Pretty much all children that encounter the Strawhats are forkin' annoying. Filler arc or not.
Why is Jonathan on this list? He seemed pretty cool. A different league than the other characters mentioned.
Pretty much all children that encounter the Strawhats are forkin' annoying. Filler arc or not.
Why is Jonathan on this list? He seemed pretty cool. A different league than the other characters mentioned.
I thought Soran was great for the terrible children archetype of the fillers. She really has a difficult life and I felt sorry for her.
I think the worst is Noko. His whole arc made my sleep. Apis is boring too
That bitch from the sand pirates filler in Arabasta. We don't give a shit, we need to go own Crocodile
Phoenix is the worst. He gives bad name to pirates with over 100 millions bounty.
I still can't understand why Jonathan is there and why are people voting for him. He's a great character and even he isn't the others are much worse.
Once again, an old thread is dragged from the ashes. At least this one isn't from 2007.
But yeah, G8 was awesome. The ice one was ok, everything else kinda blew.
Filler characters in G8 were great.
Who was the fat Colonel in the Apis arc? THat character made no sense, and is easily the worst Toei has created.
Nelson.
He was…..realy odd. He never even interacted with his one named commanding officer, and he just seemed to exist in a completely different world. Hell I doubt the cast could even see him from that big a distance, and yet they're yelling at each other. It was quite surreal.
Stil, kickass ship.
Yoko is easily the worst IMO, and Johnathan shouldn't be in this poll.
They're all terrible no offense to the anime.
I wonder, when the next filler rolls around, should I bring this back to life ?
http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=28844
http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=28827
Maybe ask the mods to make it a full out parody of the Tournie and use it at the end ?
They're all terrible no offense to the anime.
Even Jonathan?
The others are pretty bad, I admit (at least those who I actually know. I didn't watch all of the fillers)
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@No:
I wonder, when the next filler rolls around, should I bring this back to life ?
http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=28844
http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=28827
Maybe ask the mods to make it a full out parody of the Tournie and use it at the end ?
We should make a best filler character poll. With Chibin and Yukimura.
Jonathan shouldn't even be on that poll. That said, I guess yoko since that's the only filler arc I've watched besides G-8
@Mr.:
[qimg]http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w272/Mr_Luffy/Nelson-Royale-1.jpg[/qimg]
You're obscuring the awesome ship man :getlost:
Ugggh….I remember that guy. He had bigger tits than Nami.
barf
For some reason, I think that if I watched the filler arcs, Apis would annoy the shit outta me, so I'll vote for her.
Why the hell is Jonathan on this list? G8 was easily the best filler arc and it flowed well between the two arcs. And besides that? Jonathan was flippin AWESOME. You fail. FOREVER.
Aside from Eric, Nelson, and the Accino family characters (Except Lil), I don't have any problems with filler characters.
I would say Carmen or Noko, but I feel like Noko played a bigger role. I mean, he did cause the Straw Hats to forget the memories they had together. o_o It was pretty interesting watching that. I'd have to say Carmen. :/ She was kind of annoying I think.
all mentioned pretty much sucked…... also annoying to me were those pumpkin pirates and foxy and his crew..... that moron moron beam was such a lame idea!!!!
all mentioned pretty much sucked…... also annoying to me were those pumpkin pirates and foxy and his crew..... that moron moron beam was such a lame idea!!!!
Foxy wasn't filler, the arc served to present aokiji but in the anime they extended the davy back fight, added filler and put aokiji in another island.
i'm sorry then, i don't read the manga blush
….. but still hate him!!!!! :P
i dont like Redbeard,because i dont like pirates running wild in the desert
all mentioned pretty much sucked…... also annoying to me were those pumpkin pirates and foxy and his crew..... that moron moron beam was such a lame idea!!!!
You skipped 8 pages and said all mentioned sucked, and then you proceeded to diss Oda, the creator of One Piece. Tsk tsk. :/
~
Question: Is this a thread for filler characters that failed as One Piece characters or filler characters that you hate because of their personality?
~
Personally, I liked the Warship Island Arc.
First, the idea of the bratty kid was still fresh and new. Hello it was the first filler episode ever!
Second, I think people "hate" Apis because her personality has been implemented on a dozen other characters.
Third, Erik, as a villain, was okay. The puns about sicko and okama never get old.
