@Kitsune:
Do you love me? Do you think lynching an active or non-active player will be more useful to us today?
Stop torturing me Kind of hard to say. Looking at this setup, I'd say that for now we have enough of a majority over mafia that I'm not feeling that urgent about lynching a lurker, although this will probably become a serious consideration very soon as we want to have the numbers to achieve a lynch. But it's always easy for mafia to be on board with lynching inactives, and I think lynching an active player would give more information.
So far today, I don't feel enough suspicion to drive a lynch on any active players (other than Shushu, but that seems to be out of the question for today), so I'd probably go for a no-show if I had to.
@Outerspec:
Updating my previous suspicion of Habaneroo where I previously remarked he said, "Keep an eye out" twice. I noticed he wrote a variation of 'look out for something strange' 3 times in a row. Coincidence? Plus, he has been advocating a no-lynch and hasn't told us what his Gotcha is. He might be playing all his cards to make sure he's not lynched and if he is, he winds up winning anyway.
I didn't notice that. Noted, and thanks~
@Shuhan:
I believe I answered this somewhat above, but I didn't see your question when I was posting. In the end, old fashioned scum hunting is the way to go. The gotcha feature is there, but I also believe I talked about this in my first post, and I still believe in it.
So where's your scumhunting? You still haven't clearly explained what your reason for Gotcha-ing was, and why we should still believe that you intend to be on town's side. The bulk of what you've done so far today has more or less resulted in a lot of attention being drawn to you. If you're town, then you should be more focused on discovering what other people are, not derailing town into wasting time on you (again, assuming that you have townlike intentions).
If you intend to go for the permanent Fool, or you're mafia trying to appear that way, it'll be quite simple to catch you before you do so. In fact, I'm still quite willing to lynch Shushu first thing tomorrow, in case he tries to Gotcha a second time.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@Kitsune:
Oh, hey, thanks for reminding me. Unless we go the Mass-Gotcha route (which is pretty blah), I want to emphasize how POINTLESS it is for Town to attempt Gotcha. We overwhelmingly outnumber the Mafia right now, and do not need to complicate the playing field by throwing unnecessary Fools into the mix. You might be a Nilla Wafer looking for fun, but it's far more important that we not make things easier for the Mafia by making a ton of fools. Nillas can be Masoned or Jailed, which is far more fun than trying to get yourself lynched for no reason.
Agreed, especially with the last sentence. After all, being masoned in my first game was how I found my true -
Dangit, Bogart! >=(
kids
have