The first person suggest a OP What if, then the next poster answers it and posts a What if of their own and rinse and repeat. I'll go first I guess.
What if the Straw Hats were Space Pirates?
The first person suggest a OP What if, then the next poster answers it and posts a What if of their own and rinse and repeat. I'll go first I guess.
What if the Straw Hats were Space Pirates?
They would meet up with Enel. It would be sort of cool to see them in space for an arc though.
What if Smoker joined the crew?
Doesn't thsi seem like ask a stupid question get a stupid answer?
Or maybe we could do like "What if insert pirate here never joined Luffy" or "what if Luffy never saved insert name here", "What if they couldn't find Skypiea", this kind of things. Interesting stuff from an alternate universe. I remember reading some drabbles in which all future Strawhats died in their childhoods, and thus Ace took Luffy's place to honour him and his crew had Coby (navigator), Nojiko (cook), Kuina (swordswoman), Kaya (doctor) and maybe others I forgot.
Well, better get straight the ideas. I don't wanna be a prick, but in the wrong tracks, this place can really turn into a "ask a stupid question get a stupid answer" tread.
Then we should ask more serious questions with serious answers… like... hmmm... what if Kuina was alive?? Would Zoro's dream of being best sworsman be even "stronger"?? Or it's stronger because she died and it's an honour matter to keep his promise?
It would be stronger because Zoro wants to Surpass her.
What if ussop was sent on a Quest to difeat kuma after he went to Elbath.
What if you could understand pokemaster? Oh shi-, wrong thread. Sorry.
What if Luffy had lost an arm to Arlong during their fight? Would he have started wearing a hook like Crocodile? Or would he just fight on as "Stump-Armed" Luffy? Would he still have such a positive outlook on life? How would it affect Nami, seeing his ruined arm every day and being reminded of how much Arlong took from her?
Luffy would have a stereotypical pirate part to him then.
What if…
...Zeff had never attacked the ship Sanji was on?
...Bellmiere kept Nami and Nojiko a secret from Arlong?
...Merry had landed smack dab in a Marine fortress when descending from Skypiea…..... oh, wait...
...
Sanji would be a happy young boy attending a fancy cooking school
Nami and Nojiko would have still been forced to leave the island and would've probably gotten eaten by sharks or something
We would have a filler
What if Pokemaster95 stopped saying Usopp is going to fight Kuma?
I mean, what if the strawhats couldn't get on the train to see Robin in time?
Then Cp9 vs the straw hats would never happen.
What if Zoro used three rifles as swords like Ben Beckman does.
What if Zoro used three rifles as swords like Ben Beckman does.
Then there would be some very ugly accidents while his friends are standing next to him.
What if Shanks never gave Luffy his strawhat?
Luffy would have an afro.
As such, what would be Luffy's power up at his fight with Foxy?
Luffy would not have gotten mad at Buggy for touching it.
To Buuhan 1 what if.
The Gigantic Black ball that Foxy used.
What if Foxy joined Buggy's crew.
(contemplating re-asking his What If)
he would have cornrows
what if Luffy were to find out that his mom really was a monkey?
^ He would say COOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!
What if Zoro and Sanji ate Devil Fruits would they be better than Luffy?
Maybe Zoro but not sanji.
What if Dragon had the power of the weather and battled Nami who would win.
dragon cuz well he's dragon
what if robin dies before she finds out the true history
Edited for Kaizoku Mugen's question.
Local would hunt down and kill Oda.
What if the Straw Hats landed on Wookie Island..?
@Van:
What if the Straw Hats landed on Wookie Island..?
Things would get hairy.
ba-dum-PISH!
What if Brook had a hairstyle other than an afro?
Scary though, isn't it?
He would be even more awesome (Has no idea who the character is besides apperance)
What if Luffy stretched his hair out to make an afro?
It would replace his strawhat.
What if the 5 Elder Stars were celestial beings?
^ Pirates would look to the night sky and crack their knuckles in anticipation for a fight. Or else they'd get the I-Suddenly-Became-Allergic-to-the-Night sickness.
What if the Strawhats had learned their ship was "alive" before Eines Lobby. Would they have talked to it, felt uncomfortable about the bathroom situation, ect.?
