thunk
You people !! Can't you just keep one big thread down about our gaikotsu ? Criminy. I have merged this thread w/ Brooke and the Strawhats.
thunk
You people !! Can't you just keep one big thread down about our gaikotsu ? Criminy. I have merged this thread w/ Brooke and the Strawhats.
brooke's VA needs to be the guy who did Mr. 7 >: [
the guy who did kuwabara(yuu yuu hakusho) and Don Kan'onji(bleach) i think its the same
chiba shigure I guess
Sarcasm taken. But if Doflamingo is related to anyone, it's Goldenweek. Their powers are similar in that they exert control over people. And they both dress flamboyantly.
Must you point out tiny similarities and try to blown them out of proportion, crafting crazed theories about how "puns" that make absolutely no sense mean that some people are related to others?
Gah. Apologies for any offence but that "10-11" stuff was absolute crap.
he'll probaly be the fastest SH..
Gear 2 and Sanji.
I'm not so sure about him. He has stated he would like to join the Strawhats in battle.
I've made a "clean" Brooke for your viewing pleasure. Feel free to impose text on it.
thunk
You people !! Can't you just keep one big thread down about our gaikotsu ? Criminy. I have merged this thread w/ Brooke and the Strawhats.
WhatĀ“s done is done ā¦
...but I really canĀ“t see the need of it (nor like it).
I think itĀ“s quite natural that Brooke stirs up a lot of discussion (with quite a possibility of becoming the next nakama). And due to this "importance" I think that different aspects deserve their own threads. Some of them may be stupid or sucked dry over the time but then you might as well close them or just let them die rather than create one big garbage-thread. Just my feeling.
EDIT: per example I donĀ“t like it to find my post under the reference "Admiral Aokiji and Brooke are relative!!??" - I would not have been seen dead in this thread:getlost:
Must you point out tiny similarities and try to blown them out of proportion, crafting crazed theories about how "puns" that make absolutely no sense mean that some people are related to others?
Gah. Apologies for any offence but that "10-11" stuff was absolute crap.
Gear 2 and Sanji.
I'm not so sure about him. He has stated he would like to join the Strawhats in battle.
I've made a "clean" Brooke for your viewing pleasure. Feel free to impose text on it.
[qimg]http://img45.imageshack.us/img45/4599/skellieyo8.png[/qimg]
If it turns out that Doflamingo's power over people is not a DF, then it would be painfully obvious. They're both individuals who exert control over people using unorthodox methods.
And I apologize for the "Brook is Mr. 11" idea. But seriously, what would the point be of introducing a named character just to kill him off? Especially one with a distinct look?
And I apologize for the "Brook is Mr. 11" idea. But seriously, what would the point be of introducing a named character just to kill him off? Especially one with a distinct look?
He was not very distinctly looking. A moustache and flamboyant stuff, he is overrode by people such as Franky.
Now who wants pork chops?
So, with the Yomi Yomi no mi, can he only come back once, or as many times as he wants?
@Impel:
So, with the Yomi Yomi no mi, can he only come back once, or as many times as he wants?
only once i believe..
anyways..to those who are saying brook is evil-
he left the booat already-that means he has no bad intentions
[1] besides he's a musician
[2] luffy is persistent in wanting him to join..
[3] he has aa complete different and unique personality compared to other strawhats
add those 3 and you'll get our newest crewmember
You should change your sig from Chopper / Doc Q to Brooke / Doc Q (Dr. Death vs. Death itself) and add Chopper / Stronger if he joins. XD
@Fire Fist:
You should change your sig from Chopper / Doc Q to Brooke / Doc Q (Dr. Death vs. Death itself) and add Chopper / Stronger if he joins. XD
that would be cool!! Dr. Death vs. Death itself**
although brook and laffite seems to have similarities as well (cane)
i'll just wait and see(hoping) if he joins..
Who is Zoro fighting in your BB vs SH fight anyway?
random thought here so bear with me.
Based on what Broke told us, his power allows the soul to return to its body after death, but as seen in Brooke's case that works regardless of the condition the body is in so based on that what would happen if someone's body was completely destroyed when they were killed? let's say the DF user was blown up and killedā¦ then what?
Look, you die and your soul gets to come back or just float around. It doesn't matter how you died.
random thought here so bear with me.
Based on what Broke told us, his power allows the soul to return to its body after death, but as seen in Brooke's case that works regardless of the condition the body is in so based on that what would happen if someone's body was completely destroyed when they were killed? let's say the DF user was blown up and killedā¦ then what?
Get to another body, and it doesnt have to be a human body..i guess it could be like Kon's situation from Bleach.
It would reassemble.
