since no one ever dies in one piece (ITS A JOKE FANBOYS) maybe gol d roger is alive?
that could make luffy his son.
GASP!
discuss.
since no one ever dies in one piece (ITS A JOKE FANBOYS) maybe gol d roger is alive?
that could make luffy his son.
GASP!
discuss.
nope…. it's a flashback for Gol D. Roger means he is really 6 feet under.....
no. a million times, no.
no. a million times, no.
where is your proof? how many one piece characters must almost die but not actually die till you sway!
I thought this thread was just a joke! O.O
Do you really think they stabbed the pirate king and didn't check if he is dead? There is no way, sry.
where is your proof? how many one piece characters must almost die but not actually die till you sway!
everyone in that town (forgot the name) saw him get executed…and theres no reason to fake death anyways
if u fake death...then u will have to hide for the rest of ur life...cant even show ur face to anyone...
and unless oda decides to make one piece into doraemon...and sends to back into time and stuff...THERES NO CHANCES FOR GOL D ROGER TO BE LUFFY'S FATHER...:getlost:
nope…. it's a flashback for Gol D. Roger means he is really 6 feet under.....
no. a million times, no.
I thought this thread was just a joke! O.O
I thought this thread was just a joke! O.O
Do you really think they stabbed the pirate king and didn't check if he is dead? There is no way, sry.
everyone in that town (forgot the name) saw him get executed…and theres no reason to fake death anyways
if u fake death...then u will have to hide for the rest of ur life...cant even show ur face to anyone...and unless oda decides to make one piece into doraemon...and sends to back into time and stuff...THERES NO CHANCES FOR GOL D ROGER TO BE LUFFY'S FATHER...:getlost:
Nothing but a bunch'o Trendwhores.
@Octogon:
Nothing but a bunch'o Trendwhores.
Do you have to be insulting? I don't like to be called a whore at all and especially not when I just say my opinion -.-
Mods please save us! This forum gets ultimatly spammed…
Junkman ... nomen est omen?
i know there's a problem when you start making logic out of a comic about a rubber pirate who never steals or kills and yet is a pirate.
its like someone trying to explain to me how superman can fly.
anyways, my point is everyone is on the boat that gol d roger isn't his father, but…
there are ways around it.
and honestly one piece does seem to be one of those comics where the most absurd things happen, and that's why i love it.
so why is it so hard to believe that gol d roger is still alive? possibly?
honestly i think the funny thing is how everyone's getting so worked up about this little thread. i barely post on this forum anyways and usually its to make a silly comment.
i was just sick of people totally tossing out the idea that gol d roger could be luffy's dad. i mean there is a way he could.
for all i know gol d roger is that dog navy guy in disguise. thus gol d roger captured himself :P
i know there's a problem when you start making logic out of a comic about a rubber pirate who never steals or kills and yet is a pirate.
its like someone trying to explain to me how superman can fly.
anyways, my point is everyone is on the boat that gol d roger isn't his father, but…
there are ways around it.
and honestly one piece does seem to be one of those comics where the most absurd things happen, and that's why i love it.
so why is it so hard to believe that gol d roger is still alive? possibly?
Cause it is a really stupid argument that has been going on for 8(?) years.
There is no point on arguing on it, till there are canons. Just arguing it over and over every 2 weeks withaunt any proof to any side gets us nowhere.
Do you have to be insulting? I don't like to be called a whore at all and especially not when I just say my opinion -.-
**You shouldn't take things so seriously. I didn't mean to be particularly insulting to anybody.
My point is,99% of people out there are saying Gol's dead just cause everyone else says so. and why does everyone else say so? It's not spears went through him, it's because they think it'd be lame. And why do they think it is lame? Because of that old "It's happened before so much, so it can't be good" idea. People try to "proove" he isn't alive but they can't. Because their are 1,000,000 possible things that could have happnened. Fact is, it's entirley and completley possible that the Pirate King is still alive.
As for my stance, I personally believe he's dead.**
Well, it's right that we all would be really flashed when what you are saying is true but since the very beginning it's said that Gol D. Roger is dead… that's why it's so hard to believe that
and like Ramza said, everyone saw him die. It would be something else if that wasn't the case but with that... It's just too hard to believe.
@Octogon: Ok then, but you shouldn't say such things to people without good reason... that just isn't right
Cause it is a really stupid argument that has been going on for 8(?) years.
There is no point on arguing on it, till there are canons. Just arguing it over and over every 2 weeks withaunt any proof to any side gets us nowhere.
um so what's the point of the forums then?
Well, it's right that we all would be really flashed when what you are saying is true but since the very beginning it's said that Gol D. Roger is dead… that's why it's so hard to believe that
and like Ramza said, everyone saw him die. It would be something else if that wasn't the case but with that... It's just too hard to believe.
