question…
when i saw the kaizoku fansub for one piece in one epiosde Dr. Kureha refered to Gold Roger as Gol D Roger
Was I mistaken when i read this or is it possible that Gold Roger is luffy's dad?
question…
when i saw the kaizoku fansub for one piece in one epiosde Dr. Kureha refered to Gold Roger as Gol D Roger
Was I mistaken when i read this or is it possible that Gold Roger is luffy's dad?
dad i dont think so, related yes hope we will find out
hmm strokes chin he looks so much like luffy also
i wish they tell us soon
Originally posted by azuma joestar@Apr 17 2005, 01:53 AM
**question…when i saw the kaizoku fansub for one piece in one epiosde Dr. Kureha refered to Gold Roger as Gol D Roger
Was I mistaken when i read this or is it possible that Gold Roger is luffy's dad?
[snapback]32307[/snapback]**
No, it is impossible for him to be Luffy's father. While his name is Gol D. Roger, no relationship has been confirmed.
Don't worry about things like this, they'll be explained as we go, if they haven't been already.
why leave us hanging oda!?!?!?! LOL
OK whenever this discussion comes up I try to bring in good arguments about what of the said might correct or false but I actually bring never one of my strangest views into discussion. So I guess now I´ll have to out myself and just share it with everyone else.
It´s just a sick idea, but could it be that Gold Roger truly lives on in Luffy? I mean he died five years before Luffy was born so maybe that Luffy is some strange kind of reincarnation of Roger. However some part of Roger might live in Ace (intelligence, strengh) while the more important part (spirit and sense for adventure) went over to Luffy.
I know this theory is very far off and I´m not convinced of it myself but aslong as I thought about it I can´t forget it anymore. The reason why I had this idea is that it was Gold Roger himself who launched the "Great Age of Pirates" with his words. It could be that he did that on purpose. Either to bug the government with even more pirates or to go through all his adventures again but with more obstacles. Just an idea. I mean there must be a reason why Dragon is helping Luffy to get One Piece. He must be convinced that this kid (Luffy) has something that all the other powerful pirates are lacking. Gold Roger´s spirit maybe???
if gold roger is related to luffy then luffy will have roger blood in him. (geneticly wise) people look like there father sometimes act like there father since there related
There is no way that Gol D. Roger is luffy's father, I think that he could be his grand father
Originally posted by ZORO THE DEMON@Apr 17 2005, 10:46 AM
There is no way that Gol D. Roger is luffy's father, I think that he could be his grand father
[snapback]32567[/snapback]
same…......... shanks could be his father....................................nah :P
it could be a possibility but i doubt it
Originally posted by devil^^kid_@Apr 17 2005, 07:56 AM
dad i dont think so, related yes hope we will find out
[snapback]32308[/snapback]
:rolleyes: I say the same
That's something i pondered about over and over again, maybe there is a possibility that he his indeed luffy father. That would be so cool. :lol:
Originally posted by azuma joestar@Apr 17 2005, 12:53 AM
**question…when i saw the kaizoku fansub for one piece in one epiosde Dr. Kureha refered to Gold Roger as Gol D Roger
Was I mistaken when i read this or is it possible that Gold Roger is luffy's dad?
[snapback]32307[/snapback]**
Nope,he's most likey Luffy's and Ace's GrandDad
Maybe Gold D. Roger is Luffy and Ace's distant uncle, who was raise in Logue Town by his father. And, Luffy and Ace's father was raise by his mother in Fushchia Village. And maybe Luffy's grandparents were divorce.
Or maybe Gold D. Roger is a older Luffy from a alternate reality. However, in this reality Luffy was born on very,very earlier than his original birthdate, name Gold Roger by his parents, and he did or didn't eat any Devil Fruit.
Who knows, could be.
didn't Ao Kiji say something like.. "your too much like your grandfather" or something to luffy? I'm not sure but i remember him saying something like that… could Luffy's grandfather be Gold D Roger?
i dont remember him saying that but it would be so cool
You're right Jucubus, Ao kiji does say that.
