Well, Jean Bart and Brook would be better examples. Former captains.
Not that I am supporting Bonney. Just saying.
Last Two Nakamates (vol. 5)
-
-
Frankie was, and so was Robin . Those two were serious enemies of the Straw hats. Bonney seems more in the leagues of the straw hats. I'm still pissed Oda didn't want to get Wiper as a crew mate dude was freaking beast
-
@Tokoro:
Well Brook lead a crew…then again he took it over from someone else and it essentially all died under his command but at least he had an extra life.
Honestly, unless Oda says otherwise, we really should just close the book on most of these candidates and wait and see if any substantial evidence shows up between now and Fishman Island.
But considering we're the ones who wrote the books (well, AGOG wrote the Perona for Nakama book) how can we possibly abandon them now?
-
They would be better examples but they too no longer had a crew due to death or slavery.
-
Ace was the leader of the Spade Pirates at a time.
-
@Superbear:
Ace was the leader of the Spade Pirates at a time.
Yeah, and that proves something since he joined the crew. And is still alive.
-
@El:
Frankie was, and so was Robin .
Was what? Pirate captains?
Robin wasn't even the leader of the opposing faction.
I did specifically say pirate captains that left their pirate crew to join the SHs.
Not characters that use to be enemies.
@Superbear:Ace was the leader of the Spade Pirates at a time.
I forgot when he became a SH.
More importantly, Ace got his ass beat and he and his entire crew were allowed in to the WB pirates.
LuffyOda aint doing that shit -
Yeah, and that proves something since he joined the crew. And is still alive.
No what I'm saying was that he was the leader of his own crew but then joined Whitebeard.
-
Bonney won't join.
-
This goes for any SN or any other pirate captain of a crew.
-
@Superbear:
No what I'm saying was that he was the leader of his own crew but then joined Whitebeard.
Oh, somebody rename this thread the Last 1592 Nakamates thread, because apparently Luffy is doing what WB did.
-
-
Why is anyone even addressing the Bonney thing? It should be taken just about as seriously as someone saying "Enel 4 nakama!"
-
A chapter is out. Fans scramble. Endeavoring to seek a chance to be the first one to predict the new member, trampling on each other to be the first one to be right.
You heard it here first, bitches!!
I told ya bitches, he/she joined~~!!! -
@Zik:
Was what? Pirate captains?
Robin wasn't even the leader of the opposing faction.
I did specifically say pirate captains that left their pirate crew to join the SHs.
Not characters that use to be enemies.
I forgot when he became a SH.
More importantly, Ace got his ass beat and he and his entire crew were allowed in to the WB pirates.
LuffyOda aint doing that shitNo I was trying to point out that it is possible for a pirate captain to become a member of another captain's crew. Hey look at Blackbeard's new members, you can't tell me that none of the Level 6 prisoners weren't captains of the own crews at some point.
-
I don't know how anyone is getting Bonney joining vibes from the latest chapter.
Clearly its Law and Bepo that will be joining the crew. He's waiting for Luffy to come out of hiding and everything.
-
At least Bonney could have her own custom color. The same can't be said for the other candidates.
-
@Superbear:
At least Bonney could have her own custom color. The same can't be said for the other candidates.
That shit isn't valid or relevant. It isn't a point at all in ANY shape or form. Only a dumbass would believe otherwise.
A random color Oda gives a SH in the SBS does not prevent characters from joining. They join first and then get a color.
@Superbear:No I was trying to point out that it is possible for a pirate captain to become a member of another captain's crew.
Yeah when Luffy and his crew defeats them and IF he wants them to join.
-
Yeah, it's possible for a captain to become part of another crew. But my impression is that Ace's men joined with him, which isn't happening with a bunch of fodder and the SHs. And honestly, I would have to call it sexism if the only female supernova gave up being a captain to work under another pirate.
At least Bonney could have her own custom color. The same can't be said for the other candidates.
I don't think any of these choices are going to join, but sorry, actually being connected to Luffy and the SHs trumps little crap like this. I hate it when people use animals/colors/family members to back up their nakama arguments. It's little extra stuff that doesn't affect the actual manga. I could give a "color" to every side character with a backstory, but that doesn't mean they'll join.
-
@Zik:
That shit isn't valid or relevant. It isn't a point at all in ANY shape or form. Only a dumbass would believe otherwise.