Fourth:
Personally, I hate Nelson.
Professionally, Nelson is okay.
Spiritually, Nelson should banish from the Earth of One Piece.
Lastly, Warship Island was unique before other fillers came.
~
Rainbow Mist Arc had so MUCH potential; the build-up was okay. But Toei HAD to mess up the story towards the end.
It was Apis-wannabes galore!
~
BUT. BY. FAR. ONE. OF. THE. WORST. FILLER. CHARACTERS. IS.
Shitty.
Oh.
I'm mean Zenny.
~
I'm still trying to finish the G8 arc (I watch the Funimation episodes only; Now that's self-explanatory) and Ice Hunter grabbed my attention.
Is it a good arc?
@400MillionBelis:
You skipped 8 pages and said all mentioned sucked, and then you proceeded to diss Oda, the creator of One Piece. Tsk tsk. :/
~
Question: Is this a thread for filler characters that failed as One Piece characters or filler characters that you hate because of their personality?
~
Personally, I liked the Warship Island Arc.
First, the idea of the bratty kid was still fresh and new. Hello it was the first filler episode ever!
Second, I think people "hate" Apis because her personality has been implemented on a dozen other characters.
Third, Erik, as a villain, was okay. The puns about sicko and okama never get old.
Fourth:
Personally, I hate Nelson.
Professionally, Nelson is okay.
Spiritually, Nelson should banish from the Earth of One Piece.
Lastly, Warship Island was unique before other fillers came.
~
Rainbow Mist Arc had so MUCH potential; the build-up was okay. But Toei HAD to mess up the story towards the end.
It was Apis-wannabes galore!
~
BUT. BY. FAR. ONE. OF. THE. WORST. FILLER. CHARACTERS. IS.
Shitty.
Oh.
I'm mean Zenny.
~
I'm still trying to finish the G8 arc (I watch the Funimation episodes only; Now that's self-explanatory) and Ice Hunter grabbed my attention.
Is it a good arc?
First off, my intention was never to "diss" oda or anything, i just expressed my opinion and that's about all there is to say.
I liked the warship island arc aswell and couldn't agree more with your analysis….. anyhow, i think "filler" characters cannot succeed or fail as one piece characters, just because they are filler, so i'm assuming the thread is about personal liking.
i also agree with you about the rainbow mist arc - as i mentioned, the pumpkin pirates are totally annoying.
g8 is one of my favorite arcs, very funny and full of suspense.
zenny is not all bad i guess. it was hilarious when the strawhats thought zoro had killed him. :P besides, that was only 2 or 3 episodes, not worth mentioning.
i still can't explain to myself though, what the ice hunter arc has to do with all this, since the ice hunter arc is like ages after g8 arc.
Eric the whirlwind is terrrible lol
@400MillionBelis:
I'm still trying to finish the G8 arc (I watch the Funimation episodes only; Now that's self-explanatory) and Ice Hunter grabbed my attention.
Is it a good arc?
I would say skip Ice Hunter. There is an annoying girl, an annoying pirate boy and a Nelson doppelgänger with a devil fruit. God I hate this Arc >.< I wouldn´t watch it again, even if Tele5 (german Tv Channel) would show this Arc again, and I LOVE the german dub. I have no problems to rewatch OP 10 times again, but Ice Hunter was a pain in the ass.
if apis counts as a loli she is my favourite character and the second is the other loli from little east blue arc the worst is eric
This thing. I know Oda designed it but still. Hope the movies count as "filler".
I would say skip Ice Hunter. There is an annoying girl, an annoying pirate boy and a Nelson doppelgänger with a devil fruit.
You mad ?
I would Say Apis i don't like the fact that her fruit had virtually no offensive powers or sth like bon clay's..Hearing the voice of all things kinda reminded me Gol D. Roger's reason of reading a poneglyph…But damn luffy could hear the voice of that dragon too... (remind you sth? )....The whole filler thing was 4/10 but hey for first time filler was cool...Ow and for those who tell jonathan was not cool come on the guy was genius...The whole plot was flowing so naturally between the 2 arcs...(i liked many scenes from that filler eps....Especially sanji's,when he went with nami at the waver )
We all know Condoriano is the best filler, along with Jonathan!
How Apis so readily beats Yoko on this I'll never know…
Noko. That dude was the most terrible thing I've ever seen, together with his stupid dream-and-memory-eating Hippocampus.
