I'm fine with random order, how do you propose we go about it?
One Piece Mafia: Part III
-
-
You go first.I haven't quite gotten that far yet. Trying to think of a way that couldn't be manipulated. Or a way to provide proof?
-
Ah, okay, we've started! Cool.
Okay, lemme think. The first townie sees the Mafia stab Garp. The second townie (falsely) sees his/her fellow townie stab Garp. The Mafia, naturally, doesn't see anything except the blood on his own hands.
Problem I'm seeing here is, no matter what order the real killer "confesses" in, he can lie his way out one way or another. If two people's claims contradict each other, it'll just be one person's word against the other's, and the third person (second townie) won't know whom to believe. The person who "confesses" soonest isn't necessarily in the clear, because it could just be the Mafia taking a random stab in the dark, and if it contradicts one of the two real townies' claims, the Mafia can just claim that said townie is lying. Or, it could be the other way around.
If we do wanna randomize it, though, here's an idea. The Ghost of Garp (i.e. trappedolphin) picks a number between 1 and 100. Then we all have to guess. The person who gets closest to that number gets to go last (#3), the next closest is #2, and the person who's furthest off goes first. Or we could do that in the opposite order, if you'd like.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Oops, apologies for the small green text. Hopefully you can still read that.
-
Well on the chance that the killer doesn't guess right, it will bring the odds down to a 50/50 for one remaining townie as opposed to a 50/50 with both townies having a chance to mess up. And if nothing happens, at least it's revealed to the townies who they saw do what.
I like your idea. I think trappe will play along, so I'll send her a number before I crash.
-
That's a great idea and all guys, and I love creative thinking, but it's a little unethical and they might take away my mod cert. Plus I'd probably cheat. So nope.
-
You're no fun and is not unethical at all.
-
Well I guess we could vote for who should claim first. First to 2 votes? Woddy/Faith any thoughts?
-
Sure, that sounds okay to me. I honestly don't really care what order I go in. How about the person who gets 2 votes claims first, whoever gets 1 goes second, and the person with none goes third?
Vote Claim: Wooden_Giraffe
-
I can dig that. Vote Claim: Faith
-
Sigh Well, time grows short, and my availability for the rest of the time will be sporadic. Since Wooden's not gonna vote for himself, I'll assume he'll vote for me, meaning I'd be chosen to claim first. Might as well just do so now to ensure we have time to look at it and then vote.
I am Kizaru. I saw Aokiji stab Garp.
-
There's only 20 minutes left :(
-
Quick, Kubi. At least make your claim. If Wooden doesn't show soon, I'm voting him.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Well, I'm off to watch Game of Thrones. For inactivity reasons:
Vote Lynch: Wooden_Giraffe
-
Welp I'm Akainu and I saw Kizaru kill Garp.
I guess we'll Vote Lynch: Wooden Giraffe
-
Oh yeah, this was happening. Oh well.
I win!!!
-
-
http://zh141114-0223.890m.com/kdao/_1411/src/1415946859031.png
Oh, hey, Space! You should totally sign on for Huschel's 14-person game that will start…eventually!
-
-
Not only did they kill Wooden, but they've gone and killed the thread too!
NOOOOOO! Mafia Survivor, i will make you pay for this! >:C -
It's true, I do miss Mafia, but Survivor has been a full-time job so far. Still, if a game ever does start here before Survivor's done, I probably am crazy enough to join anyway.
-
Actually they did not kill me, the hammer was technically too late. So I won!!!
-
But as long as nobody confirms your alignment we can't know whether you won or lost. It's Schrödinger's giraffe.
-
I also forgot the underscore, I think. But the sentiment was there. We wanted you dead.
-
You did, but you didn't hammer until after the 24 hrs was up. So it's now nighttime and which point I win!!
-
So it's now nighttime and which point I win!!
I don't know, which point do you win?
:ninja:
-
I don't know, which point do you win?
:ninja:
Considering my luck? Probably the ones that don't matter in the show that's made up.
-
What's goin' on in here, fellas? Weird shit? Mmkay, sounds fun.
-
But as long as nobody confirms your alignment we can't know whether you won or lost. It's Schrödinger's giraffe.
Sorry to barge right in guys, but I just love this comment!
Schrödinger's giraffe, haha
-
Sorry to barge right in guys, but I just love this comment!
Schrödinger's giraffe, haha
As I dwell on it this line keeps getting more awesome. I'll have to steal that, I'm sure Huschel will understand.
-
What is this? Somebody stealing my original, intellectual property? Cool, cool.
-
Yay, this thread's been brought back to life! Mafia Thread = Jesus Thread.:ninja:
-
Hey I learned all about Fair Use recently, and how totally vague it is! Copyright Law for the win!!!
-
Yay, this thread's been brought back to life! Mafia Thread = Jesus Thread.:ninja:
@Wooden: That's fair.
-
I always feel that my avatar choice will give me a certain disadvantage when playing mafia. :ninja:
I say this is the Phoenix Thread. Squawk.
-
@le:
I always feel that my avatar choice will give me a certain disadvantage when playing mafia. :ninja:
I say this is the Phoenix Thread. Squawk.
It's actually the innocent looking avatars I suspect the most.
The Legend of ScumModa. -
When's the next game?!
-
-
We could probably do it now :ninja:
-
-
Day 700 my friends are all dead. Even Spalding is out to get me, and lives amongst the forest somewhere plotting against me.
I hope that I grow out of this insanity and ascend to a less cruel place. As I am in no postition to ask for a good place. -
Awww, no, Shinobu, stay with us! :sad: Hopefully more people will be around and this thread will revive after Survivor/Big Brother/The Mole/whatever other crazy games we play are all finished.
-
Or Shinobu could come join in the chaos.
-
If I have a look at my setup from months ago now, I will probably think that it's the worst thing ever! So no change there.
-
Sorry for 'false alarming' the thread, but sign me up, Huschel, if that game still exists.
-
I´ll only be able to participate in future games in 3 weeks or so, so if there´s anything around that time say so.
-
I'm kinda back as well. Might actually sign up for one of the next ones. Fond memories.
-
I'd be interested in this so-far theoretical game
-
I've probably had enough time to cool off by now, so I'd play again.
-
If it's sooner rather than later I can join…
-
Huschel, is that partial list you made before still valid? You still planning to host?
-
If a host needs extra support I'm willing to offer it