Last Two Nakamates (vol. 5)

Gladiator777

16 chars of Gin got poisoned don't you remember? unless Kreig had an antidote for it Gin would have died within 2 hours if I remember right

In Other Words ?

RPGJay

@KiShiDo:

That's why I said. Each character an join. Unknown members, returning characters and so on. Do we need to speak about them, if they aren't even near or we have some base to discuss about them?

No

You seem to be under the impression that just anyone can join.

Then again, I'm talking to someone who believes Vivi is still counted as a crewmember and the SH crew will only have one more member. So, why am I bothering with you?

@Ryuunaga:

16 chars of Gin got poisoned don't you remember? unless Kreig had an antidote for it Gin would have died within 2 hours if I remember right

Because it would be retarded storytelling for Gin to promise Sanji and Luffy he would meet them again only to die offscreen.

Please tell me what would be the point of that.

Ryuunaga

@RPGJay:

Because it would be retarded storytelling for Gin to promise Sanji and Luffy he would meet them again only to die offscreen.

Please tell me what would be the point of that.

There would be no point to it. Only reason I say Gin would be alive is how Oda never shows anyone being killed only what seems like a characters death and bringing them back later.

Gladiator777

Now That i think about it, Doesn't the SHs has 504 Former Nakama ?

Viva (Choosed Her Own way and Left)
Carue (Followed her Mistress and Left)
Merry (deceased)
Old Usopp (Left cause of Whining)
500 Foxy Pirates Won on the Davy Back. (Dismissed)

So if anyone still Think Viva as a Nakama, Please Consider the 500 Foxy Pirates too as nakama.

Ryuunaga

@Gladiator777:

Now That i think about it, Doesn't the SHs has 503 Former Nakama ?

Viva (Choosed Her Own way and Left)
Carue (Followed her Mistress and Left)
Merry (deceased)
500 Foxy Pirates Won on the Davy Back. (Dismissed)

Well technically Vivi and Carue are still nakama they just aren't traveling with them.

Maki707

Actually Gin was no longer devoted to Don Kreig by the end of the baratie arc right? Did'nt he indicate he was going to set off and make his own way, no longer hiding under the shadow Don Kreig?
He is not going to join the crew but it is very reasonable to guess he will show up later as an ally.

Gladiator777

@Ryuunaga:

Well technically Vivi and Carue are still nakama they just aren't traveling with them.

They are Nakama, but not as Pirates.

Ryuunaga

@Gladiator777:

They are Nakama, but not as Pirates.

True enough but otherwise yes Luffy had 503 former nakama lol

GetsugaZoro

@Gladiator777:

Now That i think about it, Doesn't the SHs has 504 Former Nakama ?

Viva (Choosed Her Own way and Left)
Carue (Followed her Mistress and Left)
Merry (deceased)
Old Usopp (Left cause of Whining)
500 Foxy Pirates Won on the Davy Back. (Dismissed)

So if anyone still Think Viva as a Nakama, Please Consider the 500 Foxy Pirates too as nakama.

Who da fuck is Viva…(I know its a typo but you did it two times).

You cant compare that though... Vivi and Carue are completelly diferent fromt he 500 foxy pirates it doesnt even make sense to make a comparison like that...

How the fuck does Usopp counts two times...?

If someone offers me a dog and I rufese, that dog inst my former dog... its a dog wich was offred to me and I didnt want, Foxxy doods were never Luffy nakama.

RobinotX

They were a part of the crew even if you like it or not.

Luffy had juristricition over them. And gave them a command. Too Dismiss..

Kishido

@RPGJay:

You seem to be under the impression that just anyone can join.

Then again, I'm talking to someone who believes Vivi is still counted as a crewmember and the SH crew will only have one more member. So, why am I bothering with you?

Because it would be retarded storytelling for Gin to promise Sanji and Luffy he would meet them again only to die offscreen.

Please tell me what would be the point of that.