Noko. That dude was the most terrible thing I've ever seen, together with his stupid dream-and-memory-eating Hippocampus.
You have to admit thought it was kinda funny to see everyone losing their memory.
Hey I liked it.
Jonathan shouldn't be on this list he was awesome! I liked the Marine Base Filler, The cooking, tactics and the sneaking around was pretty cool in my opinion :)
Yoko is by far the worse, Apis wasn't as bad, the part where she tried cooking was pretty funny, Altho she is just a female version of chopper.
@Mr.:
http://i178.photobucket.com/albums/w272/Mr_Luffy/Nelson-Royale-1.jpg
+1 My eyes!!!
Nelson is by far the worst filler character. What were they thinking? I wish I could just forget this, thing, ever existed.
and it's been said already, but for the hundredth time, Jonathan shouldn't be on this list. G-8 was great.
Why is Johnathan even on this list??????? He is better than some canon characters. :getlost: I also really liked Soran from Robin's side story.
Carmen was the worst for me with Apis second. I always skipped those episodes.
I like jonathan, he's great, I dont like that one with the seashorse. I hate it when people lose their memories and all great things they did together.(well except when it is a part of the anime, like eden of the east) I just can't stand that.
Definitely that kid from the Pheonix crew. I got so sick of his crying and whining "Senchou, senchou!" all the time. My god.
I hate:
That girl who talked to animals
The fat marine dude
The Mexican who created nets out of spit
I liked:
The guy who created heat balls
The Marines from G8(Jonathan was even at Marineford in the anime!!)
The master Humandrill from Zoro's training
The sunflower monster from Usopp's training.
they dont have any sense of presence. i cant remember them
I disliked the fat blob and Erik from Apis's filler, the brat with the memory-stealing seahorse (and the seahorse itself), and pretty much the entire Apachino family. The arcs themselves I didn't mind, though…
This is why I don't watch filler arcs.
Apis… THE BEST IS JONATHAN!!!!
Voting for the worst is difficult (and I can't vote since I'm new here), but if we're voting for the best, it would have to be Jonathan and the whole G8 arc. Apis was pretty alright for me actually, being the 1st filler and all. I didn't even know Soran was a filler character until recently, plus she's depicted as a strong-willed child, so she second place on my list.
I dislike filler characters that uses up DF power ideas(G8 was great even without using up any DF ideas), and the whinny kids. I guess some people may have enjoyed the Ice Hunter arc, but I dislike the fact that they have two DF, and how Luffy goes gear second against a weak opponent. Didn't even like the idea of Luffy coming into physical contact with Don Accino, he could've smashed large chunks of ice to knock him out, Gomu Gomu no Jet Ice Block or something along that line.
I guess I did the right thing when I told my friend who's new to One Piece to skip the fillers using the One Piece Wikia story arc page.
Apis sucked.
Johnathan's a boss.
Can't comment on the ones after Enies Lobby, though. I stopped watching when they had that weird 5 episode flashback montage or whatever during it.
The oceam's dream arc was irritating as hell the character design was all shit aswell but if robin went to bed the whole one piece story would have cut short by about 800 episodes
The filler arc of buggy recollecting his body parts it's a stupid arc considering im not the biggest fan of buggy or his crew except alvida but she's not really part of his crew.
From memory since the warship arc was the first filler I didn't mind it at all. I don't know why everyone hates apis but haha she is kind of useless since chopper was introduced but it was a good filler arc as it featured a hint of Luffy's ability to hear the voice of all things like Roger did.
NO DOUBT THE 4 or 5 PERSONAL CHARACTER FILLER ARCS AFTER ALABASTA WERE THE WORST FILLER EPISODES AND ALL THE CHARACTERS
goat island was really kind of boring
the idea of rainbow mist was really interesting but all the characters were gay as hell
G-8 dragged on for a bit but ahhh i guess it was structured well enough to support the landing of merry from skypiea
I HATED THE DAVY BACK FIGHT ARC THAT WAS BORING AND STUPID EXCEPT FOR AFRO LUFFY
also any flashback arc or episodes were stupid
Ice Hunter arc was alright despite some of the really stupid characters
Spa Island was kind of stupid the only good bits was a gif I made of nami's boobs bouncing a lot
Most of the tv specials were stupid