Possibly. Since Brooke's joints would have rotted or something.
@Impel:
Who is Zoro fighting in your BB vs SH fight anyway?
i guessing that BB is their final battle, if it is,
then mihawk will be his final opponent-i didn't include him bec. he's not on BB's crew
Everyone will fight someone one-on-one on Raftel. It'll probably be;
Luffy vs Blackbeard, Sanji vs Laffite, Usopp/ Sogeking vs Van Auger, Franky vs Burgess, Chopper or Brooke (if he joins) vs Doc Q.
Zoro wont need to fight any of the BB pirates because he'll be fighting Mihawk. So that's;
Zoro vs Mihawk.
I'm guessing Robin will end up fighting one of the Admirals; most likely Aokiji but maybe Akainu. So that's;
Robin vs Aokiji or Akainu.
With Nami, it's difficult to say. But I think she'll end up fighting Hina. So;
Nami vs Hina.
So Brooke could go into a pair of Robin's underwear with his soul.
http://www.msnusers.com/onepiecemangav-3/chapter443mq.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=10727
I've been wondering here, what Brooke's "wish" is. He says that it's rather fortunate that Thriller Park has come, and that his wish has come true.
Could this mean the guy who stole his shadow is nearby? On the island?
@$abZ:
http://www.msnusers.com/onepiecemangav-3/chapter443mq.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=10727
I've been wondering here, what Brooke's "wish" is. He says that it's rather fortunate that Thriller Park has come, and that his wish has come true.
Could this mean the guy who stole his shadow is nearby? On the island?
Uh, by his wish he obviously meant to meeting the guy who stole his shadow. That's the only thing that's keeping him from leaving there.
I think. I really think.
Anyways, I think some of you didn't get Brooke's DF ability, or I didn't. Here's what I got [fix me if I got a theory instead of fact]:
1. It grants him the ability to leave the road to heaven and come back to earth as a pure soul.
2. It grants him the ability to resurrect with his body once found.
2.a. No matter what shape the body is in, Brooke will be able to live again with it.
2.b. If the body is seriously injured and is missing parts that are needed to live, the DF will grant him "imaginative" ones who besically don't exist. So in Brooke's case, his muscles will exist while not exist. His muscles are designed to a human body, not to something as light as a skeleton, explaining his jump power and overall speed.
3. Brooke will be unable to swin before death. Unknown if this applies to the new life too, but likely so.
That's how it is, I think. You're welcomed to fix me or tell me it's true. Hopes that if it's true it'll clear things up.
@Rai:
Uh, by his wish he obviously meant to meeting the guy who stole his shadow. That's the only thing that's keeping him from leaving there.
I think. I really think.
Uh, it's obvious how?
Obvious isn't the correct word here.
So here's what I think: The Florian Triange exit is the big lips, which are controlled by chains that are connected to Thriller Barque. So basically, Thriller B. tracks ships in the Florian, cuts them off and kills them/steals their shadows.
Uhhhh I thought that Brooke's wish was to be a crewmate but he couldnt because he would die in the outside world, ergo his wish is to get his Shadow back so he can leave.
@Rai:
Uh, by his wish he obviously meant to meeting the guy who stole his shadow. That's the only thing that's keeping him from leaving there.
I think. I really think.Anyways, I think some of you didn't get Brooke's DF ability, or I didn't. Here's what I got [fix me if I got a theory instead of fact]:
1. It grants him the ability to leave the road to heaven and come back to earth as a pure soul.
2. It grants him the ability to resurrect with his body once found.
2.a. No matter what shape the body is in, Brooke will be able to live again with it.
2.b. If the body is seriously injured and is missing parts that are needed to live, the DF will grant him "imaginative" ones who besically don't exist. So in Brooke's case, his muscles will exist while not exist. His muscles are designed to a human body, not to something as light as a skeleton, explaining his jump power and overall speed.
3. Brooke will be unable to swin before death. Unknown if this applies to the new life too, but likely so.That's how it is, I think. You're welcomed to fix me or tell me it's true. Hopes that if it's true it'll clear things up.
Signed for great justice! This is exactly what I was thinking about. If it wasn't for you I would have had to write this down, so thanks Rai! This explains how he can see without eyes or digest food without digestive organs. About sex, I'm not that sureā¦ but anyways, we can cancel out Brook taking off one of his bones to use it as a weapon. Because he would lose that limb forever.
I'm not sure if it's important or actually implied that his soul came back from heaven "pure" though.
Yes and no.
Yes, because that is awesome and true
No, because that picture was so badly drawn, 84 pregnant teenagers died in labor.
@Impel:
Yes and no.