And Vivi being counted as far more likely than Gin joining so far^^

And it is your logic… If Gin appears in the future he might join... So I could say... If Enel appears or who the fuck else... he might join.

GetsugaZoro

@RobinotX:

They were a part of the crew even if you like it or not.

Luffy had juristricition over them. And gave them a command. Too Dismiss..

They were never Nakama in the true meaning of the word like Vivi and Carue were, that retarded to even compare.

Gladiator777

@Gladiator777:

Now That i think about it, Doesn't the SHs has 503 Former Nakama ?

Viva (Choosed Her Own way and Left)
Carue (Followed her Mistress and Left)
Merry (deceased)
500 Foxy Pirates Won on the Davy Back. (Dismissed)

So if anyone still Think Viva as a Nakama, Please Consider the 500 Foxy Pirates too as nakama.

alright i will fix that old usopp even if i was right, The old Usopp who didn't the Follow the Captain Order isn't the same as now.

Well what im trying to say, if people still consider vivA a pirate nakama, then The Same should be said about the other 507 Former SHs. Once you leave you are no More (Once a whore you are No more (VivA) ).
VivA may be a nakama, but not a nakama as PIRATE.

Ryuunaga

@Gladiator777:

alright i will fix that old usopp even if i was right, The old Usopp who didn't the Follow the Captain Order isn't the same as now.

Well what im trying to say, if people still consider vivA a pirate nakama, then The Same should be said about the other 507 Former SHs. Once you leave you are no More.
VivA may be a nakama, but not a nakama as PIRATE.

I understood this before :3 and I agree with it

Noqanky

@Gladiator777:

alright i will fix that old usopp even if i was right, The old Usopp who didn't the Follow the Captain Order isn't the same as now.

Well what im trying to say, if people still consider vivA a pirate nakama, then The Same should be said about the other 507 Former SHs. Once you leave you are no More (Once a whore you are No more (VivA) ).
VivA may be a nakama, but not a nakama as PIRATE.

I was under the impression that the crewmembers won at the davy back fight were filler. In the manga Luffy just took Chopper back and then the flag.

Zagi

I kind of want a brother/sister (maybe even twin) fishman pair to join, it would add an extra dimension to the crew imo. Doesn't even have to be a fishman, just make them brother/sister and ill be happy, you get combo attacks, funny crew interaction etc.

RPGJay

@GetsugaZoro:

You cant compare that though… Vivi and Carue are completelly diferent fromt he 500 foxy pirates it doesnt even make sense to make a comparison like that...

No, they really aren't different from them considering they aren't in the current crew.

Also, the 500 pirates thing was anime filler.

@GetsugaZoro:

WHow the fuck does Usopp counts two times…?

Sogeking :ninja:

@KiShiDo:

And Vivi being counted as far more likely than Gin joining so far^^

Not really, they're both at 0% as far as I'm concerned. Just one of us is being delusional about it.

@KiShiDo:

And it is your logic… If Gin appears in the future he might join... So I could say... If Enel appears or who the fuck else... he might join.

Again, I don't think Gin will join. As I've said, I'm only open to the possibility in the future. As of now, it's not possible, aka 0%.

If I wanted Gin to join, why would I present the reason why he wouldn't join? Why would I point out that he is loyal to Krieg?

And at least Gin was a noble guy. Enel was a fucking mass murderer with a literal god-complex. Comparing the two is just idiotic.

All I'm saying is the possibility may exist. Not that it will happen. Again, it's no different then the mermaid princess argument right now.

@GetsugaZoro:

They were never Nakama in the true meaning of the word like Vivi and Carue were, that retarded to even compare.

Are you even paying attention to what Gladiator is saying? Vivi and Carue were just traveling companions at best. Counting them in the current crew is legendarily retarded.

Kishido

@Noqanky:

I was under the impression that the crewmembers won at the davy back fight were filler. In the manga Luffy just took Chopper back and then the flag.

