which dub arc has been the worst so far….......... i think baratie, because they edited some stuff, also voices are horrible (except for krieg)
Untitled
-
-
are you allowed to do this??
if i had to choose ill chose baratie same reason as warps reason -
i dont know…...... i thought itd be a intresting dissicion/ poll
-
What about the Buggy arc? :huh: Shouldn't it be in the options?
-
oh crap i forgot….......... does anybody know how to add it in
-
ask a mod or someone else
-
Probably the Baratie.
-
That Kunia thing! "She…. was.... beaten... up.. by.. guy.. embarrresesed... friend.... come... help... POW!!! BANDITS!!!!......ack..hospital... GAH! what are trying to say!?!? >_<
I picked Baratie. The Kuro thing pissed me off
-
Originally posted by joekido the Second@Apr 24 2005, 08:04 PM
**That Kunia thing! "She…. was.... beaten... up.. by.. guy.. embarrresesed... friend.... come... help... POW!!! BANDITS!!!!......ack..hospital... GAH! what are trying to say!?!? >_<I picked Baratie. The Kuro thing pissed me off
[snapback]36884[/snapback]**Heh, it kindda pissed me off too, but i'll go with the Baratie Arc, God it was sheer toture. <_<
-
I vote with the Baratie Arc, as the subs were ok in the beginning, but got intolerable when it reached the Baratie Arc.
Ever notice that the subs are nice at the beginning but turn to crap later on??
By the way, I watch the Hong Kong Subs.
-
Spawnraven get kf fansubs they are always good
anyway i picked Baratie becuas not only was that where sanji comes in but i also include zoro flash back in that arc it was horrible and there was the whole zoro vs mihawk fight and then the poison sucktion cups <_<
although i have a feeling that arlong park might soon become the worst -
Baratie…because of Moo
-
Baratie, for many reasons, but there's one that comes to mind, Sanjis voice.
-
I've just watched a few from each arc, but Baratie left the most scars. It just goes beyond words.
-
Nothing beats the Baratie arc. Sanji sounds like Dr. Girlfriend from the venture brothers.
-
I'am already watching the Kaizoku Fansubs, ronozoro. But I only started around 120.
I'am almost there….. downloading episode 130 :D
By the way, are you watching the english dub, Sanji? (you know, the moore treatment!).
-
Here is the lowdown in my view on the dub arcs.
Morgan- This was the best arc voice wise. Alvida was the worst voice, but it fit her then, but not as skinny. Morgan, Helmeppo, and Koby were good in this. The crew sounded good, save Nami in the first episode. Back then Luffy sounded okay.
Buggy- The best arc they handled so far. Sure Buggy got drunk off Grapejuice and Shanks was well…you know. But the only time a weapon got edited was that corkgun. Everything else was good, save Cabaji's voice. Plus the edit when Luffy kicked Buggy looked real. Buggy had a good voice and most of the dialogue was on par.
Kuro- Kuro, Kaya, and Merry had good voices. Thats it.
Baratie- Moo, Suction Cups, lollipop. At least they kept bomb in. Good voices are Zeff after awhile, Krieg at times, and Gin. Mihawk sucked.
Arlong- I didnt see the first episode but watch. If everything stays like this episode then suprisingly this would be the best arc. But I doubt it. -
The Krieg arc definatly, why?
-David Moo
-lollipops
-Mihawk's French accent.
-"OMG, HE TORE MY SHIRT!"~Zor-err, Zolo.
-David Moo
-Ash Keturm and a New Yorker boy playing Kid Sanji.
-David Moo
-POISON SUCTION CUPS
-"You old geezaaah!"~Sunji
-That last episode was probably the worst dubbed episode yet. -
I thought Sanji sounded like Joey Wheeler with a cold, that had been punched in the face repeatidly; so that he couldn't talk all good. And just because he's got a suit, does not mean he has to sound like he came out of Comptan. So, although I liked Gin, Zeff, and Krieg's dubs, that was not a good arc dub overall.
