Don't get me wrong Mugiwara_no_Luffy, I'm not completely sold on her yet too… I just wanted to show you guys how it would look like (in my mind) IF she really did join.
but I do get the feeling that there's more to her story than what she relayed. All we know is that she was one of the slaves that FisherTiger freed, nothing more...
Next Crew Member Speculation (Ver 3.0)
-
-
[hide]From what I gather, there's always a certain level of Idiocy with each crew member (with a bit of an exception with robin) and it's part of what makes it fun to read.
I'm not really on board with Hancock joining; but IF she does, it would look like this:
1. Luffy introduces her to the crew
2. Sanji nosebleeds all over
3. Hancock insultingly tells Sanji she only has eyes for Luffy
4. Sanji forgives her, but kicks luffy
5. Zorro insults Sanji even more, ignoring Hancock
6. Zorro has a bit of resistance to Hancock's charm thus making her look
down on him.
7. Nami gets charmed at first but it eventually fades when she learns
Hancock is a queen of an entire island (Hinting that Hancock is very rich!
<dollar signs="" on="" her="" eyes="">).
8. Usopp introduces himself as being the REAL captain of the ship (ignored)
9. Franky introduces himself with a dance.
10. Hancock insults Franky's perverted appearance and bends back even
more, looking down on him.
11. Hancock hesitates to talk to Brooke; being a skeleton and all…
12. Then Brooke asks Hancock if she could show him her panties
13. Now Hancock is practically looking up as she insults the skinless
musician while he gets a beating from Nami and Sanji
14. The shy Chopper politely introduces himself to Hancock.
15. She kicks Chopper saying "why is there a cute Reindeer in my way?"
16. Chopper starts his weird dance saying " Calling me a CUTE reindeer
doesn't make me happy at all!!"
17. Robin calmly smiles while watching everyone.
18. Luffy tell's Hancock to not kick Chopper...
19. She quickly hears Luffy's voice and behaves herself...
20. and it goes on and on.....Call me crazy but it's pretty much Vintage everyday Strawhat madness...[/hide]</dollar>
While I think there are a number of solid reasons she cannot join, I unfortunately always fall on the rulea that are, "Oda can do anything and make it work", "It's One Piece", or the more recent "Luffy is ta'veren". Having said that, that was probably the single best argument for her joining I have seen. If Oda made it work, I would like seeing her on the crew. But there are certain things that I just cannot see working. A few of those things being that she possess the same "ability" that Luffy should be learning, and it would be somewhat lame for them to both have the same skillset. Another being her duty and position with the Kuja. The list goes on. But nice post! I almost felt like I was reading and Omake or something…
-
After getting Jimbei, Hancock, and Ace to join his prestigious crew, Luffy should get Shanks to join his crew. And Rayleigh will definitely join too, and he'll be first mate. Whitebeard, too, as cabin boy. And then Dragon should walk in and be the mopboy. Garp should be the assistant chef. The admirals will be barbers, since everyone needs a haircut. The nine other supernovas should join one of Luffy's many divisions. Oh, and the Shichibukai can be the cheerleaders. All together they can go on an adventure to defeat the notorious Rika and her gang of cuddly small animals.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I'm bored:sad:BTW, Rika is working with the Tomato Gang and kidnaps Pandaman.
This is really dangerous. They'll need help from Sengoku's goat, that is if that bastard doesn't betray them all (Luffy's team) and join Rika.Meanwhile, Coby and Helmeppo enter the Hyperbolic Time chamber and learn the fusion dance.
-
After getting Jimbei, Hancock, and Ace to join his prestigious crew, Luffy should get Shanks to join his crew. And Rayleigh will definitely join too, and he'll be first mate. Whitebeard, too, as cabin boy. And then Dragon should walk in and be the mopboy. Garp should be the assistant chef. The admirals will be barbers, since everyone needs a haircut. The nine other supernovas should join one of Luffy's many divisions. Oh, and the Shichibukai can be the cheerleaders. All together they can go on an adventure to defeat the notorious Rika and her gang of cuddly small animals.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
I'm bored:sad:BTW, Rika is working with the Tomato Gang and kidnaps Pandaman.