True that^^ It never happened in the manga

kyb597

Sooo, Foxy for nakama anyone?

GetsugaZoro

@Noqanky:

I was under the impression that the crewmembers won at the davy back fight were filler. In the manga Luffy just took Chopper back and then the flag.

Yeah its true I was seeing the Foxxy arc recently and now I want to check the manga and yes thats, filler I didnt even remember, well it supports even more what I said.

Gladiator why ares you still making the mistake in Vivi name? with the VivA and you even capitalized the A? are trying to make some kind of pun ir portuguese/spanish by saying she is "alive" or something…(Viva = Alive for a girl, Vivo would be for a guy.) really not getting where you are trying to go with that.

RPGJay, yes they are different, ignoring its filler stuff if it actually happened in the manga it is completelly diferent from the situation of Carue and Vivi regardinh the crew denying this is just stupid, with this im not even implying she is coming back if thats what you are getting from what Im saying, It is diferent she was with the crew for 3 entire arcs traveling as their companion she didnt had a dream and her story with them finished there for the traveling part but she was trully one of their friends/companions.

With this said on the Gin subject if he didnt leave Krieg back then he wont leave now unless, the dude is dead or something but I would also like him to join if he actually got some kind of objective, his fightning style was cool and can be expanded for sure but he would actually need an personalitty, we didnt get much of his character back then ignoring the loyalist sutff and that he seems pretty chilled.

I hope some of the old crew actually appear in the future it was a two years timeskip so if Krieg actually got humbled, he might be stronger and not as full off himself as before.

kyb597

@GetsugaZoro:

Yeah its true I was seeing the Foxxy arc recently and now I want to check the manga and yes thats, filler I didnt even remember, well it supports even more what I said.

Gladiator why ares you still making the mistake in Vivi name? with the VivA and you even capitalized the A? are trying to make some kind of pun ir portuguese/spanish by saying she is "alive" or something…(Viva = Alive for a girl, Vivo would be for a guy.) really not getting where you are trying to go with that.

He simply like capitals, as we've seen :)

Zhenja

http://read.mangashare.com/One-Piece/chapter-318/page011.html

Noqanky

I think this thread needs perona, it's falling apart without all the hate towards her …

With that in mind ... have you guys noticed that Sanji was the sixth to arrive to SA, not the seventh? So if Zoro said Sanji was the seventh, that might mean he came with Perona!!!!11!!1

awaits avalanche of hate

kyb597

@Noqanky:

I think this thread needs perona, it's falling apart without all the hate towards her …

With that in mind ... have you guys noticed that Sanji was the sixth to arrive to SA, not the seventh? So if Zoro said Sanji was the seventh, that might mean he came with Perona!!!!11!!1

awaits avalanche of hate

Maybe we're in the eye of the storm…

RPGJay

@Noqanky:

I think this thread needs perona, it's falling apart without all the hate towards her …

No it isn't. Nothing has changed really. The internet is full of delusional idiots that think certain members will join.

Stop encouraging them. The Perona argument is dead. Let. Them. Die.

And I'd rather not have this discussion locked by the mods, so keep it on-topic shall we?

Ryuunaga

@kyb597:

Maybe we're in the eye of the storm…

In Soviet Russia storm is in you

GetsugaZoro

@Noqanky:

I think this thread needs perona, it's falling apart without all the hate towards her …

With that in mind ... have you guys noticed that Sanji was the sixth to arrive to SA, not the seventh? So if Zoro said Sanji was the seventh, that might mean he came with Perona!!!!11!!1

awaits avalanche of hate

No he was the 7th, Robin came at 8th and Luffy 9th.

I dont know if you are joking.

Stop bringing Perona to the subject…

kyb597

The Perona for nakama is an on-topic discussion. Although I really don't approve of it.

Zhenja

Brook was the sixth.

