Do you think Rufi and the others go in space?Eneru did it why not Rufi?There would be new adventures for them and Rufi want to be the king of all space pirates.
Untitled
-
-
The day the Strawhats go into space, is the day I stop reading One Piece.
-
Originally posted by Battle Franky@Feb 15 2005, 11:28 AM
The day the Strawhats go into space, is the day I stop reading One Piece.
[snapback]3169[/snapback]I second that emotion. However, I hope that they have some sort of underwater adventure in an Atlantis setting (or something along those lines..)
-
Why do stop then?Im sure it would be good.
-
In DBZ Goku went to space, why not Luffy and his crews go? Battle Franky why are you gonna stop reading One Piece if they do that?
-
I have so much trust in Oda such that I'm sure even if he brings them to space, it'll be believable, acceptable and enjoyable B)
-
Yes that is what i think Kaka.
-
Originally posted by KNOW@Feb 16 2005, 12:30 AM
Why do stop then?Im sure it would be good.
[snapback]3174[/snapback]It wouldn't be good, because it would make no sense. The One Piece universe is largely based on the age of sail which was between the early 1600s till the the mid 1800s, with of course a few quirks added by Oda exclusive to the One Piece world.
Sure he could do it… someway... somehow, but I think it would be generally dismissed by the fans & perhaps send the series popularity into a nosedive.
-
No i think if they go to space one piece would become more popular than it is now.
Instead to travel from island to island they would travel from planet to planet. -
Originally posted by Battle Franky@Feb 15 2005, 06:28 PM
The day the Strawhats go into space, is the day I stop reading One Piece.
[snapback]3169[/snapback]Word. -_-
-
retarded.
-
….. Going Merry, travelling from planet to planet across the galaxy.
:rolleyes:
Gosh, that sounds like a retarded fanfic or something.
-
It wouldn't be good, because it would make no sense. The One Piece universe is largely based on the age of sail which was between the early 1600s till the the mid 1800s, with of course a few quirks added by Oda exclusive to the One Piece world.
tsk tsk! Lest we forget there's an unwritten history and a period of time known as the Age of Heaven. In fact, Pluton is indeed a battleship, but Uchusenkan Yamato was also a battleship! Although I don't see the series going there, I could see how it could. Now I don't see space travel playing a part, but as far as some badass weapons heading up into space and taking someone with them, I can see that.
-
Originally posted by joekido the Second@Feb 15 2005, 11:34 AM
In DBZ Goku went to space, why not Luffy and his crews go? [snapback]3177[/snapback]Goku was from space. :P
I wouldn't want the crew to go to space, though the Atlantis idea sounds very interesting! -
Battle Franky going merry is dead!Didnt you read the new chapters?
-
One Piece in space has got to be one of the worst ideas I have ever heard. Not only that it's going to be almost impossible to think of a reason to go into space, but how are they going to break through the atmosphere with a wooden boat?
And of course, most of the crewmembers are not the sharpest knifes in the drawer so they are probably going to die from the lack of air when they reach outer space. And Nami's books will have nothing about outer space in there because it would require astronauts to get there first and report their findings.
It's a dumb idea and I would stop reading One Piece if Oda uses that idea because it is just so silly. (Not the funny silly.)
-
Merry is dead?! Last time we saw Merry, she was still afloat & intact. I believe there has been no decision to scrap her yet, and until that choice is made by Usopp, her fate is still very much undecided in my eyes.
-
Originally posted by Battle Franky+Feb 15 2005, 10:00 AM–>QUOTE(Battle Franky @ Feb 15 2005, 10:00 AM)
-
Not only that it's going to be almost impossible to think of a reason to go into space, but how are they going to break through the atmosphere with a wooden boat?
I do believe a topic of some concern right now are the ships known as ancient weapons. Who says they're just wooden?
-
Originally posted by omae no kaasan v.2@Feb 15 2005, 12:54 PM
**> Not only that it's going to be almost impossible to think of a reason to go into space, but how are they going to break through the atmosphere with a wooden boat?I do believe a topic of some concern right now are the ships known as ancient weapons. Who says they're just wooden?
[snapback]3236[/snapback]**Because if they were made of steel, I think they would have passed down the technique of building ships out of steel to today's shipwrights and leave out the details about the weapons of mass destructions installed on those legendary ships.
