Shanks and Buggy seem to be likely crewmates for Gold Roger
Nico Robin- Former Member of Gold Roger's Crew!?
-
-
We've been over this >< we SAW their captain, and he was nothing like Roger.
Here's a possibility: Robin is related to Gold Roger in some way, like a niece maybe.
-
We've been over this >< we SAW their captain, and he was nothing like Roger.
Here's a possibility: Robin is related to Gold Roger in some way, like a niece maybe.
Um…Do you guys think that the man who told Shanks and Buggy to settle down was maybe not the captain but instead a second commander or something?
-
Um…Do you guys think that the man who told Shanks and Buggy to settle down was maybe not the captain but instead a second commander or something?
Yep, I think so because of a very simple reason.
-
maybe the captain lost to Gold Roger in a davy back fight :o
-
I don't know if it was mentioned before… but in # 32 Nico robin is wondering about the thing, that Roger could write the "old script" ..so if Roger taught her how to read this script (how some of you had suggested), she would know about it, instead of wondering about this stuff.
-
There is NO chance Robin could have been on. Take in to account that she was 6 when Rogers WAS EXECUTED. Even if he had met her, it would be more likely she was even younger when that would have happened, so no, she wasn't on his crew.
The possibilty of Shanks, Buggy, or Robin's parents being there, however, is more likely.
Maybe someone from Luffys family (grandpa) if there is no direct link between him and Roger.
I still think Rogers could actually be his grandpa. :l
But the Captain of the ship Buggy and Shanks where in doesn't look like Gol D. Roger
It was never mentioned that this guy even was the captain. It's more likely that he could have just been a more "senior" member of the crew.
-
What makes that collar a captains collar? I looked at it and I can't see anything special about it nor do I see any other captains with anything like it.
-
What makes that collar a captains collar? I looked at it and I can't see anything special about it nor do I see any other captains with anything like it.
I´ve you´ve seen a couple of pirate stories then you´ll notice that only captains have such a colar. It is actually very clear in such stories.
To bring another example. What makes Roger´s, Whitebeard´s or Bellamy´s jacket the captains jacket? Oda never labeled them like that but is clear that this is captains jackets. The colar is practically the same thing, though it´s not that famous as the jacket. The jackets are stereotypes in pirate stories. Even if you don´t have seen much of them, among the hook, the wood leg, the eye-hatch and the parrot, the captains jacket is a typical stereotype for pirate stories.
The "captains colar" however is not such a stereotype. But if you´ve seen lots of pirate stories then you´ll actually notice that it also is an element of them.
So why does the "captains colar´s" authenticity gets questioned, while the "captains jacket´s" doesnt´.
The only logic explanation I have for that is that people aren´t familiar with this "captains colar" because they haven´t seen much pirate based stories before One Piece. And since in One Piece this guy is the only one with such a colar there´s no comparison.I´m not trying to sound like a smartass but really, in lots of the old school pirate movies such a "captains colar" appeared. It´s something that really existed and not something I made up.
-
Thanks for the explanation I have certainly never heard of that before. Well I can't doubt with that info that he was their captain, but even still I'm drawn to wonder what their relationship was to either Whitebeard or Roger from the personal knowledge that they, Buggy and Shanks, seem to have of them. On top of that the way in which White Beard addresses Shanks makes me consider there is something more there. It also seemed pretty convienient of Oda to have only one generic Jolly Roger showing in the flashback while hiding the sails.
-
You´re welcome. It´s moments like this where it appears that I wasn´t wasting my life by watching all kinds of movies in my youth. I have to thank you for that.
About Shanks, Buggy, their captain and Whitebeard. If you´re open for whack ideas then just read the following paragraphs for a theory I made up about the relation between those characters.
I think that the Whitebeard Pirates and the pirate crew Shanks and Buggy belonged to fought with each other and that the Whitebeard Pirates emerged triumphant.
It could possibly be that once Shanks´and Buggy´s captain killed (be it accidentally or intentionally) a member of Whitebeards crew and Whitebeard wanted to avenge him/her with this fight.
Then it could be that the Whitebeard Pirates wiped out the entire pirate team except for Shanks and Buggy. The reason why they survived could be similar to the scene where kid Sanji impressed Zeff the Red Leg Pirate with his attitude. Maybe Shanks impressed Whitebeard that he let him and his "friend" Buggy live.
Of course I´m aware that this theory has at no point be hinted anywhere to hold any water in the manga. It´s just my personal interpretation that would fit with the limited info that we have on that matter so far:
1. It would work with what this statement of Buggy about Whitebeard in chapter 233: "And the one thing Whitebeard will not stand for AT ALL is the death of his crew!!! THIS IS ABSOLUTE!! THAT'S WHAT KIND OF MAN HE IS!!!"
2. It would work with this statement of Buggy in the same chapter: "Years ago…I met the man himself, here on the Grand Line...!!!"
3. It would work with this statement of Whitebeard about Shanks from the same chapter: "Since when did THAT BOY get to be so important?"
Just some (old) food for thought.
-
Yep, I think so because of a very simple reason.