Ali D

I think if there will be more members of the crew, they don't need to be fighters at all. Somebody like a poet or a painter would be helpful to tell the world of the adventures the Straw Hat's experienced. Maybe someone who turns out to be the narrator of the whole story.
At least someone using pistols is missing, not as a sharpshooter like usopp, but every pirate I remember so far from films had pistols in their belt…

kyb597

@Ali:

I think if there will be more members of the crew, they don't need to be fighters at all. Somebody like a poet or a painter would be helpful to tell the world of the adventures the Straw Hat's experienced. Maybe someone who turns out to be the narrator of the whole story.
At least someone using pistols is missing, not as a sharpshooter like usopp, but every pirate I remember so far from films had pistols in their belt…

To survive in the New World you really need to be able to protect yourself.

GetsugaZoro

@Ali:

I think if there will be more members of the crew, they don't need to be fighters at all. Somebody like a poet or a painter would be helpful to tell the world of the adventures the Straw Hat's experienced. Maybe someone who turns out to be the narrator of the whole story.
At least someone using pistols is missing, not as a sharpshooter like usopp, but every pirate I remember so far from films had pistols in their belt…

Oh you mean Sabo ofc, :D he wants to catalog his jounrey has a pirate.

kyb597

@GetsugaZoro:

Oh you mean Sabo ofc.

16 Chars of We wish.

Sea

@Ali:

I think if there will be more members of the crew, they don't need to be fighters at all.

LOL, no, Usopp will always be the weakest.

Noqanky

@RPGJay:

No it isn't. Nothing has changed really. The internet is full of delusional idiots that think certain members will join.

Stop encouraging them. The Perona argument is dead. Let. Them. Die.

And I'd rather not have this discussion locked by the mods, so keep it on-topic shall we?

How is it not on-topic, Perona is still up there in the poll. Which, btw, should be changed …
And if you think things aren't worse right now, consider all the ridiculous candidates put forth so far. WTF, Enel? Dear god ... (no pun intended)
Also, terrible arguments are never dead.

@GetsugaZoro:

No he was the 7th, Robin came at 8th and Luffy 9th.

I dont know if you are joking.

Stop bringing Perona to the subject…

http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/35970330/17

But yea, I joke, it's clear Zoro counted Brook before Sanji.

Haha, wasn't aware Perona was still such a sore spot for you guys …

Ryuunaga

@Ali:

I think if there will be more members of the crew, they don't need to be fighters at all. Somebody like a poet or a painter would be helpful to tell the world of the adventures the Straw Hat's experienced. Maybe someone who turns out to be the narrator of the whole story.
At least someone using pistols is missing, not as a sharpshooter like usopp, but every pirate I remember so far from films had pistols in their belt…

Usopp paints stuff for them (he made the Strawhat Jolly Roger) they have their painter already :ninja:

brennen.exe

Just a reminder that " <insert random="" character="">for crewmember" isn't allowed, and by extension neither is intentionally bringing up troll topic characters or characters you know will never join. If you've already argued all the characters a million times, let the thread rest until new information comes out rather than forcing posts just for the sake of it.

Edit: Also fanfics. Take your fanfics somewhere else.</insert>

RPGJay

@kyb597:

The Perona for nakama is an on-topic discussion. Although I really don't approve of it.

No it isn't. It's like saying Wiper for nakama is on-topic discussion.

@Noqanky:

How is it not on-topic, Perona is still up there in the poll. Which, btw, should be changed …

If you think Perona shouldn't be on the poll either, then why are you telling me it's on-topic?

And yes, Perona is no longer on-topic. Perona's chances don't exist. They never have existed, but only delusional fans are left to think she ever had a chance.

@Noqanky:

And if you think things aren't worse right now, consider all the ridiculous candidates put forth so far. WTF, Enel? Dear god … (no pun intended)
Also, terrible arguments are never dead.

Terrible arguments can die. How many people are still thinking Paulie will join?

Just let the Perona talk cease from now on. It's over. Now let it be over.