A random color Oda gives a SH in the SBS does not prevent characters from joining. They join first and then get a color.
Yeah when Luffy and his crew defeats them and IF he wants them to join.
So uniqueness isn't valid?
That wasn't the point I was trying to make but whatever.
-
jesus christ shut up about bonney
akianu 4 nakama, he was in chapters and talked and stuff HE MUST BE A STRAWHAT!!!
-
San Juan Wolf seems to be not popular in the BB crew. That is an obvious hint that he will betray them someday and join the Sh. Along with Avaro. This is undeniable.
-
@Superbear:
So uniqueness isn't valid?
That wasn't the point I was trying to make but whatever.
Ha! Not when you're talking about a category that is irrelevant and has no bearing on who joins the crew.
How is she unique because of that when Hina and Perona and whoever else have been shown to have pink hair?
-
why are no rocks being suggested, they are VALID candidates
-
Bonney will NOT join. End of discussion.
-
@Sea:
San Juan Wolf seems to be not popular in the BB crew. That is an obvious hint that he will betray them someday and join the Sh. Along with Avaro. This is undeniable.
I could see him and Luffy having an eating contest, and Luffy still ends up winning.
-
@Zik:
Ha! Not when you're talking about a category that is irrelevant and has no bearing on who joins the crew.
How is she unique because of that when Hina and Perona and whoever else have been shown to have pink hair?
Sigh Pink wasn't the color I was looking at. Besides why would I choose that when its on the crew already?
-
-
@Superbear:
Sigh Pink wasn't the color I was looking at. Besides why would I choose that when its on the crew already?
You've already said that Bonney has some custom color and that can't be said for other candidates. That's a stupid argument and it's not even a valid point as it pertains to the next nakama.
Maybe you're stupidity knows no bounds and you forgot that somebody else already has pink in the crew?
-
why are no rocks being suggested, they are VALID candidates
The rock would make an excellent duo fight with Usopp.
-
@Zik:
You've already said that Bonney has some custom color and that can't be said for other candidates. That's a stupid argument and it's not even a valid point as it pertains to the next nakama.
Maybe you're stupidity knows no bounds and you forgot that somebody else already has pink in the crew?
Woah someone getting serious. But I was thinking brown seeing as how there's brown in her costume, and that would fall into her smell and personality as well. I'm not saying she will join but she's far more interesting than anyone else as of late so why not?
-
@Superbear:
Woah someone getting serious. But I was thinking brown seeing as how there's brown in her costume, and that would fall into her smell and personality as well. I'm not saying she will join but she's far more interesting than anyone else as of late so why not?
So you're just making baseless speculation about her custom color and claiming no other character has one.
You know, that shade of gray on rock must be its custom color so rock obviously has the best chances of all candidates.
-
@Zik:
So you're just making baseless speculation about her custom color and claiming no other character has one.
You know, that shade of gray on rock must be its custom color so rock obviously has the best chances of all candidates.Well its not that hard to see that the other candidates don't have one. Unless you're a rock and have no eyes. But seriously I'm not claiming that there's no one with a custom color, I'm saying tat out of the popular three choices there is no one.
-
I'm not saying she will join but she's far more interesting than anyone else as of late so why not?
"Interesting" is subjective (not that I don't find Bonney interesting, but I think Jimbei and Hancock are too.) She doesn't have any connection to the SHs, and her plot has nothing to do with them. There are plenty of side characters with interesting backstories. And it's not a "cool characters" thread but a "people who might actually have a chance at joining" thread.
Well its not that hard to see that the other candidates don't have one. Unless you're a rock and have no eyes.
I have no idea how you came up with brown. I'm pretty sure I could find some small detail in Hancock's clothing, make that her color, and connect it randomly to her personality.
-
"Interesting" is subjective (not that I don't find Bonney interesting, but I think Jimbei and Hancock are too.) She doesn't have any connection to the SHs, and her plot has nothing to do with them. There are plenty of side characters with interesting backstories. And it's not a "cool characters" thread but a "people who might actually have a chance at joining" thread.
She's Marine related, possibly Akainu related,and she has some sort of vendetta towards Blackbeard.
Brown lines on pants, brown, and spenders brown Jacket.
-
@Superbear:
Well its not that hard to see that the other candidates don't have one. Unless you're a rock and have no eyes. But seriously I'm not claiming that there's no one with a custom color, I'm saying tat out of the popular three choices there is no one.