And you are assuming that The Straw Hats are going to get a legendary weapon, which would only extend the series to near pointless battles over that weapon and of course, the question of "Who has the better legendary weapon?".
Keep in mind that Oda wants to finish the story of One Piece before he kicks the bucket.
-
I agree with Battle Franky right now in that, the "feel" of One Piece is the Pirate era of the 1500-1600s. Even though the technology in the series is vastly different in some cases, the "feel" of the show would not translate well to outer space. Sure, there are some cartoons that have done it (Titan AE and Treasure Planet) but too much backstory has gone into this world that Oda has created to suddenly take it into space and go from planet to planet. These were pirate movies that were written in mind with space travel from the start. Oda's version of travel is from island to island rather than planet to planet. It conveys a different "feel".
Ever see The Adventures of Baron Munchausen? They go into space at one point on a ship but it is done in a very surreal way. "Space" is a very dreamlike place where the 'rules' and 'feel' established for this world are carried over into this little outer space adventure. That's probably the only way I could see One Piece going into space and they already kind of did it with Skypiea.
-
Originally posted by joekido the Second@Feb 16 2005, 01:49 AM
Battle Franky, the One Piece world is not connected to our world, the One Piece world has a differant history and future. You seem to forget that One Piece has nothing to do with our world because it's set in a fictional universe that does not exist plus One Piece world is not earth but a fictional world.
[snapback]3231[/snapback]Err… my point is, that Oda drew inspiration from that age of our world, while adding his own original twists.
...of course I know that our world & that of what Oda has created are completely different, I never said they were the same. It's just that Oda has based his manga largely on specific era in our time to create his world, where the means for space travel & other complicated feats are impossible as the technology, knowledge & laws of that era dictates, just like in our world, two or three hundred years ago.
It would've simply been inconceivable. However, I do agree with omae, that perhaps the weapons could be advanced beyond the technology of that era & could be capable of space travel, though that seems abit unlikely, but still a possibility.
-
_Originally posted by GunMetal: Reloaded+Feb 15 2005, 11:07 AM–>QUOTE(GunMetal: Reloaded @ Feb 15 2005, 11:07 AM)__I agree with Battle Franky right now in that, the "feel" of One Piece is the Pirate era of the 1500-1600s. Even though the technology in the series is vastly different in some cases, the "feel" of the show would not translate well to outer space. Sure, there are some cartoons that have done it (Titan AE and Treasure Planet) but too much backstory has gone into this world that Oda has created to suddenly take it into space and go from planet to planet. These were pirate movies that were written in mind with space travel from the start. Oda's version of travel is from island to island rather than planet to planet. It conveys a different "feel".
Ever see The Adventures of Baron Munchausen? They go into space at one point on a ship but it is done in a very surreal way. "Space" is a very dreamlike place where the 'rules' and 'feel' established for this world are carried over into this little outer space adventure. That's probably the only way I could see One Piece going into space and they already kind of did it with Skypiea.
[snapback]3241[/snapback]Well what if the Straw Hats gets teleported to one planet and teleport back without going through the Atomshpere? If you play Final Fantasy 9, Zidane and his party went to the other world call Terra(yet just one planet, would it be nice if the same thing happens in One Piece?
Originally posted by Battle Franky@Feb 15 2005, 11:10 AM
**Battle Franky, the One Piece world is not connected to our world, the One Piece world has a differant history and future. You seem to forget that One Piece has nothing to do with our world because it's set in a fictional universe that does not exist plus One Piece world is not earth but a fictional world.
[snapback]3231[/snapback]Err… my point is, that Oda drew inspiration from that age of our world, while adding his own original twists.
...of course I know that our world & that of what Oda has created are completely different, I never said they were the same. It's just that Oda has based his manga largely on specific era in our time to create his world, where the means for space travel & other complicated feats are impossible as the technology, knowledge & laws of that era dictates, just like in our world, two or three hundred years ago.
It would've simply been inconceivable. However, I do agree with omae, that perhaps the weapons could be advanced beyond the technology of that era & could be capable of space travel, though that seems abit unlikely, but still a possibility.
[snapback]3243[/snapback]**Well, just remamber that the One Piece world may have advent techology, One Piece may not have a strict tigth with the era of 1600-1800_
-
Joekido:
1. That is Final Fantasy 9, not One Piece. Just because it happens in different games or anime series doesn't mean it applies to One Piece. And it still leaves the question of WHY the Straw Hats should do something like what you described.