This is really dangerous. They'll need help from Sengoku's goat, that is if that bastard doesn't betray them all (Luffy's team) and join Rika.Meanwhile, Coby and Helmeppo enter the Hyperbolic Time chamber and learn the fusion dance.
and then Luffy found 5 WHOOOOOLE dollars!
but seriously, when IS Pandaman becoming an SH? he's been tailing them for how long now?
-
While I think there are a number of solid reasons she cannot join, I unfortunately always fall on the rulea that are, "Oda can do anything and make it work", "It's One Piece", or the more recent "Luffy is ta'veren". Having said that, that was probably the single best argument for her joining I have seen. If Oda made it work, I would like seeing her on the crew. But there are certain things that I just cannot see working. A few of those things being that she possess the same "ability" that Luffy should be learning, and it would be somewhat lame for them to both have the same skillset. Another being her duty and position with the Kuja. The list goes on. But nice post! I almost felt like I was reading and Omake or something…
Thanks man. and although I ain't pro-Hancock, I just HAD to write that. it's the humor that got me hooked on OP, and it's how I felt it would be like if she were to join. and I don't think it would be an issue if she has the same ability that Luffy should be learning because (1) I think Luffy's too much of an idiot to notice she has it and (2) If Luffy wants to learn it from her, she can't teach him seriously…
and you do have a point with her duty with the Kuja. Luffy would never in a million years let her join if it meant doom to the Kuja. (the same thing happened with Vivi in Alabasta... i think)
-
and then Luffy found 5 WHOOOOOLE dollars!
but seriously, when IS Pandaman becoming an SH? he's been tailing them for how long now?
Sugei! I can buy,… 2 packs of candy! Or a stick of meat! It's the best DAY! EVAR!!!!!!!!11!!111!!11ONE0ONEONEZEROZOROONEPIE!
Anyway, there's a gigantic prospect that Luffy's crew is complete, you know guys?
-
Sugei! I can buy,… 2 packs of candy! Or a stick of meat! It's the best DAY! EVAR!!!!!!!!11!!111!!11ONE0ONEONEZEROZOROONEPIE!
Anyway, there's a gigantic prospect that Luffy's crew is complete, you know guys?
i wouldn't say "gigantic", where's the proof of that??
and i won't personally be satisfied until he's reached 10 as thats what he said from the start. "…I think 10 men will do" or something like that, i think he was talking to himself... on of the first few chapters anyway
-
Well, how many more crew members are actually needed to complete his crew?
Oh God! I forgot about Vegapunk! He should be head physicist! How could I forget!
Although seriously, where's the "proof" that Jimbei will join? And no do not link me to Brennen's gargantuan argument for Jimbei joining. I read it, and there is 0 absolute solid evidence.
And a beam should join too!
-
Well, how many more crew members are actually needed to complete his crew?
And a beam should join too!
a beam certainly gets my vote, preferably a mystery beam! but to reach 10 he needs two more
I'm very anti Jimbei and i don't want any known characters to join. i'm a fan of new. But in my own perfect world, buggy would join, as little sense as that makes
-
Although seriously, where's the "proof" that Jimbei will join?
Has anyone said there was proof?
-
Has anyone said there was proof?
NOPE!
And your argument kind of breaks down on the part where you said Jimbei's crew split up. We know Arlong left, but that's not the entire crew splitting up.
More importantly, I apologize sincerely for my offensive remarks.
-
If there ever was an Ironclad "proof", we wouldn't call this thread "next nakama SPECULATION" would we?
-
Oops!!! posted too early… sorry bout that "igetownd"
-
Well, no one really needed proof to speculate in the first place. I just don't quite understand why people would go to such lengths to back up their opinions on subjects we have no effect over.
