just like the alliances he made with Bege and Crocodile.

                                                                                  Big Mom doesn't know they stole the Poneglyphs, and she doesn't care about Sanji in and of himself. Just the clone technology. Jimbei may complicate things a bit, as well as how much blame she may place on the Straw Hats for ruining the wedding before stuff goes to hell and they have to save the day. And she does not need to be the one with the most to gain. That can easily be the Straw Hats in a deal where Big Mom is forced to make a compromise in order to not lose more of her resources after all of this chaos. And Pudding is a wild card in general that is probably the key to all of this, whether she's manipulated Linlin's memories or will do so at the end of the arc to save the Straw Hats or whatever. It's all a bit hazy, but it's pretty doable.

                                                                                  That's doubtful, considering how she sends out random mooks in her crew to destroy entire islands. Look at Bobbin and his bounty. It's not like she would have to give up a Sweet Commander. The Baratie is mad weak. And that would be a pretty lazy and convenient solution to all of the questions this arc, Big Mom not going anything without any of the tension being resolved at all even though the Straw Hats pissed her off as much as possible. We need some payoff here.

                                                                                  Spoiler:

                                                                                  "Life's not about finding out which card is yours, but finding out which cards you're not."

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                  • K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                    K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                    last edited by
                                                                                    K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                    spiral
                                                                                    K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                    spiral

                                                                                    I mean it is doors away, so let's just sit back and see it resolve. At this point if anything is going down it is at least Big Mom's forces and to what extent and how much does it paralyze her we will find out soon enough. Can she afford to send anyone or not? Baratie is a ship, they would still have to chase them. Fishman Island might be a bit more difficult to handle because if the Fishmen prepare themselves, they can focus on breaking the coating, they are at their strongest underwater. Considering Aladdin went ahead to warn them.

                                                                                    And with respect to Luffy. Until we see how connected the Voice of All things and haki are connected, then that is just part of his haki he cannot control.

                                                                                    It's entirely possible and enough for the four gears and awakening to be the repertoire we see here with Big Mom and with Kaido. Or ever, if you prefer(I also do not wish to ponder in trivial debates) I mean the first part of your response we agree that gear four has given him a fighting chance. You just call it very small, jajaja. What I am saying is that from what we have seen, Luffy's performance is what I would expect from his training[Gear Fourth and King Kong Gun]. However, with the introduction of awakening and that gear fourth has transformation, then the potential it has is more than enough given Luffy's arsenal. With that being said, I think there is at least 1 more transformation in gear fourth: Boundman, Tankman, X? (which might be this extra I am talking about). I just kept calling a new gear I think, when it could just be another transformation to gear fourth, how many did you think it had before tank man? And now?

                                                                                    Not sure where the Zoro thing came from, but I for sure would have loved to see that struggle.

                                                                                    Hidden:

                                                                                    Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                                                    Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                                                    Hidden:

                                                                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                    • Count Mario
                                                                                      Count Mario
                                                                                      last edited by
                                                                                      Count Mario
                                                                                      spiral
                                                                                      Count Mario
                                                                                      spiral

                                                                                      Until we see how connected the Voice of All things and haki are connected, then that is just part of his haki he cannot control.

                                                                                      Um, don't you mean that until we see that they're connected, we should assume that it's an ability OTHER than Haki? I won't deny that they could be linked, but your Occam's razor logic seems a bit off.

                                                                                      And I mentioned Zoro because he is evidence of how Oda likes to write meathead characters, like Luffy, that pick fights even though they should know they have little chance of winning. Zoro isn't as strong as Luffy and still wants to fight Fujitora.

                                                                                      Spoiler:

                                                                                      "Life's not about finding out which card is yours, but finding out which cards you're not."

                                                                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                      • K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                        K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                        last edited by
                                                                                        K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                        spiral
                                                                                        K. Kira XXIII
                                                                                        spiral

                                                                                        I meant for my statement to also include the possibility of not at all.

                                                                                        Hidden:

                                                                                        Originally Posted by Tamiel

                                                                                        Try out my first game! All feedback is welcome, enjoy and thanks. Heroine: Kiku

                                                                                        Hidden:

                                                                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                        • G
                                                                                          GoustiFruit @Megaman
                                                                                          @Megaman last edited by
                                                                                          G
                                                                                          spiral
                                                                                          GoustiFruit
                                                                                          spiral

                                                                                          @Megaman:

                                                                                          Honestly after they destroyed the wedding cake, destroyed mother caramels photo, tried to kill and poison big mom, then blow up the treasure in her face, I just can't see her agreeing to ally with or sparing their lives or Zeffs willingly. I think the only way out is to take pudding as a "hostage". Of course they won't hurt her and with pudding getting redeemed she would agree to it but it should work as a bluff. Big mom won't risk something as valuable as the third eye ability for her own revenge.

                                                                                          Another way out would be to have Pudding erase Big Mom and her families' memories.

                                                                                          M 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                          • M
                                                                                            Megaman @GoustiFruit
                                                                                            @GoustiFruit last edited by
                                                                                            M
                                                                                            spiral
                                                                                            Megaman
                                                                                            spiral

                                                                                            @GoustiFruit:

                                                                                            Another way out would be to have Pudding erase Big Mom and her families' memories.

                                                                                            I doubt this 1 girl can wipe out the entire yonkou crews memories, specifically big mom, katakuri, and smoothie. How would she even get such an opportunity against them during the chaos? I could see her getting the underworld guests which was probably the original plan.

                                                                                            Then there's the case of how much big mom would forget if pudding actually does change her memory. If she only forgets the events during the wedding, then she just have a wedding the next day as if it never happened yet, which if Sanji doesn't show up then Zeff dies.

                                                                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                            • G
                                                                                              GoustiFruit
                                                                                              last edited by
                                                                                              G
                                                                                              spiral
                                                                                              GoustiFruit
                                                                                              spiral

                                                                                              Pudding can rewrite the memories so she could make Big Mom believe that, for ex., she changed her mind about the SH or the marriage or killing everybody and is now a kind person instead of being evil.
                                                                                              Then AFAWK, Pudding probably already mass-changed the memories of people attending previous marriages. So why not the entire crew.
                                                                                              And then once she manage to change the memories of one person, that person can become an ally and help control the others one after another.

                                                                                              –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                                                                                              BTW, now thinking about it: the picture of BM's "mother", could it be a memory that Pudding created to somehow control BM ?

                                                                                              KageKageKing 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                              • KageKageKing
                                                                                                KageKageKing @GoustiFruit
                                                                                                @GoustiFruit last edited by
                                                                                                KageKageKing
                                                                                                spiral
                                                                                                KageKageKing
                                                                                                spiral

                                                                                                @GoustiFruit:

                                                                                                BTW, now thinking about it: the picture of BM's "mother", could it be a memory that Pudding created to somehow control BM ?

                                                                                                That's not the first time this was brought, actually.

                                                                                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                                • S
                                                                                                  SHpirates @Broccoli
                                                                                                  @Broccoli last edited by
                                                                                                  S
                                                                                                  spiral
                                                                                                  SHpirates
                                                                                                  spiral

                                                                                                  @Broccoli:

                                                                                                  O.K.

                                                                                                  1. Provide * evidence * of why it won't happen before saying it won't as if it was the truth. When you do, I might start caring about what you have to say.
                                                                                                  2. "It doesn't make any sense", Jesus Christ you people just blunder your way through discussions by repeating lines like that. My versus board was well thought-out and it displays that for each big name from Big Mom's crew there's a Firetank Alliance counterpart.
                                                                                                  3. I don't know why you bring up Doflamingo when it has nothing to do with anything.
                                                                                                  4. Well of course they'll need a very big alliance to take over Wano, this situation is VERY different, can't you see that?

                                                                                                  I'll also quote myself once more:

                                                                                                  Read that and tell me that Big Mom's "vastly outnumbers" the Firetank Alliance.

                                                                                                  ??? That's exactly how the fight went! LOL. Cracker just kept throwing biscuits at Luffy and hiding behind them, hoping Luffy would fight them endlessly and die once he ran out of stamina. Which is why Luffy decided to start eating the biscuits untill Cracker ran out of stamina.

                                                                                                  Also Cracker's ability counters Luffy perfectly, since Luffy's a brawler. Katakuri, however, seems to fall in Sanji's cathegory. (Both are CoO specialists)

                                                                                                  Katakori should be at the same level as Marco who could fight evenly with a admiral, are you saying Sanji is there ? I don't think so maybe in 3-4 sagas but for now he could probably take on anyone exept the comanders (maybe Cracker though).

                                                                                                  Furthermore, there was Compot, and the at least 10 ministers you have what 3? the remainders of firetank pirates was 6 or 7… furthermore Smothie would need something like Jimbei+Nami+Brook i would say since Jimbei is around Ace level in combat who was weaker than Vista, Marco and Jozu.

                                                                                                  there might be fight and so on but the last thing I would like to point out is Luffy+Capone against BM, Kaidou finished of 3 entire crews, I think if the plan fail (which it will) they would need Judge, Ichi, Niji, Yonji and maybe more just to get a fighting chance... Unless she is extremely weakened somehow.

                                                                                                  F 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                                  • BellisarioFaith
                                                                                                    BellisarioFaith
                                                                                                    Warlord Mod
                                                                                                    last edited by
                                                                                                    BellisarioFaith
                                                                                                    spiral
                                                                                                    BellisarioFaith
                                                                                                    Warlord Mod
                                                                                                    spiral

                                                                                                    Chapter comparisons, actually relatively early this week. Not too many big differences today.

                                                                                                    • The name of the chapter is "Cerebral."
                                                                                                    • As before, the song rhymes, at least for most of it, in the VIZ version: "There are times when love is tough / and there are times where love is rough / but after all your tests and trials / you'll finally walk down the aisle / come rain or come spears, don't let that hand go!"
                                                                                                    • For some reason, Mangastream had Big Mom call the Head Chef "Streusel." Jaimini's Box and VIZ use the correct name, "Streusen", though Jaimini's misspells it.
                                                                                                    • Reiju's thoughts about the Vinsmokes being surrounded by the Charlotte siblings are a little different in each version. In MS, she notes that their seats are open and easy to hit; Jaimini's has her think that the Charlottes don't seem like easy opponents; and in VIZ, she notes that they (the Vinsmokes) are "in a very convenient spot to be attacked".
                                                                                                    • In the scene with Sanji and Pudding standing at the altar where the priest begins the vows, in both scanlations, the part about "in sickness and in health, for richer, for poorer" appears in the top three speech bubbles; in the official, it appears in the bottom two instead, with the top three saying instead "Do you take this woman to be your lawfully wedded wife, to have and to hold".
                                                                                                    • In the panel after Big Mom thinks to herself that Pudding is too slow, there's a bubble that says, in MS, "My third eye!", as though it's Pudding thinking about it. However, both Jaimini's and VIZ instead say "Three-eyes!", implying that it's actually Pudding remembering someone calling her that.

                                                                                                    Hidden:

                                                                                                    S 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                                    • S
                                                                                                      shadyagent @BellisarioFaith
                                                                                                      @BellisarioFaith last edited by
                                                                                                      S
                                                                                                      spiral
                                                                                                      shadyagent
                                                                                                      spiral

                                                                                                      @BellisarioFaith:

                                                                                                      • For some reason, Mangastream had Big Mom call the Head Chef "Streusel." Jaimini's Box and VIZ use the correct name, "Streusen", though Jaimini's misspells it.

                                                                                                      I didn't read the scans but seeing your post as a german speaker I have to say Streusel (derives from "Streuselkuchen"/Streusel-cake ) would be the correct choice if you want to honor the overall theme (sweets/food) of this arc
                                                                                                      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streuselkuchen

                                                                                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                                                                                      • Shadowgreed
                                                                                                        Shadowgreed @MrBits
                                                                                                        @MrBits last edited by
                                                                                                        Shadowgreed
                                                                                                        spiral
                                                                                                        Shadowgreed
                                                                                                        spiral

                                                                                                        @MrBits:

                                                                                                        You mean "I'm going to be King of the Pirates?" That's different because Luffy's actively working towards that goal in most arcs. Sanji has never made an effort to "make the marines fear him" unless they go after the crew first.

                                                                                                        And besides, do you really thing Oda would give Sanji a higher bounty than Luffy and Zoro?

                                                                                                        That quote is not meant to be taken literally at this point "fear him" but rather it translate to (IMO): I'm going to make your institution work the hardest now because ME (Sanji as the main culprit) and my captain are going to set up the New World in flames!

                                                                                                        Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                                                                                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0

                                                                                                        • 1
                                                                                                        • 2
                                                                                                        • 8
                                                                                                        • 9
                                                                                                        • 10
                                                                                                        • 11
                                                                                                        • 12
                                                                                                        • 10 / 12
                                                                                                        • First post
                                                                                                          Last post
                                                                                                        Powered by NodeBB | Contributors