What is captains colors?
And maybe Buggy and Shanks were just younger, rookies or whatever, and that guy just told´em to quit fighting. -
It´s captains colar. The thing around his neck and part of his shirt.
-
Aha, you meant it THAT way. :) Sorry. But, what if he is the captain for that ship? Maybe Roger or Whitebeard had/have more then one ship?
-
You´re welcome. It´s moments like this where it appears that I wasn´t wasting my life by watching all kinds of movies in my youth. I have to thank you for that.
About Shanks, Buggy, their captain and Whitebeard. If you´re open for whack ideas then just read the following paragraphs for a theory I made up about the relation between those characters.
I think that the Whitebeard Pirates and the pirate crew Shanks and Buggy belonged to fought with each other and that the Whitebeard Pirates emerged triumphant.
It could possibly be that once Shanks´and Buggy´s captain killed (be it accidentally or intentionally) a member of Whitebeards crew and Whitebeard wanted to avenge him/her with this fight.
Then it could be that the Whitebeard Pirates wiped out the entire pirate team except for Shanks and Buggy. The reason why they survived could be similar to the scene where kid Sanji impressed Zeff the Red Leg Pirate with his attitude. Maybe Shanks impressed Whitebeard that he let him and his "friend" Buggy live.
Of course I´m aware that this theory has at no point be hinted anywhere to hold any water in the manga. It´s just my personal interpretation that would fit with the limited info that we have on that matter so far:
1. It would work with what this statement of Buggy about Whitebeard in chapter 233: "And the one thing Whitebeard will not stand for AT ALL is the death of his crew!!! THIS IS ABSOLUTE!! THAT'S WHAT KIND OF MAN HE IS!!!"
2. It would work with this statement of Buggy in the same chapter: "Years ago…I met the man himself, here on the Grand Line...!!!"
3. It would work with this statement of Whitebeard about Shanks from the same chapter: "Since when did THAT BOY get to be so important?"
Just some (old) food for thought.
0.0 that would explain things, huh…
-
Aha, you meant it THAT way. :) Sorry. But, what if he is the captain for that ship? Maybe Roger or Whitebeard had/have more then one ship?
Well there´s no fact that speaks against it actually. I may not go with this theory personally, but it definitely is possible.
-
I still think there exists the possibility that Shanks and Buggy were either a part of Gol D Rogers crew or White Beard. As for the fact that the captain of the ship was neither Roger or White Beard we should remember, at least for White Beard and if you consider Shanks 90mil berri rookie, that there are other ships under the same flag where someone like Ace will be in command of The captain's, White Beards, crew.
Of course I just had to point out that something I considered way back when turned out to be true. So much for that theory that Roger couldn't possibly be The Captain because of that guy with the collar. We're seeing more and more who is connected to who in the latest chapters and how. It just might be that Mihawk was a cabin boy on Whitebeards ship at the same time.
-
"Two-Ring" Jack, as I call him, is a pirate in his own right. Look at the wanted posters on the wall in Gen-san's office. He's on one of them, and his bounty is 23 million. Of course, that was 8 years ago. You can't really see it in scanlations, but he's holding a glass of wine.
-
lol, even her boobs still look too alive, how could she be 38? lol
-
Any aged woman could seem to have very alive boobs with the right cleavage.
-
First off, the incident in Ohara happened 20 years ago. Roger was executed 22 years ago. Though that a parent could have been one of Roger's crewmembers is still valid. I was personally thinking that it might be Ben Beckman, Shank's First mate (the guy with the cigarette and the rifle who likes to use it as a bat). He seems like he'd be old enough. Plus, he's the smartest person from East Blue, so we have an idea where Robin's intelligence comes from.
Second, the latest chapter specifically says that both Shanks and Buggy were on Roger's crew. So the other guy can't possibly be the captain.
-
^ I don't see how that means Roger can't be Robin's dad.
-
I don't see how this topic is still active.
-
who ever start this post must hv some really huge imagination … i just cant believe anyone would suggest nico robin is part of gol d. roger crew.
-
First off, the incident in Ohara happened 20 years ago. Roger was executed 22 years ago. Though that a parent could have been one of Roger's crewmembers is still valid. I was personally thinking that it might be Ben Beckman, Shank's First mate (the guy with the cigarette and the rifle who likes to use it as a bat). He seems like he'd be old enough. Plus, he's the smartest person from East Blue, so we have an idea where Robin's intelligence comes from.
Second, the latest chapter specifically says that both Shanks and Buggy were on Roger's crew. So the other guy can't possibly be the captain.
I don't believe that Oda would consider Ben Beckman as having the highest IQ in One Piece anymore. At the time Oda answered that SBS question he was only up to the end of the Don Krieg arc. Oda specifically said that Beckman had the highest IQ of all of those characters introduced in One Piece.
Since Robin is 28 years old Roger could still be Robins father and Olvia's husband that the scholars spoke of. Who knows if he was already spoken of as a legend at that time. When the scholars first left Ohara 26 years ago he may not have been so well known to the world as the pirate king at the time.