I could make an argument that Luffy's next bounty will be a billion, and will happen after he defeats an admiral in the New World, but I won't.
I guess it's a form of stylish approach to reading a series one loves. Some just like to kick back most of the time and read, while others like to debate eternally until the series loses its fans.
-
I just don't quite understand why people would go to such lengths to back up their opinions on subjects we have no effect over.
Some just like to kick back most of the time and read, while others like to debate eternally until the series loses its fans.
for some people, they just like to see how well they can deduce situations using the information already presented. Some people like to throw out random fanboy claims. Others do it to be internet dicks, lol
as to why they do it, we do it, its something that brings us closer as fans, uniting us to what we love, sharing opinions and ideas, knowing full well of out lack of actual influence. It's something to do to spend the time in between chapters. I doubt any series has ever lost its fanbase because of forum debates
-
You guys must have a LOT of time. I envy you. Or pity. I'm not sure.
Part of what frustrates me is that Greg and Brennen have successful careers while feel the complete freedom to debate and discuss their heart out. I do not pity them.
Anyway, I'm not sure how to continue the topic. Sorry.
-
You guys must have a LOT of time. I envy you. Or pity. I'm not sure.
this is not an attack this is an honest question, so please take it as such: if not to discuss One Piece, why did you join the site?
anyway back on topic:
I'm very hesitant to put my support behind a Shichi to join the crew of Luffy. I mean, after leading your own life and having such an honoring title, it seems like supporting someone else, as well as loosing your immunity from the WG would be a step down. Jimbei probably wouldn't care, but i really just don't see it
-
Honest answer: I wanted to make friends with people who, like me, love One Piece.
Anyway, next nakama needs, needs, needs, to be a girl. Well, not needs, but the crew needs a grandma, or a little sister. Preferably a little sister.
-
well said the both of you…
as to who their next nakama would be, I pretty sure Oda will find a way to make it work. it always does
-
Your argument kind of breaks down on the part where you said Jimbei's crew split up. We know Arlong left, but that's not the entire crew splitting up.
We know the crew split up. The comment from Yokasu about Arlong makes it clear that as part of joining the Shichibukai, Arlong left with some other cronies. We see quite a few people at Arlong Park, so we know a lot followed him. We know from Nyon that the crew split up completely though. I referenced it, but I might have trimmed that portion out of the "whole" theory. Keep in mind the theory was made up of an single small post, that expanded as I discussed it. In fact, that is–- well, I will get to that. Anyway, she doesn't seem to know why they split into several crews, but I believe we should know since Oda gave us other hints elsewhere. The rest is assumption on my part, and logic. Logic says that other fishmen wouldn't remain in a broken crew with a man who sided with the World Government for immunity. Of course, it is still possible he has a crew. Him being alone in prison seems to hint towards no crew though. Unless the rest are locked in other floors, but that would make Jinbei's escape too complicated.
[Chapter 521]
Nyon: And this Fisher Tiger fellow is now dead. It seems his fishman pirates have split into several crews.
@igetownd:Well, no one really needed proof to speculate in the first place. I just don't quite understand why people would go to such lengths to back up their opinions on subjects we have no effect over.
Most speculation – at least on my part -- comes from what we already know or have seen hinted at. I tend not to pull things out of nowhere or try to reason out the impossible. I will throw out ideas to chew on and discuss, but only for productive conversation. The ultimate reason is because discussing a story (especially on this scale) allows me to remember things I forgot when they are brought up in discussion, point out things I missed when they are brought up in discussion, and consider where I (we) think the story is heading in the near future. There are reasons outside of that, but that is why I spend "so much" time on here and discuss to my hearts content.
Part of what frustrates me is that Greg and Brennen have successful careers while feel the complete freedom to debate and discuss their heart out. I do not pity them.