Originally posted by stephen's 319 script
"I don't know, you're like…
You're just like your grandfather... Monkey D. Luffy...
Maybe it's the wildness...
Or that you're hard to grasp...!!"
Didn't Luffy freak out or something after that was said?
hmm yeah, i mean if Luffy's grandfather wasn't a important person, why would a high ranking marine remember him? nor know who his grandson is? I think this is sort of like the Naruto and Yondaime thing, probably Oda has given us other clues to the relationship between Gold D Roger and Luffy.
Originally posted by Mr. Santoryu@Apr 19 2005, 02:48 PM
Didn't Luffy freak out or something after that was said?
[snapback]33837[/snapback]
Yeah, he was sweating. Though it's difficult to grasp just how he was reacting. Was he surprised, embarrassed perhaps even scared? Does he even know he has a Grandpa? :P
Originally posted by Battle Franky+Apr 19 2005, 09:58 AM–>QUOTE(Battle Franky @ Apr 19 2005, 09:58 AM)
Hey, what if the D that Luffy, Ace, and Gold Roger carry represents the Devil. Either meaning all of them are descendant of the Devil or they are have a family curse which all the man in the family would become pirates.
And why is that a curse it must be a gift because pirates are awsome espically luffy. he has a different personality then the rest
i think if the d meant devil it should be more along the lines of everyone in that family has eaten a devil fruit
or all of them act wiered and evil which they dont
Oh, So it's a MYSTERY relationship.
Haven't there been lots of signs that he's Luffys grandfather? Kurahara.
And while the idea of reincarnation is cool, I think it's more that luffy has Rogers will.
Remember that luffy (like everyone) has TWO grandad's.
And isn't One Piece's Blackbeard's real name Marshall D Teach? You think he could have a hand in this?
Yeh, Blackbeard has long been theorized to be a relative of Luffys. Uncle is usually what's thrown around most.
well, i thought about that monkey D. luffy, ace D. portgas, and gol D. rogers thing before, and after some careful research, the D. as their middle names WAS NOT A COINCIDENCE. (if thats how you spell it) so i think their family have the same middle name instead of the same last name.
and ivotas might have a point. it looks like a good theory.
why must we wait!?!?
I seem to recall people saying that Monkey in Monkey D. Luffy actually represents the middle name, with Luffy being the given name and D. the surname. So Monkey D. Luffy would be written as Luffy Monkey D. if it was an English name. Can anyone confirm this?
i think its there middle name. i want to now there relationship not which part of the name it is. it would be nice to now about luffy since we now about everybody except him
Originally posted by Klabautermann@Apr 30 2005, 02:37 PM
I seem to recall people saying that Monkey in Monkey D. Luffy actually represents the middle name, with Luffy being the given name and D. the surname. So Monkey D. Luffy would be written as Luffy Monkey D. if it was an English name. Can anyone confirm this?
[snapback]40186[/snapback]
I'm sure the D is the last name. I don't have a link, but it makes a lot more sense that way.
Originally posted by Klabautermann@Apr 30 2005, 12:37 PM
I seem to recall people saying that Monkey in Monkey D. Luffy actually represents the middle name, with Luffy being the given name and D. the surname. So Monkey D. Luffy would be written as Luffy Monkey D. if it was an English name. Can anyone confirm this?