@Octogon: Ok then, but you shouldn't say such things to people without good reason... that just isn't right
wasn't that cat pirate guys suppose to be dead. maybe there's a super jango out there who did a mass hypno thingy!
or there's a LIER LIER fruit that makes things look like they're happening but they're not
um so what's the point of the forums then?
To discuss theories that have valid proof (looks pointevly at the people who state that dragon will appear the next chap. over and over) and don't cost people excessive amounts of brain cells.
PS: My english sucks. Get over it! <_<
@Octogon: Ok then, but you shouldn't say such things to people without good reason… that just isn't right
**I'm sorry, but I just can't do that. I know when I absolutley should not say it and this isn't one of those times.
Junkman, please don't double post. The edit button is there for a reason, plus it's annoying.**
p.s. please keep this discussion or agrument depending on your half glass full half empty perspective LIGHT HEARTED.
the second i start taking one piece seriously is the second i lose intrest.
kk sorry bout the double posting!
i know there's a problem when you start making logic out of a comic about a rubber pirate who never steals or kills and yet is a pirate.
its like someone trying to explain to me how superman can fly.
**anyways, my point is everyone is on the boat that gol d roger isn't his father, but…
there are ways around it.**
and honestly one piece does seem to be one of those comics where the most absurd things happen, and that's why i love it.
so why is it so hard to believe that gol d roger is still alive? possibly?
theres ways around everything….nothing is 100% impossible...but the 0.01% requires imagination...like GOL D ROGERS OBTAINED THE DRAGONBALLS!!
he will never die...thats the reason why a lot of people dislike DBZ...and im positive that Oda wont follow the same footsteps...
the second i start taking one piece seriously is the second i lose intrest.
…huh how does that work...u cant be serious over something u are not interested in...
theres ways around everything….nothing is 100% impossible...but the 0.01% requires imagination...like GOL D ROGERS OBTAINED THE DRAGONBALLS!!
he will never die...thats the reason why a lot of people dislike DBZ...and im positive that Oda wont follow the same footsteps...
how many people died in one piece thus far? and not in flash backs cause people died all the time in flash backs in dbz, infact i willing to bet more people have died in dbz then one piece :P
oh and about that serious coment i made, i take one piece as seriously as i do reading a story about batman, it may be an instresting read but batman boils down to a rich emo guy who's crazy attacking other crazy people dressed in halloween costumes.
Ok, what are you saying now? You think that Garp is actually the believed dead Roger, right?
Do you have any evidence for that?
Oh, and I think you take One Piece really seriously because otherwise you wouldn't be discussing with us XD
points to spoiler
The allmighty Enel must hate you, Junkman.
Ok, what are you saying now? You think that Garp is actually the believed dead Roger, right?
Do you have any evidence for that?Oh, and I think you take One Piece really seriously because otherwise you wouldn't be discussing with us XD
i'm keeping an open mind about garp actually being gol d roger but mind you if he is i'll make a post on the forum about it :D
if ya seen my posts on these forums, few as they are, you'd know i don't take much seriously. plus i don't think of oda as the best comic book artist out there, or enel as my god
about the spoliers
ya a saw that, hehe, based on that i'm gonna say one of my theories goes out the window, unless its a lie. eh i won't believe it till luffy dad dies and goes ghost form to smile at his kid at the ewok homworld.
If a character appears to die in modern scene, they most likely are alive. I for one believe characters such as Mr. 9 and Bellamy to still be alive.
However, it has been proven that if a character dies in a flashback, they are most certainly DEAD.
Oh and if anyone is looking for the Kuina = Tashigi idea to break the thread, it won't work.
Tashigi and Kuina are twin sisters. They were split apart at birth, one lived with her mother (Tashigi) the other with her father (Kuina). Tashigi eventually joined the marines, and with practice from swords, she became a sword-geek and became her own Sword-woman. This is the most LOGIAL non story-breaking assumption about Kuina and Tashigi.
I always have believed Gol D. Roger has the copy copy fruit. So he sent one of his clones to his "execution".
but since the very beginning it's said that Gol D. Roger is dead… that's why it's so hard to believe that
It also called him Gold Roger but people didn't have a hard time believing his real name was Gol D. Roger.
Authors' manipulation of their readers' trust in what they see or read is one of their greatest strengths.
ie. CP9
gold roger being alive = the whole world crumbling in on itself
sorry its not happenin'
sorry its not happenin'
Sorry, it's not your place to decide.
haha another bitchy forum fights. continue yapping kids.
haha another bitchy forum fights. continue yapping kids.
Awww <3
With that Avatar I imagine how Robin says that, while sitting on the deck of Going Merry, chin leaning on her hand, smiling like she always does XD