And families. Not sure why that frustrates you. I work, I reserve most of my free time for my wife and child, I make time for my friends, I make time for my new house and extended family, I make time for hobbies, I make time for 2-3 college classes a semester, and I make time for reading a few books a month. Within the cracks of free time outside of that I read and post on the forum. While having a mobile phone that allows the freedom of posting whenever and wherever helps, it's really just a matter of balance.
-
i really don't like the idea that jinbei will join the strawhats.. but i foreseen about jinbei's story about how Whitebeard protected fishman island in chapter 529. I guess it will take fishman island arc to have a new nakama for the straw hats, and I think Jinbei will surely fill the spot. or maybe i hope xD
-
We know the crew split up. The comment from Yokasu about Arlong makes it clear that as part of joining the Shichibukai, Arlong left with some other cronies. We see quite a few people at Arlong Park, so we know a lot followed him. We know from Nyon that the crew split up completely though. I referenced it, but I might have trimmed that portion out of the "whole" theory. Keep in mind the theory was made up of an single small post, that expanded as I discussed it. In fact, that is–- well, I will get to that. Anyway, she doesn't seem to know why they split into several crews, but I believe we should know since Oda gave us other hints elsewhere. The rest is assumption on my part, and logic. Logic says that other fishmen wouldn't remain in a broken crew with a man who sided with the World Government for immunity. Of course, it is still possible he has a crew. Him being alone in prison seems to hint towards no crew though. Unless the rest are locked in other floors, but that would make Jinbei's escape too complicated.
[Chapter 521]
Nyon: And this Fisher Tiger fellow is now dead. It seems his fishman pirates have split into several crews.If Jimbei is a solo pirate, which I doubt because he has the qualities of a great leader, he may have a chance of joining. Even then, Jimbei won't join just because Luffy releases him. Luffy would either have to defeat the World Government and protect Whitebeard, which is not possible at this point in the story, or he'd have to take over Fishman Island and have the fame and influence to keep it peaceful. Luffy's not famous enough, even though he's known for defeating Enies Lobby.
Jimbei could join if Luffy takes down an admiral, but Luffy needs to master his Haki first. At this point in the story, he doesn't even know what's going on when he releases his Haki. However, Jimbei could serve the purpose of teaching Luffy Haki, since Jimbei was able to take down Ace to near death.
Of course, even Luffy with mastered Haki cannot defeat an admiral with his whole fleet (powerful subordinates & weapons). The whole crew needs to grow exponentially, with at least Luffy, Zoro and Sanji as Haki masters.
Most speculation – at least on my part -- comes from what we already know or have seen hinted at. I tend not to pull things out of nowhere or try to reason out the impossible. I will throw out ideas to chew on and discuss, but only for productive conversation. The ultimate reason is because discussing a story (especially on this scale) allows me to remember things I forgot when they are brought up in discussion, point out things I missed when they are brought up in discussion, and consider where I (we) think the story is heading in the near future. There are reasons outside of that, but that is why I spend "so much" time on here and discuss to my hearts content.
And families. Not sure why that frustrates you. I work, I reserve most of my free time for my wife and child, I make time for my friends, I make time for my new house and extended family, I make time for hobbies, I make time for 2-3 college classes a semester, and I make time for reading a few books a month. Within the cracks of free time outside of that I read and post on the forum. While having a mobile phone that allows the freedom of posting whenever and wherever helps, it's really just a matter of balance.
The reason I ended up questioning why discuss and speculate is because I had momentarily forgot due to jealousy clouding my thoughts. The whole point to discussion is to share ideas and receive opinions as feedback.
And jealousy is also the reason why I'm such a dick to you. I have to put aside that immature and malicious behavior, and use my emotions more constructively. Instead of wishing and trying to make other people fall, I can instead build up my strengths and bolster my weaknesses.
At this point I offer my sincere apologies. Gomennasai.
-
However, Jimbei could serve the purpose of teaching Luffy Haki, since Jimbei was able to take down Ace to near death.