Yes, because that is awesome and true
No, because that picture was so badly drawn, 84 pregnant teenagers died in labor.
what|:?
dude. you have to be less critical. the person who draw it is not Oda, and it's in msn.
another Brooke-fangirl suddenly appears
Whoo, first posting ^^ I hope I will stay here for more than a few weeks x.x
IĀ“m sure, Brooke is a perfect musician! A musicianĀ“s job is to make his crew happy no matter how bad the circumstances areā¦ and this guy is the happiness itself! XD Even after these 10 awful years, heĀ“s still able to laugh and his face is a (creepy) grin all the time. Who does not get happy while seeing him? XD
another Brooke-fangirl suddenly appears
Whoo, first posting ^^ I hope I will stay here for more than a few weeks x.xIĀ“m sure, Brooke is a perfect musician! A musicianĀ“s job is to make his crew happy no matter how bad the circumstances areā¦ and this guy is the happiness itself! XD Even after these 10 awful years, heĀ“s still able to laugh and his face is a (creepy) grin all the time. Who does not get happy while seeing him? XD
First things first: Welcome to the forums!
Nowā¦
A skeleton isn't the first thing I think of when I want to think happy thoughts. XD But Brook is cheerful despite his situation, which is more than I can say for most of the Strawhats.
@ FFA
Thanks ^^
But skeletons are funny! XD Just look how happy Luffy was, when he saw Brooke XD And Brookes teeth seems so bigā¦ I beg his smile was really awesome when he was alive XD
@ Topic
Well, I noticedā¦ on page 14 Brooke says: ā I donĀ“t know if IĀ“ll meet him (the shadow thief) by the end of my second lifeā
Perhaps our evil shadow snatcher really is some kind of Davy Jones XD A person the sailors meet when they die on sea oo When Brooke talked about how his shadow was stolen (first panel page 10) he also said: āI floated around in this ocean for too many months!ā Maybeā¦ every sailor who spends too much time in the Florian Triangle is doomed by Davy Jones himselfā¦ and so he steals the shadows of his doomed victims so that they can never leave his realm alive. And IĀ“m sure Davy Jones is VERY angry because one of his victims is still āaliveā. Robin mentioned Davy Jones before, so it could explain her behaviour when Brooke talked about his stolen shadow.
I know, another very stupid fangirl theory XD (because Davy Jones only take things on sunken ships, so itĀ“s no reason to let his victims burn under the sun) But the sentence āI floated around in this ocean for too many months!ā still sounds a bit misplacedā¦ oo It sounds like his shadow was stolen because he spends too much time within the fogā¦ but still a real reason is missing.
And thenā¦ why should Brooke try to face Davy Jones.. this would be pure suicide. (Or this could be Brookes desireā¦ ask Davy Jones if he can die now. But I beg Oda is through with this āI want to dieā-thingā¦ even if Brooke mentioned it on page 12)
Soā¦ another crazy selfmade theory XD And I disproved it by myself now XD But IĀ“m still wondering about this sentenceā¦ how his stolen shadow ist related to the time he spended within the Triangle.
Wow..You crashed your own theory. If it was me I'd not mention it untill someone else would ^^
And yeah, if Brooke wanted to die he can jump to the water and finish this. No need to ask Davy Jones to do it.
Anyways, am I the only one who sees that shadow stealer as a fat round grandpa idiot [Lucky Roux-ish], and he's silly and stuff like that?
I have that same image on Vergapunk too, only his is a little better. Like that scientist in Old Times section of one of the Color Walks.
Oh, and btw, welcome to the forums Hiso, hope you like it here. One important thing to remember is not to go with the flow, EVER.
I think the shadowstealer has some really awesome/crazy devilfruit ability which allows him to put the shadows he obtained to some good use (ghosts?). Perhaps they have the same limitations as the remaining corpse (no sunlight) so that he HAD to build his powerbase in the foggy area of the triangle. IĀ“m really dying to meet him.
hiho.
I am new hereā¦IĀ“ve read in this forum for a while and now i registered myself. I have a new theory. Maybe Brook is the killed Sachi from Whitebeard.
i dont know, but how disappeared brooks shadow? Is it just a thing came up, cause of his DF? Maybe BB absorbed his shadow with his black hole. But otherwise its just a weird theory, because then BB would have killed Sachi for nothing, because he allready has eaten a DF. And BB must have killed Sachi immediatly after eating the fruit. Did Brook loose his shadowto that ghosts? Maybe BB absorbed his shadow when Brook was already a skeleton! Yeah i know, a strange theory, but what do you think about it?
mfg hurrricane
hiho.