What are you talking about? By making Bonney a candidate, everyone else is a candidate. You can't say every other character shown doesn't have their own custom color.
Plus rock's custom color is gray.
The popular candidates were never joining so if that's the point you were making then Bonney would be ahead of candidates with chances below zero but she has even less of a chance so she's still behind.
-
@Zik:
What are you talking about? By making Bonney a candidate, everyone else is a candidate. You can't say every other character shown doesn't have their own custom color.
Plus rock's custom color is gray.
The popular candidates were never joining so if that's the point you were making then Bonney would be ahead of candidates with chances below zero but she has even less of a chance so she's still behind.
I see what you mean but the arc is not over yet so you can't say that; I mean people said that Moria was going to die but is he dead? No.
The Rock won't join its obviously the Red line who's gonna join, gosh. -
She's Marine related, possibly Akainu related,and she has some sort of vendetta towards Blackbeard.
Brown lines on pants, brown, and spenders brown Jacket.
But her plot hasn't intersected with the SHs' at all. Yeah, it'll interconnect at some point, if only to give more understanding to the Gorusei/Akainu/Whitebeard/whatever, but every other crew member has been connected to the SHs since their first introduction. Even Robin as a villain was shown meaningfully interacting with them.
And like I said, just choose a color from any potential nakama's clothing. Brown hardly seemed obvious to me.I see what you mean but the arc is not over yet so you can't say that; I mean people said that Moria was going to die but is he dead? No.
Then we can point at any random side character and say "they might join." After all, we don't know what'll happen next. But as of now, she has had no interaction with Luffy and the SHs. Come back when that has happened.
-
Then we can point at any random side character and say "they might join." After all, we don't know what'll happen next. But as of now, she has had no interaction with Luffy and the SHs. Come back when that has happened.
She protected Zoro in Shabondy.
-
After reading this discussion, I now hope to see a character with a rock-based Devil Fruit in the future so I can use these amazing theories.
-
After reading this discussion, I now hope to see a character with a rock-based Devil Fruit in the future so I can use these amazing theories.
That would be awesome! I hope its a Logia that can break apart into tiny pebbles.
Wait that "former boss" thing that was mentioned does fit her, just saying.
-
@Superbear:
I see what you mean but the arc is not over yet so you can't say that; I mean people said that Moria was going to die but is he dead? No.
The Rock won't join its obviously the Red line who's gonna join, gosh.I can and I did.
-
@Superbear:
Wait that "former boss" thing that was mentioned does fit her, just saying.
I guess I overlooked the chapter where the Straw Hats had to foil the villainous schemes of Bonney and her crew. Anyone care to summarize it for me?
-
I guess I overlooked the chapter where the Straw Hats had to foil the villainous schemes of Bonney and her crew. Anyone care to summarize it for me?
No, no, no, it was something mentioned in a SBS about the next crew member being a former boss. Boss doesn't have to amply to an enemy.
-
I think Sabo's going to be the last crewmate. I'm not going to be a big fan of the idea until we see what he and his abilities are like in present time, but I've had a hunch since this page: http://www.mangareader.net/103-51821-11/one-piece/chapter-585.html. His dream is just so specific and random (him writing didn't have any relevance in the flashback and doesn't serve any purpose if he's a revolutionary.) I really can't think of any other reason for that panel - it would have been easier to just have him say that he's going to be a pirate. If he does join, it won't be for a while, though.
-
To be honest I didn't I just remembered that being said by Oda at some point. But judging by what I have read so far "boss character" could be anyone, the Strawhats have encountered who holds some sort of leadership position.
-
The SHs never met Bonney. Only Zoro did and he didn't know who she was.
I should've realized this is what Oda meant all along though. He's so unpredictable.
-
Wow this thread really is run by trolls, all the constant no X can't join, without backing it up at all, look her crew is nearly dead and she is linked to further chapters with her escaping the WG for some reason so she will be in the story further, also is now linked with who most think will be one of the final major villians in OP (BB). Comparing her to Akainu who wants Luffy dead for justice is insane, and Enel hasn't shown up in how many chapters?
-
@Zik:
The SHs never met Bonney. Only Zoro did and he didn't know who she was.
I should've realized this is what Oda meant all along though. He's so unpredictable.
Yep random encounters don't mean anything, I mean Ace drinking with Buggy didn't do anything for Buggy story wise later on.