This is assuming Ace had his logia already. I personally do not think he did for reasons shown in the manga, but there isn't much point debating it. I have said my reasons elsewhere though, if you want me to post them. As for the rest of what you said, I am not sure what you mean by some things, but it sounds like you didn't read (or pay attention to) all of my reasons for thinking he might join. Anyway, I never took offense to anything you said, so there is no reason to apologize. Outside of that, I take internet personalities low and high as a matter of course, so I feel there is no point in getting worked up over something someone says.
My best friend thinks Sphinx should join the crew. I agree. The real pet. Franky can make a perch for him at the top of the Sunny.
-
I could picture Jimbei in a colorspread. i still don't think he will join but I can picture him in one nonetheless. Though he would take up a lot of space.
-
The closest character that gives me a feeling of possible nakama would probably be hancock though im not entirely pleased with the idea.
Though, I hope for something better. I definitely believe that a female would be the next nakama. I root for a scientist profession hahaha~ someone to counter and give the SH advantage over WG weapons and stuff. As a scientist, it would also give useful knowledge about the devil fruit's power and stuff.
As for that character's usefulness, with the SH's need to become stronger, I don't see that character as personally someone strong but someone that can help them refine their techniques to its utmost potential and reducing the risks.
Ah well, those are basely based on my desire not from any characters introduced so far.
To have the next female as a tomboy would be of utmost horror to Sanji and interesting to luffy perhaps. LOL.
Just ideas for the next nakama ^^;
-
i really don't like the idea that jinbei will join the strawhats.. but i foreseen about jinbei's story about how Whitebeard protected fishman island in chapter 529. I guess it will take fishman island arc to have a new nakama for the straw hats, and I think Jinbei will surely fill the spot. or maybe i hope xD
LOL WUT?
16 characters of contradiction
-
If Jimbei is a solo pirate, which I doubt because he has the qualities of a great leader, he may have a chance of joining. Even then, Jimbei won't join just because Luffy releases him. Luffy would either have to defeat the World Government and protect Whitebeard, which is not possible at this point in the story, or he'd have to take over Fishman Island and have the fame and influence to keep it peaceful. Luffy's not famous enough, even though he's known for defeating Enies Lobby.
Jimbei could join if Luffy takes down an admiral, but Luffy needs to master his Haki first. At this point in the story, he doesn't even know what's going on when he releases his Haki. However, Jimbei could serve the purpose of teaching Luffy Haki, since Jimbei was able to take down Ace to near death.
Of course, even Luffy with mastered Haki cannot defeat an admiral with his whole fleet (powerful subordinates & weapons). The whole crew needs to grow exponentially, with at least Luffy, Zoro and Sanji as Haki masters.
The reason I ended up questioning why discuss and speculate is because I had momentarily forgot due to jealousy clouding my thoughts. The whole point to discussion is to share ideas and receive opinions as feedback.
And jealousy is also the reason why I'm such a dick to you. I have to put aside that immature and malicious behavior, and use my emotions more constructively. Instead of wishing and trying to make other people fall, I can instead build up my strengths and bolster my weaknesses.
At this point I offer my sincere apologies. Gomennasai.
I assume that he took Ace down to near death by consuming a large amount of seawater and performing an ironically similar act to what Luffy did against Crocodile with his spring water, with the exception that sea water would fuck ace worse than spring water, and then wailed on him with a physical beating while Ace was in a weakened state and unable to transform into fire, not that he's mastered Haki.
-
I don't think Jimbei will join, but I'm waiting for more on him before I play "Devil's Advocate" for him joining like I did with Hancock (at first, I was against Hancock joining, but after defending her I actually want her to join the crew, even while I still think she won't).
So far, we have seen too little of Jimbei. All we know is:
- He hates the "traditional" violent, pillaging pirates;
- He's siding with Whitebeard in this war;
- He fought Ace in the past;
- He's a whale-shark fishman;
- He's obviously strong.
We know no gimmicks, no dreams, no fighting style, no powers, no influence, nothing. It's too early to defend him joining (it's like defending Hancock after only two appearances…). He's a likeable character because he seems to be level-headed and honor-bound, unlike Hancock who was the queen bitch of the seas at first glance, but so far I can't see how Jimbei would add something to the crew that it currently lacks, nor how would he interact with the rest of the crew.
-
nah she wont join
-
I want Ace or Smoker in the crew.Jimbei has week chances to join , more probably Hancock than him.So for me Ace will join surely , because Luffy will not save him just to let him be imprisoned again.Withebeard will for sure loose the battle , and thatțs the end of Ace s dream.
-
Ace's destiny is indeed a mystery. I don't think he would wish to join Luffy, but then again I think WB's going to lose the war. If Oda had the guts to kill someone in the present, I'd say Ace would die trying to escape from Impel Down, and his last words would be for Luffy to help Whitebeard or something.
Anyway, Ace is a character that, while cool, I would not like to see in the crew. I dunno why, he just don't fit in my mind. Then again, it's just my opinion, and I am probably wrong anyway.
-
Well i think it will be Buggy i mean look they got a musician, doctor, carpenter, and all they need now is a….....Comedian lol well i think that Mr 3 and Buggy will join. Man Mr 3 looks more cooler and badass than before, fuck tht would be the best if he joins.
-
it think Mr3 and Mr2 will join buggies crew, that would be so comical that buggy will become the protagonist, or buggy joins luffy temporaroly untill he finds his own crew. that way you get the comedy stylings of all of them.
-
Personally I can only see 1 of 2 people joining if anybody joins and that's Mr 2, since we know unlike Buggy and Mr 3 he's not likely to try and take advantage of Luffy but rather genuinely help him, or Perona, if her and Zoro actualy bond which seems likely since Zoro is incapable of directing himself back to Shanbondy then I can see Luffy letting her join as thanks. Now the question is whether Perona wants to go back to Moria if she does her chances of joining are very low but so far as I can see she was living her dream but for the fact Kuma didn't provide any servants. The Thousand Sunny isn't particularly gloomy but I reckon Sanji would be willing to act as a servant although I don't think he matches Perona's cuteness requirement.
-
From what I gather, there's always a certain level of Idiocy with each crew member (with a bit of an exception with robin) and it's part of what makes it fun to read.
I'm not really on board with Hancock joining; but IF she does, it would look like this:
1. Luffy introduces her to the crew
2. Sanji nosebleeds all over
3. Hancock insultingly tells Sanji she only has eyes for Luffy
4. Sanji forgives her, but kicks luffy
5. Zorro insults Sanji even more, ignoring Hancock
6. Zorro has a bit of resistance to Hancock's charm thus making her look
down on him.
7. Nami gets charmed at first but it eventually fades when she learns
Hancock is a queen of an entire island (Hinting that Hancock is very rich!
<dollar signs="" on="" her="" eyes="">).
8. Usopp introduces himself as being the REAL captain of the ship (ignored)
9. Franky introduces himself with a dance.
10. Hancock insults Franky's perverted appearance and bends back even
more, looking down on him.
11. Hancock hesitates to talk to Brooke; being a skeleton and all…
12. Then Brooke asks Hancock if she could show him her panties
13. Now Hancock is practically looking up as she insults the skinless
musician while he gets a beating from Nami and Sanji
14. The shy Chopper politely introduces himself to Hancock.
15. She kicks Chopper saying "why is there a cute Reindeer in my way?"
16. Chopper starts his weird dance saying " Calling me a CUTE reindeer
doesn't make me happy at all!!"