I am new hereā¦IĀ“ve read in this forum for a while and now i registered myself. I have a new theory. Maybe Brook is the killed Sachi from Whitebeard.
i dont know, but how disappeared brooks shadow? Is it just a thing came up, cause of his DF? Maybe BB absorbed his shadow with his black hole. But otherwise its just a weird theory, because then BB would have killed Sachi for nothing, because he allready has eaten a DF. And BB must have killed Sachi immediatly after eating the fruit. Did Brook loose his shadowto that ghosts? Maybe BB absorbed his shadow when Brook was already a skeleton! Yeah i know, a strange theory, but what do you think about it?
mfg hurrricane
Brook was killed decades ago. Satch was killed less than a year ago. Plus, Satch didn't have an afro. Lastly, Satch wouldn't be able to eat the Yami Yami fruit without disintegrating if he already at the Yomi Yomi no Mi.
Besides, Satch looked like a Douche.
A pondering: how would seastone or Yami Yami powers affect Brooke?
@IT'S:
A pondering: how would seastone or Yami Yami powers affect Brooke?
His DF power is gone, technically. It should have no effect.
I guess, theoretically, if he had been killed by seastone or drowning, he wouldn't have come back.
Wouldn't it be terrible if Brook was somehow an allegory for Jesus? I mean he can walk on water and risen from the dead. Hah, that'd be a fun spoiler thread.
@raj:
Wouldn't it be terrible if Brook was somehow an allegory for Jesus? I mean he can walk on water and risen from the dead. Hah, that'd be a fun spoiler thread.
Dude, Franky is. Franky came back from the dead and he's a carpenter. Plus he's Super.
@Fire Fist:
I guess, theoretically, if he had been killed by seastone or drowning, he wouldn't have come back.
I don't think so.. Death is still death.
Although, I dunno if he'll be able to come back to surface if the corpse has remained underwater, He should just die again.
Drowning with yomi yomi no mi = shit happens XD Imagine this little soul, floating around its corpseā¦ and thinking "Revive or not?"
Is it just me....?
ā¦ IĀ“m talking about this "I noticed something!"-thingy. While reading both chapters the first time, I was thinking "WhatĀ“s wrong with that guy?" I canĀ“t explain... itĀ“s just very strange, how often we can see this thingy next to him oĆ“ (at least seven times in two chapters) Maybe Brooke notices many things XD Or itĀ“s really just me... yes, itĀ“s just me XD
Drowning with yomi yomi no mi = shit happens XD Imagine this little soul, floating around its corpseā¦ and thinking "Revive or not?"
Is it just me....?
[qimg]http://i62.photobucket.com/albums/h88/Hisolein/Sonstiges/notice.jpg[/qimg]
ā¦ IĀ“m talking about this "I noticed something!"-thingy. While reading both chapters the first time, I was thinking "WhatĀ“s wrong with that guy?" I canĀ“t explain... itĀ“s just very strange, how often we can see this thingy next to him oĆ“ (at least seven times in two chapters) Maybe Brooke notices many things XD Or itĀ“s really just me... yes, itĀ“s just me XD
I would assume it's because skeletons have a hard time showing facial emotion, so Oda uses that to show surprise.
His bones are bleached, remember. They shine.
lol makes you wonder wat will brooke do if luffy decides to have a dog
@Fire Fist:
His DF power is gone, technically. It should have no effect.
I guess, theoretically, if he had been killed by seastone or drowning, he wouldn't have come back.
Judging by the way the others acted when he dropped to the ocean I'd say the sea still effects him.
Naw, he'd have come back even if he was dead. Now SS and water just weakens him like a normal. Basically, he no longer has any powers other than he's a skeliton.
Judging by the way the others acted when he dropped to the ocean I'd say the sea still effects him.
They don't know, dude. They're not Brook. The way they understand it, once a DF user, always a DF user. But Brooke is dead, so technically he's no longer a DF user.
so if I get this right if Brooke gets his shadow back he will sail with the Shs cause he would be able to go in light/
I wonderā¦ if Blackbeard Teach touches Brook, would he temporarily become lifeless?
@Fire Fist:
They don't know, dude. They're not Brook. The way they understand it, once a DF user, always a DF user. But Brooke is dead, so technically he's no longer a DF user.
But if he was no longer a DF user, wouldn't he just collapse and die for good? As long as Brook is still alive, then the DF seems very active. It's difficult to tell.
When he runs on water, he probably runs so fast that he touches the water for a slight second and so on, so it won't completely weaken him. Somehow he manages to stay up. The quickness and area of his legs probably keep him up, like a bird's wings would keep them up. Or it could be "NaRuTO STYLe!!" :shocked: