I threw the list of contestants into excel and alphabatized it for those who wanted that:
! Absalom (Sid)
Admiral Akainu (LeeWii)
Admiral Aokiji (Ao kiji)
Admiral Kizaru (Melville)
Alvida (MooseLizard)
Aphelandra (Silence)
Arlong (Dragon Warrior)
Aum (Zkaiser)
Banchi (Urouge)
Bartholomew Kuma (MagneticMonkey)
Basil Hawkins (PenguinHat)
Bellamy (vgmusic15)
Bellemere (Captain Hypersock)
Benn Beckman (Dark_Kaomi)
Bepo (supertramp law)
Blackbeard (Vanessa)
Blueno (BarrelCrate)
Boa Hancock (Boa Hancock)
Boa Sandersonia (BakaFish)
Brook (Cyborg009)
Buggy (Mdmartin101)
Calgara (chpollastrini)
Calico Yorki (Palochka)
Camie (igetownd)
Capone Bege (DanialG)
Captain Hina (moshi)
Carue (Togashi)
Coby (Hiroy)
Commodore Smoker (Buuhan1)
Domino (Local-Chan)
Don Krieg (ultimateclima)
Donquixote Doflamingo (Don Quichotte De Flamingo)
Dorry (Monkenda_mint)
Dr. Hiluluk (Oni_Santoryu)
Dr. Hogback (Dinkleberg)
Dr. Kureha (TräshCät)
Dracule Mihawk (SperoHawk)
Dragon (tigerlilly)
Duval (myogatheflea)
Emporio Ivankov (rusashi)
Eustass Kid (lelandlancaster)
Fleet Admiral Sengoku (meOme)
Foxy (fedcom)
Franky (winner 2005)
Funkfried (Calvero)
Gecko Moria (Moria)
Gedatsu (Crampz)
Gin (l2agnarok)
God Enel (V3N0M1300)
Going Merry (Lunalie)
Gol D. Roger (Jadosra)
Hannyabal (Sanigo)
Hatchan (Gecko135)
Iceburg (phyrros)
Igaram (kaizoku_chopper)
Inazuma (PiratehunterZoro)
Jabura (dRizzit)
Jaguar D. Saul (freedom)
Jambarl/Jean Bart (Whisper Shadowlight)
Jango (Psycho_Kenshin)
Jesus Burgess (h3h3h3)
Jewelry Bonney (Satsuki)
Jinbei (Jazzfeezy)
Joz (Mister Yakuza)
Kaku (Bobjr)
Kalifa (123)
Killer (Neaeran)
Kokoro (DarkNo)
Kumacy/Bearsy (Bounty1Berry)
Kumadori (onemoment)
Kuro (ron_8)
Laboon (andyprue)
Lafitte (Goty)
Lola (Mau)
Lucky Roux (Fury283)
Magellan (sunwukong)
Marco (nino rojo)
Margaret (darktravis)
Minotauros (Jarhead)
Miss Goldenweek (eapark)
Miss Valentine (KitsuneInferno)
Mohmoo (Setzer)
Monkey D. Luffy (dirt monkey AL)
Montblanc Cricket (Deltron 3030)
Mr. 1 (The Faithful Shinigami)
Mr. 2, Bon Kurei (Aduross)
Mr. 3 (El Pinguino)
Mr. 5 (Yonkou#3)
Nami (InglingX)
Nefertari Vivi (naterio)
Nico Olvia (Sanji)
Nico Robin (fxjoey0)
Norla (Zell_D_Monkey)
Odz (Roblebear)
Owner Zeff (ABSMr.Prince)
Pandaman (Pritesh)
Paulie (Solid)
Pell (The King)
Perona (Insider2000)
Portgas D. Ace (Stariana)
Richie (Dwragon)
Rob Lucci (Super Franky)
Roronoa Zoro (MrXYZ)
Ryuma (brennen.exe)
Sadi-Chan (Detheroc)
Sanji (threedayslater)
Scratchmen Apoo (GODA 8000)
Shackey (2nd Vote: Ivotas)
Shanks (Kairouseki)
ShuShu (Uso4lyfe)
Silvers Rayleigh (Coolnerd89)
Sir Crocodile (Ivotas)
Spandam (Vegetto2k2)
Stronger (Ubiq)
Tashigi (Tare_chan)
Tom (normyk)
Tony Tony Chopper (Capt Haggis)
Trafalgar Law (Zach Logan)
Urouge (Battle Franky)
Usopp (winner 2004)
Van Auger (TakinawaTonfa)
Vice Admiral Garp (Megadoomer)
Vice Admiral Momonga (gilligans island)
Wapol (Spah)
Whitebeard (sridharpolina)
Wiper (Sano)
X Drake (HEATXZ)
Yasopp (JaN JAC)
And here's an alphabatized list of characters who didn't happen to make the cut this time around (not complete):
! Aisa
Baskerville
Braham
Brogy
Buchi
Cabaji
Carne
Chaka
Chessmarimo
Chew
Chimney
Cindry
Clover
Cobra
Conis
Crocus
Dalton
Doc Q
Fukurou
Fullbody
Gaimon
Gan Fall
Gen
Gomorrah
Gonbe
Gyatharin
Halmeppo
Hattori
Hiiguma
Hildon
Kaashi
Kamakiri
Kaya
Kiwi
Kohza
Kuina
Kuroobi
Laki
Lasso the Gun-Dog
Lulu
Makino
Mariegold
Masira
Miss Doublefinger
Miss Merrychristmas
Mohji
Monblanc Norland
Morgan
Mozu
Mr. 4
Nero
Nezumi
Nojiko
Oimo
Papagg
Patty
Pearl
Pierre
Porche
Rockstar
Satori
Sentomarou
Sham
Shoujou
Shura
Sodom
Spandine
St Charlos
T-bone
Terracotta
Tileston
Tojit
Toto
Vice Admiral (all but Garp and Momonga)
Wanze
Woop Slap
Yama
Yokozuna
Zambai