17. Robin calmly smiles while watching everyone.
18. Luffy tell's Hancock to not kick Chopper...
19. She quickly hears Luffy's voice and behaves herself...
20. and it goes on and on.....Call me crazy but it's pretty much Vintage everyday Strawhat madness...</dollar>
i puked in my mouth a little :sad:
-
So a post from the Brook thread got me thinking, and I remembered how incredibly strange Oda is. Jinbei aside, the next or last crewmember (hopefully a female) could seriously be or have anything. I think most people agree that as far as Devil's Fruits are concerned, chances are we will not have any more crew members with a Zoan fruit, as Chopper's rumble ball makes that category extremely unique, and we will likely not have a Logia user as it is fairly broken. Given that, think about the female Paramecia's we have seen: Hancock and her stoning/pistol kiss, Bonney and her age changing abilities, Robin and her body parts, Kalifa and her soap, Alvida and her slippage, Hina and her cage, Miss Valentine and her weight control, and Miss Doublefinger and her spikes. I think that covers them all. Anyways, while each of them has varying amounts of natural strength and fighting ability, they all have a Devil's Fruit that gives them an extremely unique – yet useful -- secondary fighting ability. Thinking about the possibilities, I of course hope to see a strong female fighter, but wonder if Oda has plans to add another paramecia to the crew, and if so what kind of strange ability will he add next?
Anyway, this isn't anything new, I just figured I would voice my thoughts...
-
It is really, really hard to predict devil fruits. We often think things like "Metal Fruit" or "Wind Fruit", and then Oda comes up with Soap Fruit that rubs strength off.
-
I suppose there is the possibility of a weapon that's eaten/absorbed/whatever a Devil Fruit. And then there're the possibilities of what would happen if one of those snakes the Amazons carried around were to swallow one…
-
Hancock will surely join.Either that or she will die because of love for Luffy.
-
Saldeath will join the crew. He is unique and cool and a monkey.
-
Too big to go inside, interact normally, or generally do anything else on the ship other than sit around on the deck looking silly.
-
Poor Saul.
-
Meh the SH have a onboard shipwright. If Franky wanted to he can make a area for a giant SH to stay at. It's not like Franky can't add on to the ship if the need arises.
-
Silence Pheonix! You will not get in between Crossword and I!
-
Silence Pheonix! You will not get in between Crossword and I!
Why the hostility? I wasn't even copying you.
-
I find it kinda silly though that people think that Jinbei has a higher chance of joining than Hancock though. Not that I believe either would join but if it were a choice between the two, it would definitely be Hancock. She has a tragic past, her own gag routines, she's normal-sized so she can fit inside a ship and interact with everyone and she has a possible motive that is her love for Luffy. Oh and the crew desperately needs another women. There's enough male testosterone suffocating the air on thier ship. Also it'd be really funny if not only was their next crewmate a shickibukai, but one of the most beautiful women in the world. I mean seriously, Luffy has the devil's luck finding crew-mates
-
Too big to go inside, interact normally, or generally do anything else on the ship other than sit around on the deck looking silly.
Feast your eyes on THIS!
!
! ^^ The conversation and the backdrop makes this scene feel somewhat…inappropriate. -
Doesn't that sort of prove my point? It does look a bit silly.
Why the hostility?
Because our battle is a (in)glorious struggle between two men. Once two men throw down the gauntlet, no one is allowed to intervene between the two.
Now, on a lighter and more productive note, I'm curious to know what the allure of Jimbei as a Straw Hat is, other than any sort of coolness factor, because while I would like a Fishman Straw Hat just as much as the next guy, but this is not how I would want it. Wouldn't a totally new character, relatively unestablished in the world, fit in better with series theme and be more interesting and exciting?
Actually, wouldn't Jimbei as a potential ally kind of open the door to a new Fishman possibly joining, as per the mentor/Obi-Wan character pattern we've seen? (Shanks, Kunia, Bellemere, Yasopp, Zeff, Hiriluk, Saul/Clover/Olivia, Tom, Yorki,
Hancocketc.) -
Damn I forgot they even had a giant fishtank. Jinbei can just stay in there.