Whoa! WoW!
Thanks for the great work!
Recently I was also planning to make a comparison, but the workload was just, well, never mind lol.
Here are some of my thoughts:
Ichikawa: I don't know why, but the Chopper shot wasn't that Ichikawa-like to me, maybe he only corrected a little in that cut or it was by another animator? I personally prefer these shots that had a noticeable Ichikawa's style:
!
By the way, it seems that the anime staff collected some of Ichikawa's corrections and shared them with animators. Here are some LQ scans of these corrections:
!
By the way, since Ichikawa's corrections are everywhere in this arc, maybe we can add more of his works in the comparison chart? For example:
Hisada: Too bad Hisada has been too busy with designing the endless characters created by Oda, and because of which many of Hisada's episodes nowadays were rushed.
I remembered that #669 by Hisada and Ueda had some Luffy shots which were really nice and might look better than the shot in this comparison chart. Additionally, the following shot was from #803 and I liked it a lot:
!
! (I think Ichikawa didn't touch this Nami shot.)
Takagi: I'm not sure because I haven't watched Takagi's episodes again recently, but It seems we had some better Luffy shots in his episodes in WCI arc? And maybe we'll find some better Sanji shots in the 2015 winter SP.
Shingaki:
Really don't know what happened to him. Really.
S. Ito:
I remember that #762 had some nice Sanji shots by Ito. (I totally agree that it's really painful to find a decent Sanji shot by regular ADs.)
!
! (I only had this shot on my computer sorry.)
Matsuda: Matsuda has learned quite a lot from Sato from Film Gold and Episode of East Blue, and her current style is more Sato-like compared to Hisada. Matsuda's recent works might be more representative.
!
!
!
!
!
K. Ito:
It seems the Luffy and Nami shots were corrected by Ichikawa.