Bronze Kyros for Nakama.
Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)
-
Bronze Kyros for Nakama.
-
@Rolor:
Bronze Kyros for Nakama.
Came to say this, Luffy wanted a statue after all, haha.
-
How can you say no him?
-
If he appears I'm all for it… but for now Rebecca <3
-
If he appears I'm all for it… but for now Rebecca <3
Bishie Prince Cavendish showed more personality and potential interaction with Luffy than Rebecca.
-
Bishie Prince Cavendish showed more personality and potential interaction with Luffy than Rebecca.
He was also a way unfitting than Rebecca
-
Bishie Prince Cavendish showed more personality and potential interaction with Luffy than Rebecca.
He is a pirate captain, he probably has his crew and has a grudge on the supernovas, plus Luffy didn't give a shit about him, he actually seemed to like the girl but yeah nothing points out anything about her, statue guy has more of a chance then her rigth now.
-
My point is that Rebecca is very boring right now. She makes the bishie prince look interesting in comparison.
-
There is going to be more to Rebecca than right now. I'm willing to say Rebecca has a chance, but I would like to see Kyros.
Cavendish is a no for me. -
LOL
No, another swordsmen rants?
Oh yea if it's a girl it's cool.
-
No she hasn't katanas but a graet sword + a 3 shields <3333
-
My point is that Rebecca is very boring right now. She makes the bishie prince look interesting in comparison.
We haven't seen much of her, she was just introducing herself to Luffy and having a serious conversation, the other guy think he is the center of the universe and is trying to get everyone attention, yeah he standed out more then her.
Still thats the same thing as the other people that were saying, Jinbe is somehow not funny enough to be a SH.
I like the theme and she interested me, like I said I think if anyone has a chance from this chapter its the statue guy not her but I though she was more interesting at first sight then gigantic princess and all the villan girls that people wanted to join and I criticized as you want their boobs to join not them.
-
Cavendish seems to be treading on Sanji's realm too much imo.
I like the Gladiator though , she may not have charisma , but Oda made it evident she'll be somewhat
important to the Arc with her grudge against DD. -
No she hasn't katanas but a graet sword + a 3 shields <3333
Don´t even try dude, seems like everyone is eager to mock other members.
-
Walks in and sees people talking about Rebecca.
Yep, this is apforums -
Ruler 'Fake massacre adventurist' Ohlumbus !
Finally someone who looks like a pirate in Luffy's crew.
-
Walks in and sees people talking about Rebecca.
Yep, this is apforumsForget Rebecca then.
Let's talk about somebody with real NN potential:
-
We're not even sure that guy is real, or just a legend or myth. Not even close to NN potential.
-
If pretty boy joins, then Sanji really would be the ultimate punching bag for Oda lol
so right now, Rebecca for NN 8D
-
LOL
No, another swordsmen rants?
Oh yea if it's a girl it's cool.
Well if Kyros has a shield and sword, he would have a diferent style of figthing even if its a claymore like sword, I guess we can call him a swordsmen but he would be like a berserker more then what Zoro is, Brooke is pretty diferent from Zoro for example, diferent disciplines, Luffy, Chopper and Franky punch people but they aren't example the same.
-
I don't think it matters either way what weapon they use , people get caught up too much in that.
Let's say Oda added 5 more members to the crew , two of those five would be swordsmen imo.
-
I don't think it matters either way what weapon they use , people get caught up too much in that.
Let's say Oda added 5 more members to the crew , two of those five would be swordsmen imo.
It matters because people want their heroes to be unique, heck even Oda probably wants his protagonists to be as unique and distinguishable as possible. A swordsman wearing a yukata talking about the way of the sword is not distinguishable (though that is completely simplified) while a Gladiatrix with shield and sword would be, not saying i support her as nakama.
-
It matters because people want their heroes to be unique, heck even Oda probably wants his protagonists to be as unique and distinguishable as possible. A swordsman wearing a yukata talking about the way of the sword is not distinguishable (though that is completely simplified) while a Gladiatrix with shield and sword would be, not saying i support her as nakama.
