@God:
I'm not exactly new to comics, but I don't understand the general consensus on certain writers, but isn't Miller liked for everything except for his work on Batman?
Robby pretty much summed it up.
Frank Miller was an amazing writer at one point and brought the world some seminal comic book classics like The Dark Knight Returns, Batman: Year One, 300, Sin City et. al.
After 9/11 However, Frank Miller's worldview changed radically, and he's become an incredibly terrible writer as of late.
.
Plus, he tends to repeat himself. Repeatedly. Repetitious. Repeatedly. Repetitious. He repeats himself. This happens A LOT and it's annoying. Count how many times Vicky Vale says "I'm on a date with Bruce Wayne!" in the first issue of ASBAR for example, or how many times Dick Grayson, Age 12, says "They're always there for me… they always catch me". Repetition can be a good storytelling technique if used right, but Frank never does.
He also wrote this incredibly racist abomination of a story called "Holy Terror" which was intended to be a Batman and Catwoman story, but someone at DC finally came to their senses and pulled the plug, so he very lightly changed the characters (Took off the Bat Emblem and ears from Batman's suit, called him "The Fixer" for example) and released it as an original story with another company. Wow is it the single most racist and outright horrible piece of filth ever published as a comic book.
"So" you might be thinking, "He did bad in all of those areas, but this is a sequel to one of his GOOD works! Having the original to go off and use as a tonal template, couldn't he make something good out of this?"
I'd respond that yes, that would potentially be possible…. if he hadn't already done one sequel to TDKR already and proven that no,
.
I don't recommend reading any of these, as I don't want you to lose any braincells, but I've linked above to Linkara reviewing each of these things to prove just how horrible they are. He goes over all of the major problems with them and I'd say my opinion matches his on this one 100%