2. Battle Franky says that Oda added quirks to that era that is based on One Piece. For example, there is a toilet and bathtub with a showerhead in the Going Merry, the dials in Skypiea and Krieg had poison gas and a gatling gun for weapons. That's about it.
3. There is a button on each of your posts called "EDIT". Use that instead of posting THREE TIMES! -
thanks for pointing that out, zio.
yes, there's is a reason why you're given an EDIT button. USE IT FOLKS, i don't have time to merge your posts every single time.
-
Originally posted by Zio@Feb 15 2005, 11:39 AM
Joekido:
1. That is Final Fantasy 9, not One Piece. Just because it happens in different games or anime series doesn't mean it applies to One Piece. And it still leaves the question of WHY the Straw Hats should do something like what you described.
2. Battle Franky says that Oda added quirks to that era that is based on One Piece. For example, there is a toilet and bathtub with a showerhead in the Going Merry, the dials in Skypiea and Krieg had poison gas and a gatling gun for weapons. That's about it.
3. There is a button on each of your posts called "EDIT". Use that instead of posting THREE TIMES!
[snapback]3267[/snapback]Sorry to cause the double-post commotion. This portible device I'm holding rigth now is very slow and it ransomly drops connetion and if I press "reply" again, the device gets confuse and double posts, same problem goes if I press "back" button. I really need to use the desktop internet
Edit: Okay I'm on a desktop computer now and Zio skecth Final Fantasy 9 out, my point is what if the Straw hats teleport along with the ship to an another world? would that be nice. I also agreed that space traveling is a far-out-there idea, i think the Straw hats should stay on thier World uless if someone mistakly teleports them somewhere eles
-
I don't want to say anything is impossible with Oda, but I really doubt we'll see them flying from planet to planet… Sure it happened in Dragon Ball, but that was set in a futuristic world (just look at the capsules and stuff).
A cover series of Ener's adventures in space would be cool, though. Assuming he could survive somehow. -
One Piece in space is the most stupidest idea I have ever heard.
-
KNOW?
Your an idiot.
Luffy will go Super Rubberman 3 next thing you know.
And Ener was heading into space, theres no way he actually got to the moon. I'm sure a comical realization on his part took place when he reached a certain height.Skypiea is the space of One Piece. The impossoble frontier.
But please stop.Take it to the hellish void that is fanfiction.net. Please! -
We need an orginzed story background
-
Hey, it's just another forumer's opinion. You shouldn't bash… :x We can speculate whatever we want. Everyone views things differently.
Anyway, for me, Skypiea arc was kind of space already. Even though people lived there aren't alians, they kind of possess different figure from normal people (having those two things sticking out of their head and having wings). I don't think they had those when they were still on the earth. Even though Eneru went to further out to the space, it's just the difference of how far they are away from the earth.
So now that "space" is covered (for me), I wish they'll go into deep sea. Like, maybe their new ship is submarine. They might have a deep sea city with nobody have problem breathing.
-
The depths in OP are pretty creepy.
In vol.24 when Luffy,Sanji, and Zoro dive…..we see loads of big "things".
shudders -
_Originally posted by Funkmaster Carter+Feb 15 2005, 08:15 PM–>QUOTE(Funkmaster Carter @ Feb 15 2005, 08:15 PM)retarded.
[snapback]3207[/snapback]First, if you haven t read the rules, your post has to be more than 4 words!!! Secondly, do not just post to tell somebody that he is a retard!! THAT S NOT NICE! Everybody has the right to have his own crazy theory! And if he is a "retard" as you think…what don t you take the time to explain him why you don t like his theory? We re here to discuss opinions not to diss members!!
Same for Zephos!!As for KNOW i highly doubt they ll go to the space!! They re not as crazy as eneru!
But what I think is that they ll go under the sea! Maybe they ll have a merman as a crew member ^^_ -
They re not as crazy as eneru!
Oh I'm sure Luffy is as crazy, or I say, romantist as Eneru >:) I'm sure if there's "space" (whatever that is), Luffy would definitely want to go. Like how he wanted to Sora-jima.
-
Originally posted by Zephos@Feb 15 2005, 02:38 PM
**KNOW?Your an idiot.**
I warn you once!If you ever say something like this again to me i come and kick your fucking ass.