Again, I'd rather not see this thread closed.

kyb597

Look, this is what needs to happen; The next nakama NEED to have some form of fighting style involving hats! One Piece is THE hat manga and I can't believe we haven't seen any attacks involving hats but I just figured out why, Oda is saving himself for the epic that is the next nakama! Yes!

@brennen.exe:

Just a reminder that " <insert random="" character="">for crewmember" isn't allowed, and by extension neither is intentionally bringing up troll topic characters or characters you know will never join. If you've already argued all the characters a million times, let the thread rest until new information comes out rather than forcing posts just for the sake of it.</insert>

Why? Let the discussions flow, I don't see why people should be restricted to discuss their diffrent beliefs in this subject just because their have been arguments about it before, let their voices be heard aswell.

kyb597

This post is deleted!

Noqanky

@kyb597:

Look, this is what needs to happen; The next nakama NEED to have some form of fighting style involving hats! One Piece is THE hat manga and I can't believe we haven't seen any attacks involving hats but I just figured out why, Oda is saving himself for the epic that is the next nakama! Yes!

I like.
Although if we argue for hats I think that the rule was that all devil fruit users in the crew wear hats (although recently Robin has abandoned her cowgirl hat … )

Ryuunaga

@Noqanky:

http://tonova.typepad.com/photos/uncategorized/2007/05/28/oddjob.jpg

I like.
Although if we argue for hats I think that the rule was that all devil fruit users in the crew wear hats (although recently Robin has abandoned her cowgirl hat … )

Wow I never noticed that

Bakajaro

I don't post here much, mostly just read :P
But i've got a hunch that Jewelry Bonney might join,
why? Well she got defeated in the NW, she hates the marines (especially Akainu) and Blackbeard too. I can somehow relate that to Luffy. Though I don't know how they'll ever meet cuz she got inprisoned by akainu right?
anyway, just a hunch.

brennen.exe

This post is deleted!

semil

@Bakajaro:

I don't post here much, mostly just read :P
But i've got a hunch that Jewelry Bonney might join,
why? Well she got defeated in the NW, she hates the marines (especially Akainu) and Blackbeard too. I can somehow relate that to Luffy. Though I don't know how they'll ever meet cuz she got inprisoned by akainu right?
anyway, just a hunch.

Bonney said how stupid Zoro was, then said that Luffy was even more stupid. Makes me think that unless she somehow got involved in something that made her an exceptional target to the Marines and the WG, she wouldn't join. Her line to Akainu makes me think she's certainly against the marines and/or government, but her earlier comments about Luffy and Zoro shows that she isn't really interesting in confronting the full force of the WG. And once Luffy gets going again, that would be inevitable.

So I don't think its entirely impossible, but it would require some changes that we haven't seen yet.

kyb597

This post is deleted!

RPGJay

This post is deleted!

Cyan D. Funk

This post is deleted!

Chopper Madness

@Bakajaro:

I don't post here much, mostly just read :P
But i've got a hunch that Jewelry Bonney might join,
why? Well she got defeated in the NW, she hates the marines (especially Akainu) and Blackbeard too. I can somehow relate that to Luffy. Though I don't know how they'll ever meet cuz she got inprisoned by akainu right?
anyway, just a hunch.

no you are wrong!!!!(puts fingers in ears)

i hate this idea and i will bet you 100 dollars that it will not happen….

lol i dont know why lots of people like her ...imo she was the worst SN and now people want her as NN ...i guess thats just me

GetsugaZoro

@Bakajaro:

I don't post here much, mostly just read :P
But i've got a hunch that Jewelry Bonney might join,
why? Well she got defeated in the NW, she hates the marines (especially Akainu) and Blackbeard too. I can somehow relate that to Luffy. Though I don't know how they'll ever meet cuz she got inprisoned by akainu right?
anyway, just a hunch.

Most broken devil fruit in the manga.

/the end.