[snapback]40186[/snapback]
SBS Corner Vol. 6 Chap. 47
There's something hear about why Luffy and Zoro don't go by Roronoa and Monkey, i'm not sure if I can link to stephen's scripts, but i think everyone knows where to find them :)
of course at this time, there's the possibility that Oda didn't even consider a relationship between them… i always wonder how much he plans ahead in the series... i want to say lots from the way the story ties together, but maybe he's just that good :P
i think they in the same family gol d. roger monkey d. ruffy ace d. puma
marinir say "their family will be a big trouble for us" it's mean ruffy family.
and every ruffy journey same as gol d. roger.
its Portgas D. Ace
the translation in there country is different didnt you recognize he said ruffy instead of luffy so let him be
im not yelling at him or anything
i wasnt aware that he was from another country so i didnt know he had it wrong
the luffy ruffy thing is an argument thats been going around forever too
is his name luffy or is name the same name as a date rape drug
almost definitley but maybe not dad
I THINK THAT MONKEY D. LUFFY IS GOL D. ROGER CAUSE LOOK AT THEM THEY HAVE THE SAME FACE BUT LUFFY DOSENT HAVE A MOSTACHE AND ROGER IS ALL GROWN UP…. I KNOW IT DOSENT SOUND RIGHT BUT MAYBE LUFFY AFTER GROWING UP TRANSFERS BACK IN TIME THROUGH SMTHG LIKE THE RAINBOW MIST AND CONTINUES HIS JOURNEY AS A DISGUISED PERSON CALLED GOLD ROGER IF U THINK ABOUT IT IT MAKES SENSE..
it be strange and it sounds like it myight complicate the stoy big time
i think that Gold Roger is Luffy Grand Fatherbut we won't know for sure until later episodes of One Piece
And what about BlackBeard ?
He is also a D. (Marshall D. Teach)
I guess it could be luffy's other grandfather. A person has two grandfathers. i can't say for sure though. we'll just have to see how the story plays out
Originally posted by Ivotas@Apr 17 2005, 02:53 AM
It´s just a sick idea, but could it be that Gold Roger truly lives on in Luffy? I mean he died five years before Luffy was born so maybe that Luffy is some strange kind of reincarnation of Roger. However some part of Roger might live in Ace (intelligence, strengh) while the more important part (spirit and sense for adventure) went over to Luffy.
[snapback]32365[/snapback]
I think the concept of Roger reborn as Luffy seems difficult to attach with another theory– that Roger let himself fall having sort of done the whole pirate thing.
If he's already lived the best possible pirate life, why bother doing it all again. If anything, I can see him reincarnating into a different path of life, perhaps one which lets him touch base with the world he knows, yet offers a new set of experiences.
Perhaps Usopp is Gol D. Roger reborn! :D
Originally posted by Darkariel@Jun 16 2005, 04:25 PM
**And what about BlackBeard ?He is also a D. (Marshall D. Teach)
[snapback]71242[/snapback]**
well he's based on a real pirate with that name so i doubt he has any relation to luffy. plus wouldn't ace have mentioned that he was after a relative?
anyway i think (yea it's a crazy theory but hey, there are a lot of them) that the "D" might stand for dragon and dragon the man is somehow related to luffy and the other "Ds". didn't he appear when roger died? and then he appeared when luffy almost in the same town. maybe he's roger's son, therefore he's luffy's pappy. the man is a total mystery and i wanna find out more about this guy cuz it's drivin me nuts!
Originally posted by Mafioso11+Jun 19 2005, 06:56 PM–>QUOTE(Mafioso11 @ Jun 19 2005, 06:56 PM)
i had something to say ..arrrm…
while aokiji says about luffy's grandfather ,luffy was sweating ..
and actually ..Luffy always says to be a Pirate king ,and did he ever says that Gol D Roger ain't his Grandfather?Luffy seems wanted to keep secret,and he never expected Aokiji would know that His Grandfather is Roger ..Zoro,Nami,Usopp,Chopper,Robin , Shanks ,etc or some other people has never asked Luffy about it ,and Luffy did not says about it ..he might know his grandfather is roger ..but he don't want people to say it out .. maybe he wants to be like his grandfather ,so he wants to be a Pirate king? Do i make sense?
And who is Luffy's father then ???
And i don't think so because every time Luffy heard Gol D. Roger he became all shinning
But when Aokiji refers his grandfather he just freaks out
If he has Gol D. Roger's grandson would he be proud to say to everyone ???