@Tash
This is just a manga.Oda decide who is crazy and who go to space.And if he wants a Merman in the crew it will happen. -
Heeey, can we just stop with the back-and-forth bashing and debate/discuss like adults? There's really no need for profanity or name calling on either side. Thanks.
I agree with ocean. Skypiea was the OP equivalent of space. I think All Blue will be when they go underwater and encounter mermaids and that kind of thing. It's the OTHER great frontier.
-
Oooooh, All Blue being underwater sounds nice o.o! With lots of cute mermaids! And mermaids bring you the greatest ingridients to Sanji, and special medecine to Chopper >:) :P
-
I sincerely doubt that the Straw Hats will ever go into space, barring Ener coming and getting them for some weird reason.
On the other hand, I wouldn't mind seeing Oda do a science fiction series when he finally finishes One Piece, which will hopefully be quite a while from now.
-
Originally posted by KNOW+Feb 15 2005, 03:13 PM–>QUOTE(KNOW @ Feb 15 2005, 03:13 PM)
-
I would still read if they ever go Space. I expect Oda to have different kind of space story from other Manga-ka. You never know Oda's creativity, it might turn out very good. Just… Space is not necesarily a science fiction. There might be ocean in outer space (which, I still think, is covered in Skypiea -__-).
See, if you think Sora-jima as space, it wasn't bad at all, was it? :x
-
Originally posted by oceanizer@Feb 15 2005, 04:23 PM
Oooooh, All Blue being underwater sounds nice o.o! With lots of cute mermaids! And mermaids bring you the greatest ingridients to Sanji, and special medecine to Chopper >:) :P
[snapback]3333[/snapback]Haha, yeah. I like to think All Blue will be the arc before the final one where they liberate this kingdom of mermaids from Jimbei who is like Arlong X 1000.
-
One Piece may be finish by the end of this year
-
i agree with Battle Franky… cuz... um why would the Pirate theme mysteriously change to Star Wars... what are they gonna do? Battle the Dark Force Pirates? and after they'll get Chewbaka? omg...
-
This thing actually turned into a serious discussion.
I wouldn't know what to think if One Piece moved into space. Right now I find it redicilous but you never know, perhaps it could work. But honestly, I think it would take away the heart of the series.
One Piece may be finish by the end of this year
That, my friend, would be a rushed ending.
-
One Piece in space would be very weird. I found it funny that Eneru was trying to go to the moon. I don't see it as possible for the people in One Piece to do it, however, if Oda made it work then I wouldn't mind seeing them in space.
Originally posted by joekido the Second@Feb 15 2005, 03:53 PM
One Piece may be finish by the end of this yearUm…where did you hear this? Or are you just making a random guess?
-
just like i was trying to say! theres no point in taking the great pirate theme away.. cuz diudnt the story happen a few years back b4 spaceships UFO's….
cuz mixing it up is just a bad idea... cuz like i said b4... wot if they Battled the Dark Side Pirates and Chewbaka joins them after or Sabul. lol
-
Originally posted by oceanizer@Feb 15 2005, 04:23 PM
Oooooh, All Blue being underwater sounds nice o.o!
[snapback]3333[/snapback]I'm sticking with my prediction that it's underland.
It can only be in one of two places logically after all, assuming that Oda just doesn't randomly stick it somewhere that doesn't make sense.
-
What if the Straw hat teleport to one planet to learn more of the area around One Piece world, the descide that one is enough and teleports back to the One Piece world without going througth the atomsphere? Or if they find a portal and travel to one "another world?"
-
i can probably change my opinion. but if I was on the Positive side of this.. i'd say that maybe Paulie or some other robot in OP made a machine or a rocket or a catapault that flug the Going Merry somewhere and then THEY GO INTO A WARP! AND AND AND ITS ALL BLUE AND THERES LIKE POGOS ALL AROUND! AND AND AND!!!
whoops… sorry ^_^ went a little too off there.
-
Originally posted by Heritic+Feb 15 2005, 02:02 PM–>QUOTE(Heritic @ Feb 15 2005, 02:02 PM)One Piece in space would be very weird. I found it funny that Eneru was trying to go to the moon. I don't see it as possible for the people in One Piece to do it, however, if Oda made it work then I wouldn't mind seeing them in space.