And I'm not saying Oda wants to have all of his heroes the same ,but at the end of the day people saw Rebecca dubbed her NN without mentioning
that convenient argument about the crew having too many swordsmen. It's a double standard.Ive always been of the opinion that it doesn't matter as long as their styles are different. It'd be like saying all martial artists wouldn't be fair game as NN because of Sanji.
-
And I'm not saying Oda wants to have all of his heroes the same ,but at the end of the day people saw Rebecca dubbed her NN without mentioning
that convenient argument about the crew having too many swordsmen. It's a double standard.Ive always been of the opinion that it doesn't matter as long as their styles are different. It'd be like saying all martial artists wouldn't be fair game as NN because of Sanji.
I am not even arguing that she is a legitimate candidate, everything concerning that is premature at this point but it is clear that she is far more distinguishable than Kinemon ever was, especially considering that we will probably see a lot of Samurais in Wano. It is also apparent that she is gonna be the usual ally at least for this arc, people just like to think and develop it further in their mind which this thread is for anyway, not the usual "she has boobs, she is gonna join" fuss.
-
We're not even sure that guy is real, or just a legend or myth. Not even close to NN potential.
Clearly they just mean the statue will join, not the person. Luffy always did want a bronze statue for the ship :ninja:
-
All the people introduced in this chapter 4 Nakama!
-
As someone who's pretty against the whole: "A new woman, she must join!" crowd, Rebecca at least looks like she stands a chance. I mean, anything can change, but yeah.
-
Rebecca is most likely only going to be around for this arc as her 2 goals(mera mera and DD) are related to Dressrosa only.
-
Guys
Guys
One scene of talking to Luffy does not make someone a valid crew candidate
-
Interesting to see how this goes. I don't see anyone viable, but the mera mera fruit bascially gives that person the fighting ability they need for the group. If the SHs even get it.
If I could chose, Rebecca, I want another girl.
@Cyan: That's this manga's subsitute for fanshipping, but I agree.
-
Remember guys, to join the SH's, you gotta have a dream you need to fulfill.
-
It looks like Rebecca has a tragic back story (involving Doflamingo), so that's one "next nakama" criterion that she meets…
-
No one is considering the real #1 of the latest chapter: Elisabello
-
@Cyan:
Guys
Guys
One scene of talking to Luffy does not make someone a valid crew candidate
I'm more arguing that she doesn't seem invalid is all :) I wouldn't get my hopes up. Unlike say, Perona or harpy lady, who had a 0% chance of joining.
-
Abdullah will join it.
It has been spoken.
-
If Rebecca joins. I want her hair cut. Too many ladies with 4 feet of hair lol.
If Cavendish joins…Um. Not likely lol.
-
Rebecca for Strawhats! xD
-
Honestly, I love how people are completely disregarding Kinemon despite him having many varied and fun interactions with the crew (The ONLY really solid arguement against that I've seen is his son, but then Franky had the Franky family so I'm not sure how valid that is), but a new character comes up with with one interaction and suddenly they're a more likely candidate. I'm not even sure Kinemon will join, but aside from the inevitable Jinbe, he's the only candidate right now that a solid arguement could be made for. I don't even get people who call him the next Vivi and completely ignore the difference in obligations. Especially since Kin'emon is pretty useful in a fight, which hasn't really been true for any of the Vivi, Johnny, Yosaku types
-
Honestly, I love how people are completely disregarding Kinemon despite him having many varied and fun interactions with the crew (The ONLY really solid arguement against that I've seen is his son, but then Franky had the Franky family so I'm not sure how valid that is), but a new character comes up with with one interaction and suddenly they're a more likely candidate. I'm not even sure Kinemon will join, but aside from the inevitable Jinbe, he's the only candidate right now that a solid arguement could be made for. I don't even get people who call him the next Vivi and completely ignore the difference in obligations. Especially since Kin'emon is pretty useful in a fight, which hasn't really been true for any of the Vivi, Johnny, Yosaku types
I hope Kin gets killed and Momo joins the crew.