-
BARATIE ARC!!! DAVID MOO AND THE CANDY!!! MAKES ME CRAZY!!
-
awwww can't we just show david moo a little love…..................................wait hell no
-
I must have missed that episode… who is David Moo???????
-
Originally posted by anime606@Apr 28 2005, 04:02 PM
I must have missed that episode… who is David Moo???????
[snapback]39079[/snapback]David Moo's the VA for Sanji, It's really horrible, as the other members have stressed out. :)
-
I avctually liked the Captain Morgan arc.
-
anime606, David Moore is public enemy no. 1 here :lol: refer to Cornwiggle's great sig (the wanted post) to know more. :lol:
-
I'm stating that the Arlong Arc is the worst. It's not even over and the "Rubber Knife" scene clinched it as crap.
-
U should have put Arlong just in case.. cuz that Rubber Knife took all the arcs down. HANDS DOWN!
-
baratie arc all the way. it completley sucked. espesially with all the cook's voices.
-
Originally posted by Tony Tony Chopper@May 8 2005, 05:31 AM
U should have put Arlong just in case.. cuz that Rubber Knife took all the arcs down. HANDS DOWN!
[snapback]44578[/snapback]yea….... but by the time i did this poll arlong arc wasnt out yet. they had just finished up baratie
-
Give it more time people, each arc in the dub has at least one horrific edit in it! Cpt.Morgan:hammer gun, Kuro: crazy chakaram,Kaia's "slingshot",Baratie:Kuina's "accident",poison suction cups. See? The only arc that was spared was Buggy's but that's because that arc is'nt to bad anyways…. Every arc has bad things and currently Baratie is winning with the Kuina thing, wait till Arlong gets into it's later episodes before we past judgement on it being the worst arc!
-
The whole Arlong arc is already missing its somber gritty like atmosphere. Luffy and co's hijinks should feel out of place or be standing out.
But everyone is acting like everythings a thinly vailed gag. -
Originally posted by Zephos@May 8 2005, 02:10 PM
The whole Arlong arc is already missing its somber gritty like atmosphere. Luffy and co's hijinks should feel out of place or be standing out.
But everyone is acting like everythings a thinly vailed gag.
[snapback]44781[/snapback]Yeah but it's still not the worst dub arc ( it's bearly started ) All I know is that the voices in the Arlong arc are better than the ones in the Baratie arc ( Patty,Carne,Mihawk ) So at least that makes it better so far…I could be wrong once the arc continues, but I'm just saying that it's too early to judge the Arlong arc yet...
-
Originally posted by BatDan@May 8 2005, 08:25 AM
I'm stating that the Arlong Arc is the worst. It's not even over and the "Rubber Knife" scene clinched it as crap.
[snapback]44574[/snapback]I seriously wondered how 4Shame would handle that, but I didn't think they'd do something like THAT. Better than just pushing Usopp into the water… <_<
-
Originally posted by Solar Knight+May 8 2005, 05:20 PM–>QUOTE(Solar Knight @ May 8 2005, 05:20 PM)
-
This arc will definitely be the worst. My first impressions of the subs:
Buggy: Heh heh, it's cool seeing this all animated.
Kuro: Hey, this series is picking up.
Krieg: Damn, this is cool.
Arlong: Holy shit… (the stabbing scene gave me goosebumps)
That "holy shit" just can't happen here. They're really making sure the kiddies don't get scared, which is inexcusable.
A lot of us got hooked by Arlong Park. It sucks ass that it's getting butchered like this, and I hate that people can just look down on OP and its best East Blue Arc.
-
What did you expect them to do? It was a hard scene for them to get around.. No matter what that scene was screwed no matter how they did it.. I think the rubber knife was the best thing they could do for that scene, witch is'nt sayin much but it could've been ALOT worse.. At least the rubber knife fits Ussop's personality..