Talking? Luffy and Usopp would most likely talk to it a lot, the others might not as much, but occasionally.
Uncomfortable about the Bathroom? Maybe Usopp, Nami and Sanji… But Luffy, Franky, and
! Brook, wouldn't care. Also, Robin would probably be smart enough to know that the ship was built for that kind of thing.
What if Kuro learned to control his speed better? Would the battle end differentally?
yes, it wouldnt end the way it is currently, but i bet luffy will try something that time which will eventually beat the crap out of kuro.. i mean it's luffy, stupid as it may seem, most of his stuff works…
what if the original character design of franky was supposed to be a french inspired girl/woman named franceska?:ninja:
what if Kuina is actually tashigi. after that horrable accident, she lost her memories or something and became a marine in order to become the best swordsman in the world
she slowly starts to regain her memories of zoro and want the white sword back!
what if Kuina is actually tashigi. after that horrable accident, she lost her memories or something and became a marine in order to become the best swordsman in the world
she slowly starts to regain her memories of zoro and want the white sword back!
Too bad that horrible accident killed her.
what if Kuina is actually tashigi. after that horrable accident, she lost her memories or something and became a marine in order to become the best swordsman in the world
she slowly starts to regain her memories of zoro and want the white sword back!
Then the next panel would be a close-up of an asian man's face saying "WHAT A TWIST!!!"
What if the Strawhat's landed on South Island? (Sonic the Hedgehog for Nakama!)
What if the Strawhat's landed on South Island? (Sonic the Hedgehog for Nakama!)
then they would beat everyone on the island, steal all the gold and go on
What if Sanji and Zoro did a fusion?
Their eternal rivalry would cause the very atoms of the fused warrior to split, creating a cataclysmic thermonuclear reaction that would end life on their planet.
What if Sanji really did switch to Eros 500 FilterLites?
what if Kuina is actually tashigi. after that horrable accident, she lost her memories or something and became a marine in order to become the best swordsman in the world
she slowly starts to regain her memories of zoro and want the white sword back!
As if.
what if sanji, zoro, robin and luffy didnt get their shadows back?
They'd be dead because they were dying as they got their shadows back.
What if Shanks had never showed up at Luffy's town? Would that change anything?
Buggy would go to the Grand Line and get captured at Whisky Peak.
What if Nami finally fell in love with Sanji?
What if Luffy was sent back to Alabasta instead of Amazon Lily?
he would've used the alabasta troops to invade impel down….
or stole it, either works
What if Nami finally fell in love with Sanji?
Sanji would have a huge nosebleed big enough to flood the ship.
What if Usopp had stayed as Sogeking and gone to Elbaf?
Perona would've made Luffy, Zoro, Sanji and Franky her boy toys at Thriller Bark.
What if Mr. 1 betrayed Crocodile in Alabasta to become a "Supa" Hero?
Crocodile would die instead of being arrested.
What if Zoro had agreed to join baroque works?
Vivi and Zoro would be having sex right now.
What if the Strawhats were in Silent Hill?
It ends with another UFO ending and the Strawhats become space pirates –-> see post one.
What if by some random occurance, the Strawhats all awoke one day to find they had switched bodies.
What if Luffy loses his gomu gomu no powers.
Some of them would make nice experiences.
Luffy would continue his way to be Pirate King and would somehow make it.
What if Ace wouldn't be THIS loyal to Whitebeard?
He wouldn't go after Blackbeard, because he would not be the chief of the Second Division.
Which would end with ID ark
What if Luffy chosen Paulie instead of Franky as crewmember?
Nami would have to wear clothes, effectively cutting out the largest paying demographic for One Piece in Japan, which would, in turn, cause the cancellation of the series.
What if you didn't feel an overwhelming desire to respond to every topic here?
i wont be responding to that question above right now -.-
what if…..the blue lining come out from the sides of buggy's hat is actually his hair?
Um, it is his hair.
What if Oda had the crew stop for tea time in the middle of an adventure?
It would be reclaimed as the greatest episode ever. Complete with Robin actually showing Brooke her panties.
If someone destroys Nami's in-the-making map of the world, how many people would she murder and who would she start with?