Link/Zelda/Ganondorf won't move out the Smash series. I just wish they'll completely declone Ganondorf. He has so much possible moves to build an original moveset it's painful to see him as a clone. Make him use his trademark magic volleyball attack or his other magic attacks, use his trident (or a sword … but the series is already crowded with swordmen), maybe make him glide,... but declone it!!
For the other characters, I don't really want two version of Link since it's kinda pointless but, if they declone Toon Link, why not. I'd still choose an original character over him.
I wouldn't be against Sheik moveset being separated from Zelda and given to Impa since she's been in the series since ages and her last incarnation can perfectly use the same moves. Everybody use Sheik or Zelda, not both so it's kinda pointless to have them as one character and Sheik only appears in one game. Plus, it would unlock the down+b move for each character.For a completely new slot, Vaati or Tingle have a chance.
- Vaati is the only other bad guy besides Ganondorf who appears in more than one game.
- Tingle is THE secondary character of the Zelda series and has got 3 games on his own. And he's amazing. And he has an awesome potential for moveset. My personal take: a money centric moveset. He has a rupee counter over his emblem and gain rupees by dealing damage. The effect of his B moves depends on how much he spend rupees to use them (while charging). He could hire bodyguards (stronger ones come with more rupees), use balloons (number depends on rupees), shoot rupees (green, blue or red),...
That sounds pretty good to me (except tingle), and i totally agree we dont need two iterations of the same character so toon link can jump into death mountain for all i care.
Id be happy if it went like this for zelda reps:
Link (Skyward Sword Version)
Zelda (Skyward Sword Version)
Impa (Either connected to zelda by down b instead of sheik, or a split character)
Ganondorf (New moveset and possibly with a SS redesign somewhat like how sheik got a TP one for brawl)
New Zelda Reps:
Ghirahim
or
Vaati