-
Yeah, Momo's a candidate too, but until we see some indication of him being capable in a fight, I'm not sure what to think about him being used. The dragon SMILE is cool, but we hven't seen Momo use any combat applications or anything, so I'm not sure how things will go in that regard
-
Honestly, I love how people are completely disregarding Kinemon despite him having many varied and fun interactions with the crew (The ONLY really solid arguement against that I've seen is his son, but then Franky had the Franky family so I'm not sure how valid that is), but a new character comes up with with one interaction and suddenly they're a more likely candidate. I'm not even sure Kinemon will join, but aside from the inevitable Jinbe, he's the only candidate right now that a solid arguement could be made for. I don't even get people who call him the next Vivi and completely ignore the difference in obligations. Especially since Kin'emon is pretty useful in a fight, which hasn't really been true for any of the Vivi, Johnny, Yosaku types
We've already been over Kinemon for about a hundred pages, and Rebecca just showed up. People are naturally going to speculate that the new character might join the chapter she shows up.
Its not like 1 page of "Rebecca for NN" means that Kinemon's chances are now dead in our eyes, we just like talking about every possibility we can.
-
We've already been over Kinemon for about a hundred pages, and Rebecca just showed up. People are naturally going to speculate that the new character might join the chapter she shows up.
Its not like 1 page of "Rebecca for NN" means that Kinemon's chances are now dead in our eyes, we just like talking about every possibility we can.
No, people around here have pretty much dismissed Kinemon, and I see people who already seem to argue she has better chances. She isn't really a possibility yet. Maybe she will be as we see more of her, but until then there's nothing to really speculate around. And regardless of whether she does become one eventually, since we have no reason to assume she'll join right now other than "friendly with Luffy", anyone seriously trying to argue it with what we have now is being kind of dumb in my opinion
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Honestly, I feel like maybe there should be rules about a number of appearances and/or interactions necessary before anyone is allowed to discuss a character as a potential crewmate. Because I'm tired of people jumping on anyone after a single appearance, and I'm tired of people who decide its funny to make fun of that by pretending to be one of them. The mocking through imitation thing really isn't funny in this case. It's been done to death, and I'm not sure if it was ever that funny in the first place anyways
-
Rebecca for helping Luffy steal that Bronze Statue!
-
Maybe Momosuke, Kinemon's son will join the Straw Hats?
Seems more likely than anything else in my opinion. He would be a nice contrast to Chopper I think.
-
I think Rebecca is likelier to join than Kinemon
-
I wouldn't mind if Rebecca ended up in the crew, tough I'm not saying she will. At least she is much more plausible option than Monet, Kinemon or Violet for god's sake!
-
@Cyan:
Guys
Guys
One scene of talking to Luffy does not make someone a valid crew candidate
This thread stopped being about valid crew members years ago.
-
@Zik:
This thread stopped being about valid crew members years ago.
True, …. hack heck I'll jump on the bandwagon... I want BOTH Xai & Boo for namaka ...just for the chuckles when someone says thanks ;)
-
Honestly, I love how people are completely disregarding Kinemon despite him having many varied and fun interactions with the crew (The ONLY really solid arguement against that I've seen is his son, but then Franky had the Franky family so I'm not sure how valid that is), but a new character comes up with with one interaction and suddenly they're a more likely candidate. I'm not even sure Kinemon will join, but aside from the inevitable Jinbe, he's the only candidate right now that a solid arguement could be made for. I don't even get people who call him the next Vivi and completely ignore the difference in obligations. Especially since Kin'emon is pretty useful in a fight, which hasn't really been true for any of the Vivi, Johnny, Yosaku types
The main reason I don't want him to join is because he's another perv lol and then we'd have 3 pervs (to women) >_>
-
The main reason I don't want him to join is because he's another perv lol and then we'd have 3 pervs (to women) >_>
And why is that a problem? Or is it just the whole sexism brigade speaking again