I was hoping they'd drop the arc altogether knowing what kind of edits would have to be made. The rubber knife does fit Usopp's personality, but the suspense, the shock, the entire impact of that scene was reduced to a smoldering pile of crap in about 10 sentences. And this is only the third episode of the arc.
-
The only thing I can discern is that the people who are OK with dub edits like the rubber knife are probably the people that will read spoilers ahead of time and don't really care that such things as seeing a the plot of a story unfold and dramatic arcs exist.
-
I'm mad that they did do that to that scene cause it took away the suspence, but I would hate it even more if they cut the entire arc. Sure it won't get dubbed so it won't be messed up but think about it… It won't make sence to continue the series after cutting the Arlong arc.. How will we know how the Going Merry got it's Orange ochard? How will we know how Luffy got wanted for the first time? I think cutting the whole arc would've been a worse idea then dubbing it with bad edits cause veiwers who don't know about Japanese One Piece and don't care about subs won't know what happend between the Baratie arc and the Louge town arc. And while the edits might push people away there is always gonna be viewers, so cutting an entire arc, especialy one as important as this one, would be a stupid thing to do.. At least to me.
-
I'd rather have no Arlong arc than the mockery 4kids has created. And it will only get worse.
-
Originally posted by CosmicDebris@May 8 2005, 08:43 PM
The only thing I can discern is that the people who are OK with dub edits like the rubber knife are probably the people that will read spoilers ahead of time and don't really care that such things as seeing a the plot of a story unfold and dramatic arcs exist.
[snapback]45023[/snapback]People like that suck.
-
I've been reading around different forums that One Piece is doing alot better on Toonami, even though it's the same 4Kids dub..
-
um quick q who added buggy arc up there….whoever did thanks
-
If the Arlong arc was on here, I'd chose that. But, since it isn't, I'll have to go with the Baratie arc. Man; that was the shittiest one on this poll!
All of the chefs had crappy, fake accents
Pearl's surfer voice! He doesn't even look like a surfer!
Sanji, Zeff, and Mihawk's voices
Kid Sanji sounded like Ash from Pokemon if he moved to New York and picked up an accentPoison suction cups!
-
As of today, now that it's finished, I officially declare the Arlong arc to be the worst dubbed arc. Dungeons, episode fusing, corny puns galore, no emotion whatsoever, and the final episode skipped over, the dubbed Arlong arc truly is the worst yet.
I fear for Alabasta and Skypeia.(if the dub lasts that long)
-
Originally posted by DarkShinobi@Jun 25 2005, 10:47 AM
**As of today, now that it's finished, I officially declare the Arlong arc to be the worst dubbed arc. Dungeons, episode fusing, corny puns galore, no emotion whatsoever, and the final episode skipped over, the dubbed Arlong arc truly is the worst yet.I fear for Alabasta and Skypeia.(if the dub lasts that long)
[snapback]76720[/snapback]**The Arabasta arc is really long, i fear for it also. Will not be surprised at all if 4Kids cuts it down to 5 episodes. <_<
-
Damn it! If 4Kids did'nt merge so much damn episodes together I would say it at least came out to be better than the Baratie arc, but since they did…. It's the worse. Hey, we predicted it! Thank god it's over.
-
Little Garden is screwed, too. I wonder if they'll keep the idea of Zoro, Nami and Vivi turning into wax statues?
-
Originally posted by DarkShinobi@Jun 25 2005, 10:47 AM
**As of today, now that it's finished, I officially declare the Arlong arc to be the worst dubbed arc. Dungeons, episode fusing, corny puns galore, no emotion whatsoever, and the final episode skipped over, the dubbed Arlong arc truly is the worst yet.I fear for Alabasta and Skypeia.(if the dub lasts that long)
[snapback]76720[/snapback]**By final episode, Do you mean Nami heading out to sea with the rest of the straw hats, or The episode where luffy says "You are my nakama!"?
Skipping either of them is bad, but I'm curious. -
The whole party episode with Nami officially joining the crew was skipped.
-
Damn, What'd they do, Just add her leaving at the end of the episode in which Arlong got beat up?