@Mrs.:
Outerspec - really, Foolio and Galaxy Mafia? When they have been going at eachother the whole game? I know about bussing, but this seems highly unlikely. Whats your thought on Huschel?
Just to say that I´ve been saying the same thing for a while, and since Foolio´s #3262, I´m starting to feel the same.
@Foolio:
A)It's such a specific thing that has such specific rules, that how does that make any actual sense? Unless a townie wants to fess up or someone knows a role that would explain this, the only sane conclusion is that he's making this up entirely as a bluff and distraction. It's just too far-fetched otherwise. Besides, it would be too freaking obvious as a mafia power that affects a townie.
B) it means there's a decent chance Galaxy is telling the truth. Even though practically everyone finds him scummy, this just might mean Galaxy needs to rethink how he plays the game, not that he's scum. If there's one thing Iceburg has been saying that rings true, it's that if he were mafia he would probably not continue to act so scummy time after time, with his no-lynches and no votes and no power use. Then claiming townie roleblocker and contradicting an existing claim. Also it DOES sit slightly badly with me that so many of us are in principle ready to lynch him. Despite almost nobody calling him a top suspect.
C)Why is this related to SpaceCowboy? Because it also would fit in with my theory that only one non-Shuhan wagon voter was scum, and I sure as hell don't think it's firelord.
D)I see you're back to trying to draw extra meaning in me just jotting down some combos and saying they can be mixed and matched. Anyway I already kind of answered that above.
A) - I can´t disclose any more information.
B) Ah yes, because a 180º turn in behaviour would be soooo not suspicious.
Also, the only people here not to claim that Galaxy is not suspicious are Mrs. Ice and Outer to a smaller extent.
C) You´re still underestimating Firelord. His call for your claim was suspicious to say the least,besides unnecessary.
D) You´re still on with that dumb argument?
You made a list. You put Outer instead of Ice and you´ve spent quite a bit of this day going after her.
We´re still with the Outerspec triple of assumption that he is the Godfather/We have an insane cop/The insane Cop is Shuhan even without evidence?
@Huschel:
Good lord, this day is ridiculous.
A) 1) SpaceCowboy is a … I don't know. Pathological liar? How would that role even work? Can you choose not to post? Who can enforce that you do? Oh wait...no comment, is it?
B) 2) Galaxy claims to have roleblocked Foolio. Which I can confirm to be untrue because I got a report last Night. Unless Galaxy got roleblocked himself which is way to convoluted and if that's what happened, good job mafia or SUDK or whatever.
A) - I can´t disclose any more information.
B) THIS.
Have people honestly forget this?
@Foolio:
I'm really worried that there isn't more discussion happening. Nobody is trying to discuss what mafia roles there could be, what they think of Space's claim in a more serious way, etc. etc. I posed a lot of possible scenarios and instead of serious consideration I got stuff like "well all scenarios should include Foolio or Galaxy" which isn't helping. Seriously.
… because it´s the most viable one.
Unless you are asking us to ignore the ridiculous Galaxy claim.
I do want to pose a question to everyone though. What do you think of Galaxy saying he got confirmation that he can block night kills?
I don´t buy it.
So a doctor, Galaxy can block kills, two cops (one might be insane) and one tracker?
@Huschel:
I did say that I wasn't buying it. You are right that Foolio not caring too much is strange. Sigh, I guess I should (re)evaluate him.
THANK YOU!
@firelord111:
oh just because you guys say my claim is weird i say why i claimed
i was scared that if i kill townie from today to end game town will lose
If it is true, it made your role totally useless, that´s the problem.
OFC you could also be a mafia using that role to not be targeted.
@Mrs.:
I do believe Firelord's claim. It could balance things for Town.
Unlike the TWO Mafia Kill stoppers and the two (sane) Cops AND a Town Tracker…
How? It´s 50/50 really.
If we went for him, the bomb would explode in the last person to vote for him.
Seems like a dangerous mechanism, but yeah, since we have all of those roles. Maybe we could have cleared Firelord sooner and he would only get killed at the hands of mafia.
Anyway, my list of suspicions right now is something like:
Oute
Hushcel
Firelord Mrs. Ice
Foolio Galaxy
Vote to vote: Galaxy, but I would be fine with a Foolio´s lynch.